loader from loading.io

Episode Dallas Drake (510): Does the NHL Have a Tampering Problem? More Sad News for the Goalie Union.

ScuttlePuck NHL Hockey Podcast

Release Date: 09/26/2025

Episode Cam Atkinson (515): Leafs and Oilers Struggles. Hall of Fame Class of '25. show art Episode Cam Atkinson (515): Leafs and Oilers Struggles. Hall of Fame Class of '25.

ScuttlePuck NHL Hockey Podcast

After a couple of weeks away due to work and pleasure we're back and there is lots to discuss. Both the Leafs and Oilers have had middling starts to the season and we get into what's wrong and a little on how to fix it. The Hall of Fame inducted this years' new members and there were some real beauties.   Listen Here:         Title Player: Cam Atkinson News 2025 Hall of Fame Inductees Bedard Hat Trick Oilers and Leafs Struggles Guess the 5th Standings review - Atlantic  and Pacific significant surprises Connections: What connects Dit Clapper, Ted...

info_outline
Episode Jere Lehtinen (514): Milt Schmidt Award Winners. Early Surprises in NHL. show art Episode Jere Lehtinen (514): Milt Schmidt Award Winners. Early Surprises in NHL.

ScuttlePuck NHL Hockey Podcast

We finally announce the first cohort of ScuttlePuck Milt Schmidt Award winners! We also discuss the underwhelming start by both the Leafs and Oilers and look at the major surprises so far.   Listen Here:         Title Player Jere Lehtinen News Ovechkin closes on 900G Bettman Interview on 32 Thoughts Ducks off to surprising start Leafs and Oilers underwhelm NBA gambling scandaal Guess the 5th MILT SCHMIDT AWARD WINNERS NHL Surprises - East Top 3 in Atlantic includes MTL and DET Last in East is TBL Connections  Last week - Montreal numbers...

info_outline
Episode Nick Libett (513): NHL 1 Week In.  Some Big Signings this Week. Milt Schmidt Nominees! show art Episode Nick Libett (513): NHL 1 Week In. Some Big Signings this Week. Milt Schmidt Nominees!

ScuttlePuck NHL Hockey Podcast

We are 1 week into the new season but the biggest news this week wasn't game results or team performance, it has  been some big name signings plus a couple of low-key ones that could prove significant. We have the Milt Schmidt Award nominees.   Listen Here:         Title Player Nick Libett News -  Habs honoured Ken Dryden in home opener - cool  BIG Signings Lane Hutson - 8 years, $70.8 MM Jack Eichel - 8yrs, $13.5MM Kyle Connor - 8yr, $12MM Oilers Signings  Jack Roslovic - $1.5MM Mattias Ekhom - $4MM x 3  Leafs 1-2  stumble with...

info_outline
Episode Jyrki Lumme (512): MCDAVID SIGNS!!! show art Episode Jyrki Lumme (512): MCDAVID SIGNS!!!

ScuttlePuck NHL Hockey Podcast

2 Days before the season was to start for him, Connor McDavid gave the Oilers the best news possible by signing a 2 year extension at the same pay that he has been getting for the past 8 years.  It's huge news for the Oilers and their fans. Mike was away in Detroit and recorded remotely to discuss the news.   Listen Here:         Title Player- Jyrki Lumme  News McDavid - $12.5MM x 2 Bowman presser - McDavid - “Everyone understands the situation. We want to win here. We want to bring it back here and make the city proud. But mostly for the guys in...

info_outline
Episode Shawn Horcoff (511):No Need to Watch this NHL Season, We Have All the Predictions! show art Episode Shawn Horcoff (511):No Need to Watch this NHL Season, We Have All the Predictions!

ScuttlePuck NHL Hockey Podcast

The season is a week away and we give all our prognostications on what we expect to happen this year.  There were some bold predictions and some....not so much.    Listen Here:         Title Player Shawn Horcoff Shirts off for Horcoff NEWS Stolarz signs - 4 x $3.75MM Atlantic Division   Team Strengths / What’s Going Well Key Challenges / What Could Go Wrong Expectations or Projection for 2025-26 Florida Panthers They’re coming off back-to-back Stanley Cups, meaning they have experience, confidence, and a championship mindset....

info_outline
Episode Dallas Drake (510): Does the NHL Have a Tampering Problem? More Sad News for the Goalie Union. show art Episode Dallas Drake (510): Does the NHL Have a Tampering Problem? More Sad News for the Goalie Union.

