EP244 The Future of SOAPA: Jon Oltsik on Platform Consolidation vs. Best-of-Breed in the Age of Agentic AI
Cloud Security Podcast by Google
Release Date: 09/22/2025
Cloud Security Podcast by Google
Guests: No guests! Just Tim and Anton Topics: Hard to believe we've been doing these since 2022, is that right? What did we see this year at RSA, apart from AI? And more AI? And more AI? What framework can we use to understand the approaches vendors take to AI and security? Just saying “AI washing” is not enough! How to tell “AI washer” from “AI tourist”? I sense that “securing AI” (and agents) is finally growing as fast as "using AI for security”, do you agree? Is the AI vulnerability apocalypse coming? Soon? Have we seen any signs of AI backlash? Resource: ...
info_outlineCloud Security Podcast by Google
Guests: , Senior Manager, Threat Analysis, Mandiant, Google Cloud , Mandiant Incident Response, Google Cloud Topics: Do we need to rethink "Mean Time to Respond" entirely, or are we just in deep trouble? Why are threat groups collaborating so well, and are there actual lessons for defenders in their "business" model? What is the scalable advice for teams worried about voice phishing and GenAI cloning? What does "weaponizing the administrative fabric" actually mean in a world where identity is the perimeter? Why is identity/SaaS compromise "news" in 2026 when cloud security folks have...
info_outlineCloud Security Podcast by Google
Guest: , Operating Advisor, a SIEM legend since 1999 Topics: You argue that declaring existing SIEM being obsolete is a "marketing slogan" rather than a true thesis. What is the real pain point and the actual gap in traditional SIEMs as opposed to the more sensational claims? You highlight that "correlation, state, timelines, and real-time detection require locality," making centralization a necessary trade-off. Can a truly federated or decoupled SIEM architecture achieve the same fidelity and real-time performance for complex, stateful detections as a centralized one? You call the rise of...
info_outlineCloud Security Podcast by Google
Guest: , , author of Topics: Your book focuses on the US, China, and Russia. When you were planning the book did you also want to cover players like Israel, Iran, and North Korea? Most of our listeners are migrating to or operating heavily in the cloud. As nations refine their “digital battlefield” strategies, does the "shared responsibility model" actually hold up against a nation-state actor? How does a company’s detection strategy need to change when the adversary isn't a teenager looking for a ransom, but a state-funded group whose goal might be long-term persistence or subtle...
info_outlineCloud Security Podcast by Google
Guest: , CEO and co-founder @ Topics: focuses on securing generative AI in use. Can you walk us through a real, anonymized example of a data leak caused by employee AI usage that your platform has identified? AI governance gets thrown around a lot. What does this mean in the context of Shadow AI? How should organizations be thinking about governing AI in light of upcoming AI regulations in the US and in the EU? If we generally agree that employees are using AI tools before they are sanctioned, how can organizations control this? Network, API, endpoint? Many organizations struggle with the...
info_outlineCloud Security Podcast by Google
Guests: , Global Deputy CISO, Allianz SE , Director of D&R, Google Topics: We’ve spent decades obsessed with MTTD (Mean Time to Detect) and MTTR (Mean Time to Respond). As AI agents begin to handle the bulk of triage at machine speed, do these metrics become "vanity metrics"? If an AI resolves an alert in seconds, does measuring the "mean" still tell us anything about the health of our security program, or should we be looking at "Time to Context" instead? You mentioned the Maturity Triangle. Can you walk us through that framework? Specifically, how does AI change the balance between...
info_outlineCloud Security Podcast by Google
Guest: , VP of Threat Detection and Response, Fiserv Topics: What is the right way for people to bridge the gap and translate executive dreams and board goals into the reality of life on the ground? How do we talk to people who think they have "transformed" their SOC simply by buying a better, shinier product (like a modern SIEM) while leaving their old processes intact? What are the specific challenges and advantages you’ve seen with a federated SOC versus a centralized one? What does a "federated" or "sub-SOC" model actually mean in practice? Why is the message that "EDR doesn't cover...
info_outlineCloud Security Podcast by Google
Guest: , Global CISO at Topics: You mentioned that centralized security can't work anymore. Can you elaborate on the key changes—driven by cloud, SaaS, and AI—that have made this traditional model unsustainable for a modern organization? Why do some persist at centralized, top down approach to security, despite that? What do you mean by "Freedom, Responsibility and distributed security”? Can you explain the difference between “centralized security” and what you define as “security with distributed ownership”? Is this the same “federated”? In our...
info_outlineCloud Security Podcast by Google
Guest: , Director of Detection Engineering at UKG Topics: We ended our season . In your opinion, are we living in the world that the guests describe in ? Do you think AI-powered attacks are really here, and if so, what is your plan to respond? Is it faster patching? Better D&R? Something else altogether? Your team has a hybrid agent workflow: could you tell us what that means? Also, define “AI agent” please. What are your production use cases for AI and AI agents in your SOC? What are your overall SOC metrics and how does the agentic AI part play into that?...
info_outlineCloud Security Podcast by Google
Guest: , CEO at Topic: Why is agent security so different from “just” LLM security? Why now? Agents are coming, sure, but they are - to put it mildly - not in wide use. Why create now and not wait for people to make the mistakes? It sounds like “agents + IAM” is a disaster waiting to happen. What should be our approach for solving this? Do we have one? Which one agentic AI risk keeps you up at night? Is there an interesting AI shared responsibility angle here? Agent developer, operator, downstream system operator? We are having a lot of experimentation, but sometimes little...
info_outlineGuest:
- Jon Oltsik, security researcher, ex-ESG analyst
Topics:
- You invented the concept of SOAPA – Security Operations & Analytics Platform Architecture. As we look towards SOAPA 2025, how do you see the ongoing debate between consolidating security around a single platform versus a more disaggregated, best-of-breed approach playing out?
- What are the key drivers for either strategy in today's complex environments? How can we have both “decoupling” and platformization going at the same time?
- With all the buzz around Generative AI and Agentic AI, how do you envision these technologies changing the future of the Security Operations Center (and SOAPA of course)?
- Where do you see AI really work today in the SOC and what is the proof of that actually happening? What does a realistic "AI SOC" look like in the next few years, and what are the practical implications for security teams?
- “Integration” is always a hot topic in security - and it has been for decades. Within the context of SOAPA and the adoption of advanced analytics, where do you see the most critical integration challenges today – whether it's vendor-centric ecosystems, strategic partnerships, or the push for open standards?
Resources:
- Jon Oltsik “The Cybersecurity Bridge” podcast (Anton on it)
- EP236 Accelerated SIEM Journey: A SOC Leader's Playbook for Modernization and AI
- EP242 The AI SOC: Is This The Automation We've Been Waiting For?
- EP202 Beyond Tiered SOCs: Detection as Code and the Rise of Response Engineering
- EP180 SOC Crossroads: Optimization vs Transformation - Two Paths for Security Operations Center
- EP170 Redefining Security Operations: Practical Applications of GenAI in the SOC
- EP73 Your SOC Is Dead? Evolve to Output-driven Detect and Respond!
- Daniel Suarez “Daemon” book and its sequel “Delta V”