454. An Evening at Rare Eagle 2.0

In this special episode of The Bourbon Road, hosts Jim Shannon and Todd Ritter reunite with returning guest Rob Carter at the beloved Rare Eagle Bar for a crowd-powered tasting experience unlike any other. But this time, the listeners have spoken—literally. The episode features five top-shelf, extra-aged bourbons selected through a Bourbon Roadies community vote. Each pour has over a decade of maturity and was chosen by fans of the show.

The episode kicks off with a warm-up dram of the iconic Eagle Rare 10-Year, perfectly appropriate for the venue’s patriotic ambiance. But the real showstopper is a highly-anticipated taste of the Eagle Rare 12-Year, a limited release that recently caused a frenzy at Buffalo Trace. Thanks to some local luck and great timing, Todd and Amy Winning managed to snag bottles from the short drop of just 1800 units.

The team dives deep into how the extra two years of aging and the bump to 95 proof shape the 12-year pour. They compare it directly to the classic 10-year, analyzing shifts in flavor, depth, and finish. Rob points out the richer oak and leather notes that rise above the familiar cherry-cola backbone, while Jim and Todd highlight subtle changes in spice and sweetness. For a modest $10 increase in retail price, the consensus is clear—Eagle Rare 12 offers exceptional value if you’re lucky enough to find it.

This episode isn’t just about what’s in the glass; it’s a celebration of bourbon community. The very lineup was chosen by Bourbon Roadies through a social media poll that included newer expressions like the 7-Year Old Fitzgerald and classic bottled-in-bond favorites. It’s a testament to how the bourbon world thrives on shared knowledge, enthusiasm, and a touch of good fortune.

Expect a few laughs, plenty of tasting notes, and a healthy dose of Kentucky bourbon culture as the hosts share not only what they're sipping, but the stories behind how they got their hands on these coveted bottles. And with the Rare Eagle Bar as their backdrop—complete with historic American flags and an eclectic whiskey collection—this episode hits every note for fans of bourbon, community, and conversation.

So pour yourself a dram, settle into your favorite chair, and join Jim, Todd, and Rob for a deep dive into age-stated classics, Roadie favorites, and the unmistakable joy of whiskey shared.

Bourbon on the Banks 2025

Smokeys Lifestyle Cigars

The Hill House Bed and Breakfast 

Be sure to check out our private Facebook group, “The Bourbon Roadies” for a great group of bourbon loving people. You will be welcomed with open arms!