#81: The Pregnant 10 Year-Old: Thinking Well About This Tragic Story (with Robin Atkins)
Release Date: 07/26/2022
Equipped for Life Podcast
Josh Brahm and Monica Snyder wrap up their series of recent discussions by addressing denial-of-care stories. In this episode, Monica and Josh define what a denial-of-care story is, explain why abortion bans are often blamed for causing pregnancy-related deaths, identify the actual problems behind the most sensationalized stories, empathize with tragic outcomes and legitimate pro-choice concerns, and propose courses of action that pro-life people can take to help prevent similar tragic stories from happening in the future. Related Links: Secular Pro-Life’s entire blog category of debunking...
info_outlineEquipped for Life Podcast
Josh Brahm and Monica Snyder return to discuss the question: “Do You Need Religion to be Pro-Life?” The conversation touches on practical and philosophical points, including discussion about objective and subjective morality and its relationship with deism, as well as Monica’s experiences responding to both pro-life and pro-choice people who raise a scrutinizing eyebrow when they realize that they are talking with a pro-life atheist. Links: Secular Pro-Life: Secular Pro-Life: A couple of examples of pro-choice religious-ish-ness: Human Life...
info_outlineEquipped for Life Podcast
After much anticipation, Josh Brahm FINALLY gets to interview Monica Snyder from Secular Pro-Life about her background and expertise in Forensics. Monica explains how her work in forensics and DNA analysis affects her view on the abortion issue, particularly when it comes to questions about the justice system and why we shouldn’t prosecute women who have had abortions. Content warning: Includes discussion of forensic rape kits as well as methods of testing whether a baby was aborted instead of miscarried. Links: National Right to Life: ERI Statement: Chapters: 00:00:00...
info_outlineEquipped for Life Podcast
Content warning: This whole episode is about sex. It’s probably not the episode to listen to around your kids. Secular Pro-Life’s Monica Snyder returns to the Equipped for Life Podcast for another series of episodes, beginning with the topic, “It’s About Babies, Not Your Sex Life.” Stemming from real-life conversations, Monica and Josh identify many of the various factors that contribute to pro-choice perceptions or labeling of pro-life people as being “anti-sex” and then respond accordingly to each factor. The Dynamic Duo also provides some fun commentary...
info_outlineEquipped for Life Podcast
We brought the entire staff on for our 100th episode! The team planned the outline without Josh, and the result was a fun, retrospective celebration of the podcast. Related Links: Ellen's first blog post: Ellen's most recent blog post: Joshua's episode on the podcast: Rebecca’s talking head video: Our first podcast with Rebecca co-hosting: Josh’s article the atheist responded to: Ellen’s favorite episode: Rebecca’s favorite episode: Joshua’s favorite episode : Emily's favorite episodes: Josh's favorite episodes: Tim Hull's favorite episode: ...
info_outlineEquipped for Life Podcast
It’s October, and 40 Days for Life campaigns are in full swing! Josh, Emily, and Rebecca share and react to short video tips sent in from pro-life activists from around the country on how to effectively participate in your local 40 Days for Life campaign. (SPOILER ALERT: it’s not as hard as you think!) Chapters: 00:00 Introduction 07:40 Tip #1: Herb Geraghty 13:43 Tip #2: Rebecca Carlson 19:45 Tip #3: Kristi Burkhart 24:52 Tip #4: Michael New 28:07 Tip #5: Emily Geiger 32:26 Tip #6: Jim Burke 38:04 Tip #7: Rebekah Dyer 41:24 Tip #8: Josh Brahm 45:33 Tip #9: Jay Watts 50:45 Tip...
info_outlineEquipped for Life Podcast
LIGHTNING!!! (in slow motion). In this podcast, Josh Brahm and Monica Snyder from Secular Pro-Life sort through listener mail from SPL’s mailbag and give quick responses to several questions and requests. Part 2 of 2 addresses eight main topics, to include the biological case for the unborn, how to combat viral misinformation, the concept of abortion as healthcare, why women advocate for abortion, the medical necessity of third trimester abortions, what to do if the pro-choice person jumps topics, if brain activity should define personhood, and counseling resources for nonreligious,...
