Unmasking the 1982 Chicago Tylenol Killer - America's First Product Tampering Panic
Scary Savannah and Beyond
In this gripping true crime episode, Crystal and Brett dive into the chilling case of the 1982 Chicago Tylenol murders—a nationwide panic that changed the way we package and trust over-the-counter medicine forever. Explore the tragic string of cyanide-laced Tylenol deaths, the ensuing public hysteria, and the intense manhunt for the elusive killer. With dark humor, historical context, and a deep dive into suspects like James William Lewis and Roger Arnold, the hosts unpack one of the most infamous unsolved cases in American history. If you love true crime, unsolved mysteries, 1980s...
info_outline
Beach Bums, Buckets of Water, and Bad Decisions - Tybee Island Police Blotter May 2025
Scary Savannah and Beyond
This week on the Tybee Island Police Blotter, we’re diving into the wildest and weirdest crimes from May 2025—including a naked man wandering Butler Avenue, public drunkenness, paddleboard theft, and multiple bizarre DUI arrests (one involving a psychedelic mushroom candy bar!). Brett and Crystal bring their signature humor and storytelling flair as they react to each case, relive chaotic Beach Bum memories, and discuss the island’s unique police antics. Tune in for true crime with a comedic twist, small-town oddities, and unexpected legal drama—all set on the quirky shores of Tybee...
info_outline
Stolen Baby Jesus Surfboard on Tybee? Tybee Island Police Blotter - Small Town True Crime
Scary Savannah and Beyond
Join Brett and Crystal in this hilarious comeback episode of the Island Police Blotter podcast, where they unpack outrageous crime reports from Tybee Island — from stolen surfboards and rogue golf carts to marijuana mishaps and wild nursing home brawls. After a long break and a chaotic studio revamp, the duo is back with their signature banter, witty commentary, and laugh-out-loud takes on local mayhem. If you love true crime with a comedic twist, quirky small-town drama, and behind-the-scenes podcast chaos, hit play and subscribe for more episodes full of island antics and unpredictable...
info_outline
Tybee Island Police Blotter 3/1/25-3/31/25 Updates From Savannah's Beach
Scary Savannah and Beyond
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. We’re using a new studio setup this week, and it’s wild. And as always, we’re finding odors emitting. Find us on the web: Please leave us a 5 star review, and we’ll read it on air! You can find a link to do this on our webpage, just click on the links tab. If you do, send us a message through the contact form on our webpage, let us know, and we’ll send you some free Scary Savannah stickers! Give...
info_outline
Ep. 94: The Philadelphia Experiment, A World War 2 Era Mystery
Scary Savannah and Beyond
This week we’re talking about the alleged event “The Philadelphia Experiment,” which is said to have happened around October 1943. The USS Eldrige was supposedly testing new government technology that might allow things like time travel and dimensional warping. Woohoo! On What We’re Watching we talk about the 2019 show “Tacoma FD.” On Layla and Coffee Talk, the girls are up to their usual shenanigans. Find us on the web: Please leave us a 5 star review, and we’ll read it on air! You can find a link to do this on our webpage, just click on the links tab. If you do, send us a...
info_outline
Tybee Island Police Blotter 1/1/25-3/1/25 Updates from Savannah's Beach
Scary Savannah and Beyond
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. After a long delay we’re back - and we’re recapping some of the things that have been happening around the island up to March of 2025. As expected, odors emitting. Find us on the web: Please leave us a 5 star review, and we’ll read it on air! You can find a link to do this on our webpage, just click on the links tab. If you do, send us a message through the contact form on our webpage, let us know,...
info_outline
Tybee Island Police Blotter 12/31/24-1/12/25 Updates from Savannah's Beach
Scary Savannah and Beyond
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. Before the show we reveal more information regarding Cynthia (the haunted life preserver), as it turns out some locals were familiar with the vessel it came from. We’re dealing with several dazed people on this episode, and of course, a plethora of odors emitting. Find us on the web: Please leave us a 5 star review, and we’ll read it on air! You can find a link to do this on our webpage, just click on...
info_outline
Ep. 93: Ghosts of Tybee Island Vol. 1 - The Haunting of Cynthia
Scary Savannah and Beyond
We’re back in the New Year with our first regular episode! We haven’t done a paranormal show in a little while, and we’ve always wanted to talk about some of the mysterious ghost stories on our home of little Tybee Island (which is just outside of Savannah). We have several stories we’ll be releasing throughout several episodes, but for our first in the series, we wanted to talk about one that really hit home. And we’re serious about home, because this story is about our very own ghost. Several years ago we came into possession of a life preserver that was used on a tug boat in...
info_outline
Tybee Island Police Blotter 9/30/24-12/31/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
Scary Savannah and Beyond
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. One of our New Year’s resolutions is to get back to the podcast! We’ve spent some time doing other things, but for 2025 we’re back! New episodes every other week and police blotters on their normally scheduled days. We had a lot to get through, so we summed up from 9/30-12/31/24! So basically an entire quarter of odors emitting and other weird things. Find us on the web: Please leave us a 5 star...
info_outline
Tybee Island Police Blotter 9/2/24-9/29/24 Updates from Savannah's Beach
Scary Savannah and Beyond
In this week’s bonus episode, we’re going back to the Tybee Island Police Blotter to talk about some of the crazy things that go on on the island right outside of Savannah, Georgia. Lots of guns left in weird places, the usual speeding and odors emitting. Wrong ways on a one way, are the juveniles returning? We talk about that and more on this episode. Find us on the web: Please leave us a 5 star review, and we’ll read it on air! You can find a link to do this on our webpage, just click on the links tab. If you do, send us a message through the contact form on our webpage, let us...
info_outlineThis is an update regarding our show.
We've been going since Halloween 2021 and haven't missed issuing an episode every Sunday since then. This has been a lot of fun and we love doing it, but we've come to the point where we need to step back a little and take a little break.
We've decided to take a Summer break, so to speak, from regularly scripted episodes.
This will be until August of this year.
We're still going to release our bi-weekly police blotter as scheduled during this time.
We need a break to rest and recharge for all of the new stories we want to keep bringing you.
We're not quitting - we love doing this. We just realized that we need a little time to ourselves to get back to peak podcasting form.
Podcasting is something we both love and in order to keep going, we need a break.
To all of our listeners - we hope you stick with us, and thanks for listening to Scary Savannah and Beyond!