DZ-48: One-Shot - Blade Runner 2049 – Agency vs Choice
Draft Zero: a screenwriting podcast
Release Date: 02/28/2018
Draft Zero: a screenwriting podcast
How does your protagonist’s final choice resolve the plot, character arc and theme? In this episode, Stu and Chas focus solely on the final choices made by protagonists and how that reflects their character journey and successfully, or not, dramatises the internal. We compare and contrast different uses of narrative POV in respect to these final choices, in particular whether and when the audience is made aware of the options available to the character, the act of making the choice, and the consequences of the choice. We breakdown examples from DUNGEONS & DRAGONS: HONOR AMONG THIEVES,...
info_outlineDraft Zero: a screenwriting podcast
How do dramatic questions create tension? In this episode, Stu and Chas delve into the cultural phenomenon of ADOLESCENCE. We try to find the craft tools that have made the show so compelling and such a catalyst for conversation. In particular, we breakdown how the show’s emphasis on questions creates tension: not just tension through plot, but tension through character, and ultimately tension through theme. We analsyse the show episode-by-episode, and discuss how the overall structure skilfully shifts from a plot-heavy police procedural towards a thematic-heavy melodrama...
info_outlineDraft Zero: a screenwriting podcast
How can we teach our audience new storytelling rules in the middle of our story? Following on from our episodes on establishing tone through action lines and through character, this is what we have been building up to: how to pull off a tonal switch… that does not throw the audience out of the film. And, in particular, how to pull that off on the page when writers don’t have framing, lighting, music, editing, etc. at our disposal? With that goal in mind, Mel and Chas dissect specific moments on the pages of SHAUN OF THE DEAD, SORRY TO BOTHER YOU and SWISS ARMY MAN. While there are definite...
info_outlineDraft Zero: a screenwriting podcast
How do you make extended technical scenes funny on the page? Mel joins Chas to tackle physical comedy. We limited our homework selection to extended scenes (as opposed to moments and sight gags) in live action projects and - with the help of our Patreons - selected early sequences from BRINGING UP BABY, the pilot for HAPPY ENDINGS and that wonderful food poisoning scene in BRIDESMAIDS. We discover how these incredible writers take their time (on the page) to set up geography, framing and running gags. We also get tips on judicious use ALL CAPS, ellipses and M-dashes to recreate visual gags…...
info_outlineDraft Zero: a screenwriting podcast
What magic do Christmas movies use to make them so rewatchable? In this “backmatter” episode of Draft Zero, Stu, Chas, and Mel Killingsworth embark on a festive exploration of what makes holiday films so engaging and so re-watchable that they can become part of our rituals. To that end, we breakdown the charm of of Christmas films like KISS KISS BANG BANG, RIDERS OF JUSTICE, and IT’S A WONDERFUL LIFE. We discuss what defines a holiday movie, the power of nostalgia, the importance of ensembles to a sense of family, and how voiceover, snappy dialogue and intricate plots can make...
info_outlineDraft Zero: a screenwriting podcast
How does ending your story on the climax affect audience experience? While Stu is on show, Mel and Chas sit down to analyse the meaning behind the ending of 2024’s CHALLENGERS, especially when - upon reading the script - the most impactful moment of the ending on screen (for Chas in particular) is not written on the page. Following on from episodes on filmmakers talking directly to the audience as well as previous exploration into choices and decisions (and hopefully serving as a prelude to our episode on Hero’s Choice), Mel and Chas explore the choices the characters make in that final...
info_outlineDraft Zero: a screenwriting podcast
What tools help ensure that you as the filmmaker are not misunderstood? In our final (ha!) episode looking at Talking Directly to the Audience, we turn away from character-and-text based craft tools to look at other ways that filmmakers - whether they be directors, writers, editors, or anyone else - can make the audience feel their 'hand' more. To that end, Mel, Stu and Chas dive into ADAPTATION, STORIES WE TELL and THE FORTY-YEAR-OLD VERSION. We discuss structure (in particular how to structure more “meta” stories), the influence of TikTok and YouTube in portraying character...
info_outlineDraft Zero: a screenwriting podcast
DZ-112: Breaking the 4th wall How is the effect of breaking the 4th wall different to VoiceOver? As part of our series on how filmmakers can directly communicate to the audience, we finally examine the most blatant tool of them all: when character look directly down the barrel of the camera… and thus look directly at us, the viewer. Chas, Stu and Mel take the craft tools/levers they identified in previous episodes and use them to examine HIGH FIDELITY, ABBOTT ELEMENTARY and - of course - FLEABAG. By examining how “in-world” the camera is, who is talking, and whom the character is talking...
info_outlineDraft Zero: a screenwriting podcast
How does the unreliability of a narrator impact the way a story is told? In this episode, Stu and Mel (sans Chas!) take a deep dive into FIGHT CLUB and its use of the unreliable narrator. This is a bridging episode between our previous episode on VOICEOVER and our forthcoming episode on TALKING TO CAMERA as Fight Club does both. We dissect the film’s disconnected sequence-driven structure and how the voiceover ’stitches’ the film together. And then we look at what makes ‘Jack’ an unreliable narrator and how his control over the storytelling impacts us. As...
