Wicked Stage Podcast
"Life upon the wicked stage ain't ever what a girl supposes..." A true crime podcast in the spotlight of arts and entertainment!
info_outline
2nd Annual Floozy Awards
08/14/2026
2nd Annual Floozy Awards
Jen, Ashley, and Olivia host the second annual Floozie Awards for Season 3 of The Wicked Stage Pod, a true-crime podcast under arts and entertainment, using real-time voting across comedic and serious categories. They define “biggest thumb” and award it to Lou Pearlman over nominees including Charles Manson, Jerry Lee Lewis, Joseph McCarthy, Andrew Cunanan, Arthur Miller, and Alan Griffin Stanford Jr. “Creepiest old man” goes to Marilyn Monroe’s boarding house predator. Best side character is Orson Welles; most unproblematic man is the boy bands; most shocking moment is the Twilight Zone helicopter crash; best surprise cameo is Alice Cooper; most wanted merch is “The blimps all crashed. We’re starting a boy band.” Floozy of the Year is unanimously Marilyn Monroe. They promote socials, Patreon, Spotify playlist, and sponsorships. 00:00 Listener Warning 00:16 Meet The Hosts 00:42 Floozie Awards Setup 02:53 How Voting Works 03:47 Biggest Thumb Nominees 15:58 Thumb Winner Reveal 17:36 Creepiest Old Man Category 22:51 Jen Panera Dating Story 28:57 Olivia Disney Liar Story 37:14 Boarding House Predator 38:36 Picking the Worst Floozy 39:55 Emotional Support Triscuit 44:53 Blimps to Boy Bands 46:16 Fresh Whores and Dickies 51:17 Triscuits Blimps Whores Vote 54:07 Best Side Character Nominees 01:00:47 Orson Welles Wins 01:02:58 Merch Brainstorm Aftermath 01:04:50 Most Problematic Stage Mom 01:13:23 Charlotte Shelby Takes It 01:14:12 Most Unproblematic Man 01:19:09 Boy Bands Win One 01:20:55 Most Shocking Moments 01:29:59 Best Surprise Cameos 01:32:18 Most Wanted Merch 01:35:50 Floozy of the Year 01:43:17 Season Wrap Up
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/42381730
info_outline
Athalia Ponsell Lindsley: A Florida Floozy Struck Down Too Soon
07/31/2026
Athalia Ponsell Lindsley: A Florida Floozy Struck Down Too Soon
The hosts of Life Upon the Wicked Stage introduce a true-crime/arts podcast episode about Athalia Ponsell Lindsley (born Maryanne Fetter), a wealthy Florida-raised former Powers model, Broadway chorus girl, and early TV hostess whose life later shifted to real estate, civic organizations, political activism, and inventing a patented potato-related kitchen utensil. After moving to St. Augustine, marrying former mayor James “Jinx” Lindsley, and clashing publicly with neighbor/county engineer Alan Griffin Stanford Jr. over his credentials and alleged corruption, Athalia reported he threatened her. On January 23, 1974, she and her pet blue jay Clementine were brutally killed on her porch with a machete. Evidence included an eyewitness who initially identified Stanford, a blood trail to his home, and a dumped bundle containing a machete checked out by Stanford and his bloodied clothing and watch, but police mishandling and defense arguments led to his acquittal; a friend, Frances Bemis, was later murdered while Stanford was out on bail, and both murders remain officially unsolved. 00:00 Listener Warning 00:17 Show Intro and Hosts 01:03 He-Man and Movie Chat 02:07 Small World Animatronics 04:35 Robocall Name Riff 06:50 Meet Athalia Ponsell 12:29 Old Money Origins 17:13 New York Reinvention 23:18 Modeling and Chevy Girl 33:18 Broadway Chorus Years 35:01 Game Show Hostess Era 37:34 Gossip Column Romance 41:25 Midroll Intermission Break 43:51 First Marriage Ends Fast 47:40 Florida Reinvention Years 50:58 Clubs Patents And Pedigree 53:58 Move To St Augustine 58:50 Town Politics And Prejudice 01:04:35 Feud With County Engineer 01:10:54 Threats And Case Date 01:14:28 Bathroom Stop Setup 01:16:57 Doorbell And Mailbox Walk 01:18:25 Machete Porch Attack 01:21:09 Eyewitness And Suspect ID 01:29:58 Blood Trail And Coverup 01:31:34 Dump Bundle Evidence 01:36:39 Motive And Trial Fallout 01:41:04 Acquittal And Lasting Impact 01:45:26 Closing Tribute And Signoff
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/42241745
info_outline
The Murder of Gianni Versace Part 2: Andrew Cunanan’s Killing Spree
07/17/2026
The Murder of Gianni Versace Part 2: Andrew Cunanan’s Killing Spree
The hosts of “Life Upon the Wicked Stage,” a true-crime podcast framed through arts and entertainment, discuss the distinction between serial and spree killings while recounting Andrew Cunanan’s 1997 murder spree. They describe the first two murders involving Cunanan’s acquaintance Jeffrey Trail, beaten to death with a hammer in David Madson’s apartment, and Madson, who was forced to travel with Cunanan and later shot near Rush Lake, Minnesota. They note law enforcement missteps, including treating the early deaths as domestic violence, delays in FBI coordination, and Cunanan not being added to the FBI Most Wanted list until June 12. They cover subsequent killings of Lee Miglin (brutally murdered and car stolen), William Reese (killed for his truck), and Gianni Versace, shot at close range outside Casa Casuarina on July 15, 1997, amid a rapid media circus and failure to warn Versace despite Cunanan’s claims of knowing him. 00:00 Listener Warning 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:41 Spree vs Serial Killers 03:08 Cunanan Case Begins 03:48 Jeffrey Trail Murder 04:42 Motive and Relationships 09:38 Confrontation at Apartment 12:35 Hostage and David Madson 16:49 Mid Episode Intermission 17:57 Law Enforcement Missteps 19:01 Police Bias Missteps 19:50 Spree Case Reforms 20:38 Miglin Brutal Murder 22:33 Truck Theft Killing 23:44 Most Wanted Delay 26:49 Versace Risk Ignored 30:24 Versace Final Morning 36:05 Media Circus Aftermath 39:01 Dove Bullet Mystery 40:16 Podcast Wrap Up
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/42119850
info_outline
The Murder of Gianni Versace Part 1: Murder Is So Last Season
07/03/2026
The Murder of Gianni Versace Part 1: Murder Is So Last Season
