S9 Ep24 CHERRY PICK VINTAGE: Brooklyn O’Neill, co-founder - on sorting and grading 250,000 lbs of secondhand clothing each month for 3 vintage shops and a wholesale business.
Pre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl
Release Date: 08/18/2025
Pre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl
On today's show, we're chatting with Karyn Dethrow, owner of Dethrose Vintage in Chicago. Dethrose Vintage specializes in ultra-rare pieces, and Karyn takes pride in restoring every find – from the 1910s through the 1990s – to as close to its original state as possible, so it's ready to be worn and loved again as soon as it arrives at your door. In this episode, Karyn shares her journey into vintage, which started with her vintage dealer sister introducing her to the Bins in Southern Illinois, where she found some of her first 1940s pieces. She shares why vintage from the 1930s became her...
info_outlinePre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl
On today's show, we're chatting with Renée Morin, Chief Sustainability Officer at eBay. eBay has been in the resale game since 1995 – long before 'recommerce' was even a term. Today, as Chief Sustainability Officer, Renée leads eBay's environmental programs and sustainability strategy. In this episode, Renée shares her journey from being the kid who petitioned her school to stop using styrofoam plates to leading sustainability efforts at one of the world's largest recommerce platforms. She shares how her time in the Peace Corps brought environmental concerns into sharp focus, and how she...
info_outlinePre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl
On today's show, we're chatting with Annapurna Rogers, a Brooklyn-based vintage curator and the owner of Annapurna Vintage. Anna specializes in exceptional pieces from the 1960s through the 1990s for the modern woman – think well-constructed blazers, iconic coats, and those showstopper garments that elevate any wardrobe. In this episode, she shares her journey from growing up as a thrift-loving kid in Portland, Oregon – where she'd walk to Valley Village and find mod 60s dresses to wear to middle school – to running the daily operations of the Arcade vintage store for A Current Affair in...
info_outlinePre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl
On today's show, we're chatting with Stef, the founder of Costura, a Y2K vintage fashion business that does serious volume on Whatnot. Stef started reselling full-time after losing her job during the pandemic, and for the last three and a half years, she’s been hosting live auctions on the livestream platform, Whatnot – sometimes she even goes live daily. In this episode, she shares how she’s built a loyal community of cool people who love early 2000s fashion, plus her best tips for livestream sales. Earlier this year, Stef teamed up with a few business partners to make her biggest...
info_outlinePre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl
On today's show, we're chatting with Hilliary—a vintage collector and event producer who's building community at the intersection of sustainability and style. Hilliary is the founder of Circle of Friends, where she hosts The Stoop Series—a live interview series that's making circular fashion accessible and inspiring. With Circle of Friends, she's using her platform to elevate the voices of vintage dealers, sustainable brands, and circular economy innovators, showing people why secondhand should always be the first choice. And if you're a collector yourself, you're going to love this...
info_outlinePre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl
On today's show, we're chatting with Hailey and Hallie –two best friends who turned their high school thrifting hobby into a thriving brick-and-mortar vintage shop in Asbury Park, New Jersey. Hailey and Hallie met in high school gym class, and bonded over their shared love of thrifting, Tumblr, fashion, and magazines. They started thrifting together and listing their finds on Depop as a fun creative outlet after school. As they grew up, the shop’s story evolved – the duo opened their first brick-and-mortar store in a tiny beach town while finishing up school. They’ve since moved their...
info_outlinePre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl
On today's show, we're chatting with Tara, of Call Me the Breeze – where she’s best known for curating and restoring vintage wedding dresses. Tara lives in rural South Australia on an off-the-grid farm with no neighbors for miles. Last year, Tara made a huge pivot – closing her decade-old multi-brand brick-and-mortar shop to lean into her love for vintage and antique fashion. It all started when she acquired a massive collection, which included suitcases of antique bridal and lingerie, the works. Now Tara operates an online vintage studio business out of a haunted (!!) heritage mansion...
info_outlinePre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl
On today's show, we're chatting with Janelle Abbott, the artist and designer behind JRAT. Raised in her parents’ Seattle clothing factory, Janelle grew up with an early respect for the labor that goes into making clothing. After graduating from Parsons, she rejected corporate fashion, choosing a radically sustainable, zero-waste path. Through her brand JRAT, she transforms discarded and found materials into one-of a-kind garments – her work merges activism, art, and performance—as she exposes fast fashion’s farce through garment reclamation, reminding us that all garments...
