Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
YOUR true crime book club podcast.Jill tells the true crime book stories in 3 parts. Dive deep into the criminal psyche, updates, and outcomes with the greatest respect for accuracy, victims and families!
info_outline
Ep 175: Pt 2 Killer in the House by Kathryn Canavan- 'Let's Be Careful Out There'
07/22/2026
Ep 175: Pt 2 Killer in the House by Kathryn Canavan- 'Let's Be Careful Out There'
Part 2: On March 12, 1976, a wave of violence struck Pennsylvania, claiming eight lives in two brutal incidents. In Trevose, the Abt family—Jack, Peggy, their children Margie, Johnny, and Kathy, along with Margie’s boyfriend, Gary Engle, and their dog, Heidi—were ambushed. Just four miles away in Langhorne, Ed and Marguerite Vogenberger were found murdered in their farmhouse, which had been turned into a torture chamber. Investigators worked tirelessly to solve the case as anxious residents feared a merciless killer or cult was lurking just beyond their doorsteps. Stunned investigators, grappling with the enormity of the tragedy, tirelessly searched for clues, combing through the neighborhoods. Survivors Clifford and Michael Abt faced a nightmarish reality during a time without modern technology and communication. As dark clouds loomed overhead, three somber funerals unfolded, filled with heart-wrenching sorrow for the eight slain victims. Amid the escalating media frenzy, where rumors ran rampant, a police officer's intuition led to a significant breakthrough, igniting a glimmer of hope. However, while law enforcement is confident they know the identity of the killer, the daunting challenge of collecting evidence to prove it looms before them, complicating their pursuit of justice in this tragic saga. Buy Kathryn Canavan’s book, Killer in the House: Ten Days of Terror in the Pennsylvania Suburbs on or . (Thinking about going to Crimecon 2027? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub Sources, photographs, and information can be found on https://www.murdershelfbookclub.com/2026/07/
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/42068695
info_outline
Special Ep 174: Tell Me Everything by Brad Beeler
07/15/2026
Special Ep 174: Tell Me Everything by Brad Beeler
Twelve hours before a presidential candidate is set to speak, a startling threat is received. How did Secret Service Special Agent Brad Beeler and his partner swiftly identify the caller and ensure the candidate's safety? In a riveting conversation, Brad Beeler, with 25 years of experience in high-stakes investigations as a top polygraph examiner, joins Jill to tackle this pressing issue. He also shares insights from his compelling book, Tell Me Everything, which is relevant in numerous arenas of life—including police interrogations, dating, communication, parenting, job interviews, and even climbing the corporate ladder. By diving into real-world case files, from interrogation settings to presidential security details, Brad unveils the science and psychology of human behavior. He illustrates the importance of recognizing subtle nonverbal signals and verbal inconsistencies, building rapport, and empowering listeners to effectively distinguish truth from deception, with concrete examples anyone can use! He stresses the vital skill of active listening and respect for others in communication. This engaging conversation equips you with practical tools to enhance your personal and professional interactions. If you've just graduated from college or are preparing for job interviews, consider listening, and then- buying Brad Beeler's book for a comprehensive guide on how to create the best impression! Buy Brad Beeler’s Tell Me Everything on and (Thinking about going to Crimecon 2027? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on a month! Help pick our next book, enjoy Jill’s exclusive content, and serial killer case studies! www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub Sources, photographs, and information can be found on https://www.murdershelfbookclub.com/2026/07/
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/42033475
info_outline
Ep 173: Pt. 1- KILLER IN THE HOUSE, 'Lying in Wait’ -by Kathryn Canavan
07/08/2026
Ep 173: Pt. 1- KILLER IN THE HOUSE, 'Lying in Wait’ -by Kathryn Canavan
Part 1: Trevose, Pennsylvania, 1976—a safe, middle-class suburb where children slept under the stars and front doors remained unlocked. This idyllic peace was shattered when a brutal massacre claimed the lives of the Abt family, marking one of the most horrific crimes in the state’s history. The killer meticulously planned the deaths of six people, leaving the community paralyzed with fear and demanding answers. Enter Kathryn Canavan, a determined young journalist thrust into the heart of a chaotic media storm. In a landscape devoid of cell phones and the internet, the Bensalem Police Department had to rely on old-fashioned grit to piece together a slow-burning mystery before the killer—or killers—could strike again. Subscribe so you do not miss Part 2, 3, and Jill's exclusive interview with author, Kathryn Canavan! Buy Kathryn Canavan’s book, Killer in the House: Ten Days of Terror in the Pennsylvania Suburbs on or . (Thinking about going to Crimecon 2027? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book, enjoy exclusive content, and Jill’s serial killer case studies. www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub All sources, photographs, articles, diagrams, recipes, and drink pairing information are found on
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/41957015
info_outline
Ep 172 Pt 4: The Caregiver's Game "Nemesis"- Charles 'Chip' Wallace Jr Joins Jill
06/30/2026
Ep 172 Pt 4: The Caregiver's Game "Nemesis"- Charles 'Chip' Wallace Jr Joins Jill
Happy 250th Anniversary, America! Out early for the holiday! Part 4: In this compelling discussion, author Charles “Chip” Wallace, Jr. joins Jill to share the deeply personal account of his mother, Joell Fleming, and the shocking elder abuse and financial exploitation she faced while battling dementia. Since the publication of his revelations, what steps have been taken to address this issue? It’s crucial for us to understand how we can safeguard our loved ones against such horrors. What proactive measures are our institutions taking to protect our elderly family members and friends? What questions need to be asked? Together, we can ensure that elder abuse and fraud become relics of the past, not realities we face in our own lives. Did you listen to the first 3 parts? Ep 166, 168, and 170! June is Elder Abuse Awareness Month! Buy The Caregiver’s Game by Charles E. Wallace, Jr Thinking about going to Crimecon 2027? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Want to suggest a book or case? Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Sources, photographs, and information can be found on