The Floozies open with personal travel updates, including Ashley’s “soft elopement” wedding before an Italy trip, Jen’s Lisbon Filmapalooza trip with Rotten Rabbit TV (including making a short film) followed by 10 days in Paris, and Olivia’s private-jet travel to an Alice Cooper concert where she reconnects with theater contacts. They then introduce the episode’s topic: Gianni Versace’s life and murder, discussing American Crime Story and questions about “assassination” vs murder and serial vs spree killers. Olivia outlines Versace’s upbringing in Italy, his mother’s tailoring influence, classical studies, founding his label in 1978, his bold aesthetic, supermodel-era runway innovations, Medusa branding symbolism, and long-term partner Antonio D’Amico. Olivia begins profiling killer Andrew Cunanan’s background—elite schooling, status-obsessed fantasies, family instability, sexuality conflicts, relationships with older wealthy men, and escalating pathology after his father fled in 1988—setting up a later timeline of the 1997 killings and law enforcement missteps. 00:00 Listener Warning 00:15 Meet The Hosts 00:47 Chipmunks Nostalgia 03:34 Louvre Ninja Turtles 04:16 Soft Elopement Wedding 08:51 Lisbon Film Festival Trip 14:53 Private Jet Alice Cooper 19:07 Versace Episode Setup 23:46 Versace Early Life 28:59 Milan Label Breakthrough 31:04 Supermodels And Runway Shows 35:43 Medusa Logo Meaning 38:29 Partner And Privacy Talk 44:05 Privacy And Algorithms 44:50 Versace And Damico Reality 46:41 Cunanan Enters Story 48:16 Murder Versus Assassination 57:37 Cunanan Childhood And Status 01:09:01 Sex Work And Grooming Talk 01:16:38 Family Collapse And Rage 01:19:43 Psychology Risk Factors 01:30:12 Spree Timeline And Wrap
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/41911355
info_outline
Marilyn Monroe, Part 2: The Bombshell, Bombshells, and Remembering Norma Jean
06/19/2026
Marilyn Monroe, Part 2: The Bombshell, Bombshells, and Remembering Norma Jean
Jen, Ashley, and Olivia discuss theories about Marilyn Monroe’s death, separating documented facts from speculation, following Donald Wolfe’s 1998 book Last Days of Marilyn Monroe. They review claims that Monroe may have been a homicide victim tied to alleged Kennedy relationships and potential political fallout, including testimony from Deputy DA John Miner suggesting drugs entered through the large intestine (possibly via enema) and questions about missing organ samples. They examine Peter Lawford’s (yes, Jen gets it right this time) reported sedated phone call and contrast it with Joe DiMaggio Jr.’s later account that Monroe sounded normal, plus disputed time-of-death estimates. They highlight shifting statements by housekeeper/nurse Eunice Murray, delays in contacting police, Sergeant Jack Clemmons’ discomfort with the “soldier position” and orderly pill bottles, and a broken window with contested glass patterns. They cover alternative explanations including medical negligence, accidental overdose, narrative control, intelligence monitoring, and organized crime connections, noting the 1982 DA review found no conclusive homicide evidence, and the death remains listed as “probable suicide.” 00:00 Listener Warning 00:16 Meet the Hosts 00:52 Cold Open Banter 01:48 Marilyn Death Theories 04:35 Wolfe Kennedy Theory 07:52 Autopsy Enema Evidence 13:59 Peter Lawford Call 19:21 Eunice Murray Timeline 30:00 Conflicting Phone Calls 32:45 Clemmons Scene Doubts 36:04 Soldier Pose Window 43:48 Intermission Plug 44:39 House Layout Window 46:11 Odd Scene Details 46:57 Kennedy Timeline Debate 49:57 Claims Versus Facts 50:31 Toxicology And Drug Risks 56:07 Theory Medical Negligence 57:02 Theory: Accidental Overdose 01:03:27 Theory: Timeline Shifts 01:10:20 Theory: Narrative Control 01:12:18 FBI CIA Surveillance Theory 01:15:48 Mob And Staging Theories 01:22:06 Why The Case Endures 01:28:29 Final Reflections And Wrap
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/41693850
info_outline
Marilyn Monroe, Part 1: Norma Jean, the Hollywood Machine, and a Death That Still Raises Questions
06/05/2026
Marilyn Monroe, Part 1: Norma Jean, the Hollywood Machine, and a Death That Still Raises Questions
Jen, Ashley, and Olivia open their true-crime-in-entertainment podcast with personal updates and then begin a two-part episode on Marilyn Monroe, including a warning about disturbing content and an apology for misnaming Peter Lawford. Jen recaps Monroe’s early life as Norma Jean Mortenson (born June 1, 1926), marked by her mother Gladys Baker’s severe mental illness, foster care and an orphanage, an unknown father, and reported childhood sexual assault by a tenant. At 16 she married James Dougherty to avoid returning to an orphanage; after he joined the Merchant Marines, she was discovered modeling at the Radio Plane Company, divorced, and signed with 20th Century Fox in 1946 as “Marilyn Monroe,” with a studio-driven image overhaul. They discuss her intelligence, acting study under Lee Strasberg, founding Marilyn Monroe Productions, troubled marriages to Joe DiMaggio and Arthur Miller, worsening mental health and heavy sedative use, and the contested August 4–5, 1962 timeline of her death in Brentwood, including accounts from Eunice Murray, Dr. Greenson, Sgt. Jack Clemmons, and rumors involving the Kennedys to be explored in part two. 00:00 Quick Correction and Warning 00:36 Hosts Catch Up 01:39 Kristin Chenoweth Encounter 02:56 Movie Cameo and Scheduling Chaos 08:29 Introducing Marilyn Monroe Case 11:38 Death Night Overview 12:49 Before Marilyn Childhood 17:08 Foster Homes and Abuse 27:12 Teen Marriage Escape 34:51 Brains Behind the Bombshell 41:52 Making of Marilyn Begins 44:06 Intermission and Plug 44:55 Fox Contract and New Name 47:13 Face Changes Debate 48:17 Platinum Blonde Power 49:47 Hair Color Confessions 51:57 Early Films and Playboy 53:51 Manufactured Icon Persona 57:24 Love and Marriage Tension 57:55 DiMaggio Jealousy Fallout 01:01:11 Arthur Miller Betrayal 01:10:02 Marilyn Pushes Back 01:14:02 Doctors and Drug Spiral 01:26:01 Final Day Timeline 01:28:13 Clemmons and Suspicions 01:34:04 Kennedy Theories Tease
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/41535140
info_outline
The Twilight Zone Movie Disaster and the Rage of Triscuits
05/22/2026
The Twilight Zone Movie Disaster and the Rage of Triscuits
