Settle For Me: A Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Podcast by TV Winner

An episode-by-episode journey through the romance-comedy-musical CW series "Crazy Ex-Girlfriend" that aired 2015-2019. Hosted by your TV Winner Podcast hosts Hannah and Beth.

BONUS: "Yes, It's Really Us Singing" and "Rachel Bloom: Death, Let Me Do My Special" 01/06/2026

BONUS: "Yes, It's Really Us Singing" and "Rachel Bloom: Death, Let Me Do My Special" We officially wrap up our Crazy Ex-Girlfriend coverage with a casual discussion about the final final episode of season four, the concert special: "Yes, It's Really Us Singing." Then, we dig deep with Rachel Bloom's Netflix special from 2024, Death, Let Me Do My Special. We talk all about our love of the songs, cast, and then about pets, death, the pandemic, David Hull, Dear Evan Hansen, and how life does NOT make narrative sense! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/39630850

4.17: "I'm in Love" (Series Finale) 10/14/2025

4.17: "I'm in Love" (Series Finale) After four seasons of songs, romance, and personal growth, we're finally at the finale of Crazy Ex-Girlfriend. Is Rebecca in love and "truly happy" at last? We discuss the series finale and all the things we learn about the fate of our beloved characters, along with some behind-the-scenes stories and theories. Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/38573685

4.16: "I Have a Date Tonight" 09/23/2025

4.16: "I Have a Date Tonight" It's almost the end of the series (of holidays)! Rebecca gets her time as Bachelorette with three dates from her swooning suitors. Plus, White Josh gets a song! We talk all about the Guys and Dolls of it all, what "Team" we are on and why, and ponder whether this show is too good at crafting romance. Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/38318790

4.15: "I Need to Find My Frenemy" 09/03/2025

4.15: "I Need to Find My Frenemy" This week, the girl group goes to Vegas to rescue a frenemy and do some light gambling. We also watch the guys be down bad for Rebecca and reckon with the concept of columns. We're approaching the end of Crazy Ex-Girlfriend! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/38051040

4.14: "I'm Finding My Bliss" 08/19/2025

4.14: "I'm Finding My Bliss" Buckle up, this one is for the musical theater heads out there! As Rebecca reignites her love of the Theater, your Settle For Me co-hosts cover such topics as problematic musicals, the many subjects of musicals, casting jocks, character songs, excellent bad singing, and love languages Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah . /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/37857040

4.13: "I Have to Get Out" 07/29/2025

4.13: "I Have to Get Out" Paula is trying to get out of the hospital to take a test, Greg, Nathaniel & Josh are quarantined for ?? amount of time, Darryl meets a nice lady, and Rebecca faces mortality! There's a lot going on this week, along with our appreciation for the perfect La La Land dupe and plenty of our own thoughts about medication and the evolution of medicine over the course of human history! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/37570200

4.12: "I Need a Break" 07/08/2025

4.12: "I Need a Break" There are water slides AND backslides this week in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend! Listen to our discussion of the best faux Springsteen song, water/amusement park compatibility, high expectations, doing the oh-so-boring work of keeping yourself healthy, Tyler Darkness, and the stigma around mental health medication. Let's get into it all! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/37328965

4.11: "I'm Almost Over You" 06/24/2025

4.11: "I'm Almost Over You" We take a detour in Rom-Com Land and Nathaniel's Mind as Crazy Ex-Girlfriend takes an episode to revel in the best/worst rom-com tropes we all know and love. Listen to our chat about this unique episode and the many romantic comedies and tropes we can't think too hard about. Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/37115350

4.10: "I Can Work With You" 06/03/2025

4.10: "I Can Work With You" Crazy Ex-Girlfriend spends a Saturday night playing games and sitting with babies. We've got sports analogies (and a surprising amount of sports talk from your hosts), the importance of communication, and some swooning over, men, babies, and men with babies. Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/36826680

4.09: "I Need Some Balance" 05/20/2025

4.09: "I Need Some Balance" We're halfway through the final season, and it's time for Cats! Rebecca has lots of opinions on Cats. We have fun discussing musical theater, the delicate balance Rebecca screws up, and the brief straight male friendship of Nathaniel and Greg. Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/36634340