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/41642165
info_outline
Special Episode 171: Though the Lens of a Monster by William A. Noguera
06/24/2026
Special Episode 171: Though the Lens of a Monster by William A. Noguera
In this special episode: Forty-two harrowing years on death row, former inmate William A. Noguera has a gripping story to share. In his chilling true-crime memoir, Through the Lens of a Monster: A Serial Killer on Death Row, an Unsolved Murder List, and an Inmate’s Deadly Play for Redemption, he opens up to Jill about his life behind bars. While at San Quentin Penitentiary, Noguera courageously documented his conversations with notorious serial killers, risking everything to uncover the dark truths within their minds. This compelling discussion offers a rare glimpse into Noguera's unsettling psychological bond with Joseph Naso, the infamous Alphabet Killer, revealing unsolved murders linked to him. Noguera also shares insights into his personal relationships with other notorious names, such as Richard Ramirez (The Night Stalker), Lawrence Bittaker (The Toolbox Killer), and Rodney Alcala (The Dating Game Killer). Embracing a role as the "serial killer whisperer," Noguera turned his time in prison into an opportunity for growth, pursuing education and advocating for change. Now, with a law degree, he steps into the world on parole, determined to do the right thing, choosing a life of integrity and repentance. See William A. Noguera’s art? https://williamnoguera.com/ Thinking about going to Crimecon 2027? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub Sources, photographs, and information can be found on ! https://www.murdershelfbookclub.com/2026/06/
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/41641750
info_outline
Ep 170: Pt 3 The Caregiver’s Game 2nd Cast, by Charles E. Wallace, Jr.; “Pseudocide”
06/17/2026
Ep 170: Pt 3 The Caregiver’s Game 2nd Cast, by Charles E. Wallace, Jr.; “Pseudocide”
Part 3: After his mother’s death, Charles "Chip" Wallace is faced with a shocking realization: Esmeralda Gomez, the caregiver hired to look after his mother, Joell Fleming, had lied, manipulated, and committed elder abuse and fraud. She exploited a woman in her 80s who was suffering from dementia. Determined to prevent the caregiver from inheriting a fortune, Chip embarks on a thorough investigation, using FOIA requests, advanced cybersleuthing techniques, probate court, and discovery process. He is committed to uncovering the truth about what occurred during his mother’s final years. However, the situation becomes complicated when Esmeralda dies—reportedly. But had she? June is Elder Abuse Awareness month. This book serves as a warning to everyone about the growing issues of elder abuse and financial exploitation. Don’t let this happen to you or your loved ones! Stay tuned for Jill’s upcoming interview with Chip Wallace! Be sure to listen to all The Caregiver’s Game episodes: Parts 1 & 2, Episodes 166, 168, 170 & 172. Subscribe so you do not miss a thing! For more information on elder abuse: Thinking about going to Crimecon Orlando 2027? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub Sources, photographs, and information can be found on
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/41641555
info_outline
Special Episode 169 Confessions of the Green River Killer by Maria DiLorenzo
06/10/2026
Special Episode 169 Confessions of the Green River Killer by Maria DiLorenzo
In Special Episode 169: Jill welcomes investigative journalist Maria DiLorenzo, the author of the new book Confessions of the Green River Killer: A True Story of Manipulation, Madness, and a Search for Justice. Maria DiLorenzo reached out to Gary Ridgway, a serial killer, who pleaded guilty to the murders of 49 women, to gather information about possible unidentified victims. Despite his typical reluctance to communicate with the media, Ridgway engaged in extensive conversations with DiLorenzo, resulting in hundreds of phone calls over several years. While DiLorenzo focused on uncovering investigative leads, these interactions became a complex psychological ordeal. Ridgway discussed his past actions, motivation, and philosophy on relationships- an eye-opener- during their conversations. The resulting true-crime narrative chronicles this long-term interaction and explores the personal impact of maintaining contact with a psychopathic serial killer on the author. Do not miss this intense conversation about one of America's worst serial murderers, his psyche, and where the investigation stands now. Thinking about going to Crimecon 2027? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub Sources, photographs, and information can be
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/41592960
info_outline
Ep 168: Pt 2 The Caregiver’s Game by Charles E. Wallace, Jr,; “They didn’t know what they didn’t know”
06/03/2026
Ep 168: Pt 2 The Caregiver’s Game by Charles E. Wallace, Jr,; “They didn’t know what they didn’t know”
Part 2: During the COVID-19 lockdown, Joell Fleming's adult children—Chip and his siblings—were prohibited from visiting their mother, who suffers from dementia. This left her entirely dependent on her caregiver, Esmarelda Gomez. As communication became increasingly difficult, Joell’s children were often the last to learn about critical decisions being made regarding their mother’s care, often without their knowledge. Esmarelda began to take a more dominant role in managing Joell’s affairs, prompting Chip to initiate an investigation. He was determined to uncover what transpired during the final years of his mother's life, especially regarding the extreme violation of a vulnerable woman's trust. The Caregiver’s Game is part true crime, part memoir, serving as a critical warning for anyone with older people in their lives. June is Elder Abuse Awareness Month! Thinking about going to Crimecon Orlando 2027? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub Sources, photographs, and information can be found on
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/41520795
info_outline
Special Episode 167: Joseph Scott Morgan Joins Jill!
