Ep 139: Part 4- “Aurora Officers Speak!” - A Dark Night in Aurora Part 4
Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
Release Date: 10/07/2025
Ep 163: Shadows in Fire by Judith A. Yates
Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
Judith A. Yates, an award-winning author and criminologist, brings a unique perspective to true crime with her latest project, her book, Shadows in Fire. For the past seven years, she has been in communication with Shirley Winters, a little-known serial killer and serial arsonist. As one of the rare female serial killers, Shirley has never shared her story outside of law enforcement—until now. Discussing Judith's forthcoming book, Shadows in Fire, she and Jill discuss the chilling details of Shirley Winters' crimes, her troubled childhood, mental health challenges, motivations, and her...
info_outline
Ep 162 "Perennial Bloom"- Pt 3 While She Slept by Marion Collins, 2ndCast
Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
Part 3: As Jill Cahill teeters at death’s door, her family is engulfed in grief, reeling from the sudden tragedy that has shattered their world and deeply affected her children. Investigators are diligently unraveling the intricate details of the murder plot, all while a pivotal trial looms on the horizon. Her parents braced themselves for a fierce custody battle, determined to secure their grandchildren, while they fervently prayed for justice. When the verdict finally arrives, its shockwaves resonate throughout New York State, triggering significant judicial changes that are still...
info_outline
EP 161: “Bitter Almonds” While She Slept by Marion Collins Pt 2
Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
Part 2: Nearly beaten to death, Jill fights for her life as she endures a grueling cycle of comas, surgeries, and infections, fluctuating between hope and despair. A fierce custody battle erupts over her children, coinciding with the investigation into the brutal assault. Meanwhile, Jeff Cahill finds his life shattered, unaware that his choices will lead him down a more devastating path, leaving a wider trail of destruction that no one could anticipate, forever altering the laws of the State of New York. (Be sure to listen to Part 1, Ep 159 before this episode! Context is crucial!) BUY...
info_outline
Special Ep 160: The Tylenol Murders: A Father's Confession to His Son by Joseph Cibelli
Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
In 1982, a wave of terror swept across the Chicago area and the rest of the United States as seven people suddenly died; the manner of death was homicide; the cause: POISON! Tampering, someone had spiked Tylenol capsules with cyanide and American changed overnight. This shocking crime left the public in fear; anyone could have been targeted! For 44 years, an extensive investigation aimed to uncover the truth, but the case grew cold, leading many to believe that the cunning killer had escaped justice. Now, however, there is a startling revelation. Forensic psychologist Joseph Cibelli has...
info_outline
Ep 159: Pt 1: "The Ne’er’do-well" - While She Slept by Marion Collins
Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
Part I: A boy meets a girl, and love ignites. They marry, craft a life together, and welcome their son and daughter, a perfect family. But as time unfolds, pressures rise, people evolve, and dreams unravel. While divorces are part of many people's stories, Jeff and Jill Cahill's tale is far from ordinary. It's a nightmare that shocks and devastates at every turn. When their lives take a dark twist, disastrous choices have ripple effects that devastate those around them. Families are shattered, hearts are left in ruins, and overwhelming confusion leaves us questioning: “How can anyone treat...
info_outline
Special Ep 158: True Crime and Consequences by David Lyons
Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
It's time to start a conversation! The amazing David Lyons, a retired homicide detective and co-host of The Murder Police podcast, is Jill’s guest. These podcast hosts have an important discussion about David's new book, True Crime and Consequence. In it, David Lyons examines the increasing influence of the true crime community on real-life investigations. This timely work raises important questions about how podcasts, social media, and amateur sleuthing impact investigations, for better or worse. How can everyday citizens ethically, legally, and compassionately contribute to solving cases?...