4.08: "I'm Not the Person I Used to Be" 05/06/2025

4.08: "I'm Not the Person I Used to Be" It's the Return of Greg... right? We have a lot to talk about in this episode about people changing, revisiting old loves, high school cliques, the series of holidays, and a whole lot more! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/36448995

4.07: "I Will Help You" 04/23/2025

4.07: "I Will Help You" We go back to Scarsdale for Rebecca to try being honest with her mother. Will it work?! We discuss Rebecca "final boss-ing" through the season, the growth of Valencia, Josh's redemption journey, and the new, weird "do-gooder" version of Nathaniel. We've also got a lot of thoughts on the many mistakes Josh makes as a houseguest/person. Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/36257125

4.06: "I See You" 04/08/2025

4.06: "I See You" Things get wacky this week on Crazy Ex-Girlfriend when three unlikely pairs end up on the road together. We discuss Nathaniel's attitude, Darryl's extra-ness, and Paula's procrastination, and naturally, our discussion of the Beach Boys turns to Charles Manson. Another typical day in West Covina! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/36045260

4.05: "I'm So Happy for You" 03/25/2025

4.05: "I'm So Happy for You" This week we feel feelings as some characters say goodbye and others regress to old habits. We discuss mothers and sons, life milestones, feeling competitive with others, and "shipping" real and/or fictional people. We also discuss the season two finale of Severance at the top! [Skip the first 30 minutes to be clear of Severance talk] Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/35837355

4.04: "I'm Making Up for Lost Time" 03/11/2025

4.04: "I'm Making Up for Lost Time" This week we revert to adolescence with Rebecca and her half-brother Tucker! Turns out they have some fundamental similarities, but only one of them can sing outside of their imaginations. We talk about child stars, Nathaniel & Rebecca, escape rooms, and more in our latest episode! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/35589285

4.03: "I'm On My Own Path" 02/18/2025

4.03: "I'm On My Own Path" Everyone is starting to go down their own paths this week as Rebecca reconsiders the law, Heather and Hector navigate insurance and ~love~, and Josh takes to therapy surprisingly well! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/35319170

4.02: "I Am Ashamed" 01/28/2025

4.02: "I Am Ashamed" This week we get our first Halloween episode on Crazy Ex-Girlfriend! We talk all about ghosts, novelty holiday songs, and Rebecca contending with every person in West Covina knowing her history. This week, we are women of science and séance! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/35020970

4.01: "I Want to Be Here" (Season Four Premiere) 01/14/2025

4.01: "I Want to Be Here" (Season Four Premiere) We're back for the final season! Rebecca is in jail?! Nathaniel is in the woods?? Josh is taking online quizzes?! Join us as we travel back to West Covina for the start of this great season of Crazy Ex-Girlfriend! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/34845555

3.13: "Nathaniel Is Irrelevant." (Season Three Finale) 12/03/2024

3.13: "Nathaniel Is Irrelevant." (Season Three Finale) It's the season three finale! We've come so far, and you can never guess how this season ends. Join our extensive discussion as we talk about "The Miracle of Birth," Rebecca's guilt, "Nothing Is Ever Anyone's Fault," and the bedrock of the show, Paula and Rebecca's friendship. Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/34246405

3.12: "Trent?!" 11/19/2024

3.12: "Trent?!" Always when you least expect it... Trent returns! Where has he been since last season? We learn all that and more in this whirlwind of an episode that also features a choreographed dance by Josh and Valencia. Let's get into it! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on Blusky at and Find us on Instagram at and You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/33973472

3.11: "Nathaniel and I Are Just Friends!" 11/04/2024

3.11: "Nathaniel and I Are Just Friends!" We're nearing the end of season three, and a LOT is happening! We discuss all the big reveals of this episode, as well as the complicated and disappointing actions of Rebecca and, especially, Nathaniel. We also take detours regarding insurance, affairs, pregnancy limitations, and movie-musical adaptations! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on socials at @nobriggity and @yourbeth_friend You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/33776632