ScuttlePuck NHL Hockey Podcast

Elliotte Friedman has suggested twice in the past week that the Kirill Kaprizov contract situation makes him believe that there is tampering going on. Will the NHL do anything about it? Can they? It's been a tough month for hall of fame goalies as Bernie Parent and Ed Giacomin passed away last week.  All this plus we look to the upcoming season and what we might expect with some off the wall predictions.   Listen Here:         Title Player Dallas Drake Shoutout - Nathaniel from Edmonton -been listening Sending stickers News  Kirill Kaprizov - turned...

info_outline
Episode Dennis Hextall (509): Ken Dryden Tribute. Plus, Why Hasn't McDavid Signed? show art Episode Dennis Hextall (509): Ken Dryden Tribute. Plus, Why Hasn't McDavid Signed?

ScuttlePuck NHL Hockey Podcast

NHL Legend Ken Dryden passed away this weekend and we discuss the remarkable hockey career and post-hockey career he had.  Carey Price's contract got traded and Connor McDavid's next contract has yet to be signed.  Listen Here:         Title Player -  Dennis Hextall News Carey Price Trade to San Jose -  McDavid watch - why hasn’t he signed? Marner Interview with Mark Masters - puff piece extraorinaire CBA - implementing new rules this year -my Tkachuk theory is shot down! Teams can send one 19 year old to AHL instead of Junior Retention rules...

info_outline
Episode Mark Johnson (508): SPECIAL GUEST AARON BELL Talks Junior Hockey. Milt Schmidt Award Candidates Discussion. show art Episode Mark Johnson (508): SPECIAL GUEST AARON BELL Talks Junior Hockey. Milt Schmidt Award Candidates Discussion.

ScuttlePuck NHL Hockey Podcast

Not much going on in the NHL but author Aaron Bell has a new book out titled "Junior Hockey Giants" and he joined us to tell us all about the book and regale us with tales from his time working for the CHL. Plus we have a lively discussion on who should win the inaugural Milt Schmidt award.   Listen Here:         Get Visit Aaron Bell's website   Buy Aaron's Book Title Player  Mark Johnson  News: McDavid contract watch continues - things pretty quiet but “insiders” expect something before training camp in 3-5 year range  Tkachuk -...

info_outline
Episode Darryl Sydor(507): Summer Update. Milt Schmidt Award Brainstorm. show art Episode Darryl Sydor(507): Summer Update. Milt Schmidt Award Brainstorm.

ScuttlePuck NHL Hockey Podcast

We are mid-summer so not alot going on in the NHL but that doesn't we've stopped thinking about hockey. On this episode we finally put together the criteria for the Milt Schmidt award.  We also get up to speed on the latest NHL news including the acquittal of the 5 Hockey Canada players.   Listen Here:         Get Title Player - Darryl Sydor  News  Ehlers signs with Hurricanes $8.5 x 6 yrs Marner signing - tampering explanation from Friedman - Vegas offered Roy to make sure Leafs didn’t place tampering complaint Hockey Canada players...

info_outline
Episode Dit Clapper (506): Draft and Free Agency are Done. It's Summer! show art Episode Dit Clapper (506): Draft and Free Agency are Done. It's Summer!

ScuttlePuck NHL Hockey Podcast

A quick review of the draft and the dreadful presentation by the NHL. We then discuss free agency which had its moments but wasn't really all that consequential. Plus, we give some insight on our summer plans.   Listen Here:         Get Title Player - Dit Clapper - Milt Schmidt  News 2025 Draft - thoughts on decentralized approach / presentation Receiving line of players Draft house where players talked to GMs Will this approach last?  Big moves Canadiens trade 2 x 2025 1st round picks for Noah Dobson  Dobson, 25,  was RFA and looking...

info_outline
 
More Episodes
Elliotte Friedman has suggested twice in the past week that the Kirill Kaprizov contract situation makes him believe that there is tampering going on. Will the NHL do anything about it? Can they? It's been a tough month for hall of fame goalies as Bernie Parent and Ed Giacomin passed away last week.  All this plus we look to the upcoming season and what we might expect with some off the wall predictions. 
 Listen Here:  Apple Podcasts   Direct MP3   iHeart Radio

Title Player Dallas Drake

Shoutout - Nathaniel from Edmonton -been listening Sending stickers

News 

Kirill Kaprizov - turned down 8 x $16,000,000 

Friedman: ON 32 thoughts said his take was that since it didn’t get accepted, Kaprizov’s camp must believe they have an offer higher elsewhere. 

