Unfinished: Encountering Jesus, Becoming Disciples

Unfinished: Encountering Jesus, Becoming Disciples – John 21 - Martha Balmer - a2vc.org. Like us on fb.com/vineyardannarboror watch our livestream Sundays @ 10:45am - vimeo.com/annarborvineyard

Summary:

In this sermon, Martha Balmer explores the transformation of the apostle Peter in John 21, highlighting how discipleship is a journey of becoming. After Peter’s painful denial of Jesus, he fades into the background, wrestling with disillusionment and shame. But in the final chapter of John’s Gospel, Jesus reappears to him—not to rebuke or dismiss, but to restore. Through the familiar scene of a miraculous catch of fish and a simple meal by the sea, Jesus invites Peter back into discipleship. This passage demonstrates that every experience—our failures, doubts, and missteps—is part of how Jesus forms us into his likeness.

Peter’s journey illustrates that discipleship is not about never failing, but about being willing to return to Jesus, again and again. His encounter with Jesus by the fire—mirroring the setting of his denial—becomes a moment of grace. Three times, Jesus asks, “Do you love me?” not to shame Peter, but to reaffirm his calling. In this exchange, Peter is not only forgiven but recommissioned, given the charge to “feed my sheep.” This transformation shows how Jesus meets us in our worst moments, offering not condemnation but a path forward.

Martha closes by reminding us that we, too, are unfinished disciples, continually being shaped by Jesus. Like Peter, we may experience disillusionment with ourselves, but these moments are opportunities for deeper dependence on God’s grace. Through scripture, prayer, and community, we are formed into people who reflect Christ—not through perfection, but through persistent faithfulness. As Peter learned, following Jesus is a lifelong journey, one that invites us to let go of false identities and embrace the truth of who we are in Christ.