Surgery is Not More Cost Effective Than Active Surveillance, with Dr. Jeremy Freeman from Mt. Sinai
Release Date: 03/07/2023
Doctor Thyroid
I share my personal journey with thyroid surgery performed by Dr. Michael Yeh at UCLA. I break down what happened before, during, and after my surgery for a small thyroid nodule that was diagnosed as papillary thyroid cancer. Learn about the devastating complications I experienced, including vocal cord damage requiring an implant and nerve damage affecting my shoulder. I discuss important research showing that many thyroid cancers don't require immediate surgery, including a Finnish cadaver study and Dr. Miyauchi's 30-year watch-and-wait approach in Kobe, Japan. ...
info_outlineDoctor Thyroid
Join us as Dr. Emad Kandil, a leading expert in thyroid ablation, sits down with Philip James in the heart of New Orleans. In this candid and insightful conversation, Dr. Kandil shares his journey from aspiring engineer to becoming a renowned thyroid surgeon, influenced by a life-changing event involving his younger brother. Against the backdrop of the city's iconic Café du Monde and a rigorous CrossFit session, the two explore the complexities of thyroid surgery, discussing why Dr. Kandil often advocates for ablation over traditional thyroidectomies to preserve patients' quality of life. As...
info_outlineDoctor Thyroid
In this interview with Dr. Emad Kandil, a leading expert in thyroid ablation, patient Elizabeth shares her journey of receiving conflicting medical advice regarding her thyroid nodule. After consultations with multiple doctors in New York who recommended surgery, Elizabeth sought an alternative in New Orleans with Dr. Kandil, who offered a less invasive option—thyroid ablation. This video explores the benefits of microwave ablation (MWA) as an effective treatment for thyroid nodules, avoiding the complications of surgery and long-term medication dependency. Dr. Kandil provides in-depth...
info_outlineDoctor Thyroid
In this in-depth interview, Dr. Emad Kandil, a leading expert in thyroid ablation at Tulane University, discusses the advanced technique of Microwave Ablation (MWA) for treating thyroid nodules. Dr. Kandil explains the science behind MWA, how it compares to Radiofrequency Ablation (RFA), and addresses common misconceptions such as concerns over excessive heat. He also explores the benefits of MWA over traditional thyroid surgery, including the preservation of thyroid function and the minimization of complications. This discussion is precious for medical professionals, researchers, and...
info_outlineDoctor Thyroid
In this expert-level analysis, we compare the clinical effectiveness of Microwave Ablation (MWA) and Radiofrequency Ablation (RFA) for the treatment of thyroid nodules, with a focus on key decision-making criteria for selecting the optimal minimally invasive treatment. This detailed case study, featuring Dr. Emad Kandil and patient testimony, offers a comprehensive exploration of advanced thyroid nodule management techniques. We begin with the patient’s journey, documenting her initial treatments with RFA, which resulted in limited success and the eventual regrowth of the thyroid nodule. Dr....
info_outlineDoctor Thyroid
Dr. Emad Kandil, one of the leading thyroid surgeons in the U.S. and a pioneer in non-surgical thyroid cancer treatment, is featured in this video discussing the benefits of thyroid ablation as an alternative to surgery. Based at Tulane University, Dr. Kandil has successfully treated numerous patients using this minimally invasive procedure, which allows for the targeted destruction of cancerous thyroid nodules without removing the thyroid gland. - The patient story told by Vanessa: "you have thyroid cancer" - 12:38 Dr. Kandil discusses treating thyroid cancer without surgery In...
info_outlineDoctor Thyroid
Innovations and Issues: from the RFAMD podcast hosted by In recent years, a medical revolution has been quietly taking place in the treatment of thyroid conditions. Thyroid ablation, a procedure that offers an alternative to traditional surgery, is gaining popularity across the globe, particularly in the United States following its FDA approval. Dr. , a leading interventional radiologist from Milan and recognized as one of the top 2% scientists by Stanford University, shares insights into the advancements and challenges of this transformative treatment. The concept of thyroid ablation isn't...
