The Search for Nancy Guthrie | 02.21.26.
Middle Theory
This week, as the desperate search for Nancy Guthrie continues, we examine the latest developments in the tragic disappearance that has shocked the entire nation. Nancy Guthrie was reported missing on February 1, 2026, marking the beginning of a multi-agency investigation that has gripped Americans as law enforcement works against the clock to determine her whereabouts. The 84-year-old mother of Today co-anchor Savannah Guthrie, Nancy was last seen entering her home after being dropped off by her son-in-law, Tommaso Cioni, at her residence in Catalina Foothills, Arizona. As the...
info_outline
"Domestic Terrorists" | 02.14.26.
Middle Theory
This week, as the U.S. Department of Homeland Security announces the end of its immigration enforcement crackdown in Minnesota, we examine the stories of American citizens who have been injured or negatively affected by the operations of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents, and later mischaracterized as "domestic terrorists." As "Operation Metro Surge" comes to an end in Minnesota, questions linger about the effectiveness of DHS operations amid recent testimony provided to members of Congress by U.S. citizens whose lives were impacted by ICE activities. These include Marimar...
info_outline
Jeffrey Epstein: An American Haunting | 02.08.26.
Middle Theory
This week, following the release of a massive trove of documents by the U.S. Department of Justice related to Jeffrey Epstein, we examine the main takeaways and look at why the file release is raising new questions about the disgraced financier and sex offender's death. The sordid story of Jeffrey Epstein, as well as the intrigue surrounding his fortune, his alleged associations with the U.S. Intelligence Community, and connections to American politicians and other high-profile individuals, has become a story that won't go away. In recent months, the late sex offender's past associations...
info_outline
The Killing of Alex Pretti | 02.01.26.
Middle Theory
This week, within days of the tragic shooting death of Minneapolis resident Renee Good, America has reached a tipping point in the aftermath of a second shooting incident involving the killing of Alex Pretti by agents with the Department of Homeland Security. As outrage over Pretti's death ensues, we examine what videos of the tragic incident reveal, as well as the context provided by additional videos that have revealed earlier encounters between Pretti and ICE agents in Minneapolis. We also examine the contradictory statements provided by federal officials in the aftermath of the...
info_outline
Fire and ICE | 01.19.26.
Middle Theory
It's time to get back to work. Chaos has erupted in the streets of Minneapolis, Minnesota, following a deadly confrontation between federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents and a 37-year-old mother of three, Renee Good, who was shot and killed by Jonathan Ross, a 10-year ICE veteran. In our analysis of the tragic events that led to Good's killing, we examine what is currently known about the circumstances leading up to the incident, as well as responses from state, local, and federal officials, and what multiple independent analyses of videos captured as the events...
info_outline
This is Middle Theory | 05.12.22.
Middle Theory
This week, we ask how we became so polarized, and look at the underlying reasons for division in our culture in a discussion about the meaning behind the "Middle Theory." Can't we all just get along? What are the roots of the conflicts we see in the world around us... from the geopolitical stage, to our neighborhoods and communities? Although polls over the years offer mixed results, a recurring theme is that voters often tend to be more moderate than the politicians they vote for. Why, then, does there appear to be so much polarization in society, both in politics, and in other...
info_outline
Nuclear Options | 05.03.22.
Middle Theory
This week, growing concerns over Russia's nuclear rhetoric in recent days have experts looking at how far Vladimir Putin might go in his quest to conquer Ukraine. This week, as recent polls (finally) show Biden's approval ratings are on the rise, we take a look at what it could mean heading into the mid-terms in November. Meanwhile, Elon Musk has provided reporters with a few vague ideas of what he plans to do with Twitter... putting him into a unique position in terms of political perception and leanings. Then, shifting our attention to the ongoing conflict in Ukraine, world leaders...
info_outline
Elon Musk and the Battle for Twitter | 04.27.22.
Middle Theory
With Elon Musk's acquisition of Twitter, controversy ensues over issues of transparency and freedom of speech, and whether the platform can improve under Musk's leadership. This week, the White House announced that Vice President Kamala Harris has tested positive for COVID-19, which may be the least of her problems based on a new book that reportedly reveals tensions between she and other members of the Biden Administration, including the President. We also look at the current situation involving statements this week by Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff General Mark Milley and Secretary of...
info_outline
Holy War | 04.18.22.
