Mastering Mental Health Evaluations: Insider Tips for Attorneys with Criminal Defense Lawyer Marcia G. Shein
Mental Disabilities and the Criminal Justice System
Release Date: 05/28/2024
Youthful Offenders and Mental Health: Insights from Judge Jay Blitzman
Mental Disabilities and the Criminal Justice System
In this episode, Elizabeth Kelley talks with her guest, Judge Jay Blitzman. The two discuss the intersection of youthful offenders and mental health issues in the criminal justice system, the shift away from using the term "juvenile", and the ongoing challenges in achieving due process for youthful offenders. In this episode, they discuss: The relevance of including a chapter on youthful offenders in a book about representing people with mental disabilities, and why understanding brain development is crucial for criminal defense lawyers. The shift away from using the term...
info_outline
Substance Use Disorder: Legal Implications and Treatment Options
Mental Disabilities and the Criminal Justice System
In this episode, Elizabeth Kelley talks with her guest, Dr. Carol Weiss. The two discuss the terminology of substance use disorders, the co-occurrence with mental health issues, and the effects on decision-making within the criminal justice system. In this episode, they discuss: The distinction between substance use disorder and substance abuse disorder, and the implications of stigmatizing terms. The high co-occurrence rate of substance use disorder with other mental health disorders, and theories explaining this correlation. Effective treatment modalities for substance use...
info_outline
Post-Conviction Remedy in Criminal Cases
Mental Disabilities and the Criminal Justice System
In this episode, Elizabeth Kelley talks with her guest, Zach Segal. The two discuss post-conviction remedies, specifically 2254 and 2255 motions and motions for Compassionate Release, as well as the challenges people with mental disabilities face in filing these motions. In this episode, they discuss: What is a post-conviction remedy When a 2254 or 2255 motion might be filed What challenges people with mental disabilities face in filing these motions In what circumstances a 2254 or 2255 provides relief for ineffective assistance of counsel claims How the Supreme Court’s...
info_outline
Neuroimaging in Criminal Cases
Mental Disabilities and the Criminal Justice System
This week Elizabeth Kelley talks with her guest, Stephen Cobb. The two discuss the relevance and power of neuroimaging in the courtroom, as well as what the process entails and produces. In this episode, they discuss: What is neuroimaging and why criminal defense lawyers should pursue it An explanation of SPECT and FMRI Intriguing examples showing the significance and power of neuroimaging from Mr. Cobb's experiences How Mr. Cobb became interested in brain imaging An overview of the neuroimaging process and the outcomes it generates Stephen G. Cobb, BCS is a highly...
info_outline
Working with the Forensic Mental Health Expert
Mental Disabilities and the Criminal Justice System
This week, Elizabeth Kelley talks with her guest, Dr. Elliot Atkins. Dr. Atkins is the author of the chapter entitled “Working with the Expert: From the Perspective of Experts” in the upcoming 2nd edition of Elizabeth’s book, Representing People with Mental Disabilities published by the American Bar Association. In this episode, Dr. Atkins and Elizabeth discuss: How can attorneys most effectively use mental health experts How a forensic mental health expert can properly communicate and create the best scenario for attorney-client relations What Dr. Atkins...
info_outline
Mastering Mental Health Evaluations: Insider Tips for Attorneys with Criminal Defense Lawyer Marcia G. Shein
Mental Disabilities and the Criminal Justice System
In this episode, Elizabeth Kelley interviews Criminal Defense Lawyer Marcia G. Shein. The two discuss essential components of good mental health evaluations, how an attorney can be particularly sensitive to red flags, and practical aspects for newer attorneys in cases such as these. Attorney Shein is the author of the chapter entitled “Mitigation” in the upcoming 2nd edition of Elizabeth’s book, Representing People with Mental Disabilities published by the American Bar Association. In this episode: What red flags Attorney Shein looks for to see if a forensic evaluation is...
info_outline
Criminal Responsibility: Mental Health Defenses and Forensic Evaluations with Professor Lucy Guarnera
Mental Disabilities and the Criminal Justice System
This week Elizabeth Kelley talks with her guest, Professor Lucy Guarnera. The two discuss when a criminal defense lawyer should consider criminal responsibility as a defense, resources for finding mental health experts, and critical components of a thorough forensic evaluation. In this episode, we discuss: When a criminal defense lawyer should consider criminal responsibility as a defense What “mental illness” refers to in the courtroom, and what falls under its umbrella What happens when mental illness and substance abuse occurs together, and what obstacles it poses...
