Unfinished: Encountering Jesus, Becoming Disciples - Failure Before Restoration

Unfinished: Encountering Jesus, Becoming Disciples - Failure Before Restoration (Matthew 16) - Rev. Donnell T. Wyche - a2vc.org. Like us on fb.com/vineyardannarboror watch our livestream Sundays @ 10:45am - vimeo.com/annarborvineyard

Summary:

In this week’s sermon, Pastor Donnell Wyche explores the tension between failure and restoration through the lens of Peter’s journey with Jesus. He begins by reflecting on our cultural obsession with success and how failure is often viewed as something to be avoided at all costs. Using a contemporary story of a student fabricating their achievements to appear more impressive, Pastor Donnell highlights how we often prioritize appearance over truth. He then turns to Peter, whose expectations of Jesus as a conquering Messiah clashed with Jesus’ actual mission. Peter, like many of us, struggled to trust God’s plan when it didn’t align with his assumptions, leading him to rebuke Jesus—a moment that resulted in Jesus’ sharp correction, calling him a “stumbling block.”

Pastor Donnell unpacks how Jesus radically redefined what it meant to be the Messiah. Unlike Judas Maccabeus, who led a rebellion, Jesus would defeat evil not through force but through selfless love and submission, ultimately going to the cross. This reversal of expectations unsettled Peter, just as it unsettles us when God’s plans challenge our understanding. Pastor Donnell draws parallels between Peter’s resistance and our own struggles to trust God, sharing personal experiences of advocacy and opposition. He emphasizes that when we stand for what is right, we will face resistance, much like Jesus did. The temptation, as seen in Jesus’ wilderness testing, is to take shortcuts—to trust power, control, and our own strength instead of surrendering to God’s way.

Bringing the message home, Pastor Donnell reminds us that failure is not the opposite of discipleship but an essential part of it. Peter’s failure in misunderstanding Jesus was not the end of his story; instead, Jesus later restores him, showing that grace is always present. As disciples, we must resist the belief that God is only on the side of success. Instead, we are called to trust God fully, even in failure. The sermon closes with a practical challenge: to reach out to someone we’ve been avoiding, acknowledging that reconciliation and restoration are core to following Jesus. Through Peter’s journey, we are invited to embrace both failure and grace, trusting that God is present in every part of our story.