loader from loading.io

Bob’s Burgers Thanksgiving Throwdown - Ranking The Best Holiday Episodes

Challenge Accepted

Release Date: 11/27/2025

Thank you and Goodbye. show art Thank you and Goodbye.

Challenge Accepted

In this final episode of Challenge Accepted, Frank and Thomas Law reflect on what the show became over three years and 250-plus episodes, and why ending it now feels like the right move. They talk about the grind of weekly reviews, the fun of theme months, the lessons they’re carrying forward, and how the best parts of this podcast will live on through Geek Freaks and what’s next for the network. Thomas also shares where Sick Burn is headed, why the message matters more than the metrics, and how storytelling and vulnerability have become a core part of the work. Timestamps and Topics 00:06...

info_outline
2025 Year in Review: Superman Takes the Crown, Thunderbolts Surprises, and Big 2026 Hype (Supergirl, Doomsday, Odyssey) show art 2025 Year in Review: Superman Takes the Crown, Thunderbolts Surprises, and Big 2026 Hype (Supergirl, Doomsday, Odyssey)

Challenge Accepted

Thomas and Frank look back on the movies and TV that defined their 2025, from why Superman hit so hard to how Marvel’s three-film run landed with Thunderbolts, Fantastic Four, and Captain America: Brave New World. They also talk about the stuff that disappointed them, why TV felt like it “won” this year, and the shows they could not stop thinking about, including IT: Welcome to Derry, Alien: Earth, and Andor. To close it out, they shift into 2026 mode: what’s got them genuinely excited again, which upcoming releases feel like “event” movies, and how they want to evolve Challenge...

info_outline
Night of the Living Dead | The 1968 Classic That Wrote the Zombie Rulebook show art Night of the Living Dead | The 1968 Classic That Wrote the Zombie Rulebook

Challenge Accepted

Frank revisits Night of the Living Dead (1968) and breaks down why it still feels ahead of its time, even with a shoestring budget and simple setup. He walks through the full plot from the cemetery opening to the brutal ending, calls out the movie’s “proto zombie rules” (headshots, fire, escalating panic), and digs into the constant clash between Ben and Harry Cooper over how to survive. Frank also shares a handful of behind-the-scenes trivia, then closes by asking listeners to help pick the next holiday movie review. Timestamps and Topics 00:00:05 Welcome to Challenge Accepted and why...

info_outline
Fargo | Snow, Schemes, and a Woodchipper show art Fargo | Snow, Schemes, and a Woodchipper

Challenge Accepted

In this single-player episode of Challenge Accepted, Frank bundles up with the winter classic Fargo and breaks down why this 1996 Coen Brothers film still hits so hard. From Jerry’s desperate spiral and Gaear’s cold brutality to Marge Gunderson’s calm, quietly heroic presence, Frank walks through the story, performances, music, and snow-covered Midwest setting that make the movie timeless. He also talks about how the Fargo TV series connects back to the film, why the woodchipper scene has become legend, and how the Coens turn empty white fields into one of the most effective...

info_outline
Batman: Mask of the Phantasm | Fresh Look at the 90's Cult Classic show art Batman: Mask of the Phantasm | Fresh Look at the 90's Cult Classic

Challenge Accepted

In this solo episode of Challenge Accepted, Frank finally sits down with the iconic animated film Batman Mask of the Phantasm after years of calling it a major Batman blind spot. He shares his deep love for Batman The Animated Series, breaks down Bruce Timm’s distinctive art style, and explores why Kevin Conroy and Mark Hamill’s performances still define Batman and Joker for entire generations. After watching the movie for the first time, Frank gives his immediate reaction, digging into Gotham’s timeless look, the horror-inspired presentation of the Phantasm, and the emotional core of...

info_outline
Bob’s Burgers Thanksgiving Throwdown - Ranking The Best Holiday Episodes show art Bob’s Burgers Thanksgiving Throwdown - Ranking The Best Holiday Episodes

Challenge Accepted

In this Thanksgiving special of Challenge Accepted, Frank and Jonathan celebrate the Belchers by ranking their top Bob’s Burgers Thanksgiving episodes and crowning a definitive winner. They break down why the holiday episodes hit so hard, talk about the emotional gut punches hidden inside the jokes, and revisit the wild chaos of turkeys, hoarding, broken ovens, and cursed outdoor cooking. The guys also reveal the results of their “Turkey Brawl” social media tournament and wrap up with a few extra Thanksgiving watch recommendations to keep your holiday cozy and geeky. Bob's Burgers...

info_outline
Stranger Things Seasons 1–4 Recap – Getting Ready For The Final Battle show art Stranger Things Seasons 1–4 Recap – Getting Ready For The Final Battle

Challenge Accepted

On this episode of Challenge Accepted, Frank Lourence (@franklourence79) teams up with Jonathan to walk through Stranger Things seasons 1 through 4 so you are fully refreshed before season 5 lands. The two revisit the early days in Hawkins, the rise of the Mind Flayer, the Starcourt Mall showdown, and Vecna’s terrifying curse, mixing clean plot recaps with personal memories and reactions. Along the way they talk about why the show’s ’80s nostalgia still works, how characters like Hopper, Billy, Max, and Eddie evolved, and what they hope to see in the final season. They close by sharing...

info_outline
The Ballad Of Buster Scruggs | Death and Legends show art The Ballad Of Buster Scruggs | Death and Legends

Challenge Accepted

In this solo Thanksgiving episode of Challenge Accepted, Frank breaks down The Ballad of Buster Scruggs, the Coen Brothers’ Netflix Western anthology that has quietly become one of his holiday staples. Story by story, he digs into how each vignette wrestles with death, chance, and human nature, from Tim Blake Nelson’s singing gunslinger to Tom Waits’ stubborn prospector and that iconic “First time?” hanging meme. Along the way, Frank talks about why the film feels so cozy despite its bleak themes, how the Coens use digital cinematography to shape tone, and what these stories say...

