Episode 215: Winning Ad Creative: What Works Now & How to Measure It
Release Date: 04/16/2025
Episode 230: What’s Working Mid-2025, Part 4 – Mindset (Part 2) My Dad Died and It Sucked, But It’s Also Been the Most Beautiful Thing That’s Happened in My Life
The Smart Marketer Podcast
Episode 230: What’s Working Mid-2025, Part 4, Mindset (Part 2) "My Dad Died and It Sucked, But It’s Also Been the Most Beautiful Thing That’s Happened in My Life" Episode Description In this powerful continuation, Molly Pittman picks up where Part 1 left off and shares the final seven lessons she learned after losing her father. This isn’t just about grief. It’s about redefining success, leadership, and what it means to fully live. If you’re feeling stretched, stuck, or just want to lead with more presence, this episode will move you. “Presence is often more healing than...
info_outline
Episode 229: What’s Working Mid-2025, Part 4 – Mindset (Part 1) My Dad Died and It Sucked, But It’s Also Been the Most Beautiful Thing That’s Happened in My Life
The Smart Marketer Podcast
Episode 229: What’s Working Mid-2025, Part 4 – Mindset (Part 1) "My Dad Died and It Sucked, But It’s Also Been the Most Beautiful Thing That’s Happened in My Life" Episode Description In this deeply personal episode, Molly Pittman reflects on the sudden loss of her father, and the powerful lessons it’s taught her about life, business, and what truly matters. If you’re navigating grief, burnout, or just feeling disconnected from your purpose, this raw and reflective solo episode will meet you where you are. “Our only sole purpose here on Earth is to be ourselves and to give and...
info_outline
Episode 228: What’s Working Mid-2025, Part 3, Conversion Rate Optimization with John Grimshaw
The Smart Marketer Podcast
Episode 229: What’s Working Mid-2025, Part 4, Conversion Rate Optimization with John Grimshaw Episode Description In this episode of the summer series, Smart Marketer CMO John Grimshaw breaks down one of the most overlooked growth levers in digital marketing: conversion rate optimization. Whether you're optimizing headlines, simplifying your landing pages, or bundling smarter offers, these case studies from Boom, Pretty Farm Girl, and SafeSleeve show you exactly what’s working right now. “Bringing more money in when you drive a sale is the easiest way to grow the business.” – John...
info_outline
Episode 227: What’s Working Mid-2025, Part 2 - Improving Retention and Monetization Strategies with Email and SMS
The Smart Marketer Podcast
Episode 227: Improve Retention and Monetization Strategies with Email and SMS - What’s Working Mid-2025, Part 2 Episode Description Retention is the engine behind sustainable growth, and it’s more important than ever in 2025. This is part 2 of a 4-part series on what’s working right now in direct-to-consumer marketing. In this follow-up episode, Molly Pittman and John Grimshaw share four tactical retention and monetization strategies using email and SMS. These are the backend wins that help you convert more leads into buyers and get the most value from your list. If you want to...
info_outline
Episode 226: What’s Working Mid-2025 In Paid Traffic - 5 Paid Ad & Offer Strategies Driving Results
The Smart Marketer Podcast
Episode 226: What’s Working Mid-2025 - 5 Paid Ad & Offer Strategies Driving Results Episode Description The digital landscape is moving fast, but Smart Marketer is staying ahead. This is part 1 of a 4 part series about what is working right now halfway through 2025 in direct to consumer marketing. In this tactical check-in, Molly Pittman and John Grimshaw share five strategies that are helping businesses generate better results in 2025. Whether you're working on ads, funnels, or creative, this episode gives you practical ideas to tighten up your offers, test smarter, and set up growth...
info_outline
Episode 225: How We Scaled Meta Ad Spend from $500/Day to $5K/Day
The Smart Marketer Podcast
Episode Title How We Scaled Meta Ad Spend from $500/Day to $5K/Day Episode Description What does it really take to scale ad spend 10x—and still stay profitable? In this in-depth case study, Smart Marketer’s Pep Hufen shares how our agency helped Pretty Farm Girl grow fast using Advantage Plus campaigns, conversion-focused landing pages, and sharp backend tracking. “Advertising is acceleration. We cannot fix a broken offer.” – Pep Hufen If you want the full breakdown of creative structure, data-driven testing, and campaign strategy that got this brand a 7x ROAS, this episode is...
info_outline
Episode 224: The AI Ad Playbook - How to Save Time, Create Better Hooks & Scale Your Campaigns
The Smart Marketer Podcast
Ep 224: The AI Ad Playbook — How to Save Time, Create Better Hooks & Scale Your Campaigns Episode Description How do you create compelling ad copy, research your avatar, and generate high-performing creative—without burning out or hiring a team of specialists? In this live replay from The Smart Marketer Show, Molly Pittman and Pep Hufen walk you through Smart Marketer’s complete AI workflow. You’ll learn how to use ChatGPT for deep customer research, how to write high-converting hooks in minutes, and how to train AI to write like your brand. Pep also shares how Meta’s new tools...