He then said on The Fan Hockey Show - “I do believe there has been tampering going on. I’ll never be able to prove it, but I believe it.” 

Will this be the case where the NHL finally gets to drop the hammer on teams.  

Who is it? 

Oilers

McDavid - waiting for Kaprizov to sign largest deal? 

Friedman says he thinks when McDavid signs, we will be very surprised at how low it will be

Zack Hyman - will be out for a month at least recovering from wrist surgery 

 

Key Departures / Losses

Player

Role / Impact

What the Oilers Lose

Evander Kane

Big, physical winger; provided playoff grit; scored some clutch goals in their run. New York Post+3ESPN.com+3NHL+3

Loss of experience, net-front presence, and some scoring ability on the wing. Cap space freed up. Puckpedia+1

John Klingberg

Veteran defenseman, could move the puck and helped on power plays. Daily Faceoff+1

Leaves a gap in puck-moving defense; need someone to replace his skill set. Daily Faceoff

Corey Perry

Veteran winger, presence in locker room; some scoring and depth contributions. ESPN.com+1

Less veteran depth up front; more need for younger players or middle-6 to step up. FlamesNation

Major Additions & Re-Signings

Player

What They Bring / Role

Expectations or Potential

Andrew Mangiapane (F)

Free agent wing; solid two-way game; brings energy and speed; adds depth to forward group. NHL

Likely to slot into middle-6; expected to provide secondary scoring and help in puck retrieval/forecheck. NHL

Curtis Lazar

Depth forward; solid veteran; can move between lines; helps with penalty killing or bottom-6 work. NHL+1

Probably not a game changer offensively, but gives the Oilers more stable options in depth and more flexibility in line matchups. NHL

Evan Bouchard (D)

Re-signed to a long(er) deal; one of their young top-defensemen; carries big responsibility. NHL+2Puckpedia+2

Expected to be a top pairing or heavy minutes defenseman; important part of their transition and stability at blue line. Puckpedia+1

Vasily Podkolzin (F)

Signed a 3-year extension; was fairly productive; brings physicality (hits/blocked shots) as well as modest offensive contributions. Reuters+1

Should see him keep developing; potentially more trusted in key situations; might take on bigger role if injuries or slumps hit. Reuters

Defense & Goaltending

  • Defense: Largely stable. Outside of Klingberg’s departure, many of the same names remain. There’s some competition for depth defense spots: Ty Emberson is in the mix, as is Troy Stecher. Daily Faceoff+1
    • Key defensemen (like Bouchard, Ekholm, Nurse, Kulak, and Jake Walman) will need to hold up; some have had criticism but generally the group is considered good, if not perfect. Daily Faceoff
  • Goaltending: The plan is to stick with Stuart Skinner as the “starter” with Calvin Pickard backing him up. The Hockey News
    • They brought in a new goalie coach (Peter Aubrey) to try to improve that tandem rather than making a big signing or trade in that area. The Hockey News

 

Cap / Roster Space & Composition

  • The Oilers are tight on cap space. They currently project very little wiggle room (just a few hundred thousand) under the cap. Puckpedia
  • They added some depth cheap, and held on to core players like Bouchard, Draisaitl, McDavid, etc. Puckpedia+2NHL+2
  • The forward group has been revamped a bit — more balance, more depth. Mangiapane and Lazar add to that. NHL+1

 

