402: Tolkien - Certainly there was an Eden on this very unhappy earth
Release Date: 08/01/2025
Banned Books
Going Cold Turkey at Christmas? In this episode, we read G.K. Chesterton’s essay, On Christmas, wherein he discusses celebrating Christmas too early, vivisection, vegetarians versus turkeys, and what to do about the poor at Christmas. It’s another curmudgeonly Christmas episode with one of our favorite British apologists and satirists. SHOW NOTES: "On Christmas" by G. K. Chesterton A Christmas Message for Contemporary Pagans https://www.1517.org/articles/a-christmas-message-for-contemporary-pagans More from 1517: : http://www.1517.org/podcasts : :...
info_outlineBanned Books
I’m Wasted, and I Can’t Find My Way Home. In this episode, we again invite C.S. Lewis to teach us about Christmas. We also discuss the early church fathers, worship, symbolism, mystery, Freud and Jung’s influence on modern Christians, consumerism and gift-giving, and, of course, Christmas: all this and much, much more on this episode of the podcast. SHOW NOTES: What CHRISTMAS means to me... Xmas and Christmas: A Lost Chapter from Herodotus Christian Wonder Tales by Martin Shaw The Quest for the Holy Grail by Dr. Martin Shaw More from 1517: :...
info_outlineBanned Books
In this episode, we read C.S. Lewis’ “A Christmas Sermon for Pagans.” Why does the post-Christian person need to become pagan again to be prepared to hear the gospel? How has a mechanistic view of nature led us to kill each other? Why do we reject the good news that Jesus ended the need for guilt-offerings, sin-sacrifices, and fear about the afterlife? What happened as a consequence of moderns pushing heavenly truth out of the material world? What is the message of Christmas that offers a cure for all that ails us? SHOW NOTES: A Christmas Sermon for Pagans More from...
info_outlineBanned Books
Son of a Preacher Man. In this episode, we conclude our study of Martin Luther’s Smalcald Articles, discussing the office of the keys and confession. We go through and sum up the previous episodes — the gospel, the mass, repentance, sin, and the law — then sit with the function and power of the forgiveness of sin. What is the office of the keys for? Where does it come from? Who gets to use the keys? Then, we talk over confession and its consequences for pastoral care and its effect on the churches. SHOW NOTES: The Book of Concord - Smalcald Articles Smalcald Articles history ...
info_outlineBanned Books
How Deep Is Your Love! In this episode, we continue our reading of the Smalcald Articles, focusing our attention on sin and the law. What is sin? What does it do to us? What are its effects? And, in following, what is the relationship of the law to sin? Does the law empower us to sin less? Can the law produce good works and good fruits? What is the function of pastoral care in relation to sin and the law? All this and much, much more on this episode of the podcast. SHOW NOTES: The Book of Concord - Smalcald Articles Smalcald Articles history The Smalcald Articles are a summary of...
info_outlineBanned Books
Don’t Look Back in Anger. In this episode, we continue reading Martin Luther’s Smalcald Articles, focusing on contrition, repentance, and freedom. Why does the law need to terrify and leave us hopeless? How does attention to the self lead us into death and hell? What happens when belief is preached as something “we do” rather than something “done to” us? Likewise, when repentance is self-activated and self-actuated, what are the consequences for our daily lives? This and much, much more on this episode of the show. SHOW NOTES: The Book of Concord - Smalcald Articles ...
info_outlineBanned Books
Mass Effect. In this episode, we continue our reading of The Smalcald Articles, focusing on Luther’s critique of the Roman Mass and all its consequences for the churches and Christian life. We discuss mimetic desire, sacrificial religion, the exclusive work of Jesus. SHOW NOTES: The Book of Concord - Smalcald Articles Smalcald Articles history The Smalcald Articles are a summary of Lutheran doctrine written by Martin Luther in 1537 for a meeting of the Schmalkaldic League, which aimed to unify Lutheran territories against Roman Catholic forces. Although they were not officially...
info_outlineBanned Books
An Arm-Twisting Confession. In this episode, we read Martin Luther’s Smalcald Articles on the gospel, baptism, and the Lord’s Supper. Why did he have to have “his arm twisted” to write them? What is he trying to teach the churches about the gospel? How does the gospel circumscribe and define the Church, worship, and Christian life? Why does something written in the 1530s matter today? We look to answer all these questions and more on this episode of the Banned Books podcast. SHOW NOTES: The Book of Concord - Smalcald Articles Smalcald Articles history Edward Riojas Study Guide...
