Episode 275: The Paid Ads Machine: Creative Systems That Scale in the Age of AI

Episode 275: The Paid Ads Machine: Creative Systems That Scale in the Age of AI

Episode Description

What if your ad creative system could think more like Meta’s algorithm?

In this live session from Mentor Table Nashville, Smart Marketer’s Director of Creative Ben Bennett and Creative Operations Manager Melvin Cotton III break down the exact system they use to plan, produce, analyze, and scale paid social creative in the age of AI and Andromeda.

From diagnosing what’s actually working inside your ad account to building scalable creator systems and using AI to uncover hidden performance insights, this episode is a masterclass in modern paid creative strategy.

“Our overall goal is to establish a strong system that provides us good creative and strong feedback.” – Melvin Cotton III

If you’re tired of guessing what makes ads work and want a smarter process for creating winning creative, this episode is for you.

You Will Learn:

• Why marketers are overcomplicating “Andromeda” and what actually matters

• The difference between what Meta sees in your ads vs. what it knows about users

• How to use AI to analyze creative at scale

• The creative variables Smart Marketer tracks across every ad

• Why “creative volume” alone isn’t enough anymore

• How to identify gaps in your messaging and creative strategy

• The framework for building a scalable creative production system

• Different ways to source UGC and creator content effectively

• Why operational systems are critical for creative scale

• How feedback loops improve ad performance over time

LINKS & RESOURCES:

• Smart Marketer: https://smartmarketer.com/

• Smart Marketer Free Trainings & Resources: https://smartmarketer.com/free-resources/

• Smart Marketer Agency: https://smartmarketeragency.com/

• Mentor Table: https://smartmarketer.com/mentor-table/

• OmniSend (Sponsor): https://smartmarketer.com/omnisend
  Use code SMART for 50% off your first three months.

TIME STAMPS:

00:00:17 – Introduction: The Paid Ads Machine
00:01:19 – Ezra Firestone on Why He Uses OmniSend
00:02:41 – Live from Mentor Table Nashville
00:03:55 – How Ben Bennett Joined Smart Marketer
00:06:18 – Creative Planning in the Age of Andromeda
00:08:18 – Why AI & Andromeda Feel Like a “Black Box”
00:12:55 – Using AI to Analyze Creative at Scale
00:17:08 – Building an AI-Powered Creative Data Lab
00:22:34 – Closed Variables vs Open Variables in Creative Analysis
00:25:55 – Applying Marketing Frameworks to Ad Creative
00:29:20 – Turning Creative Data Into Actionable Insights
00:33:32 – What AI Reveals About Winning Creative Patterns
00:36:07 – Why Beginner-Focused Ads Outperformed Problem-Aware Messaging
00:40:56 – Transitioning from Analysis to Production Systems
00:42:01 – Building a Creative Menu for Your Team
00:45:16 – Different Systems for Sourcing UGC & Creator Content
00:48:20 – Creator Compensation & Contracts
00:49:59 – Managing Creative Operations & Tracking Systems
00:51:48 – Identifying Where You Are on the Creative Spectrum
00:52:23 – Final Thoughts & Downloadable Resources

YOUR ENGAGEMENT MATTERS!

Thank you for tuning into the Smart Marketer Podcast! Your support helps us continue bringing you actionable marketing strategies, behind-the-scenes systems, and real-world business insights.

If you enjoyed this episode:

Leave a 5-star review on Apple Podcasts
Share this episode on social media and tag @smartmarketer
Send feedback or questions to [e-mail]

Serve the World Unselfishly and Profit!