Ashley dives into the “Twilight Zone: The Movie” disaster, detailing the July 23, 1982, on-set helicopter crash in California that killed actor Vic Morrow and child actors Micah Dinh Le (7) and Renee Shin-Yi Chen (6) and injured six others. They discuss John Landis’s “Time Out” segment and explain how studio concerns about an unsympathetic protagonist led Landis to add a Vietnam rescue ending involving the children, who were hired illegally and paid under the table, hidden from safety personnel, and whose parents were allegedly misled about helicopters and explosives. Testimony and an NTSB report attributed the crash to special-effects explosions damaging the helicopter, while Landis and others were tried and acquitted of manslaughter; civil suits were settled. The episode covers fallout involving Spielberg, industry safety reforms and hotlines, and reflections on performers advocating for safety. 00:00 Listener Warning 00:14 Meet the Hosts 00:39 Rage Triscuit Banter 01:53 Tea Talk and Catnip 04:31 Episode Reveal and Intro 06:15 Twilight Zone Disaster Overview 07:32 Movie Structure and Cast 11:48 Landis Segment Plot 16:34 Key Players Landis and Morrow 22:17 The Night of the Crash 35:37 Safety Failures and Illegal Child Labor 44:33 Aftermath and Spielberg Reaction 47:49 Eddie Murphy Fallout 50:16 Warnings Before the Crash 53:11 Trial Testimony and Blame 01:01:12 Settlements and Film Release Ethics 01:07:53 Safety Reforms After Tragedy 01:12:49 Aftermath for Landis and Morrow 01:20:14 Safety PSA and Wrap Up
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/41334965
info_outline
The Hollywood Red Scare: Witches, Commies, and Orson Wells (yes, again)
05/08/2026
The Hollywood Red Scare: Witches, Commies, and Orson Wells (yes, again)
Jen dives into the post–World War II Red Scare in Hollywood, framing it as a true-crime-like witch hunt driven by fear rather than evidence. Beginning with HUAC’s October 20, 1947 investigation, they explain how subpoenas, the question “Are you now, or have you ever been a member of the Communist Party?”, and pressure to “name names” split witnesses into “friendly” and “unfriendly,” leading to the Hollywood 10’s contempt convictions and prison sentences. They describe the Waldorf Statement and the unofficial blacklist’s career-destroying power, highlighting affected figures including Lee Grant, Dorothy Comingore, Lillian Hellman, Orson Welles, John Garfield, Paul Robeson, and Charlie Chaplin, while noting Lucille Ball was cleared. They cover cooperators like Elia Kazan, Ronald Reagan, and Walt Disney, McCarthy’s later rise and censure, Arthur Miller’s The Crucible as allegory, and how Dalton Trumbo’s credits on Spartacus/Exodus helped crack the blacklist. 00:00 Listener Warning and Intro 00:42 Cold Open Banter 01:30 Back to 1947 Setup 04:46 HUAC Targets Hollywood 11:02 What the Red Scare Was 22:31 Hollywood 10 Explained 27:26 Waldorf Statement Blacklist 33:15 Who Got Hit Hardest 34:15 Women Blacklisted Stories 38:23 Orson Welles Under Fire 41:50 Blacklist Tragedies Garfield Robeson 46:48 Chaplin Exiled Lucy Survives 51:45 Lucy Beats the Blacklist 54:31 Friendly Witnesses Exposed 54:46 Kazan Names Names 56:23 Reagan and Red Scare 57:33 Disney Testifies Too 01:02:31 McCarthy Takes the Stage 01:07:36 Army Hearings Collapse 01:09:54 Arthur Miller Strikes Back 01:13:17 Trumbo Writes in Secret 01:16:18 Spartacus Breaks the Ban 01:18:21 Real Crimes and Echoes 01:22:11 Final Thoughts and Signoff
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/41166675
info_outline
Blimps, Betrayal, and Boy Bands: The Lou Pearlman Scam(s)
04/24/2026
Blimps, Betrayal, and Boy Bands: The Lou Pearlman Scam(s)
T Olivia recaps the docuseries “Dirty Pop: The Life and Times of Lou Pearlman,” and traces Pearlman’s path from a bullied, document-forging kid with an obsession with blimps to founding Airship International, allegedly aided by a Nazi-affiliated businessman and mafia-linked backing. They describe how Pearlman created Transcontinental Records, formed and controlled Backstreet Boys and NSYNC (rehearsing in a blimp hangar, touring schools, sent to Germany to break big), presented himself as “Big Papa,” and kept bands unpaid while signing himself as a “sixth member” to collect royalties, ultimately extracting a $64 million buyout. As investors and authorities closed in, an Employee Investment Savings Account and fake “German savings bank” documents unraveled into a massive fraud: about 2,000 victims, $300 million, plus $200 million in bank fraud; a questioned death of associate Frankie Vasquez; Pearlman’s Bali arrest; a 25-year sentence; death in prison in 2016 (spoiler alert); and only $10 million recovered. And of course, Olivia's very personal connection to it all. 00:00 Listener Warning 00:16 Meet the Hosts 00:42 Why Lou Pearlman 03:34 Lou Early Life 06:16 Blimp Business Origins 07:11 Nazis and Mob Money 12:58 Boy Band Blueprint 14:03 Backstreet Boys Rise 22:47 Germany Breakthrough 26:34 NSYNC Rival Setup 29:44 Money Disputes Explode 32:54 Blimp Crashes Insurance 36:18 Lawsuits and Buyouts 42:08 Transcon New Roster 42:36 Intermission Break 43:30 Natural and Flashy Life 46:22 Billionaire Mindset Gap 46:43 9/11 Jet Clearance Story 48:50 Transcon Empire Shopping Spree 52:21 Employee Savings Ponzi Pitch 55:04 Regulators Close In 56:28 Fake Checks Trigger FBI 58:56 Frankie Vasquez Tragedy 01:01:09 Natural Breakup and IRS Shock 01:06:39 FBI Raids and Global Run 01:11:46 Bali Tipoff and Arrest 01:15:45 Fraud Exposed in Court 01:22:18 Prison Calls and Survivor Guilt 01:29:23 Death and Aftermath
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/40961260
info_outline
The Gig is Up: Hollywood Actor Gig Young’s Tragic End
04/10/2026
The Gig is Up: Hollywood Actor Gig Young’s Tragic End
Ashley delves into the life and death of Hollywood actor Gig Young (born Byron Ellsworth Barr), a prolific Golden Age performer with over 100 film credits, Oscar nominations, and a Best Supporting Actor win for They Shoot Horses, Don’t They? (1969), yet persistent feelings of inadequacy rooted in an emotionally cold childhood and alleged sexual abuse by a caregiver. Known as the charming second lead who “loses the girl,” Young struggled with insecurity, career frustration, and alcoholism, leading to lost roles including Blazing Saddles and the original voice of Charlie on Charlie’s Angels. Married five times, he had one daughter, Jennifer, and fought child support before later being linked to controversial psychologist Eugene Landy. On October 19, 1978, three weeks after marrying fifth wife Kim Schmidt, Young fatally shot her and then himself in their Osborne Apartments unit in Manhattan; no motive or note was found, and the case was ruled murder-suicide. 00:00 Listener Warning 00:17 Meet the Hosts 00:37 Elderberry Cold Open 02:32 Case Reveal Gig Young 05:06 Early Life and Family 14:12 Abuse and Insecurity 18:17 Acting Breakthrough 22:27 Second Lead Career 30:25 Oscar and Downfall 33:51 Sexuality Rumors 40:12 Five Marriages Timeline 45:14 Patreon and Ratings 46:09 Paternity Fight Fallout 48:12 Fifth Wife Kim Schmidt 49:50 Career Collapse Alcoholism 52:55 Osborne Apartments Detour 56:48 Meet Dr Eugene Landy 01:03:45 Brian Wilson Control Scheme 01:11:19 Landy Treats Gig Young 01:13:57 Murder Suicide Discovery 01:21:16 Aftermath Motives Legacy 01:28:07 Closing Reflections Next Pod