info_outline
Episode 223: Cracking the Code on AppLovin Ads - A New Traffic Channel for DTC Brands
The Smart Marketer Podcast
Episode 223: Cracking the Code on AppLovin Ads: A New Traffic Channel for DTC Brands Episode Description If you're tired of being stuck between Meta and Google for your media buys—this episode is for you. Pep Hufen is back with a behind-the-scenes look at AppLovin Ads: the breakout ad platform that’s scaling DTC brands like Breeze and Boom. Discover why this mobile-first platform is outperforming Google for some advertisers, how it works, and why it might just be your next great opportunity for customer acquisition. Plus, Pep shares a step-by-step walkthrough of how Smart Marketer tested...
info_outline
Episode 222: Build Your E-Commerce Site Right: How to Turn Browsers into Buyers
The Smart Marketer Podcast
Episode Description Your website is more than a digital storefront—it’s the heart of your brand. In this episode, John Grimshaw, Ezra Firestone, and Kurt Elster unpack the proven strategies behind high-converting e-commerce sites. From the pitfalls of homepage design to the power of mobile-first thinking, they reveal how to turn casual visitors into loyal customers. If you want to build a brand that lasts (not just a business that sells), this is your roadmap. "Get out of your own way. Your customers don't care how pretty your site is—they care how easy it is to buy." — Kurt Elster ...
info_outline
Episode 221: The 5 AI Tools I Use Daily as a CEO (to Save 10+ Hours per Week)
The Smart Marketer Podcast
Episode 221: The 5 AI Tools I Use Daily as a CEO (to Save 10+ Hours per Week) Episode Description In this episode, our very own Pep Hufen, CEO of the Smart Marketer agency, shares the five AI tools he uses every day to save over 10 hours per week and stay ahead in a rapidly evolving digital landscape. Pep walks through practical, real-world use cases for each tool—no fluff, just strategies you can actually implement. Plus, for those of you who love a visual learning experience, there’s a full video version of this episode on YouTube—complete with on-screen graphics and tool demos. Check...
info_outlineEpisode 215 – Smart Marketer Show
Winning Ad Creative: What Works Now & How to Measure It
Episode Description
What makes an ad actually perform in 2025? In this episode, John Grimshaw and Ben Bennett pull back the curtain on the creative process that drives real sales—from emotional resonance to performance metrics. You’ll learn why good creative starts with empathy, how to identify your strongest hooks, and which numbers really matter.
Plus, we introduce a brand-new metric (yes, we named it), and show you how AI is changing the creative game—without replacing your team.
“If your ad doesn’t have a heart, it will not perform well.” —Ben Bennett
You Will Learn
-
The 3 key metrics that reveal if your ad creative is working
-
How to identify and fix poor-performing ads (without guessing)
-
Why emotional hooks beat flashy tactics every time
-
How to use AI image tools like ChatGPT to speed up creative
-
The “thumb stop ratio” metric you should be tracking (and how)
-
A 30-minute Action of the Month to sharpen your creative instantly
Links & Resources
-
smartmarketer.com/hyros – Hyros attribution tool
-
Smart Marketer Free Resources – smartmarketer.com/free-resources
-
Smart Marketer Agency – smartmarketer.com/agency
Timestamps (Chapters)
02:05 – Meet Ben Bennett: Creative Director at Smart Marketer
03:15 – Top 3 Metrics That Matter for Ad Creative
07:24 – Metric 1: Unique Link Click-Through Rate
11:54 – Metric 2: Conversion Rate & Ad Scent
15:51 – Metric 3: Thumb Stop Ratio
19:00 – How to Set Up and Benchmark Your Thumb Stop Ratio
21:07 – AI for Ad Creatives: How ChatGPT-4 is Changing the Game
26:32 – Action of the Month: Add Heart to Your Hooks
27:27 – The Heart Behind Your Creative
29:30 – If Your Ad Doesn’t Have a Heart, It Won’t Perform
30:33 – The Hook and the Hand: A Smart Marketer Analogy
34:01 – Making Facebook Ads People Don’t Hate
36:24 – Hooks vs. Heart: What's Missing in Most Ads
40:57 – A Simple Exercise
42:56 – The Nine Motivators That Move People
45:12 – Building Visual Hooks Around Real Situations
45:39 – How to Think About Hooks, and How They Fit Into Existing Ads
48:08 – How to Create Really Good Problem Hooks
56:48 – Here's How to Copy This Win
Call to Action
Enjoyed this episode? Leave us a review, share it with a marketer who needs better ad creative, and don’t forget to subscribe for weekly insights from the Smart Marketer team.