05/27/2026
Special Episode 167: Joseph Scott Morgan Joins Jill!
In this special episode, a very special guest and friend, Joseph Scott Morgan, the host of the Body Bags podcast, a professor of Applied Forensics at Jacksonville State University, and the author of the gut-wrenching book, Blood Beneath My Feet, joins Jill!. Joseph speaks about death investigations, the dire challenges of exploring the realm of death for decades, and their experiences at CrimeCon, where they are to return this week! Joseph Scott Morgan, ever the philosopher and sage, shares his insights on the pantheon of forensic pathologists who paved the way for him as he educates the next generation! Additionally, get a preview of the upcoming CrimeCon 2026 in Las Vegas! COME SEE JILL and JOSEPH SCOTT MORGAN ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS! (Thinking about going to Crimecon 2027? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub Sources, photographs, and information can be found on
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/41407355
info_outline
Ep 166: Pt 1 The Caregiver's Game- Unraveling Financial Deceit in the Shadows of Dementia: By Charles E. Wallace; "She is fine!"
05/20/2026
Ep 166: Pt 1 The Caregiver's Game- Unraveling Financial Deceit in the Shadows of Dementia: By Charles E. Wallace; "She is fine!"
Part 1: As Baby Boomers and Gen Xers age, many of us face the heart-wrenching reality of caring for a loved one with dementia. This insidious disease undermines cognition, often robbing individuals of their very identity. Chip, and his siblings encountered this heartache when their mother, Joell Fleming, began showing symptoms. Complicating matters, her children lived across the United States while she remained in her cherished home in Dallas, Texas. As they navigated this difficult situation, the need for a trustworthy caregiver became evident—someone who could assist with daily routines, cooking, shopping, manage medications, and ensure their mother’s safety. But what is one to do when a caregiver lacks genuine concern for their client, manipulating her for her own nefarious purposes? What are the red flags? This is a critical warning for anyone caring for aging loved ones: Charles E. Wallace passionately hopes that no one else has to endure the distressing experiences he and his siblings faced in their mother’s final years. Parts 2 and 3, plus Jill's exclusive interview with author and victim, Charles E. Wallace are coming soon! Subscribe so you do not miss a thing! Buy by Charles E. Wallace Jr on Amazon! COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS! (Thinking about going to Crimecon? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your 2027 badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub Sources, photographs, and information can be found on https://www.murdershelfbookclub.com/2026/05/ COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS! (Thinking about going to Crimecon? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub Sources, photographs, and information can be found on Contact: , or , or
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/41333435
info_outline
Special Ep 165: Dark Tide- Growing Up with Ted Bundy by Edna Cowell Martin and Megan Atkinson
05/13/2026
Special Ep 165: Dark Tide- Growing Up with Ted Bundy by Edna Cowell Martin and Megan Atkinson
Edna Cowell Martin grew up in a loving home in Washington State, surrounded by her parents and extended family. One of her cousins was Ted Bundy, the infamous serial killer responsible for at least 30 deaths. Bundy was executed in Florida in 1989. In her new book, Edna Cowell Martin details her experiences with Ted, whom she regarded as an older brother during her childhood and college as a young adult, while he was active as a serial killer. She contrasts his outward appearance as a "normal" man with the "dark tide" of his murderous impulses, exploring the lasting trauma and guilt that his crimes inflicted on their family. Genuine and truthful, Edna reveals the memories that have taken on a new context since Ted was first arrested in 1975. This is her story. Check out Jill''s coverage on Ted Bundy, Ep 9-11 on The Phantom Prince by Elizabeth Kendall! COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS May 29-31, 2026! (Thinking about going to Crimecon? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Sources, photographs, and information can be Contact: , or , , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/41273310
info_outline
Special Episode 164: Dog O' War by Aphrodite Jones
05/06/2026
Special Episode 164: Dog O' War by Aphrodite Jones
In this special episode, discover the gripping new true crime book, 'Dog O’ War,' which is indeed stranger than fiction! Author Aphrodite Jones unravels the chilling circumstances surrounding the mauling death of 33-year-old lacrosse coach Diane Whipple, who was attacked by a presa canario, a rare breed of dog. Jones reveals how this tragic incident became intertwined with the sinister motives of the Aryan Brotherhood, a ruthless group driven by white supremacy and greed. Additionally, the book explores a twisted love triangle and the legal fallout that resulted from this case. Listen, then buy this mind-boggling book, just released April 2026! It is the perfect read with the weather warming up! COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS May 29-31, 2026 at Caesar’s Palace! (Thinking about going to Crimecon? Day Passes are out! Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Sources, photographs, and i
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/41149995
info_outline
Special Ep 163: Shadows in Fire by Judith A. Yates
04/21/2026
Special Ep 163: Shadows in Fire by Judith A. Yates
