The Three Pauls Ride Into Prescott ... And let the storytelling begin

A lively Western history roundtable at Sharlot Hall Museum—where scholarship meets story, and legends get their labels checked

If you’ve ever wished you could pull up a chair while three top-tier Western historians swap stories, compare notes, and argue (politely) about what really matters in telling America’s story—Arizona Roundup host Stuart Rosebrook made it happen.

Recorded at Sharlot Hall Museum in Prescott, Arizona, this 1 hour and 27 minute episode is billed simply as “AZR – The 3 Pauls!”—and it delivers exactly what the title promises: a rare, warm, and surprisingly funny conversation with Paul Hedren, Paul Andrew Hutton, and Paul Fees.

They arrive from “near and far” (Prescott, Cody, Omaha), but the real destination isn’t just Arizona—it’s that place all good history takes you: the moment you suddenly understand the past as human, complicated, and still alive.


A roundtable built on friendship—and a big year in Western books

Stuart Rosebrook sets the stage with a premise any history-lover can appreciate: it’s been a banner year for Western publishing, and two major new titles are at the center of the conversation.

Paul Hedren brings Sitting Bull’s War (Pegasus Books), a work that insists the Little Bighorn story can’t be told honestly without hearing Native voices and seeing Native motives as more than footnotes.

Paul Andrew Hutton brings The Undiscovered Country: Triumph, Tragedy, and the Shaping of the American West (Dutton), an ambitious, big-arc American story told through seven lives—frontier icons and Native leaders—moving from early frontier conflict to the closing of the 19th century.

But the episode isn’t a sales pitch disguised as scholarship. It’s closer to a well-fed dinner table conversation where everyone knows the stories, the places, and the personalities—and still laughs at the odd turns that made their careers.

Walk where history happened

A theme keeps resurfacing: history isn’t just dates and arguments—it’s place.

Hedren explains how landscape isn’t scenery—it’s evidence. Hutton echoes it with a lifetime of pilgrimages to places like Cody and Little Bighorn. Fees adds the museum professional’s angle: sometimes the object and the story matter more to a child than any label—especially if the label is wrong.

The now-famous “Davy Crockett’s bloody vest” story lands as both humor and lesson: myth, memory, and meaning all collide, reminding us why museums and historians exist—not to kill wonder, but to mature it.

Why these books matter now

The conversation insists that Western history is not a side genre—it is American history.

Hutton frames the West as central to American identity, shaped by discovery, reinvention, and tragic collision. Hedren complements that arc by restoring Native perspective, voice, and consequence to stories long told from the top down.

Read together, these books help readers see the West as achievement and cost, myth and reality, memory and meaning.

The 250th anniversary invitation

With America’s 250th anniversary approaching in 2026, this episode becomes an invitation: celebrate by going somewhere meaningful, asking better questions, and standing where history happened.

Travel the two-lane roads. Let surprise happen. Listen carefully when someone points to a name on a monument and says, “That was my ancestor.”

Things to remember

The West shaped American identity.
Great history must be readable to matter.
Landscapes tell stories if we learn how to read them.

Things to share

The Davy Crockett vest story.
The idea that complexity honors history.
The joy of traveling like a historian.

Things to act on

Read Sitting Bull’s War and The Undiscovered Country.
Plan one history-centered trip in 2026.
Visit a museum and ask what story is missing.

Closing thanks

Arizona Roundup created a rare kind of episode: scholarly yet accessible, serious yet warm, and thoughtful without losing its grin.

Thanks to host Stuart Rosebrook, to Paul Hedren, Paul Andrew Hutton, and Paul Fees, and to Marv Kaiser for bringing this memorable roundtable together.

Happy New Year—and here’s to a 2026 that doesn’t just celebrate history, but learns from it.