info_outlineBanned Books
The Never-Ending Story of our Bound Will & Election. In this episode, we write an epilogue —so to speak— to our series on the Bondage of the Will and wrap up our thoughts about the Here We Still Stand Conference 2025. We ask, “From whence comes a preacher?” Where does one go for gospel-comfort and the gifts of salvation? What is the Gospel? What is the purpose of the Church? What are the practical consequences of having a will that is bound up to sin, the world, and the evil one? What happens when the churches reject the “hinge” upon which all doctrines turn? And we talk about...
info_outlineBanned Books
For What It’s Worth. In this episode, we conclude our reading of Gerhard Forde’s "Captivation of the Will." We discuss the conclusion of Luther’s treatise on the bound will, arriving at Christ and election, which reveals Erasmus’s fundamental error — his argument for the human will is actually the original sin, choosing between good and evil. SHOW NOTES: The Captivation of the Will: Luther Vs. Erasmus on Freedom and Bondage by Gerhard O. Forde HWSS SD 2025 The Gospel for Those Broken By the Church Bunyan’s “Pilgrim’s Progress” episodes: , , , , , , ,...
info_outlineGot A Machine Head. In this episode, we read J.R.R. Tolkien’s letter to his son, Christopher, about a question of Genesis’ unfashionable status amongst Christians and those who value beautiful ‘stories.’ He also discusses Eden as it was, as it is to faith, and will be on the last day, the war of the machine, its triumph, and the consequences for modern man.
SHOW NOTES:
The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien: Revised and Expanded Edition https://amzn.to/45fGOFc
Löhe Martyrology https://emmanuelpress.us/wp-content/uploads/2011/01/loehe_martyrologium.pdf
The Parental dead end of consent morality https://world.hey.com/dhh/the-parental-dead-end-of-consent-morality-e4e8a8ee
Large intersection with Luther v. Erasmus: https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m002f9f4
Billie Holiday and Strange Fruit https://www.biography.com/musicians/billie-holiday-strange-fruit
More from 1517:
- Support 1517 Podcast Network: https://www.1517.org/donate-podcasts
- 1517 Podcasts: http://www.1517.org/podcasts
- 1517 on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@1517org
- 1517 Podcast Network on Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/channel/1517-podcast-network/id6442751370
- 1517 Events Schedule: https://www.1517.org/events
- 1517 Academy - Free Theological Education: https://academy.1517.org/
What’s New from 1517:
- Sinner Saint by By Luke Kjolhaug: https://shop.1517.org/products/9781964419152-sinner-saint
- The Impossible Prize: A Theology of Addiction by Donavan Riley: https://shop.1517.org/products/9781962654708-the-impossible-prize
- Ditching the Checklist by Mark Mattes: https://shop.1517.org/products/9781962654791-ditching-the-checklist
- Broken Bonds: A Novel of the Reformation, Book 1 of 2 by Amy Mantravadi: https://www.amazon.com/dp/1962654753?ref_=cm_sw_r_cp_ud_dp_FCNEEK60MVNVPCEGKBD8_5&starsLeft=1
More from the hosts:
- Donovan Riley https://www.1517.org/contributors/donavon-riley
- Christopher Gillespie https://www.1517.org/contributors/christopher-gillespie
MORE LINKS:
Tin Foil Haloes https://t.me/bannedpastors
Warrior Priest Gym & Podcast https://thewarriorpriestpodcast.wordpress.com
St John's Lutheran Church (Webster, MN) - FB Live Bible Study Group https://www.facebook.com/groups/356667039608511
Donavon's Substack https://donavonlriley.substack.com
Gillespie's Substack https://substack.com/@christophergillespie
Gillespie's Sermons and Catechesis http://youtube.com/stjohnrandomlake
Gillespie Coffee https://gillespie.coffee
Gillespie Media https://gillespie.media
CONTACT and FOLLOW:
Email mailto:BannedBooks@1517.org
Facebook https://www.facebook.com/BannedBooksPod/
Twitter https://twitter.com/bannedbooks1517
SUBSCRIBE:
YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@BannedBooks
Rumble https://rumble.com/c/c-1223313
Odysee https://odysee.com/@bannedbooks:5
Apple Podcasts https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/banned-books/id1370993639
Spotify https://open.spotify.com/show/2ahA20sZMpBxg9vgiRVQba