info_outline
Ep 157 Pt 3- 2nd Cast 'Laws of Sanity' on INCENDIARY by Michael Cannell
Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
Spoiler Alert! Be sure to listen to Parts 1 and 2, Ep 152 and 154, before listening to this conclusion! Part 3: In this gripping conclusion, after a lengthy 16-year manhunt, the Mad Bomber, George Metesky, is finally apprehended in Waterbury, Connecticut, long after he unleashed a wave of terror across New York City with his dangerous bombings. The palpable relief among NYPD Captain Kinney and the Bomb Squad echoes through the halls of ‘The Tombs,’ a notoriously grim jail in Lower Manhattan, where Metesky is held. In the courtroom, a fierce contest unfolds between the...
info_outline
Special Ep 156: The LISK Update by Joe Giacalone, Lost Girls Pt 6
Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
Part 6- Lost Girls by Robert Kolker. Retired NYPD Sergeant Joe Giacalone, known from Crimecon, the Hamptons Whodunit, and "True Crime with the Sarge," joins Jill to discuss the latest intriguing developments in the Long Island Serial Killer case. What formidable challenges does Rex Heuermann's defense team face in light of the evidence that has emerged? What complexities confront Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney as he personally spearheads the prosecution, especially given the troubling history of missteps and corruption associated with this case? The recent revelation...
info_outline
Special Ep 155: Leslie Rule Talks, A Tangled Web Revelation!
Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
PART 4: Best-selling author Leslie Rule joins Jill for an engaging discussion about the unforgettable case she explores in her gripping book, A Tangled Web. Leslie offers her keen insights into the mind of the perpetrator, delving into her motivations and sharing a groundbreaking new development that sheds light on many of our lingering questions. Plus, she’s excited to unveil her next project, which is bound to excite true crime enthusiasts! Spoiler Alert: To fully enjoy this episode, be sure to listen to Jill’s A Tangled Web trilogy—Episodes 137, 138, and 141—first! PLANNING...
info_outline
Ep 154 Pt 2 “Oedipus Rising” -INCENDIARY: The Psychiatrist, the Mad Bomber & the Invention of Criminal Profiling by Michael Cannell
Murder Shelf Book Club Podcast
PART 2: 1956- New York City is in a state of fear as powerful bombs are discovered hidden in public spaces like libraries, movie theaters, and subway stations. Sixteen years have passed, yet the elusive Mad Bomber continues to evade capture, leaving citizens in constant dread. To draw the bomber out, the NYPD shares case details with the press, sparking a tense cat-and-mouse game. This triggers numerous bomb threats that blur the line between pranks and real danger, while genuine explosives are found, threatening death and devastation, with the NY bomb squad exhausted. With each...
info_outlinePart 4: (Yes, there is a Part 3!) In this exclusive interview, Jill engages in a candid conversation with retired Commander Jad Lanigan and Aurora SWAT Commander Mike Dailey, whom she met at Crimecon Denver. Both Jad and Mike were pivotal figures during the tragic Aurora Theater Shooting, sharing an intimate look into the chaos and immense pressure faced by first responders. Their experiences highlight the profound psychological toll that the incident took on the department. Since 2012, mass shootings have regrettably become alarmingly routine, with nearly one reported daily by 2025. In an increasingly demanding climate, law enforcement is called upon to perform extraordinary feats while being held to an often unrealistic standard of perfection. What changes have emerged in response to this crisis? What steps can you take to ensure your safety?
(Warning: This episode contains distressing audio clips from the events surrounding the shooting that may be disturbing to some.)
Going to Crimecon 2026 Las Vegas? Use Jill’s code murdershelf and save 10% on your badge!
Buy A Dark Night in Aurora: Inside James Holmes and the Colorado Mass Shooting by Dr William H. Reid, MD
Buy AURORA: The Psychiatrist who treated the Movie Theater Killer Tells Her Story by Dr Lynne Fenton and Kerrie Droban.
Contact: jill@murdershelfbookclub.com, or X, Facebook, Instagram or YouTube.
Join Jill on PATREON for $4 and help pick our next book!
The holidays are coming! Get your Murder Shelf Book Club merch!