Judith A. Yates, an award-winning author and criminologist, brings a unique perspective to true crime with her latest project, her book, Shadows in Fire. For the past seven years, she has been in communication with Shirley Winters, a little-known serial killer and serial arsonist. As one of the rare female serial killers, Shirley has never shared her story outside of law enforcement—until now. Discussing Judith's forthcoming book, Shadows in Fire, she and Jill discuss the chilling details of Shirley Winters' crimes, her troubled childhood, mental health challenges, motivations, and her victims, along with insights into crime causation theory. This compelling work is set to release this summer, but Judith needs your support! She's launched a Kickstarter campaign to raise funds for crucial photographs that will enhance the storytelling. Your contribution can make a significant difference in bringing this important narrative to life. If you're interested in donating...the link is below. You may contact Judith A. Yates at COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS! (Thinking about going to Crimecon? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Sources, photographs, and information can be https://www.murdershelfbookclub.com/2026/04/ Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40956095
info_outline
Ep 162 Pt 3 While She Slept by Marion Collins, 2ndCast "Perennial Bloom"-
04/09/2026
Ep 162 Pt 3 While She Slept by Marion Collins, 2ndCast "Perennial Bloom"-
Part 3: As Jill Cahill teeters at death’s door, her family is engulfed in grief, reeling from the sudden tragedy that has shattered their world and deeply affected her children. Investigators are diligently unraveling the intricate details of the murder plot, all while a pivotal trial looms on the horizon. Her parents braced themselves for a fierce custody battle, determined to secure their grandchildren, while they fervently prayed for justice. When the verdict finally arrives, its shockwaves resonate throughout New York State, triggering significant judicial changes that are still unfolding. This story is not just about a trial; it's about a quest for truth that will impact countless lives. It is recommended to listen to Part 1, Episode 159 and Part 2, Episode 161 before the conclusion! AND- announcing the Michael Kors GIVEAWAY for Murder Bookies! Enter your name & email. Upload a screenshot of your posted review on DOG O' WAR by APHRODITE JONES, by May 10th - Mother's Day for your chance to WIN a beautiful Michael Kors purse! BUY While She Slept by Marion Collins and COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS, May 29-31, 2026! Join Jill and new assistant, Michele, for their meetup, Thursday, May 28, 2026 at the conclusion of the Crimecon Kickoff Party, 10 pm in the Lobby Bar (across from the reception desk)! (Thinking about going to Crimecon? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Sources, photographs, and information can be found Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40793640
info_outline
EP 161: Pt. 2- While She Slept by Marion Collins; "Bitter Almonds”
04/07/2026
EP 161: Pt. 2- While She Slept by Marion Collins; "Bitter Almonds”
Part 2: Nearly beaten to death, Jill fights for her life as she endures a grueling cycle of comas, surgeries, and infections, fluctuating between hope and despair. A fierce custody battle erupts over her children, coinciding with the investigation into the brutal assault. Meanwhile, Jeff Cahill finds his life shattered, unaware that his choices will lead him down a more devastating path, leaving a wider trail of destruction that no one could anticipate, forever altering the laws of the State of New York. (Be sure to listen to Part 1, Ep 159 before this episode! Context is crucial!) BUY While She Slept and COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS! (Thinking about going to Crimecon? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is Open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Sources, photographs, and information can be found Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40761420
info_outline
Special Ep 160: The Tylenol Murders: A Father's Confession to His Son by Joseph Cibelli
04/03/2026
Special Ep 160: The Tylenol Murders: A Father's Confession to His Son by Joseph Cibelli
In 1982, a wave of terror swept across the Chicago area and the rest of the United States as seven people suddenly died; the manner of death was homicide; the cause: POISON! Tampering, someone had spiked Tylenol capsules with cyanide and American changed overnight. This shocking crime left the public in fear; anyone could have been targeted! For 44 years, an extensive investigation aimed to uncover the truth, but the case grew cold, leading many to believe that the cunning killer had escaped justice. Now, however, there is a startling revelation. Forensic psychologist Joseph Cibelli has unveiled his father's deathbed confession, presenting compelling evidence that has led him to a shocking conclusion: his father is the infamous Tylenol Killer. Buy THE TYLENOL MURDERS by Joseph Cibelli on or Listen to Joseph Cibelli’s page: For COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS! (Thinking about going to Crimecon? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Sources, photographs, and information can be found on Contact: , or , . , or
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40722620
info_outline
Ep 159: Pt 1: While She Slept by Marion Collins "The Ne’er’do-well"
03/31/2026
Ep 159: Pt 1: While She Slept by Marion Collins "The Ne’er’do-well"
