loader from loading.io

The Fallacy of the Valedictorian

The In-House Ethicist

Release Date: 08/14/2025

The Fallacy of the Valedictorian show art The Fallacy of the Valedictorian

The In-House Ethicist

Being at the head of the class has many benefits, but we all know that academic success isn't a one way ticket to the C-Suite. What the classroom rewards and what professional success requires are not one and the same thing – a lesson that some Valedictorians among us seem to learn the hard way. In this episode of the In-House Ethicist, John Paul Rollert reflects on what Valedictorian-types should think about as they transition to the real world if they hope to achieve the same elite level of success in their professional lives as they did on standardized tests. 

info_outline
The Many Faces of Capitalism show art The Many Faces of Capitalism

The In-House Ethicist

When people think about capitalism, they don’t think of abstract ideas at the heart of an economic system. They think about the things that system produces: the products, the companies, and perhaps most notably, the people. Just as capitalism has changed with technology and culture over time, so have the people most associated with it, from Benjamin Franklin to the suspendered stockbrokers of the 1980s to the tech titans of today.  In this episode of The In-House Ethicist, John Paul Rollert asks the question who will be the next face of capitalism?

info_outline
Customers Gone Wild show art Customers Gone Wild

The In-House Ethicist

Is the customer always right? In a world in which all sales are final, some buyers are bound to get duped. But if the customer’s always right, what can retailers do about unreasonable customers? In this episode of The In-House Ethicist, John Paul Rollert looks for a balance between honoring customers and indulging them.

info_outline
You think you're frugal but maybe you're just cheap show art You think you're frugal but maybe you're just cheap

The In-House Ethicist

Why is being frugal a virtue? And where exactly do we draw the line between being “frugal” and being “cheap”? In this episode of The In-House Ethicist, John Paul Rollert traces the history of frugality from the 18th century to today, explaining why it continues to be relevant as a moral yardstick.

info_outline
must you loose your morals on wall st? show art must you loose your morals on wall st?

The In-House Ethicist

Michael Lewis’s Liar’s Poker is a frank and ugly behind-the-scenes account of life as a young associate in the world of Wall St finance. The book is 35 years old, but the basic dilemma at its heart – whether follow your conscience or your bank balance—remains pertinent. In this episode of The In-House Ethicist, John Paul Rollert reflects on what the book tells us about ourselves and our professional choices. How long can you stay in a poisonous environment before you become part of it?

info_outline
American Psycho Revisited show art American Psycho Revisited

The In-House Ethicist

Stakeholder capitalism is the idea that business should be about more than just making money. That seems a world away from the brash financial types of Bret Easton Ellis’s 1991 novel ‘American Psycho,’ or the 1987 movie ‘Wall Street.’ But in this episode of the The In-House Ethicist, Chicago Booth’s John Paul Rollert asks how much we have really moved on, and reflects on the continuing relevance of Easton Ellis’s novel.

info_outline
Handouts? Hold On! show art Handouts? Hold On!

The In-House Ethicist

Some people say that you don’t help the poor by giving them money, but by giving them opportunities to earn money. This is behind the periodic campaigns to limit welfare benefits in order to encourage work. But is a handout necessarily different from a hand-up? In this episode of The In-House Ethicist, John Paul Rollert reflects on how we think about helping the poor and charitable giving.

info_outline
The kids are alright show art The kids are alright

The In-House Ethicist

What is within the power of free markets? What can capitalism do for society, what can’t it do, and what should it do? On this episode of the The In-House Ethicist, Booth’s John Paul Rollert explores how many people came to have an unshakeable faith in capitalism’s broad ability to solve nearly any problem, while the experience of others has left them skeptical. In the era after “the end of history,” capitalism’s defenders need to reckon earnestly with a series of questions about what the system may leave unresolved, he says.

info_outline
Hey Jeff Bezos. How About You give a 100 Billion to the Humanities show art Hey Jeff Bezos. How About You give a 100 Billion to the Humanities

The In-House Ethicist

What should the uber wealthy do with their money? How can they leave a lasting legacy? And what responsibilities do they have to society at large? On this episode of the The In-House Ethicist, Booth’s John Paul Rollert reflects on the role of those at the very top of the 1 percent.

info_outline
Is Being a Selfish Jerk Really in Your Self Interest? show art Is Being a Selfish Jerk Really in Your Self Interest?

The In-House Ethicist

Individuals acting in their own self-interest are, according to classical economics, an important part of a productive, efficient economy. And yet, selfishness is among the personality traits best known for impeding healthy human relationships. How do we separate the two concepts? On this episode of The In-House Ethicist, explores how we define the line between them, and why that line matters.

info_outline
 
More Episodes

Being at the head of the class has many benefits, but we all know that academic success isn't a one way ticket to the C-Suite. What the classroom rewards and what professional success requires are not one and the same thing – a lesson that some Valedictorians among us seem to learn the hard way. In this episode of the In-House Ethicist, John Paul Rollert reflects on what Valedictorian-types should think about as they transition to the real world if they hope to achieve the same elite level of success in their professional lives as they did on standardized tests.