Libsyn Directory

Murder By Moonlight - Chappaqua, New York

Release Date: 06/12/2025

Small Town Murder

This week, in Cadiz, Kentucky, an amazingly bloody quadruple murder scene seems like a miracle, when one survivor is left to tell the tale. He tells of a man, bursting into the home, and duct taping the inhabitants, then murdering three members of his family, until he finally wrestles the weapon away, and kills the intruder. Only, some parts of the story start to not add up, and what the evidence shows is one of the wildest, most insane murder plots in history!! Along the way, we find out that ham can go into a biscuit, that when someone is stalking your sister, you maybe shouldn't...

Murder Is Life - Lancaster, Texas

Small Town Murder

This week, in Lancaster, Texas, a brutal triple murder leaves detectives scrambling, but they don't know that the murderer, a dangerous man with a background of violence, had already been caught... and let go. When he is finally recaptured, he decides to confess, calling himself a "monster", but also decides to confess to many more murders, one of which ends up getting an wrongly convicted man off of death row!! Along the way, we find out that drunks are driving all over town, even at noon, that getting overcharged for a tire repair is not a reason for horrible murder, and that it seems...

Bloody Headless Mess - Shakopee, Minnesota

Small Town Murder

This week, in Shakopee, Minnesota, a crazy scene unfolds, when witnesses see a man removing a headless body from his car... in the middle of an intersection. He makes an insane excuse that somehow, he beheaded his wife, by accident, but it's obvious that more is going on. The killer has had mental problems for a while, including believing that his eyes have been removed, and cameras have been implanted in his body!! Along the way, we find out that you should always be wary of roller coasters, that when someone tries to burn themselves alive, they probably need some serious help, and...

Creepy Killer Motives - Wakefield, Massachusetts

Small Town Murder

This week, in Wakefield, Massachusetts, when two people are shockingly murdered, it leads detectives down a rabbit hole of mystery, with enemies, business associates, and even possible mafia connections. They end up settling on a much more personal, and nasty motive, all stemming from having fun times, at a lake house. It's a twisted story, filled with conspiracy, lies, partial truths, affairs, and maybe even some reasonable doubt! Along the way, we find out that no one loves mechanical bulls more than Italian people, that even spending time at a lake house can come with some stress,...

Kinky Cut Up Murder Insanity - Green Bay, Wisconsin

Small Town Murder

This week, in Green Bay, Wisconsin, one of the craziest stories, in recent history. A woman, with a strange past, gets together with her ex-boyfrined, while her husband is in prison. They have a drug fueled good time, until she decides that she doesn't want to stop choking him, during an intimate time. Police end up finding parts of him, scattered throughout a basement, and in a Crock Pot box. She also attacks her lawyer, in court, says she had sex with Jeffrey Dahmer, and more!! Along the way, we find out that the curbs are out to get you, in Wisconsin, that bad backgrounds often...

Serial Butcher Killer - Parkersburg, West Virginia

Small Town Murder

This week , in Parkersburg, West Virginia, what looks like a simple drug murder, at first, turns out to be anything but that. It turns out to be the work of a psychotic serial killer, who loves nothing more than cutting people into pieces, and even leaving heads displayed for maximum effect. He commits many more murders, and when he's finally caught, he scares even the most hardened detectives with his cold blooded violence!! Along the way, we find out that you can get a mansion in West Virginia at regular house prices, that if you see a head on your nightstand, you shouldn't look at...

Death Of The Dog Lady - Bellevue, Iowa

Small Town Murder

This week, in Bellevue, Iowa, a woman is horribly murdered, at her own business, just as she arrived for work. Her call to 911 recorded her last moments, and a name, that she screams out in terror. With all the evidence, including post-it notes, pointing at one man, he goes on the run. A manhunt ensues, with police worried that his survival skills will make him a tough one to catch. Will they find this maniac, on the run?? Along the way, we find out that horses should apparently not participate in parades, that you shouldn't rub poop on your mattress, no matter how mad you are at...

Murder By Moonlight - Chappaqua, New York

Small Town Murder

This week, in Chappaqua, New York, a brutal murder sends this extremely upscsale area into a panic, with ideas of a shadowy killer, lurking in the darkness. But the real story makes people begin to look in their own homes for monsters, after a prominent attorney's family suffers what appears to be a violent tragedy, but what turned out to be a diabolical, and well planned cold blooded murder! Affairs, scamming, and much more lead to the truth!! Or does it? Along the way, we find out that fires weren't the only thing that could take out a town, that yiou shouldn't crash into the...

Real Life Murder Songs - Farmville, Virginia

Small Town Murder

This week, in Farmville, Virginia, four people are found, unrecognizably brutalized, in an otherwise quiet neighborhood. This leads detectives to the family's teenage daughter's online love interest, a "horrorcore" rapper, who came to visit, after dropping out of school, due to being picked on. Will he confess all the horrific details, or will he insist on his innocence? Along the way, we find out that the town wasn't named after an annoying app based game, that "horrorcore" rap has quite a diverse group of participants, and that if you only rap about murdering people, you...

Angriest Serial Killer Around - Chester, Pennsylvania

Small Town Murder

This week, in Chester, Pennsylvania, a young woman, who happens to be a college athlete, disappears into the night, after leaving a bar. Her car is found, by the side of the road, door open & radio on, but her terribly brutalized body isn't found until the next day, with strange burns & other awful outcomes. After clearing a very guilty looking suspect, another, even guiltier looking man is found. His past makes it obvious that he's capable of such horrors. What he tells a cellmate is incredibly cold. Will it be enough to convict?? Along the way, we find out that you shouldn't...

More Episodes

Along the way, we find out that fires weren't the only thing that could take out a town, that yiou shouldn't crash into the emergency room, if you have a problem, and that you should never send your girlfriend flowers, on the day you plan to murder your wife!

New episodes every Wednesday night!!

Donate at patreon.com/crimeinsports or go to paypal.com and use our email: [email protected]

Go to shutupandgivememurder.com for all things Small Town Murder, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions!

instagram.com/smalltownmurder

facebook.com/smalltownpod

Also, listen to James & Jimmie's other shows, Crime In Sports & Your Stupid Opinions on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts!!

TOPICS