loader from loading.io

Can We Say That? Election-Year Advocacy Rule for 501(c)(3)s

Rules of the Game: The Bolder Advocacy Podcast

Release Date: 08/19/2020

State Advocacy show art State Advocacy

Rules of the Game: The Bolder Advocacy Podcast

In today's episode, we’re focusing on the topic of state advocacy, specifically exploring the vital role that nonprofits play in shaping policy and driving change at the state level, and how that role is increasingly coming under attack. We will discuss some of the landscape nonprofits are currently facing at the state level and provide actionable tips for organizations looking to amplify their impact. And we’ll be sharing information about exciting new state resources that are in progress at Bolder Advocacy! Attorneys for this Episode Brittany Hacker Maggie Ellinger-Locke Sarah Efthymiou...

info_outline
Threats to Tax Exempt Status show art Threats to Tax Exempt Status

Rules of the Game: The Bolder Advocacy Podcast

On this episode, we’re diving into a topic that’s especially important in today’s high-stakes advocacy environment — threats to your tax-exempt status. Yes, we’re talking about that precious 501(c)(3) status, the one that lets your organization do good in the world without paying taxes, and with the constant challenge of figuring out how to advocate, influence policy, and make change without accidentally stepping into ‘oops, we might lose our status’ territory. Attorneys for this Episode Monika Graham Victor Rivera Special guests, interns Ariana and Cecilia Shownotes Lobbying...

info_outline
Advocacy Check Up (Rebroadcast) show art Advocacy Check Up (Rebroadcast)

Rules of the Game: The Bolder Advocacy Podcast

This is a special rebroadcast of an episode from earlier this year on a self assessment tool that our nonprofit listeners should know about because of the continued and on-going threats of politically motivated investigations and attacks on the sector. We'll be back in two weeks with a brand new episode.  * * *  For those who caught our most recent podcast on Nonprofit New Year’s Resolutions – Resolution #2 was to conduct an Advocacy Check Up. In this episode, we’re deeper into how to do that. We released new Nonprofit Self-Assessment tool, designed to help nonprofit...

info_outline
Politically Motivated Attacks Revisited show art Politically Motivated Attacks Revisited

Rules of the Game: The Bolder Advocacy Podcast

  ROTG137 Politically Motivated Attacks Revisited   Nonprofit advocates face a complex environment in 2025 where political disagreements routinely escalate into targeted attacks—ranging from carefully crafted misinformation to more extreme tactics like organizational funding cuts, subpoenas, and personal targeting. This episode explores the emerging challenges advocates encounter, offering insights into recognizing, preparing for, and navigating these increasingly sophisticated forms of political pushback.   Attorneys for this Episode Brittany Hacker Tim Mooney Quyen Tu  ...

info_outline
Advocacy for Labor and Economic Justice show art Advocacy for Labor and Economic Justice

Rules of the Game: The Bolder Advocacy Podcast

Today we're wrapping up our eight-part series by exploring how labor and economic justice nonprofits can advance their missions through advocacy. We'll cover recent developments and examine both lobbying and non-lobbying strategies that advocates are using to improve economic justice for all.   Attorneys for this episode   Tim Mooney Susan Finkle Sourlis Sarah Efthymiou   Shownotes Current Events / Executive Orders ·      Trump Administration Directives Impacting Workers o   In March, President Trump issued an executive order exempting...

info_outline
Advocacy for Health and Disability Rights show art Advocacy for Health and Disability Rights

Rules of the Game: The Bolder Advocacy Podcast

Today we're diving into the seventh installment of our eight-part, issue-based podcast series, and we will explore how nonprofits that operate in the health and disability rights space can boldly advance their missions through advocacy. Not only will we touch on recent developments in the news, but we’ll also discuss various lobbying and non-lobbying strategies currently being used by nonprofit advocates working to improve healthcare access and disability rights.   Attorneys for this episode   Natalie Ossenfort Monika Graham Victor Rivera   Shownotes Current Events /...

info_outline
Advocacy for Democracy and Voting Rights show art Advocacy for Democracy and Voting Rights

Rules of the Game: The Bolder Advocacy Podcast

Today we're diving into the sixth of our eight-part series, exploring how nonprofits champion democracy and protect voting rights. We'll unpack the strategies these organizations use to advocate for democratic participation while operating within the law. This conversation feels especially urgent as we see acceleration to challenges to voting rights and democratic institutions in 2025.   Attorneys for this episode   Tim Mooney  Natalie Ossenfort Susan Finkle Sourlis    Shownotes Current Events / Executive Orders ·      Trump Administration...

