Outlander: 7.12 - Carnal Knowledge | Listener Feedback
Outlander Cast: The Outlander Podcast With Mary & Blake
Release Date: 12/31/2024
Outlander Cast: The Outlander Podcast With Mary & Blake
In this episode of Outlander Cast, Mary & Blake break down Outlander 8.03, “Abies Fraseri” — an hour that gives us some of the season’s best character work and one of its biggest mythology swings. Claire’s blue-light moment officially enters the chat, and let’s just say… Mary and Blake are not exactly on the same page about it. We dig into whether the reveal works, why Jamie and Claire’s fight feels messy in the best possible way, why Fanny continues to be one of the strongest emotional additions to the show, and why William and Amaranthus might have the most subtext-heavy...
info_outlineOutlander Cast: The Outlander Podcast With Mary & Blake
In this episode of Outlander Cast, Mary and Blake react to your thoughts on Frank’s voice in Jamie’s head, the sheer insanity of Amy’s bear attack, whether Jamie and Claire’s intimate scene was about connection or claiming, and why Captain Cunningham and Benjamin Cleveland are setting off every possible alarm bell. We also get into: - whether Frank is psychologically wrecking Jamie - if the bear attack worked or felt too contrived - why some of you loved the bees and others were more locked into the Ben mystery - whether William’s storyline is finally getting interesting - and if the...
info_outlineOutlander Cast: The Outlander Podcast With Mary & Blake
In this episode of Outlander Cast, we break down Outlander Season 8 Episode 2, “Prophecies” — from Amy’s shocking bear attack and Claire’s heartbreaking inability to save her, to Captain Cunningham’s suspiciously helpful hero turn, to the increasingly unsettling way Frank Randall is haunting Jamie Fraser from beyond the page. We also get into William’s Ben Grey mystery, Ian and Rachel’s baby boy, and why this episode feels like Outlander returning to the emotional engine that made the show great in the first place. Ratings Mary’s Kilt Rating: 4.6/5 Blake’s Kilt Rating:...
info_outlineOutlander Cast: The Outlander Podcast With Mary & Blake
Hook The premiere is finally here, the fandom is fully activated, and the reactions are all over the map. In this listener feedback episode, Mary and Blake sort through the love, the frustration, the theories, and the very real end-of-an-era feelings surrounding Outlander Season 8 Episode 1, “Soul of a Rebel.” Ratings Listener Kilt ratings in this episode generally land in the 4.0–4.7 range, even while many listeners still hammer the Faith storyline and debate whether the reunion beats really landed. Spoiler Warning Full spoilers for Outlander Season 8 Episode 1, “Soul of a Rebel,”...
info_outlineOutlander Cast: The Outlander Podcast With Mary & Blake
The final season opens the way a premiere probably should: with a big emotional homecoming, a whole lot of Ridge warmth, and just enough mess to remind you this show never lets anyone stay comfortable for long. Mary and Blake are thrilled to be back in Outlander with Bear McCreary, Fraser’s Ridge, and all the familiar faces — but they also dig into the episode’s biggest problem: the Faith thread, which feels less like elegant storytelling and more like the show getting a little too cute for its own good. Ratings Mary’s Kilt Rating: 4.2 / 5 Blake’s Kilt Rating: 3.8 / 5 Mary, who...
info_outlineOutlander Cast: The Outlander Podcast With Mary & Blake
Full spoilers for Outlander: Blood of My Blood Season 1 Episode 6 — “Birthright.” This one is a lot: a superstition-soaked birth episode that’s impressively made… and still wildly uncomfortable. We break down Julia’s labor under “punishment” framing, Davina’s POV shift, Henry’s grief spiral with Sema, and why Arch Bug’s “human moment” might be pure manipulation. Kilt Ratings: Mary — 3.9 | Blake — 2.5 BomB Impact: 0/5 (for us, it doesn’t really enrich Outlander proper) What we cover: The episode’s core vibe: “uncomfortable” (and why that matters)...
info_outlineOutlander Cast: The Outlander Podcast With Mary & Blake
Mary & Blake recap and give their reaction to episode 1.05 of Outlander: Blood of My Blood, entitled "Needfire" They break down Ellen being crowned May Queen while secretly handfasting with Brian (and yes… doing the business in a church), the show’s gorgeous “hands” visual motif, and why this episode finally feels like classic early-Outlander magic again. Meanwhile, Julia and Henry keep missing each other by inches, Davina detonates the pregnancy truth, Lord Lovett gets nastier, and Murtagh—day-drunk and heartbroken—pulls the most catastrophic “wrong name” slip possible....
info_outlineOutlander Cast: The Outlander Podcast With Mary & Blake
Mary & Blake recap and give their reaction to episode 1.04 of Outlander: Blood of My Blood, entitled "A Soldier's Heart" This week, they dive into the significance of Beltane, the portrayal of PTSD through Henry’s character, and the evolving relationships between Julia/Henry and Brian/Ellen. They discuss fairy folklore, Outlander Easter eggs, and the chess-like moves of Ellen Mackenzie. Plus, enjoy a listener feedback segment featuring theories, favorite moments, and a few laughs about fake beards and more Midwest salad talk. Don’t miss Blake’s outlandish theory of the week and the...
info_outlineOutlander Cast: The Outlander Podcast With Mary & Blake
recap and give their reaction to episode 1.03 of Outlander: Blood of My Blood, entitled "The School Of The Moon" This week, they dive into the political intrigue and family drama at Castle Leoch, where Ellen Mackenzie maneuvers her brothers and clan alliances, and Julia faces a life-altering decision to protect her unborn child. The hosts discuss standout moments, including the infamous rap battle, Lord Lovat’s Real Housewives-style scheming, and the emotional flashbacks that shape the Mackenzie siblings. Expect lively banter about character motivations, continuity questions, and how...
