Best Practices for Drafting Reasoned Arbitration Awards: A Conversation with John Burritt McArthur
Release Date: 06/09/2025
Breaking Barriers: Diversity on Arbitration Panels
CCA Arbitration Talk
In this special on-the-road episode of CCA Arbitration Talk, recorded at the American Arbitration Association Neutrals Conference in Dallas, Texas, host Rich Silberberg explores a timely and vital topic: diversity on arbitration panels. Joining him are two distinguished guests: Hon. Shira Scheindlin, former U.S. District Judge and now full-time arbitrator and mediator L. Tyrone Holt, nationally recognized arbitrator, CCA Past President and leader of CCA Associates Mentorship Program Together, they tackle pressing questions, including: What does “diversity” mean in the context of...
info_outline
Best Practices for Drafting Reasoned Arbitration Awards: A Conversation with John Burritt McArthur
CCA Arbitration Talk
In this episode of CCA Arbitration Talk, recorded live at the American Arbitration Association’s Biannual Neutrals Conference in Dallas, host Rich Silberberg is joined by CCA Fellow John Burritt (“Mac”) McArthur — experienced commercial arbitrator and author of The Reasoned Arbitration Award in the United States: Its Purposes, Preparation, Problems, and Preservation (Juris, 2022). Mr. McArthur shares insights from his extensive career as both advocate and arbitrator, discussing the evolving expectations surrounding reasoned awards and offering practical guidance on drafting awards that...
info_outline
Summit II: A Centennial Celebration of the FAA
CCA Arbitration Talk
In this episode of CCA Arbitration Talk, we look ahead to a pivotal moment in the evolution of commercial arbitration: Summit II, hosted by the College of Commercial Arbitrators (CCA) on June 5, 2025, in Washington, D.C. The event marks the 100th anniversary of the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) and brings together key stakeholders in the arbitration community to reflect, reimagine, and update commercial arbitration protocols for the next century. CCA Arbitration Talk host Rich Silberberg is joined by two prominent voices in the field: Dana Welch, President of the CCA with over two decades of...
info_outline
The Paris Olympics Controversy: A Battle for Bronze & the Role of CAS
CCA Arbitration Talk
What happens when an award of an Olympic medal decision is overturned? In this gripping episode of Arbitration Talk, CAS arbitrators Jim Carter and Kristen Thorsness join host Rich Silberberg to unpack the most highly disputed medal award of the Paris 2024 Olympics. A protest over scoring in the women’s gymnastics floor exercise event final led to a shocking series of reversals, leaving three athletes in limbo and setting the stage for a controversial ruling by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS) followed by a now-pending appeal to the Swiss Supreme Court. Tune in as we break down the...
info_outline
CAS, Doping Scandals & Shocking Cases!
CCA Arbitration Talk
Are you familiar with the use of tainted burrito and kissing defenses to potentially disqualifying doping charges? Or the shattering of an Olympic athlete’s dreams by a paperwork error? In this episode, CAS arbitrators Jim Carter and Kristen Thorsness and dive deep into real cases they have heard, decided, and followed over the years—some that made headlines, and others that were no less heart breaking that remained in the shadows. Whether arising on site at thethe Olympic Games or during the off-season , we uncover the high-stakes world of dispute resolution in the international...
info_outline
Demystifying the Court of Arbitration for Sport
CCA Arbitration Talk
Welcome to CCA Arbitration Talk – the podcast of the College of Commercial Arbitrators (CCA), the pre-eminent professional organization in the field of commercial arbitration. This podcast series explores the world of commercial arbitration, including its advantages, challenges, and impact upon today's legal landscape. What happens when a high-stakes dispute arises in international athletic events? Enter the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS)—the ultimate decision-maker in global athletics. In this inaugural episode of Arbitration Talk, host Rich Silberberg sits down with...
info_outlineIn this episode of CCA Arbitration Talk, recorded live at the American Arbitration Association’s Biannual Neutrals Conference in Dallas, host Rich Silberberg is joined by CCA Fellow John Burritt (“Mac”) McArthur — experienced commercial arbitrator and author of The Reasoned Arbitration Award in the United States: Its Purposes, Preparation, Problems, and Preservation (Juris, 2022).
Mr. McArthur shares insights from his extensive career as both advocate and arbitrator, discussing the evolving expectations surrounding reasoned awards and offering practical guidance on drafting awards that meet the needs of the parties while standing up to judicial scrutiny. Topics include:
- The historical development and significance of reasoned awards;
- Judicial standards of review of reasoned awards;
- Common pitfalls in drafting reasoned awards and how to avoid them;
- Best practices for creating clear, persuasive, and enforceable reasoned awards.
This conversation provides valuable strategies for arbitrators and advocates seeking to strengthen the legitimacy and durability of arbitration awards.
For more information about John Burritt McArthur’s work, or to purchase The Reasoned Arbitration Award in the United States at a discount, please click https://arbitrationlaw.com/books/reasoned-arbitration-award-united-states-its-promise-problems-preparation-and-preservation and enter “CCA” for a special 20% discount being extended exclusively to our listeners.
Subscribe to CCA Arbitration Talk to hear future conversations with leading voices in commercial arbitration.