What to Watch / Weaknesses & Question Marks

  1. Goalie performance — with essentially the same tandem, how much improvement will come from coaching changes vs. in-net execution? If Skinner or Pickard struggle, the team may regret not pursuing a more proven backup or starter.
  2. Defensive consistency — the blue line has high expectations, especially with departures and aging players. How well do the depth defenders perform? Will the pairings hold up under playoff pressure?
  3. Secondary scoring / depth contributions — losing Evander Kane is a noticeable hit in terms of grit and clutch goals. The burden will shift more onto middle lines and depth forwards to chip in.
  4. McDavid contract / future — McDavid enters 2025-26 in the final year of his current contract. There is active discussion / confidence from management that he’ll sign an extension, but the uncertainty looms. Reuters
  5. Special teams — penalty kill was mediocre last season; power play always under the microscope with McDavid/Draisaitl. How much the coaching tweaks help will be critical. Daily Faceoff

LEAFS

Major Departures

Player

Role / Impact

What They Leave Behind

Mitch Marner

Top-6 forward, key playmaker. Trailed Auston Matthews on many scoring charts.

Big offensive void, particularly in assists and secondary scoring. Reuters+1

Ryan Reaves

Enforcer / physical presence, veteran depth forward. NHL+1

Less physical grit, fewer intimidation matchups. Need others to pick up that edge.

Pontus Holmberg

Depth forward, role player. NHL+1

Loss of depth, especially useful in centre / bottom-6 roles.

Max Pacioretty

Veteran winger, scoring ability though recent decline. NHL+1

Leaves space for younger wingers or new signings to step up.

Others also left / not re-signed: some depth forwards, fringe roster spots. hockeypatrol.com+1

 

 

Key Additions & Signings

Player

What They Bring

Role / Expectations

Nicolas Roy

Acquired in the Marner trade. Good two-way forward, can chip in scoring from bottom 6. Reuters+1

 

Matias Maccelli

Younger forward, decent upside. Could slide into top-6 if needed. NHL

 

Dakota Joshua

Physical forward, heavy hitter, adds depth. Reuters+1

 

Henry Thrun

Defenseman acquired from San Jose. Adds youth / depth on the blue line. NHL

 

Michael Pezzetta

Signed to a two-year deal. Depth forward, physicality. NHL

 

Re-Signings & Extensions

  • John Tavares agreed to a 4-year extension. Provides veteran leadership and scoring. Reuters
  • Matthew Knies signed a 6-year, $46.5M deal, becoming more of a foundational piece. The Times of India
  • Goaltending: Anthony Stolarz is in contract extension talks after a strong season. The Times of India

 

Roster & Cap Implications

  • The team loses a high-impact forward (Marner), which both frees up some cap & puts pressure on finding or developing scoring elsewhere. The Hockey News+2hockeypatrol.com+2
  • Expect more responsibility for existing players (e.g. Knies) and for new arrivals like Maccelli or Roy to fill the offensive gaps.
  • Depth players and prospects are in line to get more opportunity. Names like Easton Cowan, William Villeneuve, etc., are under watch. NHL

 

What to Watch / Question Marks

  • Who steps into top-6 scoring alongside Matthews and Nylander. That line is going to be more scrutinized this season.
  • How the Leafs adjust defensively with the incoming younger D-corps (Thrun etc.), and whether the blue line depth is improved.
  • Goaltending consistency: Stolarz’s extension talks suggest they want stability there. Joseph Woll’s role likely stays important. The Hockey News
  • Whether the loss of Marner and Pacioretty will hurt in the playoffs more than during the regular season, especially in tight matchups.

Goalie deaths - Bernie Parent, Ed Giacomin passed away - 3 legendary goalies in a short span 

Guess the 5th 

Off the Wall predictions - provide 3 - we can go back and forth alternating our predictions. Discuss each and the likelihood of happening. 

ChatGPT’s 

  1. Goalie hits 10 points
  2. 100 point Defenceman - Makar, Hughes, Fox?
  3. NHL Game gets retro-outdoor twist - wooden sticks, old padding, 

Cannections:

Last week Ken Dryden, Vladislav Tretiak, Eric Lindros, Jarome Iginla - none of them played for the team that drafted them

This week - William Nylander, David Pastrnak, Patrick Kane, Andrei Vasilevskii

Crazy Stat - There are more coaches entering their first game with current team than there are coaches who have been with their team for 2 or more years.