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/40777360
info_outline
Jerry Lee Lewis: Great Balls of Fire, Indeed
03/27/2026
Jerry Lee Lewis: Great Balls of Fire, Indeed
The hosts discuss Jerry Lee Lewis’s career and controversies, including his rise at Sun Records, membership in the “Million Dollar Quartet,” and hits like “Whole Lotta Shakin’ Goin’ On” and “Great Balls of Fire,” alongside stories of ego and volatile behavior. They outline his marriages and family tragedies: a bigamous second marriage before his first divorce finalized; marriage at 22 to 13-year-old cousin Myra Gale Brown, which derailed his British tour; and allegations of physical and mental abuse. They cover the drowning death of Myra’s child, later deaths and scandals involving Lewis, and the disputed deaths of wives Jaren Pate (1982 pool drowning) and Shawn Stevens (1983 methadone overdose), citing a Rolling Stone account of blood, bruising, and inconsistencies. The episode emphasizes how fame, power, and systems allegedly protected him. 00:00 Listener Warning 00:15 Valentines Banter 02:16 Meet Jerry Lee Lewis 06:10 Early Life and Sun Records 12:26 Hits and Wild Persona 15:20 Child Bride Scandal 27:58 Backlash and Dark Turn 36:45 Intermission and Plugs 37:39 Wife Four and Threats 40:55 Fourth Wife Drowning 42:29 Power Shields Scandal 47:29 Fifth Wife Dies Fast 50:03 Blood Bruises Questions 51:53 Methadone Explained 01:00:06 Needle Marks Struggle 01:07:15 Exit Plan Cut Off 01:10:43 Why No Indictment 01:16:39 Celebrity Accountability 01:20:23 Wrap Up And Outro
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/40498430
info_outline
Missing Masterpieces: The Gardner Museum Heist
03/13/2026
Missing Masterpieces: The Gardner Museum Heist
The hosts of Wicked Stage Pod introduce an episode about the still-unsolved 1990 Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum heist in Boston, including background on Isabella Gardner’s Venetian-palace-style museum, her restrictive will, and spotty security. On March 18, 1990, two men posing as Boston police were buzzed in, handcuffed and duct-taped two guards in the basement, and spent 81 minutes stealing 13 works, including Vermeer’s The Concert and Rembrandt’s Christ in a Storm on the Sea of Galilee, cutting canvases from frames; the guards were later found unharmed. The discussion covers mishandled evidence (missing VHS tape and duct tape), theories involving organized crime and art thief Miles Connor, alleged sightings and attempted deals in the late 1990s, FBI focus on the Rossetti crew, and later investigations, with the empty frames still hanging and a $10 million reward outstanding. 00:00 Listener Warning 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:49 Cold Weather Banter 03:45 Heist Episode Setup 05:33 Gardner Museum Origins 07:18 Isabella’s Ironclad Will 09:55 St Patrick’s Night Security 17:39 Morning Discovery of Break In 28:05 Missing Art and Masterpieces 34:33 Guards’ Story Fake Cops 40:05 81 Minutes Inside Theories 46:05 Inside Job Suspicions 50:48 Guard Lets Them In 51:48 Evidence Mishandled 53:41 Scotland Yard And Mobs 56:06 Italian Crew Suspects 59:21 Cold Case And Storage Shed 01:01:36 Warehouse Art Proof 01:04:27 Paint Swatch Showdown 01:08:56 Rosetti Sightings And Deaths 01:13:54 Wiretap And Loomis Plot 01:20:31 Gentile Sting And Trapdoor 01:27:38 FBI Names Suspects 01:30:32 Where Things Stand Today 01:34:40 Final Wrap And Next Episode
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/40414860
info_outline
William Desmond Taylor: ScaDAL in Hollywood
02/27/2026
William Desmond Taylor: ScaDAL in Hollywood
The hosts of a true-crime arts-and-entertainment podcast discuss the 1922 unsolved murder of silent film director William Desmond Taylor, who was found shot in the back inside his Los Angeles bungalow; early crime-scene contamination and a mysterious “doctor” who wrongly declared a stomach hemorrhage complicated the case. Born William Cunningham Deane-Tanner in Ireland, Taylor immigrated to the U.S., married actress Ethel May Harrison, had a daughter, then disappeared in 1908, later resurfacing in California under a new name and building a successful directing career, including work with Mary Miles Minter. Suspects and theories include Mabel Normand (last known to see him, cocaine addiction), Minter and her mother Charlotte Shelby (who owned a .38 and claimed to discard it in a Louisiana bayou), former valet Edward Sands (criminal who vanished), valet Henry Peavy (a person of color targeted by sensational press), a drug-hit theory, and actress Margaret Gibson’s uncorroborated deathbed confession. 00:00 Listener Warning 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:59 Robe Reveal Banter 02:42 Case Introduction 04:40 Early Life and Dude Ranch 08:10 New York Marriage and Disappearance 15:20 Reinvention in Hollywood 20:34 War Service and Rising Fame 24:16 Body Found and Crime Scene Chaos 27:05 Autopsy Clues and Missing Cash 35:05 Media Circus and Coverup Claims 39:33 Suspect Mabel Normand 44:19 Intermission and Sponsor Break 45:10 Theories and Next Suspect Tease 45:52 Minter Letters Scandal 49:24 Press Fallout and Alibi 53:11 Stage Mom Prime Suspect 55:00 Bayou Gun Disposal 01:00:17 Valet Vanishes 01:05:32 Peevy and Profiling 01:09:20 Hitman and Confession 01:16:21 Hollywood Moral Panic 01:21:40 Final Theories and Wrap
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/40242305
info_outline
The Murder of Sharon Tate: Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
02/13/2026
The Murder of Sharon Tate: Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
In this episode of 'Life Upon the Wicked Stage,' hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia dive deep into the chilling events surrounding the Tate-LaBianca murders orchestrated by Charles Manson and his followers. They explore the brutal details of the crimes, discuss various motives including the infamous helter-skelter theory, failed music ambitions, and potential drug connections. The discussion also highlights the profound impact these murders had on Hollywood and American culture in the late 60s. The episode concludes with the fates of the perpetrators and fascinating, lesser-known connections Manson had with Hollywood's elite, including Dennis Wilson, Neil Young, and even Angela Lansbury’s family. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:39 New Year Resolutions 00:53 Beverage Choices 01:45 Upcoming Episodes 02:20 Introducing the Manson Murders 02:44 Benedict Canyon's Dark History 05:31 The Night of the Murders 10:21 The Horrific Details 24:06 The Aftermath and Trials 39:09 Cultural Impact and Hollywood's Dark Turn 45:03 The End of the Production Code 46:37 The Rise of Manson Exploitation Films 51:08 Exploring Possible Murder Motives 01:11:00 Manson's Hollywood Connections 01:19:32 Conclusion and Reflections