Middle Theory
As Ukrainian officials say the "Battle of Donbas" has begun, we look at how one controversial Russian cleric has urged for "holy war" as the conflict in Ukraine wears on. This week, news that record numbers of retirees are fleeing to countries like Portugal is making headlines amidst reports about economic woes around the world, and news about the latest strain of the coronavirus sweeping the United States. That, in addition to the unsurprising news that Alex Jones' INFOWARS company has filed for bankruptcy. Meanwhile, Ukrainian officials have now said that their fears about battle in...
info_outline
Twitter: Battle of the Bots | 04.11.22.
Middle Theory
This week, we analyze Elon Musk's new influence on social media giant Twitter, and the company's issue with bots posing as users. Former President Donald Trump is back in the news for his recent controversial endorsement of television doctor Mehmet Oz in his Senate bid in Pennsylvania, which has evoked ire from conservatives. Meanwhile, as the situation in Ukraine remains at a standstill for now, what do things look like within Russia, where Vladimir Putin appears to still be suffering from delusions of grandeur and victory? Then we turn our attention to the controversy surrounding Elon Musk's...
info_outlineThis week, as the desperate search for Nancy Guthrie continues, we examine the latest developments in the tragic disappearance that has shocked the entire nation.
Nancy Guthrie was reported missing on February 1, 2026, marking the beginning of a multi-agency investigation that has gripped Americans as law enforcement works against the clock to determine her whereabouts. The 84-year-old mother of Today co-anchor Savannah Guthrie, Nancy was last seen entering her home after being dropped off by her son-in-law, Tommaso Cioni, at her residence in Catalina Foothills, Arizona.
As the investigation continues, we examine what is known about the case, what the imagery of the suspect filmed outside her doorstep on the night of her disappearance reveals, and the crucial missteps early in the investigation that have complicated the search, which has now remained underway for weeks amid concerns for the missing woman's well-being.
This episode of Middle Theory is dedicated to Nancy Guthrie and her family: our hearts remain with them in this difficult time, and we continue to pray for her safe return to her loved ones.
Image Credit: Federal Bureau of Investigation/Public Domain.
If you like Middle Theory and want to help support the show, you can donate to the program here:
DOLLARS FOR DONUTS
- Jonathan Walsh
- Jon Haskins
- Connie Fletcher
- Tania Biswas
SHOW NOTES
- GUTHRIE KIDNAPPING: Nancy Guthrie kidnapping investigation draws scrutiny as case drags on
- YEARS? Pima County Sheriff says it may take "years" to find Nancy Guthrie
- TIMELINE: Nancy Guthrie’s Disappearance: Timeline and Key Developments
- STRANGE SWAT: ‘Mindblowing’: Reaction to Friday night’s Guthrie-related SWAT op in the Foothills
- GLOVES OFF: FBI: DNA from glove near Guthrie home appears to match glove worn by suspect : NPR
- MULTIPLE GLOVES? Multiple additional gloves found by The Post in same area near Nancy Guthrie's house where FBI found potential evidence
- 2000 MILES: Expert fumes 'every hour matters' as Nancy Guthrie cops use DNA lab 2000 miles away
- FAMILY CLEARED: Tommaso Cioni, Guthrie Family Cleared as Suspects in Nancy Guthrie Case
- MISSTEPS: Opinion: Missteps in Guthrie probe undermine confidence, former SWAT leader says
- MEXICO? FBI Contacts Mexican Authorities in Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping, New Ransom Demand
- ACCOMPLICE? Accomplice not ruled out in Nancy Guthrie disappearance, Arizona sheriff says
- SALTY SPECULATION: In Guthrie Mystery, Rampant Speculation Is Like ‘Salt on the Open Wound’
- BONDI: Pam Bondi Admits DOJ Has a Secret Domestic Terrorist List
- AUDIO: Rep. Scanlon questions Attorney General Pam Bondi in oversight hearing
- COERCION: Platforms bend over backward to help DHS censor ICE critics, advocates say
- ICE AGENTS GONE WILD: ICE Agent Moons People Protesting Against Minnesota Shootings
- CBP employee in Minnesota charged after reportedly being found ‘covered in vomit’ in car
- ICE Reportedly Stole a 10th Grader’s Phone, Then Seemingly Sold It for Cash
- More Than 40 Instances Where DHS Agents Have Used Banned Choke Holds
- TEACHER KILLED: Georgia teacher killed in crash during DHS/ICE chase
JOIN US: REACH OUT TO MIDDLE THEORY
To send us feedback, you can email us here.
Follow Middle Theory on X.com here.
Donate to the program here.