Part I: A boy meets a girl, and love ignites. They marry, craft a life together, and welcome their son and daughter, a perfect family. But as time unfolds, pressures rise, people evolve, and dreams unravel. While divorces are part of many people's stories, Jeff and Jill Cahill's tale is far from ordinary. It's a nightmare that shocks and devastates at every turn. When their lives take a dark twist, disastrous choices have ripple effects that devastate those around them. Families are shattered, hearts are left in ruins, and overwhelming confusion leaves us questioning: “How can anyone treat another human being this way?” Part I of While She Slept by Marion Collins challenges us to reflect on the fragility of love and the consequences of domestic violence. BUY While She Slept and COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS! (Thinking about going to Crimecon? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Sources, photographs, and information can be found Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40681290
info_outline
Special Ep 158: True Crime and Consequences by David Lyons
03/25/2026
Special Ep 158: True Crime and Consequences by David Lyons
It's time to start a conversation! The amazing David Lyons, a retired homicide detective and co-host of The Murder Police podcast, is Jill’s guest. These podcast hosts have an important discussion about David's new book, True Crime and Consequence. In it, David Lyons examines the increasing influence of the true crime community on real-life investigations. This timely work raises important questions about how podcasts, social media, and amateur sleuthing impact investigations, for better or worse. How can everyday citizens ethically, legally, and compassionately contribute to solving cases? AND- David and Jill delve into specific cases affected by social media, including the recent verdict involving Ashley Guillard, who was ordered to pay $10 million in damages to an innocent college professor she falsely accused of being involved in a mass murder. BUY True Crime and Consequences on and . COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS! Thinking about going to Crimecon? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! www.patreon.com/MurderShelfBookClub Contact: jill@murdershelfbookclub.com, or , , LinkedIn, or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40616980
info_outline
Ep 157 Pt 3- 2nd Cast INCENDIARY by Michael Cannell 'Laws of Sanity'
03/06/2026
Ep 157 Pt 3- 2nd Cast INCENDIARY by Michael Cannell 'Laws of Sanity'
Spoiler Alert! Be sure to listen to Parts 1 and 2, Ep 152 and 154, before listening to this conclusion! Part 3: In this gripping conclusion, after a lengthy 16-year manhunt, the Mad Bomber, George Metesky, is finally apprehended in Waterbury, Connecticut, long after he unleashed a wave of terror across New York City with his dangerous bombings. The palpable relief among NYPD Captain Kinney and the Bomb Squad echoes through the halls of ‘The Tombs,’ a notoriously grim jail in Lower Manhattan, where Metesky is held. In the courtroom, a fierce contest unfolds between the psychiatrists assessing Metesky’s mental state and a steadfast ‘law and order’ judge, resolute in his determination to see justice served. As a battle of wits and jurisdiction ensues, George’s declining physical health raises urgent questions about his ability to stand trial. Caught in this agonizing limbo, he is committed to Matteawan Psychiatric Hospital, where the evolving laws surrounding sanity lead to an unforeseen resolution. Meanwhile, Dr. James Brussel, the visionary behind reverse psychology—now recognized as criminal profiling—delves into other cold cases, offering insights that unlock the identities of elusive suspects. His expertise even aids in tracking down a chilling serial killer in Boston, whose reign of terror has left a grim trail of bodies, igniting fear throughout the city. Buy on AMAZON. Buy INCENDIARY on . Looking forward to the Hampton's Whodunit in April 2026! Look for Jill! COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGAS! (Thinking about going to Crimecon? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch Shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40346380
info_outline
Special Ep 156: The LISK Update by Joe Giacalone, Lost Girls Pt 6
03/06/2026
Special Ep 156: The LISK Update by Joe Giacalone, Lost Girls Pt 6
Part 6- Lost Girls by Robert Kolker. Retired NYPD Sergeant Joe Giacalone, known from Crimecon, the Hamptons Whodunit, and "True Crime with the Sarge," joins Jill to discuss the latest intriguing developments in the Long Island Serial Killer case. What formidable challenges does Rex Heuermann's defense team face in light of the evidence that has emerged? What complexities confront Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney as he personally spearheads the prosecution, especially given the troubling history of missteps and corruption associated with this case? The recent revelation identifying 'Peaches' as veteran Tanya Jackson and her daughter, Tatiana, which resulted in a murder indictment against Andrew Dykes, has also significantly shifted the dynamics. With Rex Heuermann set to return to court next week, on March 17, 2026, the question looms—will there be a plea deal? So many questions, and a world of answers is just around the corner! Binge Jill's series on Lost Girls by Robert Kolker, Ep 24, 25, 26, Mini-Cast Update Let the Games Begin from 9/27/21, and Ep 95 Gilgo! True Crime with the Sarge on YouTube COME SEE JILL ON CREATORS ROW AT CRIMECON 2026, LAS VEGS! PLANNING TO GO TO CRIMECON (Thinking about going to Crimecon? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!) Jill’s Merch shop is open! https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! www.patreon.com/murdershelfbookclub Sources, photographs & additional information on LISK & Lost Girls is found on Jill’s blog, June 2021 https://www.murdershelfbookclub.com/2021/06/
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40344105
info_outline
Special Ep 155: Leslie Rule Talks, A Tangled Web Revelation!