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/39862340
info_outline
A Very Floozy Christmas
12/24/2025
A Very Floozy Christmas
Holiday Horrors: JonBenét Update & Krampus' Legend In this Christmas-themed episode of the Wicked Stage Pod, the hosts delve into the darker side of the festive season. They start with Jen discussing ghost stories' deep roots in Christmas traditions, tracing back to medieval Europe and Charles Dickens' influence. Ashley updates listeners on the ongoing JonBenét Ramsey case, revealing new forensic analysis and potential breakthroughs. Olivia wraps up with an exploration of Krampus, the mythical anti-Santa of Alpine folklore, detailing his origins, cultural impact, and modern resurgence in pop culture and festivals. The episode balances dark true crime and folklore with festive cheer, ending with a surprising twist connecting host Jen to a Kevin Smith movie. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:17 Meet the Hosts 00:42 Life Updates and Holiday Cheer 02:08 Olivia's Birth Story 04:24 Floozy Merch Announcement 04:56 Special Christmas Episode 08:16 The Tradition of Christmas Ghost Stories 19:25 The Victorian Era and Charles Dickens 27:35 JonBenet Ramsey Case Overview 52:38 The Santa Theory 54:13 DNA Evidence and CODIS 56:41 New Forensic Analysis 57:05 Burke Ramsey's Interview 58:15 Annual Update from Boulder Police 01:00:24 The Role of Orum Labs 01:01:32 Genetic Genealogy and the JonBenet Ramsey Case 01:02:43 Speculations and Theories 01:08:29 Krampus: The Dark Side of Christmas 01:10:01 Krampus in Modern Culture 01:11:02 Krampus Festivals and Celebrations 01:28:07 Krampus in Pop Culture 01:35:09 Surprise Krampus Twist 01:37:59 Wrapping Up and Future Plans
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/39520600
info_outline
Halloween Special: Jack the Ripper
10/30/2025
Halloween Special: Jack the Ripper
In this special Halloween crossover episode, the Wicked Stage Podcast joins forces with the Fish 'N' Brits Podcast to delve into the infamous mystery of Jack the Ripper. The episode explores the historical context of the Whitechapel murders, examines different suspects including Joseph Barnett, John Pizer, and even the legendary Sergeant Boston Corbett, and discusses the sensational impact of the media at the time. With a detailed analysis of the canonical five victims and a review of modern theories, the podcast offers an in-depth look into one of the most captivating unsolved cases in history. Expert commentary, insightful discussions, and a touch of humor make this a must-listen for true crime enthusiasts. 00:00 Introduction and Setting the Scene 00:40 Meet the Hosts 01:21 Podcast Crossover Chaos 04:01 Historical Context: London in 1888 06:54 Living Conditions in Whitechapel 12:22 Policing and Crime in Whitechapel 13:53 Prostitution and Social Issues 24:08 The Whitechapel Murders 39:38 Police Incompetence and Early Investigations 40:40 Press Involvement and Public Pressure 42:13 Introduction of Inspector Frederick Abberline 43:10 Details of the Murders and Victim Profiles 54:44 The Double Event: Two Murders in One Night 01:02:21 The Final Canonical Victim: Mary Jane Kelly 01:09:01 Letters from Jack the Ripper 01:21:12 Cannibalism and Jack the Ripper's Letters 01:23:20 Media Frenzy: The Role of Newspapers 01:27:25 Theories and Suspects: Criminal Profiling Begins 01:28:58 John Pizer: The Leather Apron Suspect 01:37:41 Montague John Druitt: The Educated Suspect 01:45:54 James Maybrick: The Diary Confession 01:52:15 Joseph Barnett: The Jealous Lover 01:58:43 George Chapman: The Poisoner Barber 02:02:41 William Gull: The From Hell Theory 02:07:16 Debunking the Jack the Ripper Suspect: Dr. Thomas Neill Cream 02:07:54 The Tragic Life of Jimmy Kelly James 02:09:55 The Great Escape: Kelly's Connection to the Ripper Murders 02:12:20 Boston Corbett: The Unlikely Suspect 02:15:47 Jill the Ripper: A Feminist Twist 02:20:47 Aaron Kosminski: The DNA Controversy 02:31:10 Final Thoughts and Speculations 02:47:56 Outro and Where to Find Us
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/38841745
info_outline
The First Annual Floozy Awards
09/19/2025
The First Annual Floozy Awards
The First Annual Floozy Awards - Celebrating a Year of Stories, Laughs, and True Crime In this special episode, hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia celebrate the one-year anniversary of their true-crime podcast 'Life Upon the Wicked Stage' by presenting the first annual Floozy Awards. The hosts discuss various memorable episodes from the past year, highlighting their favorite moments, one-liners, shocking twists, and unproblematic men. Categories include 'Biggest Thumb,' 'Creepiest Old Man,' 'Most Unproblematic Man,' 'Best One-Liner,' 'Best Fringe Show You Didn't Ask For,' and more. They also announce some exciting upcoming collaborations and discuss potential future merch. Join the fun as they reflect on a year full of intriguing stories and hilarious discussions. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:15 Meet the Hosts 01:04 The First Annual Floozy Awards 02:06 Upcoming Halloween Collaboration 03:00 Podcast Anniversary Celebration 03:39 Dress Code and Themes 09:02 Biggest Thumb Award 17:39 Creepiest Old Man Award 26:30 Most Haunted Episode Award 35:01 Best One-Liner Award 45:33 Best Side Character Award 52:53 Best Editing Award 55:24 Introduction to Problematic Stage Moms 55:37 Harry Houdini's Overbearing Mother 56:56 Mama Nesbitt's Negligence 58:51 George Reeves' Troubled Relationship with His Mother 01:02:14 Most Unproblematic Man Nominees 01:12:42 Most Shocking Moments 01:19:01 Best Fringe Show Ideas 01:23:51 Surprise Cameo Performances 01:27:16 Most Wanted Merch Items 01:31:07 Films Olivia Needs to Watch 01:34:57 Jen's Potential Dangers 01:38:28 Best Mispronunciation 01:41:33 Floozy of the Year 01:46:05 Closing Remarks and Thank Yous
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/38201950
info_outline
Rust: Tragedy on Set
09/05/2025
Rust: Tragedy on Set
