Listener Questions, Episode 37

Welcome to the first podcast of 2026 where Roger and Pete answer more of your varied and interesting questions, covering everything from what to do when you’ve maxed out your pension and ISA, to whether you should borrow on your mortgage to invest!

Shownotes: https://meaningfulmoney.tv/QA37

 

01:30  Question 1

Hello to Roger and his trusty sidekick Pete,

Only kidding Pete, but it will make Roger feel good briefly.

I must credit the pair of you for your continued dedication and commitment to educating the wider population on all things financial.  I have gone from strength to strength in planning my retirement with the guidance and abundance of free information you have provided, the books you have written Pete, as well as signing up to the Meaningful Academy Retirement Planning and now planning to retire several years earlier than originally intended.

Using the information provided and learnt, I have got my finances in order but more importantly, that decision is to align my future life (and that of my wife) to the finances we need and when our needs are likely to be met, hence the realisation retirement is not as far away as we had originally perceived, so I really appreciate what you have done for me and my family.

My question maybe very simple, but it was sparked during a previous Q&A session
Listener Question – episode 20 - 30th July – Question 2 – The question surrounded company Shares.

I am employed by BAE and I purchase company shares each month, partially as a sensible Tax saving being a higher rate tax payer (purchase them pre Tax) but also for the first £75 worth each month I buy each month, the company will match, so effectively £150 worth of shares which technically costs less than £50 in real money each month.  Now whilst I do sell some shares along the way (after the 5-year maturity to avoid tax payment), I continue to have a reasonable amount invested (£35k subject to tax relief period on some).

A statement you made during the above session was “as a sideline issue we tend to say to people that investing in shares for the company you work for is a bad idea at any scale, thus to avoid backing one horse and it’s not a good idea to hold onto shares for a company you work for.”

Now I thought I was onto a winner and being tax efficient and building an amount of money which I tap into on an occasional basis as well as additional source of income once retired, but are you implying, as you did to that listener, I might consider cashing some in and transferring the money else where?

Perhaps in this instance it is suffice leaving it there, as the examples you gave were for smaller companies (in comparison) that folded, whereas BAE one of the larger Defence industry companies, doesn’t appear to be going anywhere soon?  I do have a Royal Naval DB pension already paying out, as well as a part DB and part DC pension with BAE (continuing to build), so I’m not reliant upon the money, which is another factor why I’ve not considered moving them away or am I doing myself a bad deal, id value your opinions (not advice ha ha)?

Thank you for your time
Regards, John

08:02  Question 2

I’m 39, a basic rate taxpayer and I have a Lifetime ISA and a SIPP with HL. Can I save for retirement in my Lifetime ISA and invest in the same funds as my Pension after receiving the 25% bonus to achieve similar growth. Then at age 60, withdraw all that money tax free and pay it into my pension (up to my allowances and possibly using previous years) to gain the 20% tax relief just before I draw the pension? I would also save some money on platform fees as the LISA is 0.25% vs the SIPP at 0.45%.

I know I can get cheaper platforms elsewhere but I find HL easy, intuitive, and feel like I can trust them with my money, which really encourages me to save in the first place.

Thanks, Robert

13:40  Question 3

Hi Pete and Roger,

Longtime fan and listener, thanks for all the great work you do!

I’m 40 years old and a member of the LGPS DB pension scheme, which I’ve been paying into since my early 20s. My partner is also in a DB scheme (Central Government). We have no debt other than our mortgage.

We currently live in a modest home we bought for £89k, but are thinking about upgrading to a bigger property for more space and comfort (no plans to have children). That said, we’ve enjoyed the low cost of living here.

We’ve built up around £160k in savings, split roughly 40% in a Stocks & Shares ISA and 60% in Premium Bonds and cash. I’ve tried to keep the ISA intact as a form of flexibility/security around retirement, potentially to retire early or reduce hours in the future.

The dilemma is:

1. Do we spend most of the savings on a better house and accept working longer?
2. Or do we stay where we are, keep our financial flexibility, and potentially one of us works less or retires earlier?
3. Or is there a sensible middle ground, spending some of the cash to improve our living situation while still preserving part of our financial cushion for future flexibility?