info_outlineDoctor Thyroid
In a world where misinformation can spread as rapidly as legitimate data, discerning the truth becomes a critical skill—especially when it comes to our health. Dr. John Whyte, Chief Medical Officer at WebMD, shares his insights on how patients can navigate the sea of health information online to find trustworthy resources and take control of their personal health. The Power of Information Dr. Whyte begins by emphasizing the importance of quality information, which he argues is more accessible than ever thanks to digital advancements. “Better information leads to better health,” he says,...
info_outlineDoctor Thyroid
Durante una entrevista detallada en el podcast RFAMD, el anfitrión Philip James conversó con la Dra. Ana Voogd, una distinguida cirujana de cabeza y cuello con más de 30 años de experiencia, sobre la integración gradual de la terapia de ablación tiroidea en el panorama médico de Argentina. La Dra. Voogd, que dirige el departamento de cirugía de cabeza y cuello en uno de los hospitales más grandes de Argentina, proporcionó perspectivas valiosas sobre el enfoque evolutivo del país hacia el cuidado del tiroides. Un Paso Hacia Procedimientos Menos Invasivos La Dra. Voogd explicó la...
info_outlineDoctor Thyroid
As the medical community swiftly embraces thyroid ablation, a groundbreaking non-surgical treatment for thyroid nodules, concerns arise about the potential risks associated with its rapid adoption. Key among these concerns is the lack of ultrasound expertise among practitioners and the contentious decision to treat nodules that may be too small to warrant intervention. This article delves into the insights of Dr. Jagdish Dhingra, a seasoned thyroid surgeon, who highlights the crucial balance between leveraging medical innovations and ensuring patient safety through skilled application and...
info_outlineAfter receiving his Fellowship from the Royal College of Surgeons of Canada in 1978, he spent two further years of advanced training, one as a Gordon Richards Fellow at the Princess Margaret Hospital in Toronto in Radiation and Medical Oncology and a second year as a McLaughlin Fellow, training in Head and Neck Oncology at the Royal Marsden Hospital in London, UK. He was the first fellow of the Advanced Training Council sponsored by the two head and neck societies.
A Full Professor, he occupies the Temmy Latner/Dynacare Chair in Head and Neck Oncology at the University of Toronto, Faculty of Medicine. He is former Otolaryngologist-in-Chief at the Mount Sinai Hospital stepping down after fulfilling his 10 year appointment. He has an active practice focusing on head and neck oncology with a primary interest in endocrine surgery of the head and neck.
He has given over 500 scholarly presentations, has been invited as a visiting professor and surgeon internationally, and has published over 280 articles in the scientific literature. He has been involved in a number of administrative roles in the American Head and Neck Society and is also on the editorial board of a number of high impact journals focusing on head and neck oncology. He has recently been appointed to the National Institute of Health (in Washington DC) task force on the management of thyroid cancer.
He is the Director of the University of Toronto Head and Neck Oncology Fellowship, considered to be one of the top three such fellowships in North America.
He was the program chair and congress chair of the First and Second World Congresses on Thyroid Cancer held in 2009 and 2013 in Toronto. He was the Keynote speaker at the Congress held in Boston in 2017. He has been invited worldwide to deliver keynotes in the management of thyroid malignancies.
In this episode the following topics are discussed:
- Cost of thyroid surgery in varies depending on jurisdiction
- Surgery and active surveillance is a fixed cost
- Costs after surgery
- TG tests, ultrasound, thyroid hormone costs
- Contrary to some proponents, surgery is not more cost effective than active surveillance
- Hypo parathyroidism leads to daily doses of calcium and vitamin D
- If there is RLN damage, then there could be more surgery and voice therapy
- There are more costs than solely the surgical fee
- Levothyroxine costs
- Ramifications of degree of thyroid cancer
- Thyroid cancer is a low risk of death
- Many people die with thyroid cancer but don’t die from it
- Possibility versus probability
- Emotional expense of malignancy and being labeled survivor
- Lead a normal life or the survivor label
- Lifetime cost of thryoidectomy
- Medical costs and cost of travel, time of work, baby-sitters, and all expenses that go into managing thryoidectomy for ancillary items
- How long can someone live without thyroid replacement hormone post thyroidectomy?
- Quality of life post thyroidectomy
- Psychological wellbeing
- Do not do a FNA for nodule under 1 cm
NOTES
Jeremy Freeman's scientific contributions