loader from loading.io

Tasty Tuesday: The Ultimate Key West Waterfront Dining Guide

Fun in Key West Podcast

Release Date: 01/19/2026

Pit Bulls in Paradise: Tony Soika on Key West Mysteries, Rescue Dogs, and Second Acts show art Pit Bulls in Paradise: Tony Soika on Key West Mysteries, Rescue Dogs, and Second Acts

Fun in Key West Podcast

Pit Bulls in Paradise: Tony Soika on Key West Mysteries, Rescue Dogs, and Second Acts Host Michele O’Connor introduces the Fun in Key West Podcast and its Book Club episode featuring author Tony Soika, a retired U.S. Army officer with 30 years of service and extensive animal-rescue volunteering. Soika discusses his deep pull toward the Florida Keys since first visiting in 1999, his transition challenges after leaving the military, and how becoming a late-in-life father shaped him and influenced his writing. He explains how his novel Pit Bulls in Paradise (first in the Conch House...

info_outline
Historic Marker Monday: How Cayo Hueso Became Key West show art Historic Marker Monday: How Cayo Hueso Became Key West

Fun in Key West Podcast

Historic Marker Monday: How Cayo Hueso Became Key West Host Michele O’Connor introduces the Fun in Key West podcast and this Historic Marker Monday episode focused on the origin of Key West’s name, highlighted by a historic marker near Mallory Square. She explains how the Taíno word “cayo” (small island) passed through Spanish usage and into English as “key,” and how “hueso” (bone) made the original Spanish name Cayo Hueso translate to “Bone Island.” Michele shares theories for the island’s bones, including Native American conflicts, shipwreck victims from the...

info_outline
Historic Marker Monday: Ponce de León’s 1513 Voyage show art Historic Marker Monday: Ponce de León’s 1513 Voyage

Fun in Key West Podcast

Historic Marker Monday: Ponce de León’s 1513 Voyage and Key West’s Marker #50   Host Michele O’Connor  introducses this Historic Marker Monday episode focused on a Duval Street historic marker (noted at 1405 Duval Street) honoring Spanish explorer Ponce de León and his 1513 voyage. She recounts his background sailing with Columbus, his roles in the Dominican Republic and Puerto Rico, and how he personally financed three ships to seek gold, expand Spain’s territory, and strengthen his position. The episode traces the expedition as he named Florida, moved through the Florida...

info_outline
Tasty Tuesday: The Best Oyster Spots in Key West show art Tasty Tuesday: The Best Oyster Spots in Key West

Fun in Key West Podcast

Tasty Tuesday: The Best Oyster Spots in Key West (Happy Hours, Hidden Gems & Upscale Bites) Host Michele O’Connor delivers a Tasty Tuesday guide to why oysters in Key West “hit different,” emphasizing freshness from local fishermen, the Historic Seaport, and markets like Eaton Street Seafood Market. She shares what to look for in a great oyster stop—freshness, variety, preparation styles, atmosphere, value (especially happy hour), and seafood focus—then highlights recommended spots including Half Shell Raw Bar, Alonzo’s Oyster Bar, Conch Republic Seafood Company, Schooner...

info_outline
Bottling the Spirit of Key West with Deejay Peak of Key West Candle & Bath Co. show art Bottling the Spirit of Key West with Deejay Peak of Key West Candle & Bath Co.

Fun in Key West Podcast

Bottling the Spirit of Key West with Deejay Peak of Key West Candle & Bath Co. Host Michele O’Connor introduces the Fun in Key West podcast as an insider guide to where to eat, drink, stay, and what to do in Key West, with updates on events and local guests. She interviews Deejay Peak, owner of Key West Candle and Bath Company, who moved to Key West seven and a half years ago after family trips and an opportunity to run her parents’ ice cream shop. Deejay describes starting her candle business with $500 by collecting top-shelf liquor bottles from local bar dumpsters, then rebranding...

info_outline
Thirsty Thursday: Best Frozen Drinks in Key West show art Thirsty Thursday: Best Frozen Drinks in Key West

Fun in Key West Podcast

Thirsty Thursday: Best Frozen Drinks in Key West (Flying Monkeys, Fat Tuesday & Mary Ellen’s) Host Michele O’Connor introduces the Fun in Key West podcast as an insider guide to where to eat, drink, stay, and what to do on the island, with updates on events and occasional local guests. In this Thirsty Thursday episode, she spotlights Key West’s frozen drink scene and encourages listeners to try new menu options beyond standard pina coladas, margaritas, and daiquiris. She recommends Flying Monkeys on Duval (near Bull and Whistle and Fogerty Mansion) for its mix-and-match frozen...

info_outline
Trust the Signs: Mark Renson on How Will I Know, Whitney Houston as a Guardian Angel, and Finding Solace in the Florida Keys show art Trust the Signs: Mark Renson on How Will I Know, Whitney Houston as a Guardian Angel, and Finding Solace in the Florida Keys

