Cosmology, Epistemology, Methodology: Back to Basics with Dr. Shadee Elmasry
Release Date: 11/08/2016
MuslimMan™
If you can bear with the awful audio quality of this recording, you are going to really enjoy this interview. Recently, I was interviewed by the BBC for their Heart and Soul podcast for a documentary about the rise of the Muslim manosphere. When I recorded this interview, I had to do it off of a screen share. I didn’t get the Zoom recording. I asked them for the recording but they refused, it’s not something they do. So I had to ninja record it. Alhamdulillah that I did, because they used less than 5% of a 45-minute interview. But the audio quality turned out to be really bad. So I had to...
info_outlineMuslimMan™
The Boys In The Cave podcast recently interviewed Becoming The Alpha Muslim. After publishing the episode, they faced criticism and pressure from SJW Muslims online. They caved to the pressure and took down the episode. Here is the full, unedited interview for your listening pleasure.
info_outlineMuslimMan™
In this episode I talk to serial entrepreneur Hodan Ibrahim about:
info_outlineMuslimMan™
I had the chance to sit down to talk to Hussein Kesvani about his work as a Muslim journalist. He's the UK/Europe editor for Mel Magazine, an online men's magazine. He's also written for Buzzfeed, Vice, The Independent, The Guardian, The New Statesman, The Shortlist, and Refinery29. He's a co-host of the No Country For Brown Men Podcast and also the Trash Future podcast. Hussein and I talked about the state of modern journalism, where it's heading, and how Muslim men can get their start in the industry.
info_outlineMuslimMan™
It's a little after one year since Donald J Trump was inaugurated as the 45th President of the United States of America.
info_outlineMuslimMan™
Every Muslim man needs to learn how to network in a way that is natural and doesn't seem fake. The key here is to not BE fake. To genuinely be interested in people and want to invest in the relationship.
info_outlineMuslimMan™
My guest this episode is dating and relationship coach, Pat Stedman.
info_outlineMuslimMan™
In this episode of the Becoming the Alpha Muslim podcast we are talking to Hussein, a Muslim Chicagoan and the founder of the Streets of Cordoba podcast. It's a brand new podcast focusing on Muslim issues in the West.
info_outlineMuslimMan™
I wasted my 20s. Here’s how: a Born Muslim’s Convert Story. It was all necessary. Those experiences made me who I am today. But that doesn’t mean others have to make the same mistakes, or worse. You don’t have to learn the hard way. Most of you will, because you don’t listen to people with more experience than you. Some of you won’t. You’re the smart ones. This post is for you. Like me, Alexander Juan Antonio Cortes wasted his 20s. I asked him to join me on the show to talk about the mistakes
info_outlineMuslimMan™
My guest this episode is Ed Latimore. Ed is a professional heavyweight boxer, physicist, published author, and self-improvement blogger.
info_outlineMy guest today is Dr. Shadee Elmasry
Dr. Shadee Elmasry was born and raised in New Jersey.
He began studying the traditiona
Since then he has studied all over the world including Hadramawt (Yemen), Mecca and Madina (Saudi Arabia), London (UK), Cairo (Egypt) and New Jersey (U.S.) under several luminaries.
He received a PhD in Islamic Studies from the University of London, School of Oriental and African Studies.
He is currently the Scholar in Residence and Director of Education and Community Affairs at the New Brunswick Islamic Center in New Jersey.
He is also the founder and head of Safina Society - an
You can follow Dr. Shadee on Twitter and Facebook.
Time-stamped show notes:
03:20 Why has Islamic Aqidah (Creed) become a bad word among Muslims in the West?
07:40 The three-part foundation to understanding Islam
- Cosmology - what do we believe exists?
- Epistemology - what are our sources of truth?
- Methodology - how do we interpret these sources?
12:33 Cosmology is where believers split with atheists.
13:45 Epistemology is where mainstream Muslims (Sunni Muslims in general) split from the deviant sects in Islam and all other religions.
16:55 Methodology is where mainstream Muslims will differ in their interpretations of Islam. Some interpretations fall within the scope of correct methodology while others do not.
23:43 What happens when someone who claims to be Muslim denies one of the axiomatic tenets of Islam? Those things that are necessarily known as part of the faith. (Arabic - ma'lum min ad-din bi 'dh-dharurah)
24:45 Dr. Shadee goes off on Big Dawah. the Dawah establishment. (I've seen this term used formally once before; I think we should make it stick.)
27:30 Dawah is a failed enterprise if it's not grounded in knowledge.
28:35 I comment on how Dr. Shadee's strategy of sticking to the masjid and using the internet and social media to spread knowledge is the safest bet.
31:47 Dr. Shadee gives the example of Sheikh Murabit Al-Hajj, who lives in a Mauritanian desert camp while his students travel from all over the World to live and study with him.
32:56 I mention one of the fundamental maxims of Islamic law - avoidance of harm takes precedence over seeking benefit.
34:42 Dr. Shadee tries to stay as financially independent as possible because the guy who writes your check owns you.
37:05 Stand by your principles and people will respect you.
38:40 Dr. Shadee explains the result of politically correct preachers.
41:40 The fake unity of politically correct Islam, and the selfishness of Muslims who don't unequivocally make the Truth clear.
45:10 How to know who to spend your time with: ask yourself "would I trade my Book of Deeds with that person on Judgement Day?"
47:10 In religion, the old way is the right way.
48:15 A personal development principle that's relevant to Dawah. Fall in love with the process, not the results.
49:40 The differences between Grassroots Dawah (in the masjid) and Big Dawah.
50:20 Doing what's best for your audience - the Web Analytics and Bounce Rate Analogy.
51:30 Identifying the true metrics of success as opposed to vanity metrics.
53:40 Allah asks Ibrahim to call all the people of the World to Hajj and He will make sure the message is conveyed.
57:05 How should Muslims go about gaining the understanding of the fundamentals - cosmology, epistemology, methodology.
1:02:42 How should a beginner student approach studying Aqidah?
1:07:40 The importance of studying the history of the transmission of the Quran and Hadith - the need of the time.
1:13:07 Why are we being negative and sounding off these alarms?
1:16:30 The fasiq (sinful) Muslims of the past had a better Aqidah than some of the Muslim academics today.
1:18:00 The Muslim community can sometimes be more dangerous to a Muslim's faith than any non-Muslim.
1:19:45 My concern over my daughters reading and being brainwashed by deviant websites like Muslim Girl, Tempest, and Altmuslimah.
1:22:30 The importance of the student guarding his humility.
1:23:00 Why does Dr. Shadee refrain from speaking about politics? Is that on purpose?
1:24:12 If you want to do one great thing you have to say no to a hundred good things.
1:24:50 What sort of classes does Safina Society offer?
1:28:40 Segregation of the sexes is a feature of all traditional societies. The longest-surviving, most successful societies seperate genders and mix ages - modern Western society does the opposite.
1:30:24 How do people enroll in Safina Society classes? Do they have online classes?
1:32:50 To close out the show I ask Dr. Shadee to give Becoming the Alpha Muslim readers his #1 piece of advice.
If you enjoyed listening to this episode, please leave be a rating and review on iTunes or Stitcher.