03/03/2026
Special Ep 155: Leslie Rule Talks, A Tangled Web Revelation!
PART 4: Best-selling author Leslie Rule joins Jill for an engaging discussion about the unforgettable case she explores in her gripping book, A Tangled Web. Leslie offers her keen insights into the mind of the perpetrator, delving into her motivations and sharing a groundbreaking new development that sheds light on many of our lingering questions. Plus, she’s excited to unveil her next project, which is bound to excite true crime enthusiasts! Spoiler Alert: To fully enjoy this episode, be sure to listen to Jill’s A Tangled Web trilogy—Episodes 137, 138, and 141—first! PLANNING TO GO TO CRIMECON LAS VEGAS MAY 2026? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10%! Every little bit helps! Sources, photographs, recipes and drink information can be found on Jill’s blog, Sept. 2025. Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’ s SERIAL KILLER CLASS! Get your Murder Shelf Book Club merch by Jan Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40300210
info_outline
Ep 154 Pt 2-INCENDIARY: The Psychiatrist, the Mad Bomber & the Invention of Criminal Profiling by Michael Cannell “Oedipus Rising”
02/23/2026
Ep 154 Pt 2-INCENDIARY: The Psychiatrist, the Mad Bomber & the Invention of Criminal Profiling by Michael Cannell “Oedipus Rising”
PART 2: 1956- New York City is in a state of fear as powerful bombs are discovered hidden in public spaces like libraries, movie theaters, and subway stations. Sixteen years have passed, yet the elusive Mad Bomber continues to evade capture, leaving citizens in constant dread. To draw the bomber out, the NYPD shares case details with the press, sparking a tense cat-and-mouse game. This triggers numerous bomb threats that blur the line between pranks and real danger, while genuine explosives are found, threatening death and devastation, with the NY bomb squad exhausted. With each tip scrutinized meticulously, police keep an eye toward Dr. Brussel’s profile of the bomber. However, as the investigation unfolds, alibis emerge that clear countless suspects, and the detectives face disappointment after disappointment. What drives the Mad Bomber? Is it revenge or something darker? When will law enforcement finally catch him, so New Yorkers can regain their peace of mind? In a bold move to break the case, Captain Howard Finney consults Dr. James Brussel, a psychiatrist from the Department of Mental Hygiene. This partnership gives rise to the groundbreaking practice now known as criminal profiling, merging psychiatric insight and intuition with the hard facts of the case. How could the profile be used to catch a serial bomber? How could law enforcement use profiling to catch serial bombers, murderers and even serial killers? Buy on AMAZON. Buy on . PLANNING TO GO TO CRIMECON LAS VEGAS MAY 2026? Jill will be on ON CREATORS ROW! Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Happy to help! Crimecon 2026 is COMING! Get Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40206825
info_outline
Special Episode 153: Who I Really Am - John Hinckley talks w. Jill
02/17/2026
Special Episode 153: Who I Really Am - John Hinckley talks w. Jill
On March 30, 1981, a tragic and shocking incident unfolded in Washington, D.C., when a troubled young man named John Hinckley Jr. opened fire as President Ronald Reagan exited the Hilton Hotel. The chaotic scene resulted in the shooting of four individuals, with President Reagan being the prime tarrget. Hinckley was swiftly apprehended by law enforcement, and his severe mental illness led to his commitment at St. Elizabeth’s Psychiatric Hospital, where he would spend an astounding 41 years grappling with his delusions and troubled psyche. Over the decades, commentators and experts have delved into Hinckley’s complex mental health struggles and the motives behind his violent actions. Now, after 45 years, he has chosen to share his side of the story through a memoir titled Who I Really Am, co-authored with Jason Norman. Today in this special episode, John Hinckley and Jason Norman engage in a candid conversation with Jill, where they will explore the intricate details of his life, his journey through mental illness, and the insights gained from his experiences. Buy Who I Really Am by John Hinckley Jr & Jason Norman on , and on . PLANNING TO GO TO CRIMECON LAS VEGAS MAY 2026? Jill will be on ON CREATORS ROW! Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Happy to help! Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Crimecon 2026 is COMING, May 29-31, 2026! Get https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40139800
