Josh Tolle on the State of Hillel on Campus

For many Jewish parents and grandparents, Hillel holds a special place in their memories of college life. Founded in 1923 above a barbershop at the University of Illinois, Hillel grew into a leading Jewish campus organization, now present at hundreds of colleges. For generations, it was where Jewish students found community, celebrated Shabbat, and felt at home as Jews while navigating the challenges of university life.

But today, Hillel faces a crisis. That’s the view of the writer and former Krauthammer fellow Josh Tolle. Now Tikvah’s associate director of university programs, Tolle worked at Hillel for three years, and saw the organization’s reaction to October 7 and all the campus frenzy that would come after it up close.

In his essay “If Hillel Is Not for Jews, Who Will Be?”—which appeared in the December 2025 issue of Commentary—Tolle examines how progressive ideology has weakened Hillel’s ability to serve its own students, especially in the days, weeks, and months after October 7, when Jewish institutions were most needed. Tolle explains how Jewish students, galvanized by October 7, looked to their campus Hillels seeking clarity and strength, only to encounter what he calls “muddled objectives and self-defeating strategies.”

Tolle calls attention to the ways Hillel has strayed from its mission precisely because he believes that mission is worth restoring. Hillel’s crisis, he argues, reflects a larger condition in American Jewish life, particularly among pluralistic institutions, and that condition must be remedied for these institutions to remain capable of serving the rising generation.

In this episode, Tolle discusses his essay and the experiences that led him to write it in conversation with Jonathan Silver.