This podcast episode, featuring hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia, delves into the tragic on-set shooting that occurred during the filming of the movie 'Rust' on October 21, 2021. The hosts discuss the circumstances surrounding the fatal shooting of cinematographer Helena Hutchins and the injury of director Joel Souza by a live round discharged from a revolver handled by actor Alec Baldwin. They highlight the safety failures, including inappropriate handling of firearms by the armorer, amateurish safety protocols by assistant director David Halls, and the broader procedural lapses. The episode explores the impact of the incident on those involved, including the ensuing legal battles and ultimate film completion as a tribute to Helena Hutchins. The hosts emphasize the critical importance of teamwork, safety, and accountability in film production. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:43 Retrograde Vibes 01:08 Annabelle Doll Discussion 01:43 Introducing the Rust Incident 03:38 Background on the Film Rust 06:42 The Role of a Cinematographer 09:00 Producer Roles Explained 14:12 First Assistant Director: David Hall 18:01 Armorer Hannah Gutierrez Reed 30:03 The Incident on Set 43:24 Immediate Aftermath 48:36 The Confusion and Panic Unfolds 49:29 The Investigation Begins 51:30 Alec Baldwin's Emotional Response 53:05 The Blame Game and Legal Battles 54:53 The Shocking Discovery of Live Rounds 59:04 The Aftermath and Legal Consequences 01:06:30 Resuming Filming and Seeking Justice 01:27:24 Final Reflections and Lessons Learned
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/38045430
info_outline
Broadway Butterfly: NYC Corruption, Tammany Hall, and Vivian Gordon
08/22/2025
Broadway Butterfly: NYC Corruption, Tammany Hall, and Vivian Gordon
In this episode, hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia delve into the true crime story of Vivian Gordon, also known as the Broadway Butterfly. The podcast explores her life, her involvement in the seedy underworld of 1920s and 30s New York, and the events leading up to her mysterious murder. The story includes her early life, attempts to escape the showgirl lifestyle, her ultimate entanglement in organized crime, blackmail schemes, and a tragic end that coincides with a significant political scandal involving New York City Mayor Jimmy Walker. The narrative also touches on the corruption within the police force and the judicial system, with notable appearances by FDR and Judge Samuel Seabury. The episode concludes with the sad suicide of Vivian’s daughter, Benita, and an overview of key historical figures connected to the case. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:50 Sponsored by Revenge 02:00 The Broadway Butterfly: Vivian Gordon 02:36 A Body in the Park 08:06 Vivian's Early Life 10:30 From Chorus Girl to Common Law Wife 15:54 A Setup and a Downfall 28:00 Vivian's Rise in the Underworld 29:16 Corruption and Blackmail 44:33 The Seabury Investigation 46:04 Vivian's Last Stand 46:41 Support the Podcast 48:59 Vivian's Bold Move 49:42 The Mysterious Death 50:08 The Investigation Begins 52:12 The Grand Jury and Corruption 57:21 A Tragic Turn 01:00:50 Breakthrough in the Case 01:08:41 The Aftermath and Legacy 01:19:57 Unsolved Mysteries and Reflections 01:28:07 Wrapping Up and Final Thoughts
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/37847575
info_outline
Before Bogie and Bacall: The Battling Bogarts
08/08/2025
Before Bogie and Bacall: The Battling Bogarts
In this episode hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia delve into the tumultuous relationship of Hollywood legends Humphrey Bogart and Mayo Method. Known as the 'Battling Bogarts,' their marriage was marked by public brawls, violence, and Mayo's increasing paranoia and alcoholism. The episode covers Bogart's rise to fame, Method's early career, and their eventual split after Bogart falls in love with Lauren Bacall on the set of 'To Have and Have Not.' The hosts also explore themes of attachment styles, spousal abuse, and the concept of battered husband syndrome. The episode highlights how Bogart eventually found happiness with Bacall after years of personal turmoil and public scrutiny. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:37 Setting the Stage: The Battling Bogarts 05:20 Humphrey Bogart: Early Life and Career 24:47 Mayo Methot: Early Life and Career 34:03 Understanding Attachment Styles 42:20 Spousal Abuse vs. Battered Husband Syndrome 47:45 Emotional Coercion and Threats 48:39 Long-Distance Jealousy and Violence 49:17 Breaking Point and Self-Preservation 50:04 Shame and Silence Among Men 51:34 Psychological Impacts of Abuse 53:51 Reactionary Abuse Explained 55:09 Bogart and Meth's Tumultuous Relationship 01:00:59 Public Violence and Decline 01:10:52 Bogart's New Love: Lauren Bacall 01:18:03 The End of a Toxic Marriage 01:21:31 Mayo's Downfall and Bogart's Legacy 01:30:44 Conclusion and Next Episode Teaser
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/37562880
info_outline
Nobody Joins a Cult: NXIVM
07/25/2025
Nobody Joins a Cult: NXIVM
This episode delves into the notorious NXIVM cult, uncovering its malicious inner workings and the harrowing experiences of its members. Hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia shine a light on the guise of self-improvement sold to recruits, the manipulative strategies employed by leader Keith Raniere, and the distressing ordeals faced by those involved, including forced labor, branded rituals, and sexual abuse. The episode also exposes the roles played by high-profile members and the eventual legal downfall orchestrated by brave whistleblowers. Plus a bonus PSA "Are YOU in a cult?" 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:41 A Chaotic Recording Session 02:17 Introducing the Episode Topic 03:27 NXIVM: The Cult Unveiled 05:54 The Dark Side of NXIVM 09:09 The Cult's Recruitment Tactics 11:37 Inside the Inner Circle 13:03 The Society of Protectors and Other Groups 34:58 Daily Life in the Cult 36:52 The Core of the Cult: DOS 42:33 Volleyball and Inner Circle Dynamics 43:17 The Victim-Abuser Dichotomy 43:46 Psychological Manipulation and Control 49:39 The Horrors of DOS 57:02 The Downfall of NXIVM 59:08 Legal Consequences and Trials 01:12:40 Guilty Pleas and Convictions 01:18:33 The Aftermath and Cult Traits 01:23:15 NXIVM's Lingering Influence 01:27:13 Final Thoughts and PSA
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/37467525
info_outline
A Very Special Interview Episode: What Would Matt Palm Do?