info_outline
Ep 152: Pt. 1 INCENDIARY: The Psychiatrist, the Mad Bomber, & the Invention of Criminal Profiling by Michael Cannell “Dastardly Days’
02/10/2026
Ep 152: Pt. 1 INCENDIARY: The Psychiatrist, the Mad Bomber, & the Invention of Criminal Profiling by Michael Cannell “Dastardly Days’
PART I: In 1956, a sinister figure known as the 'Mad Bomber' has been terrorizing New York City for 16 long years, leaving a trail of destruction in his wake. His bombs have detonated in telephone booths, restrooms, Grand Central Terminal, and other iconic landmarks across the Big Apple. While many have suffered injuries, fortunately, no one has died—yet. In a desperate attempt to reveal the identity of this elusive criminal, the NYPD bomb squad is utilizing a forensic crime lab, the first of its kind used for crime-fighting. As chilling letters from the 'Mad Bomber' continue to pour in, newspapers compete to cover the most compelling stories, amplifying the public's rising fear and anxiety. The question lingers: where will he strike next? And who is the enigmatic 'F.P.'? Buy on AMAZON. Buy on . PLANNING TO GO TO CRIMECON LAS VEGAS MAY 2026? Jill will be on ON CREATORS ROW! Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Happy to help! Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Crimecon 2026 is COMING! Get https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/40061210
info_outline
Ep 151 Pt 4: Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter by Troy A Hillman “They Chased Down the Zombie Hunter!”
02/03/2026
Ep 151 Pt 4: Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter by Troy A Hillman “They Chased Down the Zombie Hunter!”
Jill is thrilled to welcome retired cold case supervisor Troy A. Hillman, the leader of the elite cold case team that tirelessly pursued the killer of Angela Brosso and Melanie Bernas. These two young women were heartbreakingly stabbed to death in the early 1990s in Phoenix, Az. In his compelling new true crime book, Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter, Troy shares the gripping story of how the dedicated cold case detectives persevered against all odds, uncovering Phoenix’s most chilling cold case and ultimately revealing the identity of a serial killer who had been cleverly hiding in plain sight. Go behind the scenes and beyond pages with Jill and Troy! Don't miss Jill trilogy on Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter, Ep 147, 148 & 150! PLANNING TO GO TO CRIMECON LAS VEGAS IN MAY 2026? Jill will be on ON CREATORS ROW! Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Happy to help! Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER Case Studies! Crimecon 2026 is COMING! Get Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/39986955
info_outline
Ep 150: Pt 3 2ndCast: Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter by Troy A. Hillman‘ Still Room in Hell’
01/21/2026
Ep 150: Pt 3 2ndCast: Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter by Troy A. Hillman‘ Still Room in Hell’
Part 3: A cold case is now solved: A suspect has been apprehended in the haunting murders of Angela Brosso and Melanie Bernas, as Phoenix, Arizona rests more easily. After more than two decades, Bryan Patrick Miller's DNA has finally matched the evidence found on the victims. Who is the elusive figure who refers to himself as the "Zombie Hunter"? Join Jill as we embark on a detailed journey through the investigation into other possible victims, uncovering key witnesses and delving into the gripping eyewitness accounts that have shaped this case. Experience the dramatic clash between the prosecution and defense as the intricate path to justice unfolds, revealing unexpected twists and turns leading to a long-awaited resolution. As always, Jill remembers the victims. Based on the new book by Troy A. Hillman, you can purchase your copy of Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter at , , and other booksellers. PLANNING TO GO TO CRIMECON LAS VEGAS MAY 2026? Jill will be on ON CREATORS ROW! Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER CLASS! Who will be next? Get https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/39812065
info_outline
Special Ep 149: RIDERS ON THE STORM- Based on a True Story by Sherri Kukla- who chats with Jill!
01/14/2026
Special Ep 149: RIDERS ON THE STORM- Based on a True Story by Sherri Kukla- who chats with Jill!