Fun in Key West Podcast

Trust the Signs: Mark Renson on How Will I Know, Whitney Houston as a Guardian Angel, and Finding Solace in the Florida Keys   Host Michele O’Connor introduces chef, restaurant owner, and author Mark Renson about his novel How Will I Know, the Fun in Key West Book Club February pick. Renson shares his background as owner of Ambition Coffee and Eatery in upstate New York (nearly 26 years), his first book Is The Coffee Fresh? about daily life in his coffee house and how he was inspired in 2012 to write fiction using Whitney Houston as a guardian angel.   He explains how he began the...

info_outline
Key West Travel Tips and Booking Smarter with Savvy.com (Guest: Eric Goldreyer) show art Key West Travel Tips and Booking Smarter with Savvy.com (Guest: Eric Goldreyer)

Fun in Key West Podcast

Key West Travel Tips and Booking Smarter with Savvy.com (Guest: Eric Goldreyer) Host Michele O’Connor welcomes listeners to the Fun in Key West podcast and interviews hospitality entrepreneur Eric Goldreyer, who has 30+ years of experience spanning bed and breakfasts, boutique hotels, mega-yacht inflatables, and vacation rental property management. Eric shares his background (founding BedandBreakfast.com, selling it to HomeAway in 2010; co-founding TurnKey Vacation Rentals and selling to Vacasa in 2021; and launching FunAir) and explains why he created Savvy.com after experiencing high...

info_outline
First Timer Friday: Why Marathon Is the Perfect Home Base in the Florida Keys show art First Timer Friday: Why Marathon Is the Perfect Home Base in the Florida Keys

Fun in Key West Podcast

First Timer Friday: Why Marathon Is the Perfect Home Base in the Florida Keys   Host Michele O’Connor welcomes listeners to the Fun in Key West podcast and presents a First Timer Friday episode that detours from Key West to highlight Marathon as a laid-back, centrally located Florida Keys home base. She explains Marathon’s position halfway between Miami and Key West across 13 islands and why it offers quieter mornings, easier parking, and strong water access for day trips up to Key Largo, Island Morada, Big Pine Key, and Key West. Activities and highlights include snorkeling at...

info_outline
Historic Marker Monday: The Birth of the Conch Republic and the Great Battle of 1982 show art Historic Marker Monday: The Birth of the Conch Republic and the Great Battle of 1982

Fun in Key West Podcast

Historic Marker Monday: The Birth of the Conch Republic and the Great Battle of 1982   Host Michele O’Connor introduces the Fun in Key West podcast and a Historic Marker Monday episode about the 1982 events that led to the creation of the Conch Republic. She recounts how a U.S. Border Patrol roadblock at Last Chance Saloon in Florida City stopped and searched every car entering and leaving the Keys, creating massive traffic jams, generating national and international press, and causing major economic harm as tourists canceled trips and hotels sat empty. After community leaders pushed...

info_outline
 
More Episodes
Tasty Tuesday: The Ultimate Key West Waterfront Dining Guide
In this episode of the Fun in Key West podcast, host Michele O'Connor takes listeners on a culinary journey through the best waterfront dining spots in Key West. From upscale experiences like Hot Tin Roof to casual beachside eats at Loggerheads Beach Bar, Michele shares insider tips on where to savor fresh seafood, exotic cocktails, and breathtaking ocean views. She also highlights the vibrant local food scene, with recommendations for various dining options, including brunch, lunch, and dinner spots. Tune in to discover the hidden gems and must-visit eateries to make your Key West trip deliciously unforgettable.
00:00 Welcome to Fun in Key West Podcast
01:26 Diving into Waterfront Dining
04:41 Hot Tin Roof: Sunset Vibes and Chic Island Experience
05:36 Sunset Pier: Iconic Views and Live Music
06:21 Seaside Cafe: Lobster Pizza and Southernmost Charm
07:26 Southernmost Beach Cafe: Fresh Fish and Margaritas
07:59 La Trattoria Oceanside: Italian Delights
08:21 Salute on the Beach: Lunch and Strolls
08:44 Loggerheads Beach Bar: Feet in the Sand
09:15 Geiger Key Marina: Old School Vibes
10:08 Boathouse Bar and Grill: Best Happy Hour
10:47 Hurricane Hole: Kayaks and Catch of the Day
11:18 Half Shell Raw Bar: Quintessential Key West
12:06 Conch Republic Seafood Company: Fresh Catch and Happy Hour
12:56 Fisherman's Cafe: Breakfast and Lunch with a View
13:50 Louis's Backyard: Brunch and Liquid Lunch
14:37 Latitudes: Ferry Ride to Sunset Key
15:19 Wrapping Up: More Key West Dining Tips
16:21 Join the Fun in Key West Community
17:17 Farewell and Final Thoughts