Progressive Myths - Some of the Things You’ve Been Told Are Wrong
Release Date: 10/28/2025
A YA Series, a First Contact Novel, and a Startup Book Walk Into a Bar—Pursued by Wolves
We Are Not Saved
info_outline
The Origin of Politics - Kibbutzim, Chimps, and Children
We Are Not Saved
Would you like some genetics in your politics? The Origin of Politics: How Evolution and Ideology Shape the Fate of Nations – Social Disintegration, Birth Rates, and the Path to Extinction By: Nicholas Wade Published: 2025 256 Pages Briefly, what is this book about? Wade offers up an evolutionary psychology account of how to make politics actually function; how, when you try to disconnect politics and the exercise of power from core human nature, as shaped by evolution, things go off the rails. What authorial biases should I be aware of? Nicholas Wade worked as a science writer for...
info_outline
A Case for Latter-Day Christianity - (i.e. A Case for the Christianity of Mormons)
We Are Not Saved
I feel like I should make some clever connection between this book and the discussion which raged about the Shroud of Turin, but nothing occurs to me. A Case for Latter-day Christianity: Evidences for the Restoration of the New Testament’s “Mere” Christian Church By: Robert Starling Published: 2019 360 Pages Briefly, what is this book about? A broad, and intensive defense of the theology of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS). With a special focus on tying that theology to the theology of the early Christian Church. As such it spends a lot of time examining differences...
info_outline
Taking Religion Seriously - Can You Get to Belief Purely Through Reason?
We Are Not Saved
In which I mostly talk about the Shroud of Turin. Murray only spends seven pages on the it, so my review is not comprehensive. Actually, never mind. That's what the top sections are for. Taking Religion Seriously By: Charles Murray Published: 2025 152 Pages Briefly, what is this book about? Murray’s journey from agnosticism to belief, a journey that is largely intellectual rather than spiritual. Because it was largely intellectual, it’s also more explicable. This allows Murray to write a different sort of conversion story, one that’s more amenable to being mapped out as a...
info_outline
Children of Mars - Sid Meier's Civilization Lied
We Are Not Saved
Back when Rome was just one Italian settlement out of many, but a settlement with a dream! Children of Mars: The Origins of Rome's Empire By: Jeremy Armstrong Published: 2025 288 Pages Briefly, what is this book about? The deep history of Rome. What we actually know about its legendary founding, its early rise to prominence, and the shape of its military. Additionally, the development of Roman identity and how that identity interacted with the other elements. What's the author's angle? This belongs to that genre of book which takes recent scholarship and archaeological evidence and uses it to...
info_outline
Origins of Efficiency - The Glories of the Modern World
We Are Not Saved
We have a lot of nice things. We’re really good at making nice things. We should preserve these nice things. But also nothing lasts forever? The Origins of Efficiency By: Brian Potter Published: 2025 384 Pages Briefly, what is this book about? The clever and incremental ways we’ve vastly increased humanity’s ability to make stuff. We’re constantly finding ways to build stuff cheaper, faster, and with fewer resources. What's the author's angle? Potter is probably best known for his Substack Construction Physics, which covers infrastructure, manufacturing, and building stuff in general....
info_outline
The New Testament in Its World - A Brief, Thousand-Page Intro
We Are Not Saved
Everything you wanted to know about 1st Century Palestine, but were afraid to ask… The New Testament in Its World: An Introduction to the History, Literature, and Theology of the First Christians By: N. T. Wright and Michael F. Bird Published: 2019 992 Pages Briefly, what is this book about? An deep dive on the New Testament covering (as the subtitle suggests) the history: Second Temple Judaism against a Greco-Roman background; the literature: the New Testament’s genesis, structure, authors and audience; and theology: the religious claims of the book, the doctrine, miracles, and...
info_outline
Superbloom - Volume 23 in the "Social Media is Awful" Series
We Are Not Saved
Superbloom: How Technologies of Connection Tear Us Apart By: Nicholas Carr Published: 2025 272 Pages Briefly, what is this book about? On its surface, this is a fairly typical anti-social media book, though Carr does have some interesting things to say about weaknesses inherent to the medium: content collapse, algorithmic engineering, and hostility generation. All things I’ll get to in a bit. What's the author's angle? Carr comes from the Marshall McLuhan and Neil Postman school of media criticism. Media have inherent properties that lead to different sorts of communication, and different...
info_outline
We Belong to the Land - The Best Palestinian Making His Best Case
We Are Not Saved
A story of one Palestinian’s fight against brutality, bureaucracy, and bishops. We Belong to the Land: The Story of a Palestinian Israeli Who Lives for Peace and Reconciliation By: Elias Chacour and Mary E. Jensen Published: 1990 212 Pages Briefly, what is this book about? An autobiographical account of Chacour’s struggles as a Palestinian Christian working to build up his community in Galilee (Ibillin) while under continual pushback from Israeli bureaucracy and internal church politics. What's the author's angle? At the time the book was written Chacour was a Melkite Greek Catholic...
info_outline
Five Fictional Books In Search of a Common Thread
We Are Not Saved
info_outline
It’s possible that in our pursuit of justice and equity that a few things might have been exaggerated.
Progressive Myths
By: Michael Huemer
Published: 2024
277 Pages
Briefly, what is this book about?
A wide-ranging debunking of most of the myths that flourished during the recent peak of social justice activism. Some myths concern specific incidents like those around Michael Brown and Kyle Rittenhouse. Others are ideological myths like the gender pay gap, or the efficiency of masks at preventing the spread of COVID. In total he covers twenty different myths.
What's the author's angle?
Huemer comes at things from a strong classically liberal approach. He is very wary of activism in all its forms. He’s also clearly not worried about annoying people. Though he is very worried about people trying to “read between the lines”.
Do not “read between the lines” to infer what I “must be implying”. If you think of some ridiculous or horrible political view that you think I’m implying, that is almost certainly just in your imagination. I am not the sort of writer who likes to imply his point.
Who should read this book?
If you consider yourself to be a good progressive I would definitely read this book. I suspect that such people won’t, but honestly, if you’re looking for the best steelman of the opposing arguments this is it. If you’re on the opposite side of the fence you still might find some things that surprise you (Also Huemer makes a point of also covering a few things that aren’t myths. Incidents progressives were correct about.)
Many people speak very highly of Huemer’s books, and I’ll probably eventually read all of them.
What does the book have to say about the future?
Huemer has many recommendations for how to proceed, but they mostly boil down to having better epistemology. One of the great sins he identifies is motivated reasoning, which obscures facts, and beyond that leads to broad conclusions which are entirely unsupported by reality. And we seem to be getting more of such reasoning.
Specific thoughts: How do we fix epistemology?