info_outline
Advocacy for Gender & Reproductive Justice show art Advocacy for Gender & Reproductive Justice

Rules of the Game: The Bolder Advocacy Podcast

  On this episode, the fifth installment of our eight-part, issue-specific series, we’ll explore how nonprofits can boldly and safely advocate for gender and reproductive justice. We’ll review recent policy developments and discuss how nonprofits can respond through legislative, executive, and judicial branch advocacy. Join us as we break down the rules and share recent examples of how nonprofits are advancing gender and reproductive justice.     Attorneys for this episode    Quyen Tu  Brittany Hacker  Melissa Marichal Zayas  ...

info_outline
Advocacy for Environmental Justice show art Advocacy for Environmental Justice

Rules of the Game: The Bolder Advocacy Podcast

In today's episode continuing our eight-part series, we examine how nonprofits are effectively advocating for environmental justice. We'll analyze practical strategies for building awareness and securing advocacy funding while navigating the regulatory frameworks that govern nonprofit activism. Join us for a clear-eyed look at how organizations are making meaningful progress in environmental protection and climate action.    Attorneys for this episode   Tim Mooney  Quyen Tu  Susan Finkle Sourlis    Shownotes   Current Events / Executive Orders: ...

info_outline
Advocacy for Criminal Legal Reform show art Advocacy for Criminal Legal Reform

Rules of the Game: The Bolder Advocacy Podcast

On this episode of the Rules of the Game podcast (the third in an eight-part, issue-specific podcast series), we’ll discuss recent headlines impacting criminal legal reform advocates and explain how nonprofits can take action with legislative, executive branch, and judicial branch advocacy. From responding to legislative proposals to initiating litigation, nonprofits nationwide are standing up to fight for our rights and critical reforms to our criminal legal system. This episode will highlight their work and provide information about the rules that apply when nonprofits engage in advocacy...

info_outline
 
More Episodes

Can 501(c)(3)s advocate to advance their mission while remaining nonpartisan during an election year? Tim, Leslie and Quyen explain the factors that the IRS looks at, and use a recent example to show how small changes in the content or context of a communication can change things. 

 

Our attorneys for this episode

Tim Mooney

Leslie Barnes

Quyen Tu

 

Shownotes

  • The one rule 501(c)(3)s need to know during election year — 501(c)(3)s cannot support or oppose candidates for public office.
  • An election year is a great opportunity to elevate the issues your nonprofit works on every day. There are so many ways nonprofits can engage with voters, candidates and elected officials. 
  •  Think of your advocacy like a road – there's plenty of room to maneuver but this rule sets up guardrails you can’t cross.  
  •  But the guardrails define the legal advocacy that can happen on the metaphorical road, so we start there. 501(c)(3)s cannot support or oppose candidates for public office, which means their activities must be nonpartisan. 
  •  To determine whether or not a 501(c)(3) is nonpartisan, the IRS looks at all of the facts and circumstances. This is a subjective, risk analysis that takes into accounts everything the organization is saying and the context in which it’s saying that. 
  • Six things the IRS looks at in the facts & circumstances analysis:
  1. Track record of advocacy 
  2. Timing relative to election 
  3. Electoral or non-electoral factor driving the activity/communication 
  4. References to candidate/election or comparing candidate positions. 
  5. Is your message targeting for electoral or non-electoral reasons
  6. Wedge issues
  • Context matters, but intent does not. This is an exercise in risk analysis, so we use a stop light analogy – red light is risky, green light low or no risk, and yellow light somewhere in between.  

 

Example

pastedGraphic.pngSource: Earthjustice tweet of July 2, 2020.

 

  • Our analysis: this was low-to-no risk tweet. Let’s go through a facts & circumstances analysis to understand why. 
    1. Earthjustice’s track record of advocacy 
    2. Mentioning a candidate, but out of context of the election
    3. Timing of the communication is far away enough from the election
    4. Communication based on non-election trigger (ongoing litigation)
  • How do changes in timing and language affect the analysis?
    • The same communication in late October may be higher risk unless the timing were linked to something independent of the election (such as a court opinion right then) 
    • But replace the reference to the Trump administration with the named defendant Army Corps of Engineers and the risk lowers again.
    • Some additional language may make things much riskier, like adding a hashtag #RememberInNovember or some other implicit or explicit link to the election.

 

Resources