07/18/2025
A Very Special Interview Episode: What Would Matt Palm Do?
In this episode, Jen, Ashley, and Olivia from the 'Wicked Stage' podcast interview Matt Palm, a notable writer and critic for the Orlando Sentinel. They discuss Matt's extensive focus on arts and culture, specifically his unique experiences covering the 'Basquiat art scandal' at the Orlando Museum of Art. Matt shares his journey, from his start as a theater and arts critic to handling the complexities of reporting on federal investigations. The conversation highlights the critical role of journalism, the challenges of balancing fair critique with community support, and the intricacies of covering a national-level art fraud case as a local journalist. The episode dives deep into the ethics of criticism, the evolution of Matt's career, and the dynamics of the Central Florida arts scene. 00:00 Introduction and Hosts 00:38 Special Guest: Matthew Palm 02:03 Matt Palm's Role and Responsibilities 04:31 Challenges of Being a Critic 09:28 Theme Park Performers and Local Arts 13:27 Social Media and Public Perception 21:21 The Orlando Museum of Art Scandal 49:04 Breaking News and Circus Chaos 51:48 Journalistic Integrity and Responsibility 56:10 Navigating Criticism and Reviews 01:01:40 The Art of Objectivity in Journalism 01:04:16 The Challenges of Live Theater 01:11:38 The Importance of Supporting Journalism 01:19:56 Matt Palm's Personal Artistic Journey 01:29:13 Final Thoughts and Reflections
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/37402960
info_outline
The Grift of De Groft
07/11/2025
The Grift of De Groft
This episode of the podcast dives into a controversial and gripping true crime story in the art world. Hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia discuss the case of 25 alleged Basquiat paintings displayed at the Orlando Museum of Art. The episode explores the dubious provenance of these paintings, their eventual seizure by the FBI, and the downfall of art museum director Aaron De Groft. Despite expert warnings and a shady backstory involving a defunct authentication committee, the museum presented the works as authentic. The story culminates in a massive scandal with the unmasking of the forger and De Groft’s subsequent legal battles, casting a spotlight on the murky underworld of art forgery. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:20 Meet the Hosts 00:55 Today's Topic: Art World and Forgeries 01:37 Introducing the Mona Lisa Peacock 03:01 Art Forgery vs. Artistic Reproduction 04:43 Basquiat: The Artist and His Legacy 05:04 The Grift of Degraf: A Local Scandal 06:06 Basquiat's Life and Artistic Style 11:01 The 27 Club and Basquiat's Untimely Death 22:04 The Orlando Museum of Art's New Director 26:03 The Controversial Basquiat Exhibit 44:19 Basquiat's Signature and Authentication Issues 46:33 The FBI's Slow Burn Investigation 47:14 Thad Mumford's Affidavit and the Orlando Museum of Art 49:17 Jordana Morris Saggy's Involvement 01:07:27 The Smoking Gun: FedEx Label 01:13:45 The Aftermath and Legal Battles 01:21:43 The Final Twist: Aaron Degraf's Death 01:29:31 Conclusion and Reflections
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/37273395
info_outline
Cursed Curtains: The Haunting of Macbeth
06/27/2025
Cursed Curtains: The Haunting of Macbeth
In this episode, hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia delve into the mysterious and spooky history of William Shakespeare's Macbeth, often referred to as 'The Scottish Play' due to its infamous curse. The program begins with a listener discretion warning due to descriptions of violence. The trio, dressed in eclectic outfits inspired by theater green rooms, discuss the history and superstitions surrounding the play, its historical context, and notable accidents and strange occurrences that have plagued its productions. They explore the potential origins of the curse, including King James I’s demonology and his obsession with witch hunts, touching on the connections to historical witch trials. Additionally, they cite numerous instances of accidents and tragedies linked to Macbeth performances and speculate whether the curse is rooted in superstition, psychological self-fulfillment, or deeper moral and cosmic disturbances. The episode wraps up with a detailed recount of the play's plot, adaptations, famous portrayals, and the rituals used to dispel the supposed curse. Words of caution for those who dare to mention 'Macbeth' in a theater, as the hosts highlight the lingering power of stories in the world of theater. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:49 Housekeeping and Outfits 03:29 The Scottish Play: Macbeth 07:38 The Curse of Macbeth 14:51 King James and Witchcraft 37:17 Synopsis of Macbeth 40:37 Famous Adaptations of Macbeth 45:45 Sleep No More: An Immersive Experience 50:13 Famous Actors Who Played Macbeth 51:06 Origins of the Macbeth Curse 52:08 Famous Instances of the Macbeth Curse 53:03 The Astor Place Riot 54:51 The Old Vic Production and Other Accidents 57:16 Modern Productions and the Curse 01:07:04 The Curse in Popular Culture 01:09:52 Debunking the Curse 01:23:50 Theater Superstitions and Traditions 01:25:32 Upcoming Episode Teaser: The Grift of Degraf
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/37080175
info_outline
Superman is Dead: The Suspicious Death of George Reeves
06/13/2025
Superman is Dead: The Suspicious Death of George Reeves
In this episode of 'Life Upon the Wicked Stage,' hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia delve into the suspicious death of George Reeves, the original Superman. The episode explores the night of Reeves' death, the controversial ruling of his demise as a suicide, and the complex web of relationships and events leading up to his passing. The hosts uncover shady findings, including suspicious accidents and potential motives related to Reeves' breakup with his long-term lover, Tony Manix, and his engagement to Leonora Lemon. The episode also highlights a deathbed confession by Tony Manix and various theories suggesting that Reeves' death was not a simple suicide but rather a murder orchestrated by those close to him. Join the discussion as the hosts navigate through conflicting reports, hidden motives, and the ultimate question: who killed George Reeves? 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:16 Meet the Hosts 00:37 A Touch of Humor 00:59 Memorial Day Weekend Vibes 01:28 The Mysterious Call 02:11 The Life of George Reeves 03:15 George's Early Life 09:33 Hollywood Struggles 19:23 Superman and Typecasting 32:53 A New Relationship 41:11 The Fateful Night 47:52 Bizarre Details of the Crime Scene 48:27 Suspicious Behavior and Delayed Police Call 49:10 Inconsistencies in the Suicide Theory 50:33 Leonora Lemon's Odd Statements 51:43 Shady Findings and Theories 55:52 Potential Motives and Suspects 01:10:28 The Mafia Connection 01:25:30 Deathbed Confession and Final Thoughts 01:35:07 Conclusion and Legacy of George Reeves
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/36916600
info_outline