info_outlinePre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl
This episode is brought to you by —and big news: their tech just got a serious upgrade, go check it out! Plus, new customers get 50% off and free shipping when you use the code: PRELOVEDPOD. On today's show, we're chatting with Rachel Stillman, the founder of Ornate Vintage Co. Rachel's journey into vintage started young—growing up surrounded by fashion and art, with a grandfather who was an artist and dealer, a grandmother who was a fashion designer, and a mother who also graduated from FIT, where Rachel herself studied fashion, and sells vintage jewelry. At just 20 years old, as a...
info_outlinePre-Loved Podcast with Emily Stochl
This episode is brought to you by —and big news: their tech just got a serious upgrade, go check it out! Plus, new customers get 50% off and free shipping when you use the code: PRELOVEDPOD. On today’s show, we’re chatting with Ken, the founder of Stylebidder, a secondhand shop specializing in vintage and designer menswear. Ken has been selling for over thirteen years, starting out on eBay and Grailed, and he eventually expanded to his own online store and pop-ups events across the northeast including Newport Folk Festival & Alfargo's Marketplace. Ken is a true Ivy style...
info_outlineOn today’s show, we’re chatting with Brooklyn O’Neill, one of co-founders of Cherry Pick Vintage, which operates 3 vintage retail shops and a wholesale business across British Columbia, Canada.
Brooklyn’s fiancé, Andrew is a third-generation clothing recycler, and the Cherry Pick Vintage team sorts and grades 250,000 lbs of secondhand clothing at the family’s warehouse each month – proving that “everything you want already exists!”
On this episode you’ll learn what it’s like to sort through 20,000 lbs of clothing each day, and the wildest discoveries that turn up in those bales.
Plus, why Brooklyn intentionally puts her massive warehouse operation on full display and how this became key to both Cherry Pick’s social media success and their mission to show people how much clothing already exists.
I think you’re gonna love it, so – let’s dive right in!
DISCUSSED IN THE EPISODE:
- [4:13] Though Brooklyn didn’t grow up thrifting, she spotted a gap in the market for an accessible, wearable secondhand shopping experience in her community.
- [5:30] Her fiancé, Andrew, is a third-generation clothing recycler.
- [7:57] Together, they decided to start Cherry Pick Vintage, now 3 retail shops and a wholesale company.
- [10:43] They quickly realized there was a lot more value in the clothing in the warehouse than originally thought.
- [11:43] How the raghouse at Cherry Pick works.
- [12:37] The sorting process for grading 20,000 lbs of clothing a day.
- [15:03] The Rag Yard Market where shoppers can dig through thousands of pounds of pre-loved clothing for only $7/lb!
- [17:14] Opening three retail locations across British Columbia in just three years.
- [23:38] How wholesaling works at Cherry Pick Vintage.
- [26:52] How social media played a large role in the growth of Cherry Pick.
- [28:24] Why Brooklyn puts the warehouse operation on full display to show how much clothing exists.
- [31:40] Social media advice for vintage business owners.
- [33:18] The wildest find the team has ever pulled out of the bales.
- [38:28] Holy grail vintage finds including 1960s Levi's and a WWII bomber jacket.
- [40:46] Brooklyn's personal style and her treasured 1993 Elton John x Versace tour tee.
EPISODE MENTIONS:
- Cherry Pick Vintage
- @cherrypick.vtg
- @cherrypickwholesale
- Rag Yard Market
- How to Navigate Vintage Wholesale (on Pre-Loved)
- Heart and Lou
LET’S CONNECT:
- 📸Instagram: @emilymstochl
- 🐦Threads: @emilymstochl
- 🎥TikTok: @emilymstochl
- 📧 Substack: https://prelovedpod.substack.com/
- 🎧Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/prelovedpod
SPECIAL THANKS:
A special thanks goes out to my Patron Insiders – your support makes Pre-Loved Podcast possible!
- Patty Weber
- Kathy Brand
- Lisa of Queenie & Pearl
- KT
- Lydia Welp
- Michael A.
- Megan Morris
- Jennifer
- Alana Rivero
- Jerrica Yasumura