527: Challenging the Conventional Wisdom of Stocks vs. Bonds and Common Retirement Planning Strategies with Edward McQuarrie

Today, I’m speaking with Edward McQuarrie. Ed is the Professor Emeritus at Santa Clara University, where he taught in the marketing department for more than three decades before retiring in 2016. After stepping away from teaching, Ed pursued a new passion in researching financial market history and retirement income planning. 

His work has been featured in the Wall Street Journal, MarketWatch, and Barron’s, and he frequently contributes to our Weekend Reading for Retirees series. He was introduced to us by past guest William Bernstein, who insisted Ed would be a must-hear voice on the show.

In this conversation, Ed challenges decades of conventional wisdom around investing. He explains why “stocks for the long run” isn’t always the safest bet, how cherry-picked data can mislead investors, and why separating risk-free assets from growth assets may be more important than diversification alone. Ed also shares the insights from his extensive historical research, covering stock and bond returns going back to the 1700s, and how it relates to retirement planning today.

We also dig into the evolving conversation around Roth conversions, the limitations of relying solely on stocks and bonds, and why tools like TIPS ladders or annuities can help secure baseline retirement income. Ed’s clear-eyed, historically grounded perspective will challenge the assumptions you’ve been taught and help you build a more resilient, reality-based plan for the future.

In this podcast interview, you’ll learn:

• Why “stocks always outperform bonds” is a myth—and what 200 years of history actually reveal.
• The risks of relying on cherry-picked data in financial planning.
• How economic “regimes” shape investment returns across decades and centuries.
• Why risk separation, not just diversification, is key to retirement planning.
• The pros and cons of Roth conversions—and why sometimes doing nothing may be the smartest move.
• How to use TIPS ladders, annuities, and other tools to secure your baseline retirement income.

Show Notes: HowardBailey.com/527

📧 WEEKEND READING FOR RETIREES: Receive CFP® insight on 4 hand-picked financial articles delivered straight to your Inbox each Friday: https://bit.ly/3OEdGgu 

📅SCHEDULE YOUR PERSONAL FINANCIAL REVIEW: Book a 15-minute call with Howard Bailey Financial to see how the topics discussed here apply to your individual situation: https://bit.ly/3T6oNDB

ABOUT HOWARD BAILEY FINANCIAL: Our mission is to help others gain clarity in purpose and elevate meaning in their lives through personal and practical financial strategies. Our Retire With Purpose™ Framework starts with establishing your unique financial philosophy — the true meaning and purpose for your money in retirement. Through continued education, one-on-one meetings, and a comprehensive team planning approach, we have helped retirees across the country secure their financial futures. And while we can't work with everyone, our goal is to provide value to everyone we meet. Our team of advisors and support specialists strive to deliver the very best experience in pre-retirement and retirement planning. Learn more about our process here: https://howardbailey.com/our-process