Episode 07: How well are financial advisors serving client sustainability needs?
Release Date: 05/14/2024
Sustainability In Motion
We talked with Helen Neal, Founder and CEO of HN Communications, a sustainability communications company that helps companies effectively navigate a complicated sustainability landscape. We discuss greenwashing, greenhushing and how companies can best tell their sustainability story.
info_outlineSustainability In Motion
In Episode 21 of Sustainability in Motion, Matt Orsagh and Maria Maisuradze speak with Jo Paisley, President of the GARP Risk Institute, about the evolving landscape of sustainability risk in the financial sector. With deep experience from the Bank of England to HSBC, Jo brings a unique lens on how financial professionals can better prepare for climate and nature-related challenges. We cover: Jo’s journey from economist and regulator to sustainability thought leader What GARP and the GARP Risk Institute are doing to advance risk literacy in sustainability Key findings from their...
info_outlineSustainability In Motion
In this eye-opening episode, we unpack the quiet crisis in corporate governance: how boardrooms are often shaped by personal networks over real skills, leaving major ESG blind spots at the top. Guest Matt Moscardi, Co-founder of Free Float Analytics, joins us to explore signals that companies send by backtracking on their commitment and why treating investment stewardship as a cost center may be a costly mistake. We dive into the DEI backlash, flip-flopping climate commitments, and how surface-level sustainability reports (complete with curated optics) reveal more about a company’s culture...
info_outlineSustainability In Motion
We talk with Victoria Hurth, a Pracademic (practitioner and academic) to help define and describe a well-being economy. We discuss how to get to a wellbeing economy from our current state, and what companies and investors need to do to move in that direction.
info_outlineSustainability In Motion
We talk about the issue of income inequality and why understanding income inequality is important for investors. We discuss the causes of inequality, the ways that inequality impacts our economy and investments. Listeners can learn ways to measure income inequality, and how to integrate inequality analysis and analysis of other systemic issues into the investment process.
info_outlineSustainability In Motion
In this episode, Matt, Maria, and Nawar reflect on their 2024 sustainability predictions and look ahead to what’s coming in 2025. They discuss the ESG backlash, evolving sustainability regulations, and key trends shaping the future. Tune in as they analyze past forecasts and make bold predictions for the year ahead! 🎙️🌍
info_outlineSustainability In Motion
In this episode of the Sustainability in Motion podcast, hosts Matt Orsagh and Maria Maisuradze engage in an insightful discussion with William Burckart, CEO of the Investment Integration Project (TIIP), which helps investors integrate systems thinking in the investment process. The conversation explores the transformative concept of systems-level investing, a forward-thinking approach that integrates financial, social, environmental, and economic systems to address systemic risks such as climate change, inequality, and resource scarcity. Key highlights include: Introduction to Systems-Level...
info_outlineSustainability In Motion
Episode Overview: In this episode, Matt Orsagh and Nawar Alsaadi of ED4S sit down with Jon Lukomnik, a leading figure in sustainable finance and co-author of Moving Beyond Modern Portfolio Theory. Jon explores the limitations of Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT) in addressing long-term, systemic risks like climate change, highlighting the evolution toward "system-level investing." Key Takeaways: Limitations of MPT: MPT is designed for idiosyncratic risk (individual asset variance) but fails to account for systemic risks, which cannot be diversified away. Lukomnik notes that while MPT...
info_outlineSustainability In Motion
Hosts: Matt Orsagh, Chief Content Officer at ED4S Nawar Alsaadi, CEO of Kanata Advisors, Chief Advisor at ED4S Guest: Natasha Chaudhary, Research Fellow at The Institute for Climate Economics (I4CE) Episode Focus: The concept of stranded assets and a shift toward "assets at risk" to better support financial institutions in navigating climate-related financial risks. Key Takeaways: Stranded Assets Explained: Traditionally associated with fossil fuels, stranded assets refer to devalued resources due to regulatory, market, or physical climate changes. Current definitions often focus on...
info_outlineSustainability In Motion
Hosts: Matt Orsagh, Chief Content Officer at ED4S Maria Maisuradze, Founder and CEO of ED4S Nawar Alsaadi, CEO of Kanata Advisors, Senior Advisor to ED4S Episode Focus: A discussion on ED4S’s new paper, “Operationalizing Sustainability: Eight Key Roles in Finance,” which offers practical guidance for embedding sustainability in financial roles. Key Takeaways: Purpose of the Paper: This paper addresses how financial professionals can operationalize sustainability in their day-to-day roles. As organizations mature in ESG, there is a need to integrate sustainability practices within...
info_outlineSustainability in Motion Podcast – Episode 7: How well are financial advisors serving client sustainability needs?
Hosts:
- Matt Orsagh, Chief Content Officer at ED4S
- Maria Maisuradze, CEO of ED4S
- Guest: Stephen Kibsey, Analyst, Portfolio Manager, and Lecturer
Episode Overview:
This episode dives into ED4S’s latest report from a “secret shopper” campaign, evaluating how well financial advisers across Canada handle client interest in sustainable investing. ED4S engaged financial advisers from various firms to understand their readiness to meet clients’ ESG and sustainability goals. Joined by secret shopper Stephen Kibsey, the discussion unpacks the findings, challenges, and potential solutions to improve sustainable investing advice.
Key Takeaways:
-
Background and Motivation
- Maria Maisuradze shares her experience with financial advisers who were dismissive of sustainable investment inquiries, which inspired the secret shopper initiative. Since Canada’s regulations now require ESG factors to be part of the "Know Your Client" process, this study seeks to understand if advisers are integrating these requirements effectively.
-
Study Findings
- Less than 25% of advisers mentioned ESG or sustainability without prompting, even though surveys indicate strong client demand for these considerations. Once prompted, about 67% of advisers addressed ESG topics, yet only half demonstrated a good understanding of various ESG approaches.
-
Challenges for Advisers
- High turnover, lack of formalized training, and a disconnect between personal interest and corporate priorities hinder advisers’ ability to fully serve clients seeking ESG investment options. Even advisers with over 10 hours of sustainability training sometimes struggled to effectively guide clients.
-
Importance of Training and Incentives
- Both Stephen and Maria stress the need for better ESG training and communication. Maria points out that the complexity of fund sheets and inconsistent ESG labeling adds confusion. Additionally, Stephen highlights that financial institutions should invest in ongoing, practical education and tools for advisers.
-
Cultural Shift in Financial Institutions
- To truly embed sustainability, companies need support from top leadership. A culture that values ESG, starting from the CEO, will drive meaningful change across financial services, aligning firms with long-term sustainability goals.
Conclusion:
This secret shopper report highlights a clear gap between client demand for sustainable investing and the financial industry’s ability to deliver. Better training, incentives, and alignment from the top down can bridge this gap, ensuring advisers are prepared to meet the growing interest in ESG investing.
----