info_outlineDraft Zero: a screenwriting podcast
How can you use Voiceover without it feeling like a cheat? In this episode, we finally delve into the world of VOICEOVERS (as part of our larger series exploring craft tools that allow characters & storytellers to talk directly to the audience). Chas, Stu and Mel deep dive into the VERONICA MARS pilot, Disney’s THE EMPEROR’S NEW GROOVE, and the Michael Bay epic PAIN & GAIN. In exploring what makes these particular examples of Voiceover great (and not feel like a cheat or a well-worn trope), we apply the four levers identified in our Part 1 (in particular ‘when in time is the...
info_outlineCan your characters be given choices and yet still be deprived of agency?
To kick off 2018, Chas and Stu take a deep dive into one of their favourite movies of 2017: Blade Runner 2049. However, they abstained from “Fox News-ing this shit” by being joined by the most accomplished screenwriter they know, C.S. McMullen (Blood List 2017, Black List 2017, also a lover of Blade Runner 2049).
For a film that is thematically about choice, Stu and Chas thought this would be an excellent opportunity to explore how characters can be dramatised through binary choices. And yet, CS opened their eyes to the idea that characters can still be given choices without having agency. Without having choice in their choices. Not having choices that lead to different outcomes.
It is perhaps the lack of agency (rather than the lack of choice) that lead to some of the troubling depiction of women and minorities in Blade Runner 2049, which our intrepid hosts explore in detail.
As always: SPOILERS ABOUND
Audio quotations used for educational purposes only. Timestamps indicated below. Chapter markers included in the mp3.
Special thanks to our Patreon supporters. If you would like more Draft Zero episodes more often, click here!
EPISODES LINKS
- DRAFT ZERO RELATED EPISODES
- BLADE RUNNER 2049 s: Hampton Fancher w: Hampton Fancher and Michael Green [@ 2m 29s]
- Find: C.S. McMullen
- JustWatch: Blade Runner 2049
- Watch: Blade Runner 2049 - Alternate Trailer Blu-Ray (Fan-made)
- Read: Blade Runner 2049 Script
- Watch: Black Out 2022
- Watch: 2048 - Nowhere to Run
- Watch: 2036: Nexus Dawn Short
- WALLACE AND LUV [@ 10m 33s]
- K AND HIS MISSION [@ 26m 18s]
- Watch: "The world is built on a wall"
- Watch: Baseline Tests
- K AND JOI [@ 30m 19s]
- Watch: Joi Virtual Girlfriend Scene
- Watch: Joi Rain Scene
- Watch: Joi "You Look Lonely"
- K'S CHOICES AND HIS ARC [@ 36m 00s]
- Watch: DNA Searching Scene
- Watch: Officer K shares his memory with Joshi
- Watch: Officer K and Joi and Marietta
- DECKARD AND THE LAS VEGAS SEQUENCE [@ 47m 34s]
- Watch: Ruins of Las Vegas
- Watch: Deckard & K share a drink
- LUV AND JOSHI [ @ 58m 26s]
- K'S HERO CHOICE [@ 1h 01m 52s]
- K AND LUV [@ 1h 04m 45s]
- Watch: K vs Luv Scene
- TEARS IN THE SNOW [@ 1h 10m 57s]
- Watch: Ending Scene
- DEPICTION OF WOMEN AND MINORITIES [@ 1h 19m 24s]
- Read: The Conversation - Blade Runner’s problem with women remains unsolved in its sequel
- Read: The Guardian - Is Blade Runner 2049 sexist – or a fair depiction of a dystopian future?
- Read: Digital Spy - Can we talk about Blade Runner 2049's problem with women?
- Read: NY Post - You’ll love the new ‘Blade Runner’ — unless you’re a woman
- Read: Mashable - The hidden feminist message buried inside 'Blade Runner 2049'
- Read: New Statesman - Blade Runner 2049 is an uneasy feminist parable about controlling the means of reproduction
- Read: Mary Sue - Director Denis Villeneuve Tries to Defend His Portrayal of Women in Blade Runner 2049
- Read: The Mary Sue - Blade Runner 2049: Bad Representation Is Not Representation
- WRAP UP AND KEY LEARNINGS [@ 1h 35m 36s]
- BACKMATTER: Blade Runner 2019
Please send feedback to ask at draft-zero.com, via our web form or twitter @draft_zero! We are @chasffisher @stuwillis and @csmcmullen on twitter.
Please considering rating or subscribing to us on Apple Podcast! or sharing us on the Social Medias! We like finding new listeners.
Many thanks to Sandra, Paul, Rob, Christopher, Joakim and Khrob for being top-level patrons. They're good replicants.