info_outline
The Importance of Competency in the Criminal Justice System with Dr. Eric Drogin
Mental Disabilities and the Criminal Justice System
This week Elizabeth Kelley talks with her guest, Dr. Eric Drogin, the author of the first chapter in the second edition of her book, ‘Representing People with Mental Disabilities: A Practical Guide for Criminal Defense Lawyers.’ The two discuss clarification on the subject of competency and its importance, what to look for in the right mental health expert for your case, and at what point this work becomes the entree to a number of different medically and/or psychologically informed issues. In this episode, we discuss: What competency is, and why it’s so important...
info_outline
Unlocking Justice: Navigating the Criminal System for Individuals on the Autism Spectrum with Professor Larry Dubin
Mental Disabilities and the Criminal Justice System
This week Elizabeth Kelley talks with her guest, Professor Larry Dubin. The two discuss the work of helping people on the spectrum navigate “their new world” in the criminal justice system, the boilerplate knowledge that judges and prosecutors need to have in order to competently and humanely handle these cases, and the prevalence of people on the spectrum in our society. He tells us, “The numbers are showing there’s a lot of people on the spectrum, and they don’t need to be mistreated. It’s not fair, it’s not American to have them mistreated as they are currently through the...
info_outline
A Father’s Journey: When Your Child Has Bipolar Disorder
Mental Disabilities and the Criminal Justice System
This week Elizabeth Kelley talks with her guest, Senator Creigh Deeds. The two discuss the many initiatives he’s championed to relieve some of the flaws in the mental health space and the story that inspired him to take action. In this episode, we discuss: What he has done to reform the services delivered to people suffering from serious mental illnesses How his son inspired this journey for Sr. Deeds, and shifted his focus to make change in the mental health space What challenges his team has found along the way, and how they have worked to overcome them What is being...
info_outline
In this episode, Elizabeth Kelley interviews Criminal Defense Lawyer Marcia G. Shein. The two discuss essential components of good mental health evaluations, how an attorney can be particularly sensitive to red flags, and practical aspects for newer attorneys in cases such as these. Attorney Shein is the author of the chapter entitled “Mitigation” in the upcoming 2nd edition of Elizabeth’s book, Representing People with Mental Disabilities published by the American Bar Association.
In this episode:
-
What red flags Attorney Shein looks for to see if a forensic evaluation is in order
-
How her master’s degree in psychology makes her more alert to issues that people may have, and how an average practitioner can be particularly sensitive to the red flags
-
Where she looks for specific qualified experts, and what she is looking for in them
-
What essential components she looks for in a good evaluation, and how she effectively uses the report for purposes of mitigation
-
Why most lawyers are hesitant in presenting mitigating factors
-
Practical aspects for newer attorneys in terms of achieving records and waivers, bringing in mental health experts
-
Why it’s important that attorneys use their instincts and intuition in addition to listening to their clients
Marcia G. Shein is a nationally recognized attorney in matters of federal trial, plea, sentencing mitigation, appellate, and post conviction litigation. She has consulted with some of the best federal criminal defense attorneys in the nation on these matters as well as at trial to protect case mitigation issues for sentencing and appeal should the client be convicted. She has a Master’s Degree in Psychology from Nova University and was a family therapist before becoming an attorney. Attorney Shein is a life member of NACDL and Past President of the Georgia Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers. She has written numerous articles that have appeared in publications such as The Champion, The Federal Lawyer, and The Georgia Defender. These articles discuss topics such as the Federal Sentencing Guidelines, mental health issues, post Traumatic Stress Disorder, and treatments. She has represented clients from Alaska to Maine as well as beyond U.S. borders in complicated federal criminal cases.
Attorney Shein has served as an adjunct instructor of legal and psychology courses for the Criminal Justice Programs for Broward Community College and Nova University in Florida, Troy State University in Alabama, and Kaplan University in Chicago.
Attorney Shein's office is located at 2392 North Decatur Road, Decatur, GA 30033. 404-633-3797 (voice).
Website: https://federalcriminallawcenter.com/
Book: https://www.amazon.com/Love-Lies-Marcia-Shein/dp/1480988847
Disclaimer: Anything discussed in this episode is not legal advice, but commentary on experience.