We’re just trying to balance quality of life now with freedom and options later, and would love to hear your take on it. Is there anything else we haven't thought about?

Thanks so much for your thoughts!
Gez

 

19:25  Question 4

Hi Pete and Rog, big fan of the show and I appreciate the helpful topics you cover.

I am currently going through a remortgage and am extracting equity from our house to invest.
The new mortgage rate is around 4% and our LTV will be around 80%. The additional monthly costs are within our budget too.

My strategy is to invest the extracted amount in a stocks and shares ISA with my wife, utilising the £20k allowance each per tax year. This will be invested into globally diversified index funds.

I have ran calculations on how much I will be paying in additional interest vs how much is probable from stock market returns.
Over 25 years, the additional interest paid on £50k extracted at 4% is £29k
Over 25 years, having invested £50k, I would need to return 1.84% to break even from this deal. This is due to the way mortgages are amortised via repayment vs the investments compounding positively.

With conservative returns of 7% used, this will net £236k of interest.
Am I missing anything here?
Keep up the great work and I'm very interested to hear whether you have done this in the past.
Stephen

26:40  Question 5

Hi Pete and Roger,

Recent discoverer and now big fan of the show here - I have now caught up on all the Q&A episodes and am continuing to work my way through the back catalogue: a lot of material!

My questions centre on tax-efficient options once ISAs and pensions are maxed out, and how to "bridge" savings if retiring before pension-age.

I am 36, married and have 2 young daughters who are the apple of my eye. We have a very manageable mortgage and I benefit from a very well paid job. However, an extremely stressful period last year sent me on the track of better understanding personal finance (and ultimately finding you) in order to achieve financial independence and not need to tolerate that kind of situation ever again, as well as be free to dedicate my time and energy to things without worrying about how much money they pay.

1) I am trying to get to functional financial independence (i.e. paid work is entirely optional) as soon as possible - I now max out my annual pension and ISA allowance each year and am likely to continue to in the future. Are there any other normal vehicles I can use for additional saving and investing? Giving money to my wife to use her ISA allowance? Anything else? I don't want to overpay the mortgage for the next several years as we managed to get a fixed rate that is below the current rate of inflation.

2) I have a good understanding of our essential and discretionary spending, and with a conservative annualised rate of return I could theoretically stop contributing to my pension pot in the next 7ish years and compounding would mean it would be big enough to fully support us once we can access it. My question is - is there a good rule of thumb or approach for working out how much I need to save outside the pension if I wanted to stop working for money before 57? Is it just a case of working out # years x expenses or is there anything more sophisticated to it?

3) bonus question - feel free to cut if it doesn't fit: I'm familiar with the idea of asset allocation and rebalancing to "smooth the ride" for my portfolio. Most things I've read or listened to have focused on equities vs. bonds. When I was looking at a number of bond indexes recently the returns have been pretty flat, often <2% per year. If I can get >4% from a cash ISA, what's the point of the bonds? Am I missing something?

Thanks so much for all the knowledge you put into the world, giving people the tools to look after themselves. The chat is pretty great too! Kind regards,
Martin

37:18  Question 6

Hello Pete & Roger

Thank you for your fantastic materials, so well explained.
We're 62. We already have a standard pension pot Annuity and we have around £300,000 in savings in building society accounts.
(We value peace of mind over the potential for big gains, so we're not really considering stocks and shares).
We're wondering whether, rather than rely entirely on savings accounts, it would make sense to use a Purchase Life Annuity.
With current annuity rates, it looks like that's a Yes, so we're curious what your expert view is on this.

We're aware of the downside: that it leaves us without much of a savings pot for any unexpected very large need.
Have watched the Annuities: Back from the dead? video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=alTTzrd2NbY -  which talked about buying an annuity with pension, but in our case it would be Purchase Life Annuity, so does that make a difference when purchasing an annuity?

Thank you again! Moira