info_outlineOutlander Cast: The Outlander Podcast With Mary & Blake
recap and give their reaction to episode 1.02 of Outlander: Blood of My Blood, entitled "S.W.A.K." This episode recap explores the emotional World War I sequences, the blossoming (and nerdy!) chemistry between Henry Beecham and Julia Morsten, and the significance of love letters as both a narrative device and a lifeline for the characters. The hosts break down the historical context of the Battle of Passchendaele, discuss the impact of time travel on Claire’s family legacy, and analyze the visual storytelling and character parallels between past and present. Plus, enjoy their signature kilt...
info_outlineMary & Blake discuss everything YOU had say about to Outlander episode 7.12 - Carnal Knowledge.
In this episode, we discuss our podcast's history and then dive into the episode, with Blake critiquing Rob Cameron's questionable plan and praising the development of Lord John Gray. we also cover storylines like William's reaction to learning Jamie is his father, and the intimate scenes between the characters. The hosts engage thoughtfully with the different perspectives, highlighting insightful comments and respectfully disagreeing where appropriate.
Also in this episode:
- This is the last Outlander Cast podcast episode of 2024, recorded on New Year's Eve. The hosts reflect on the significance of this milestone and the number of podcasts they have done over the years.
- Blake criticizes the character of Rob Cameron, describing his plan to steal a child as incompetent and creepy. He compares Rob to a Hufflepuff, while Mary disagrees with his assessment.
- The discussion around Lord John Gray's character development is a major focus. Listeners express differing opinions on whether he could lead his own spin-off series, with Blake remaining skeptical despite the character's growth.
- Kathy offers a nuanced critique, arguing the adaptation felt stale and the editing choices during intimate scenes were problematic. She believes the show missed opportunities to make the book material richer.
- Elizabeth praises the introduction of the character Jane but is critical of the execution of the Jamie/Claire sex scene, finding it underwhelming.
- Jillian discusses the emotional complexity of the Claire/Lord John intimate scene, questioning the portrayal of consent. Other listeners echo similar concerns.
- Positive feedback includes praise for William's character development, Lord John's increased depth, and the reconciliation between Jamie and Claire, though some find fault with the execution.
SUBSCRIBE TO OUTLANDER CAST: AN OUTLANDER PODCAST
CONNECT WITH MARY & BLAKE
- Like Our Facebook Page
- Join Our Facebook Group
- Join The #NerdClan
- Follow On Twitter
- Follow On Instagram
UNLOCK BONUS EPISODES, PREMIUM PODCASTS & MORE -- www.JoinTheNerdClan.com
Sign up HERE for Blake's Book Club: DRUMS OF AUTUMN
CHECK OUT THE BEST MERCH ON THE PLANET: THE MARY & BLAKE STORE
Shop for all of our podcasts, sayings, and listener inspired designs in one easy place.
FOLLOW ALL OF OUR PODCASTS AT MARY & BLAKE:
- This Is Us Too: A This Is Us Podcast
- The Pokemon Pokedex With Rhys & Felicity: A Pokemon Podcast
- The Percy Jackson Prophecy: A Percy Jackson Podcast
- The MCU Diaries: Essays On Marvel Television Podcast
- Bridgerton With Mary & Blake: A Bridgerton Podcast
- Keep Calm And Crown On: The Crown Podcast
- Minute With Mary: A Younique Network Marketing Podcast
- Rise Up!: A Hamilton Podcast
- The Leftovers Podcast: The Living Reminders
- The North Remembers: A Game Of Thrones Podcast
- Wicked Rhody: A Podcast About Rhode Island Events and Life
- You’ve Been Gilmored: A Gilmore Girls Podcast
- ParentCast: A Podcast For New Parents
- Outlander Cast: An Outlander Podcast
- The Potterverse: A Harry Potter Podcast
- The Last Kingdom With Mary & Blake: A Podcast For The Last Kingdom
- House Of The Dragon With Mary & Blake: A Podcast For House Of The Dragon
- The Rings Of Power With Mary & Blake: A Rings Of Power Podcast
READ OUR LATEST BLOGS AT MARY & BLAKE:
A huge thank you to all of our members at the #NERDCLAN for helping to make this podcast possible.
EXECUTIVE PRODUCERS
SuzyQ, Joanne Felci, Nadra Assaf, Siobhan M. O'Connor, Katy Valentine, Maryanne St. Laurent, Sara Zoknoen, MD, Martha, Anne Gavin, Bobbi Franchella, Peg Cumbie, Dana Mott-Bronson, Kirstie Wilson
CO - PRODUCERS
Kristina Mann, Candace Galbraith, Jennifer L. Dominick, Whitney Robins, Tina Schneider, Sharon Stevenson-Kelley, Barbara Falk, Keelin Dawe, Meredith Bustillo,
ASSOCIATE PRODUCERS
Louan, Laura Dassrath, Suzanne Moss, Sarah Dietderich, Brenda Lowrie, Dianna Anderson, Stephanie Holm, Tracy Enos, Jeffrey Zellan, Shonna Chapman, Dianne Karpowicz, Candy Hartsock, Carolyn Needham, Patricia Barron Tardio, Angie Leith, Karen Snelling, Christine Milleker, Marilyn L. Neenan