info_outlineEquipped for Life Podcast
LIGHTNING!!! (in slow motion). In this podcast, Josh Brahm and Monica Snyder from sort through listener mail from SPL’s mailbag and give quick responses to several questions and requests. Part 1 of 2 (this episode) covers seven main topics, namely, whether the “pro-life movement” should actually be called the “anti-abortion movement”, the availability of abortion pills, discrimination against children with disabilities, how to welcome secular members into a pro-life space, if we should boycott pro-choice media, trying to understand how a pro-choice person thinks, and whether...
info_outlineEquipped for Life Podcast
We recorded another episode with Secular Pro-Life’s Monica Snyder, our favorite practically co-host, to discuss Secular Pro-Life’s recent survey on the differences between how both sides of the issue define abortion. A critical part of clear communication is making sure you and your dialogue partner are using the key words in the same way. Pro-life and pro-choice people often mean VERY different things when they use the word "abortion," but they don't know that, and miscommunication ensues. This episode will help you avoid that miscommunication. The ERI team offers several practical...
info_outlineEquipped for Life Podcast
Yes, abortion pills are harmful to women and unborn children. We're pro-life. But when you take an honest look at the evidence, there is no evidence that abortion pills are poisoning our wastewater. This episode includes a visual slideshow, and can be viewed at our YouTube channel here: Content warning: If you have experienced pregnancy loss, this may not be the episode for you. There’s an inherent graphic nature to the kinds of claims we’re offering factual and philosophical arguments against. While we kept the conversation as tame as possible, we know this is a...
info_outlineEveryone has been talking about the tragic case of a 10-year-old who was raped, became pregnant, and driven across state lines to get an abortion. Even President Biden referenced her story in public. Multiple ERI followers have asked us how pro-life people can answer questions about this story without sounding like a moral monster.
Josh and Emily invited licensed mental health counselor Robin Atkins to discuss the story with us. Our conversation included the rules regarding public discussion of patient information, particularly in CHINS cases, and the damage done if the rules are violated as well as how pro-life people should talk about this story.
Robin is a licensed mental health counselor, specializing in reproductive issues. She also has a philosophy degree. She spent four years doing home-based therapy with the Department of Children's Services. She's a pro-life advocate with an atypical perspective on some of the issues surrounding abortion.
Related Links:
The source that Robin read from about laws governing confidentiality in CHINS cases:
Child Welfare Information Gateway. (2022). Disclosure of confidential child abuse and neglect records. Department of Health and Human Services, Administration for Children and Families, Children's Bureau.
Reprotection:
https://www.reprotection.org/
She Found His Grace Abortion Recovery (Serena Dyksen)
https://www.shefoundhisgrace.org
Book: She Found His Grace: A True Story Of Hope, Love, And Forgiveness After Abortion:
https://amzn.to/3v7TRHv
Responding to 8 Types of Difficult Pro-Lifers (with Monica Snyder & Andrew Kaake - Part 1)
Here are the medical studies we referenced regarding young pregnancies:
Too much too young? Teenage pregnancy is not a public health problem:
https://academic.oup.com/ije/article/31/3/552/629768
What's so bad about teenage pregnancy?
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12457546/
Why I Changed My Pro-life Elevator Pitch:
https://bit.ly/3NERrrE
“Abortion is Healthcare”: A Misogynistic Non-Argument:
http://bit.ly/2oYPP5k
ERI resources on responding to the question of rape:
https://blog.equalrightsinstitute.com/rape/
Previous episodes with Robin Atkins:
A Different Perspective: Adoption vs. Foster Care vs. Abortion:
https://youtu.be/yChl-sReTP0
Mental Health and Informed Consent in Abortion:
https://youtu.be/E4Pn_wf5kSU
A Mental Health Counselor on Psychology in Debate:
https://youtu.be/sZDIVOKJ6hE
Bonus Discussion about Whether Sidewalk Counselors Should EVER Bring Up Adoption:
https://youtu.be/HaUJMcEgpcQ
Chapters
00:00 Introducing Robin and this story
06:23 CHINS cases and why the fact checkers got this story so wrong
35:14 Can abortion treat the trauma of rape?
53:31 Examining an apparent contradiction in what Robin said about how Ohio treats these crimes
57:36 Is it actually more physically dangerous when a young person is pregnant?
1:19:02 How should abortion laws treat a situation where a doctor claims that their patient has a life-threatening pregnancy?
1:27:26 How should pro-life people talk about cases like this?
Disclosure: The book above is an Amazon affiliate link. This means that, at zero cost to you, ERI will earn an affiliate commission if you click through the link and finalize a purchase.