Cafeteria Christian

Cafeteria Christian started as a place for people who love Jesus but are so over the version of Christianity that forgets love, justice, and curiosity. Hosted by Pastor Natalia Terfa and Pastor Emmy Kegler, the show is a mix of faith conversations, cultural commentary, and the beautiful, complicated mess of trying to follow Jesus in the real world. From biblical deep dives to big feelings about the world, Emmy and Natalia create a space where honesty and hope coexist. Together, we're reclaiming the term “Cafeteria Christian” — because when it comes to faith, you really can take what you like and leave the rest.

#382 I feel non-binary God in this podcast tonight 11/09/2026

#381 Death and All His Friends 11/02/2026

#380 The Witch of Endor and Other Such Things 10/26/2026

#379 Faith, Politics, and How We Go From Here 10/19/2026

#378 “Do Better You Guys” - Jesus. 10/12/2026

#377 We Can’t Care About Everything (but we’re sure gonna try!) 10/05/2026

#376 You Don’t Need a Calling with Damon Garcia 09/28/2026

#375 Macklemore, Ms Rachel, and the Myth of Neutrality 09/21/2026

#374 Catching Up and Leaning Away from Despair 09/14/2026

#373 Body Narrative Repair - with Ellie Roscher 09/07/2026

#372 Damned if She Does, with Sarah Stankorb 08/31/2026

#371 Fair Game - part 2, with Ellie Roscher 08/24/2026

#370 If Make It Make Sense Were a Person - with Janice Lagata 08/17/2026

#369 Enneagram and Faith with Holly Johnson 08/10/2026

#368 It All Counts - with Natalia Terfa 06/29/2026

#367 A Grab Bag of Topics 06/22/2026

#366 iSn'T pRiDe A sIn 06/15/2026

#365 What Are Sacraments Anyway? 06/08/2026

#364 Rupture and Repair 06/01/2026

#363 The Church’s Weird Week 05/18/2026

#362 A God of War? With Dr Michael Chan 05/11/2026

#361 I Want to Have a Different Conversation About AI 05/04/2026

#360 Not All These Stories Are Fun 04/27/2026

#359 Are We… Catholic now? 04/20/2026

#358 That’s NOT God 04/13/2026

#357 Does Easter Pass the Vibe Check? With Laura Fanucci 03/30/2026

#356 You Can’t Pray Away the Anything 03/23/2026

#355 Jesus Never Said “Can’t We All Just Get Along” 03/16/2026

#354 Grab Bag and Bible Translations 03/09/2026

#353 In All Things… Nuance. 03/02/2026