Helen Mintiks: Murder at the Met
05/30/2025
Helen Mintiks: Murder at the Met
Hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia delve into the chilling true crime case of Helen Mintiks, a talented violinist who was murdered during a performance at the Metropolitan Opera House in 1980. Through a detailed narrative, the hosts explore the investigation led by detectives Mike Struck and Jerry Giorgio, uncovering the involvement of stagehand Craig Crimmins, who ultimately confessed to the crime. The episode provides an in-depth look at the evidence, interviews, and the complex dynamics behind the scenes at the iconic opera house, while raising questions about justice and the darker side of the arts world. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:36 Podcasting Challenges and Triumphs 04:17 Murder at the Met: Setting the Scene 12:00 The Investigation Begins 28:43 A Break in the Case 39:39 The Stagehand Connection 43:27 The Investigation Begins 44:00 Interviewing the Stage Crew 45:03 A Suspicious Stagehand 46:48 Craig Crimmins Under Scrutiny 50:13 The Confession 52:08 The Trial and Aftermath 01:12:13 The Verdict and Parole 01:20:30 Reflections and Closing Thoughts
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/36643750
info_outline
Olive Thomas: The Longest Run on Broadway
05/16/2025
Olive Thomas: The Longest Run on Broadway
In this episode, Jen leads the discussion on Olive Thomas, an American silent film actress, model, and Ziegfeld girl who is rumored to haunt the New Amsterdam Theater in New York (and they celebrate Olivia finally getting a professional microphone). The episode details Olive's rise to fame, tumultuous marriage to Jack Pickford, and her mysterious death at age 25 from mercury poisoning under unclear circumstances. Various theories, including accident, suicide, and murder, are explored. The hosts also discuss Olive's posthumous appearances as a ghost at the New Amsterdam Theater, believed to be one of the most active spirits on Broadway. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:36 Podcast Milestones and Updates 02:15 True Crime and Theater 03:42 Introducing Olive Thomas 06:35 The Life and Career of Olive Thomas 33:07 Olive's Personal Life and Marriage 41:23 A Troubled Relationship 43:39 The Final Days of Olive Thomas 48:25 Unreliable Eyewitness Accounts 49:12 The Honeymoon Timeline 50:06 The Tragic Incident 52:59 Speculations and Theories 01:01:50 The Aftermath and Autopsy 01:03:09 Theories Surrounding Olive's Death 01:16:54 Olive's Haunting at the New Amsterdam Theater 01:28:59 Conclusion and Next Episode Teaser
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/36344650
info_outline
John Wilkes Booth: American Brutus Pt. 2
05/02/2025
John Wilkes Booth: American Brutus Pt. 2
This episode dives into the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln by actor John Wilkes Booth. Hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia explore how Booth's Confederate sympathies led him to kill Lincoln, detailing his failed plan to also assassinate other government leaders. They highlight Booth’s methodical approach, his escape, and eventual capture, while juxtaposing this with Edwin Booth's life and career. Through an in-depth discussion, they reveal the intertwining of art, history, and crime, ultimately reflecting on Booth's perceived and historical legacy. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:36 Act Two: The Assassination Plot 01:21 John Wilkes Booth's Plan 06:13 The Assassination Night 19:38 Booth's Escape and Pursuit 38:27 The Aftermath and Legacy 42:07 Living in an Echo Chamber 43:30 The Turning Point: Lincoln's Decision 47:17 Booth's Final Days on the Run 53:28 The Capture and Death of John Wilkes Booth 01:02:41 The Aftermath and Legacy 01:21:35 Season Two Teasers and Wrap-Up
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/36226785
info_outline
John Wilkes Booth: Everybody Called Him Wilkеs Pt. 1
04/18/2025
John Wilkes Booth: Everybody Called Him Wilkеs Pt. 1
In the season two premiere of 'The Wicked Stage Pod,' hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia dive into the convoluted early life and career of infamous actor-turned-assassin, John Wilkes Booth. From his tumultuous family dynamics to his rise as a popular but controversial stage actor, Booth’s journey is explored in detail. The episode also examines his relationships, clandestine activities, and the events leading up to his fateful decision to assassinate President Abraham Lincoln. The hosts blend a mix of historical context and modern analysis, integrating references from Stephen Sondheim's musical 'Assassins' to provide a comprehensive and engaging narrative. This episode is the first of a two-part exploration into the life of one of history's most notorious figures. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:15 Meet the Hosts 00:42 Season Two Begins 01:01 Celebrity Candles and Banter 03:06 Introducing John Wilkes Booth 03:47 The Infamous Assassination 05:27 Booth's Early Life and Family 31:57 Booth's Controversial Beliefs 38:52 Booth's Acting Career 46:35 John Wilkes Booth: The Theatrical Innovator 49:31 Booth's Romantic Entanglements 50:54 The Scandalous Correspondences 01:00:17 Booth's Rise to Fame 01:07:11 Booth's Confederate Ties 01:11:49 The Kidnapping Plot 01:27:59 The Decision to Assassinate Lincoln 01:31:04 Intermission and Cliffhanger
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/35995910
info_outline
The Black Dahlia: The Mystery, the Mob...and Orson Wells? Part 2
02/14/2025
The Black Dahlia: The Mystery, the Mob...and Orson Wells? Part 2
In the gripping season finale of 'The Wicked Stage Pod,' hosts Jen, Ashley, and Olivia dive into the mystery of the infamous Black Dahlia murder, exploring various suspects from shady nightclub owners to notorious mobsters and even the famous director Orson Welles. The episode balances detailed investigation with light-hearted banter, leading to an intense discussion on the possible culprits behind the unsolved murder of Elizabeth Short. Despite their extensive research and speculation, the case remains open, offering an intriguing end to the podcast's first season. 00:00 Listener Discretion Advised 00:14 Meet the Hosts 00:52 Formal Floozy Attire 02:23 Work and Personal Life Intertwined 03:34 Confusing Voices 05:08 Black Dahlia Recap 05:35 Theories and Suspects 08:31 Red Manly: The Last Person to See Her Alive 16:43 Mark Hansen: The Club Owner 20:21 Jack Anderson Wilson: The Drifter 27:06 Leslie Dillon: The Bellhop 34:57 Orson Welles: The Filmmaker 39:51 George Knowlton: The Father 44:01 Behavioral Issues and Repressed Memories 44:45 Los Angeles Police and Janice's Claims 45:24 Patrick S. O'Reilly: A Suspect with a Dark Past 49:34 Walter Bailey: The Skilled Surgeon Theory 56:38 George Hodel: The Most Well-Known Theory 01:13:47 Bugsy Siegel and Norman Chandler: The Mob Connection 01:23:36 The Grand Jury and Unsolved Mysteries 01:30:35 Final Thoughts and Season Finale
/episode/index/show/58112fde-4489-4b19-bb87-82e14e1817a8/id/34701035