Episode 466: Christmas Carnage with special guest Eddie Kingston
What Happened When
On this special Christmas Eve edition of What Happened When, Tony and Conrad are joined by AEW superstar and friend of the show Eddie Kingston! Eddie brings his one-of-a-kind personality for a Ring of Honor watch-along like no other, handpicking three unforgettable battles guaranteed to keep you on the edge of your seat. The lineup includes: • 08.16.2003 – ROH Bitter Friends, Stiffer Enemies: Homicide vs. Steve Corino • 12.17.2005 – ROH Final Battle: KENTA vs. Low Ki It’s a hard-hitting, emotional, and unforgettable Christmas Eve episode of What Happened When that wrestling fans...
info_outline
Episode 465: Blanchard versus Windham "88
What Happened When
On this REMIX episode of What Happened When, Tony and Conrad head to Richmond, Virginia for a hard-hitting, old-school classic from January 23, 1988, as Tully Blanchard goes one-on-one with Western States Champion Barry Windham. This match is a perfect snapshot of late-’80s NWA-style wrestling — intense, physical, and built on grit, psychology, and realism. Tully brings his trademark arrogance and precision, while Windham counters with raw power, athleticism, and championship pride. BLUECHEW - Visit . and try your first month of BlueChew FREE when you use promo code WHW -- just pay...
info_outline
Episode 464: Christopher Daniels Takeover!
What Happened When
On this episode of What Happened When, Tony and Conrad welcome AEW coach and Ring of Honor legend Christopher Daniels to the show! The Fallen Angel sits down with the guys to reflect on his iconic career and revisit some of his most unforgettable battles inside the squared circle. From clashes with El Generico, Claudio Castagnoli, Kenny Omega, Bryan Danielson, and so many more, this episode is a heartfelt and action-packed look back at the legacy of one of wrestling’s most respected veterans. Sit back and enjoy a deep dive into the storied career of The Fallen Angel Christopher Daniels! BUBS...
info_outline
Episode 463: Monsters Of The Mat
What Happened When
On this episode of What Happened When, Tony and Conrad take us back to the 1980s for some truly bizarre in-ring action from Chicagoland’s very own Bob Luce! Bob Luce’s Monsters of the Mat embraced the wild, the wacky, and the downright creepy sides of professional wrestling. From mind-controlling sinister ministers to nearly unintelligible Kentucky beasts, this show had it all — and Tony and Conrad are here to relive every outrageous moment. BLUECHEW - Visit and try your first month of BlueChew FREE when you use promo code WHW -- just pay $5 shipping. STOPBOX - Get firearm...
info_outline
Episode 462: Tony Joins Mid Atlantic Championship Wrestling
What Happened When
On this flashback edition of What Happened When, Tony and Conrad head back to the 1980s—when Tony first joined Mid-Atlantic Championship Wrestling! Tony reflects on meeting the legendary Bob Caudle, falling in love with professional wrestling as a fan, and the moment he discovered the business was predetermined. It’s a fun, heartfelt look at where it all began for our beloved host. Plus, the guys share plenty of laughs as they unpack and react to some truly bizarre social media posts from wrestling legend Marty Jannetty. This one is equal parts nostalgia and pure WHW chaos! BLUECHEW -...
info_outline
Episode 461: A Hero's Journey
What Happened When
On this episode of What Happened When, Tony pays tribute to one of the greats, Bob Caudle. The guys are then joined by AEW coach and wrestling legend Chris Hero to revisit some of the most memorable matches of his storied career. Chris guides the guys through his unforgettable battles with Kenny Omega, Bryan Danielson, Austin Aries, Kota Ibushi, and The Briscoes — offering insight, stories, and behind-the-scenes moments only he can provide. Plus, Efren's back with another incredible Game Event that'll have you on the edge of your seat. This is a WHW you absolutely can’t miss! ...
info_outline
Episode 460: ROH Death Before Dishonor IV
What Happened When
On this episode of What Happened When, Tony and Conrad dive into Ring of Honor’s Death Before Dishonor IV! The guys relive the excitement of this standout ROH event, breaking down three epic matches, moments, and rising stars that helped define one of wrestling’s most influential promotions and are now major parts of All Elite Wrestling. From hard-hitting action to insight you won't hear anywhere else, Tony and Conrad bring their signature humor and storytelling to another fun watch-along of a true ROH classic. RAYCON - Raycon’s going big for Black Friday and Cyber Monday —...
info_outline
Episode 459: Tony Watches PWG with Excalibur!
What Happened When
On this episode of What Happened When, Tony and Conrad are joined by Tony’s AEW commentary partner — the man behind the mask himself, Excalibur! The guys sit back and watch Pro Wrestling Guerrilla’s 2011 Steen Wolf, featuring some of the wildest action from one of wrestling’s most beloved independent promotions. It’s Tony’s first-ever PWG watch-along, and who better to guide him through it than Excalibur? Get ready for laughs, insight, and plenty of jaw-dropping moments on this unique edition of What Happened When! BLUECHEW - Visit and try your first month of BlueChew...
info_outline
Episode 458: The Stars Of CHIKARA
What Happened When
On this episode of What Happened When, Tony and Conrad dive into the wild, colorful world of CHIKARA! The guys sit back and enjoy a collection of matches featuring future AEW stars like Eddie Kingston, Brodie Lee, Daddy Magic, and Orange Cassidy — back when he was known as Red Fire Ant! From hilarious moments to pure wrestling magic, Tony and Conrad relive the fun, creativity, and charm that made CHIKARA such a beloved part of wrestling history. All that and plenty of laughs on this unique edition of What Happened When! RAYCON - Raycon’s going big for Black Friday and Cyber Monday —...
info_outline
Episode 457: Ring Of Honor Spectacles
What Happened When
On this episode of What Happened When, Tony and Conrad travel back 15 years to relive three unforgettable showcases from Ring of Honor’s Honor Club! Tony experiences for the very first time a wrestling classic between two future Hall of Famers — AJ Styles vs. Bryan Danielson — a match that still ranks among Conrad’s all-time favorites. Then, the guys watch a wild cage match scramble that’ll leave you wondering how anyone walked away without broken bones! And finally, Tony sees firsthand why The Briscoe Brothers are considered one of the greatest tag teams of all time. Plus, Efren...
info_outlineOn this episode of What Happened When, Tony and Conrad take us back to 1985 for some good ol' Memphis action! The guys discuss the reputation of Bruiser Brody, watch Randy Savage in action before his WWF run, and do commentary on some incredible commercials of the era. Get ready for some fun southern style on this episode of What Happened When!
PRIZE PICKS - Visit https://prizepicks.onelink.me/LME0/WHW and use code WHW to get $50 in lineups after you pay your first $5 lineup!
BLUECHEW - Visit https://bluechew.com and try your first month of BlueChew FREE when you use promo code WHW -- just pay $5 shipping.
THEME MACHINE - John Carney, a celebrated St. Louis radio icon, has dedicated his career to capturing the essence of American storytelling. As an inductee into the Radio Hall of Fame, alongside his father Jack Carney, John brings a wealth of experience and a unique interviewing style to The Theme Machine. Available now wherever you find your podcasts.WHW 448: Bruiser Brody Attacks!
SAVE WITH CONRAD - Stop throwing money away by paying those high interest rates on your credit card. Roll them into one low monthly payment and on top of that, skip your next two house payments. Go to https://www.savewithconrad.com to learn more.