loader from loading.io

The Great Sherlock Holmes Debate

The Baker Street Babes

Release Date: 11/14/2011

Introducing The Knights of Thorpe show art Introducing The Knights of Thorpe

The Baker Street Babes

What adaptation of the canon do the Baker Street Babes consider the greatest Sherlockian film of all time? Which movie weaves the best villain and a long-lost member of the Holmes family into a single immaculate tapestry known as "Thorpe"? Is it true that each and every film would be substantially improved with the addition of mechanized min-T-rexes? And which actor to play Sherlock Holmes provides both the smallest stature and the biggest presence of any to date, despite doing so with both hands wedged firmly behind his back?   Lyndsay and Maria answer these questions and far more in a...

info_outline
Episode 88: 10 Years of Sherlock Memories show art Episode 88: 10 Years of Sherlock Memories

The Baker Street Babes

Yes, it's been a decade since the airing of BBC Sherlock's "A Study in Pink." And while time has absolutely no meaning in the age of COVID, it has been an extraordinary ten years of memories thanks to the little British show that surprised the world. So we take some time to talk about our memories of the Sherlock fandom and the crazy trajectory of the show, some of your memories, and revisiting the first 221B Con and SherlockeDCC at San Diego Comic Con.

info_outline
Episode 87: Holmes at Home show art Episode 87: Holmes at Home

The Baker Street Babes

The world is a difficult place right now. A place where it's OK to not be OK. However, we do hope you're OK and that maybe some silly talk about "The Solitary Cyclist" and The Diogenes Club as places of social distancing may brighten your spirits. In this episode Maria and Ashley do just that while Curly, Lyndsay, Taylor, Sarah, and Amy check in with all of you, tell you a bit about how we're doing, and that we love you. Sure, it's a bit sappy, a bit silly, and rather giggly... but that's what we do isn't it? We're your friends who chat about Sherlock Holmes with you. And sometimes syphilis....

info_outline
Episode 86: The Left Coast Sherlockian Symposium show art Episode 86: The Left Coast Sherlockian Symposium

The Baker Street Babes

Curly chats with Elinor Gray about her new conference: The Left Coast Sherlockian Symposium.

info_outline
Live & Local 7: Michael Sims show art Live & Local 7: Michael Sims

The Baker Street Babes

Our Live & Local series are our sit down with a fascinating Sherlockian one-on-one in person chats. This go round Lyndsay sits with Edgar Award nominated Michael Sims about his work, Arthur and Sherlock, as well as some other fascinating Sherlockian tidbits and anecdotes.

info_outline
Episode 85: Cake Boss & Our Charity Ball show art Episode 85: Cake Boss & Our Charity Ball

The Baker Street Babes

We were on Cake Boss! Yes, they gave us an amazing Sherlock Holmes cake for our annual charity ball for wounded veterans during BSI Weekend. And it was amazing. Lyndsay, Tiffany, and Maria sit down and talk about the process, the cake, the ball, and every delicious morsel in between.

info_outline
Episode 84: The Many Faces of Irene Adler show art Episode 84: The Many Faces of Irene Adler

The Baker Street Babes

BSB Amy and our good friend Chris Zordan discuss everything Irene Adler with a wonderful audience at 221B Con. Who was Irene Adler? Why is she so important to fans even though she only appears in one story? Taking on this larger than life adventuress that bested Sherlock Holmes is something many adaptations (all adaptations?) get kinda wrong. Why is that?

info_outline
Episode 83: Nancy Springer Live at 221B Con show art Episode 83: Nancy Springer Live at 221B Con

The Baker Street Babes

Join us for our live podcast at 221B Con speaking with the one and only Nancy Springer, author of the Enola Holmes series. Where did Enola come from? What was Nancy's favorite book? Why did Florence Nightingale have 56 white Persian cats?

info_outline
Episode 82: Baker Street in LA show art Episode 82: Baker Street in LA

The Baker Street Babes

It's not every day you find an entire re-creation of 221B Baker Street... it's even rarer when that re-creation is in Los Angeles. Chuck Kovacic is a longtime Sherlockian and utterly devoted to having the most authentic Sherlock Holmes sitting room in the world. The amount of detail and research that has been poured into the room where so many of the stories truly took place is nothing short of astounding.

info_outline
BSB Live & Local 6: Bonnie MacBird and Unquiet Spirits show art BSB Live & Local 6: Bonnie MacBird and Unquiet Spirits

The Baker Street Babes

Babe Ardy visits Bonnie MacBird for tea, shortbread, and a discussion of Unquiet Spirits, the second of MacBird's trilogy of Holmes pastiches. Join us to hear about what it's like to write and research a Holmes novel, including tales of location-scouting for books, and visiting whisky distilleries by way of research. We also chat about the historical background for the book and Ardy learns a lot about wine, whisky, and why writing a pastiche is both fun and challenging. .   The book is available at , , and all good bookshops! . You can .

info_outline
 
More Episodes

The Great Sherlock Holmes Debate took place on November 10th, featuring audience members from over 20 countries and panelists from all walks of Sherlockiana, including yours truly! The Baker Street Babes captained Team 1: BBC Sherlock in the debate to see which Sherlock Holmes adaptation has the most prolific effect on the 21st Century audience, keeping the spirit of Sherlock Holmes alive and expanding its notoreity.

We had an AMAZING team, which included;

Babes Curly, Ardy, Taylor, and Jenn, Jules, Emma, and David from Sherlockology, Roger Johnson of The Sherlock Holmes Society of London, Charlotte Ann Walters (Barefoot on Baker Street) and Dan Andriacco (Baker Street Beat) of Episode 10, and Kate Workman.

Seriously, thank you all SO much. We are happy to share this with you all, and we hope you enjoy!

 

You can read more about the debate at MX Publishing's tumblr here

You can find the slides with expanded arguments at the following link: Final Slides This way you can even follow along with the audio!

Many thanks to Steve Emecz for organizing the debate, which was no small feat.