3.10: "Oh, Nathaniel, It's On!" 10/15/2024

3.10: "Oh, Nathaniel, It's On!" Rebecca and Heather share the spotlight this week, with plots that feature sweating, career opportunities, moving in with someone, and impulsive and (potentially bad!) choices! A lot is going on in West Covina and we can't wait to get into it! Join our discussion of Crazy Ex-Girlfriend today. Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on socials at @nobriggity and @yourbeth_friend You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/33457802

3.09: "Nathaniel Gets the Message!" 10/01/2024

3.09: "Nathaniel Gets the Message!" Rebecca tries to save the world without love, Nathaniel and White Josh launch a bromance, and we learn what Josh's new job is - all in this week's Crazy Ex-Girlfriend! Join us as we talk about allll kinds of things West Covina-related and not. Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on socials at @nobriggity and @yourbeth_friend You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/33273872

3.08: "Nathaniel Needs My Help!" 09/17/2024

3.08: "Nathaniel Needs My Help!" Crazy Ex-Girlfriend is heading into the final stretch of season 3! Join us as we discuss characters repeating patterns, Nathaniel and Rebecca's relationship growth, Paula's meddling, Darryl's "boys," and Josh's karaoke! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on socials at @nobriggity and @yourbeth_friend You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/33083562

3.07: "Getting Over Jeff." 09/03/2024

3.07: "Getting Over Jeff." Rebecca takes a break and texts Nathaniel this week, while Paula journeys into the past. Join us as we discuss the halfway point of Crazy Ex-Girlfriend season three! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on socials at @nobriggity and @yourbeth_friend You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/32717562

3.06: "Josh Is Irrelevant." 08/07/2024

3.06: "Josh Is Irrelevant." Crazy Ex-Girlfriend starts down a new path today with a life-changing moment for Rebecca. She gets a new diagnosis! And it turns out to be pretty spot on. Join us as we discuss this pivotal episode, mental health stigma, poop jokes, and Nathaniel's surprising story. Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on socials at @nobriggity and @yourbeth_friend You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/32466797

3.05: "I Never Want to See Josh Again." 07/23/2024

3.05: "I Never Want to See Josh Again." Join us as we navigate the turning point of Crazy Ex-Girlfriend. We jump back and forth between the Mama Drama in Scarsdale and the Office Antics in West Covina until we reach the cliffhanger conclusion. There's a lot to talk about, including two surprisingly peppy songs. Also please note this episode contains plot points and conversations related to suicide and depression, feel free to skip and join us next week if you feel more comfortable! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on socials at @nobriggity and @yourbeth_friend You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/32253087

3.04: "Josh's Ex-Girlfriend Is Crazy." 07/09/2024

3.04: "Josh's Ex-Girlfriend Is Crazy." This episode starts off with a maybe-intervention gone wrong, and it all goes downhill from there. Join us as we talk about this whirlwind episode, AKA "Swimchan," as well as the dynamics of these characters, harsh truths, new ships, the erotic thriller genre and its women, and Rebecca's rock bottom. *Check out our website link below for extra notes on things to check out related to "Swimchan!"* Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on socials at @nobriggity and @yourbeth_friend You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/32057602

3.03: "Josh Is a Liar." 06/25/2024

3.03: "Josh Is a Liar." Rebecca told Josh everything - will he spill the beans and reveal to everyone her true self? While Rebecca spirals out, Nathaniel is living in his own rom-com plot. We discuss Rebecca's self-destruction, Heather's graduation, Paula's friendship, Nathaniel's zoo trip, and more in this week's new episode! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on socials at @nobriggity and @yourbeth_friend You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/31875077

3.02: "To Josh, With Love." 06/04/2024

3.02: "To Josh, With Love." Rebecca still wants revenge, so naturally, she turns to the most "evil" person she knows: Nathaniel! Do they ruin Josh's life? Will Josh ever confront Rebecca? And will Tim finally learn what the buzzing in the bathroom is? All this and more in this week's Crazy Ex-Girlfriend! Until next time... Follow the podcast on and Find your hosts on socials at @nobriggity and @yourbeth_friend You can email us about all things TV at Visit our for show notes and info on all past episodes Please rate and review us on and Theme Music: Feather Duster by Shane Ivers - Cover Art by Hannah /episode/index/show/tvwinnerpod/id/31586867

Settle For Me: A Crazy Ex-Girlfriend Podcast by TV Winner

TOPICS