Author Sherri Kukla joins Jill to discuss her brand new true crime book, Riders on the Storm, which reveals the chilling true story of William E. Cook, a spree killer largely forgotten by history—until now! As kidnappings escalate into murder, they send shockwaves through the nation, prompting the largest manhunt since John Dillinger was captured in 1934. Jill and Sherri delve into the haunting story, pay tribute to the victims and their families, and reflect on a nation paralyzed by fear just five years after the end of World War II. And who was Billy Cook, the Cockeyed Killer? Told with integrity and respect, Kukla ensures the victims' voices are heard. Fun Fact: This case inspired The Doors’ rock and roll classic, "Riders on the Storm"! BUY Sherri Kukla’s Sherri Kukla’s SEE you at the Hampton's Whodunit 2026! PLANNING TO GO TO CRIMECON LAS VEGAS MAY 2026? Jill will be on ON CREATORS ROW! Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Happy to help! Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER CLASS! Crimecon 2026 is COMING! Get Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/39723505
info_outline
Ep 148: Pt 2 Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter by Troy A. Hillman 'Pathology trumps Intellect’
01/07/2026
Ep 148: Pt 2 Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter by Troy A. Hillman 'Pathology trumps Intellect’
Part 2: Phoenix, Arizona 2014. The elite cold case unit diligently worked through the files related to the Canal Murders, which included over 1,000 potential suspects. One by one, they cleared each suspect, confirming that their DNA did not match the samples collected from the brutal murders of Angela Brosso in 1992 and Melanie Bernas in 1993. The team traveled across the country in search of leads, but morale began to suffer as the investigation entered its third year without an arrest. Eager to gain fresh insights, they presented their case to the Vidocq Society in Philadelphia, a distinguished group of federal, state, and local law enforcement experts and renowned forensic investigators from various fields. Then, they heard from forensic genealogist Dr. Colleen Fitzpatrick, who offered her assistance. Would her expertise and advancements in DNA analysis lead to identifying the killer? Based on the new book by Troy A. Hillman, you can purchase your copy of Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter at , , and other booksellers. PLANNING TO GO TO CRIMECON LAS VEGAS MAY 2026? Jill will be on ON CREATORS ROW! Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Every little bit helps! Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER CLASS! Crimecon 2026 is COMING! Get https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club : Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/39644510
info_outline
Ep 147: Pt. 1 Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter by Troy A. Hillman ‘The Canal Murders’
12/21/2025
Ep 147: Pt. 1 Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter by Troy A. Hillman ‘The Canal Murders’
Part I- Phoenix, Arizona 2011: A new elite team of investigators tackles some of the most challenging homicide cases—cold cases. Led by Sgt. Troy Hillman, they are determined to solve the murders of 22-year-old Angela Brosso and 17-year-old Melanie Bernas, whose deaths in 1992 and 1993 have cast long shadows over the city for 20 years. Who is responsible for taking the lives of these young women just as they were beginning to bloom? The cold case team begins by reexamining thousands of documents, including old FBI profiles, reviewing photographs, analyzing tips, revisiting crime scenes, and interviewing new leads. Their goal is to identify the elusive clue that could finally break open the case! The suspense and frustration are real! Based on the new book by Troy A. Hillman, you can purchase your copy of Chasing Down the Zombie Hunter at , , and other booksellers. PLANNING TO GO TO CRIMECON LAS VEGAS MAY 2026? Jill be on ON CREATORS ROW! Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge! Every little bit helps! Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER CLASS! Crimecon 2026 is COMING! Get https://www.jusaskjan.com/murder-shelf-book-club : Contact: , or , or .
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/39489150
info_outline
Special Ep 146: The Las Vegas Massacre CONNECTIONS by Mark Gray with MaryJo Von Tillow
12/10/2025
Special Ep 146: The Las Vegas Massacre CONNECTIONS by Mark Gray with MaryJo Von Tillow
This special episode is not the story of a twisted perpetrator and the carnage he caused. Perfect for the holiday season, this compelling conversation features Jill welcoming survivor and author Mark Gray. October 1, 2017, Mark was a journalist covering the Route 91 Harvest Festival concert when shots rang out from the Mandalay Bay Hotel in Las Vegas. In Jill's review of The Las Vegas Massacre CONNECTIONS: Finding Strength Through Tragedy After America's Deadliest Mass Shooting, she noted that it “presents an inspiring portrait of survival after horrific loss, focusing on the victims, survivors, and their families and friends, as well as the connections that bind them together on a journey to recover and renew. These genuine, raw, and personal accounts reflect the resilience and healing that can emerge amidst the pain of grief when a loved one is lost. This inspiring and altruistic work showcases the best of humanity arising from the worst of circumstances. I encourage you all to read "The Las Vegas Massacre Connections." This book would make a marvelous holiday gift for anyone who enjoys true crime, memoirs, and even self-help. by Mark Gray on Amazon. PLANNING TO GO TO CRIMECON LAS VEGAS MAY 2026? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10%! Every little bit helps! The Holidays are almost here! Get : Contact: jill@murdershelfbookclub.com, or , or . Join Jill on and help pick our next book and enjoy Jill’s SERIAL KILLER CLASS! Merry Christmas, Happy Hanuakkah, and Good Kwanzaa!
/episode/index/show/34abed69-b1dc-4cf7-949e-e945f6b83549/id/39354855