info_outline
Gen V Season 2 | The Boys’ Campus War, Wins, and What’s Next show art Gen V Season 2 | The Boys’ Campus War, Wins, and What’s Next

Challenge Accepted

On Challenge Accepted, we break down the Gen V Season 2 finale and how it tees up the last chapter of The Boys. We talk about the big reveal around Cipher, the season’s mid-section slowdown, and why Godolkin works best when the story actually stays on campus. We dig into standout arcs for Marie, Jordan, Emma, and Sage, the villain’s core weakness, and why those Starlight and A-Train beats matter. We also highlight the effects work, tributes woven into the story, and what we expect to carry over into The Boys. Timestamps and Topics 00:00 — Welcome and gut reactions to the finale 00:37...

info_outline
Mighty Morphin Power Rangers: The Movie (1995) | Morphin’ Time at the Movies! | Feat. Becca Peterson show art Mighty Morphin Power Rangers: The Movie (1995) | Morphin’ Time at the Movies! | Feat. Becca Peterson

Challenge Accepted

On this episode of Challenge Accepted, Thomas welcomes critic and lifelong Ranger fan Becca Peterson (The Critic Buffet) for a fast-paced, fun deep dive into the 1995 feature film. We cover why this movie still hits for ‘90s kids, the charm of Ivan Ooze, the switch to ninja powers and new Zords, and how the film fits into the broader multiverse of Power Rangers stories. Becca brings great trivia, from casting changes to Sentai influences, and shares why the movie’s core message still lands. Timestamps & Topics 00:00 – 01:10 | Cold open, show intro, and guest welcome; Becca’s...

info_outline
 
More Episodes

In this Thanksgiving special of Challenge Accepted, Frank and Jonathan celebrate the Belchers by ranking their top Bob’s Burgers Thanksgiving episodes and crowning a definitive winner. They break down why the holiday episodes hit so hard, talk about the emotional gut punches hidden inside the jokes, and revisit the wild chaos of turkeys, hoarding, broken ovens, and cursed outdoor cooking. The guys also reveal the results of their “Turkey Brawl” social media tournament and wrap up with a few extra Thanksgiving watch recommendations to keep your holiday cozy and geeky.

Bob's Burgers Thanksgiving - CA


Timestamps and Topics

00:00 - Welcome and Thanksgiving setup
Shout out to Thomas and Cristina on their new baby, and intro to the Bob’s Burgers Thanksgiving episode ranking concept.

Bob's Burgers Thanksgiving - CA

01:00 - How the episode works
Frank explains the format: each host picks their top three Thanksgiving episodes, they talk themes, favorite moments, and what Bob’s Burgers “teaches” about the holiday.

02:00 - Jonathan’s #3: “Thanks-hoarding” (Season 8)
They unpack Teddy’s hoarding storyline, his emotional backstory, and how the episode balances relatable anxiety with Belcher chaos and big heart.

Bob's Burgers Thanksgiving - CA

03:45 - Frank’s #3: “Dawn of the Peck”
Discussion of the “bird uprising” Black Friday marathon, pecking order jokes, Linda’s power arc, and background gags like the infamous “Tickle Boat.”

06:00 - Jonathan’s #2: “Gail Making Bob Sled” (Season 6)
Bob’s snowbound nightmare with Gail, Mr. Business, and the inflatable pool sled gets a full breakdown, including how Gail’s dramatics nearly kill Bob for absolutely no reason.

Bob's Burgers Thanksgiving - CA

08:15 - Frank’s #2: “I Bob Your Pardon”
They talk about the turkey pardon scandal, Linda fangirling over the mayor, the caper to rescue the doomed turkey, and the reporter who gets dragged into Belcher chaos.

11:20 - Jonathan’s #1: “Now We’re Not Cooking With Gas” (Season 10)
The guys dig into Bob’s survivalist fantasy crashing into reality when the gas goes out, the backyard fire pit disaster, the fire department interventions, and the surprisingly perfect turkey under all the char.

Bob's Burgers Thanksgiving - CA

14:20 - Frank’s #1: “Turkey in a Can”
They revisit Bob’s allergy meds, the mystery of the toilet turkeys, Gail’s cat, Tina’s struggle to be “grown up,” and the romantic misunderstanding with the deli guy.

18:00 - The Turkey Brawl results and final Top 3
Frank reveals the social media tournament winners:

  • “Turkey in a Can”

  • “An Indecent Thanksgiving Proposal”

  • “I Bob Your Pardon”

Then he and Jonathan lock in their final ranking for the definitive Bob’s Burgers Thanksgiving list. Bob's Burgers Thanksgiving - CA

20:10 - What to watch on Thanksgiving
Beyond Bob’s Burgers, they recommend Thanksgiving viewing like Planes, Trains and Automobiles, Addams Family Values, and some cozy Westerns, plus the usual football and early Christmas movie season.

21:37 - Outro and thanks
Wrap up with holiday well wishes, a reminder to check out Hulu’s “Bob’s Giving” collection, and a call to leave those 5 star reviews. 


Key Takeaways

  • Bob’s Burgers Thanksgiving episodes nail the mix of heartfelt family moments and unhinged holiday chaos, which is why they have basically become comfort viewing for the hosts.

  • “Thanks-hoarding” uses Teddy’s clutter problem to explore how childhood trauma and a fixation on “fixing” things can leave you emotionally stuck.

  • “Dawn of the Peck” turns a discount turkey disaster into a full bird uprising, while still keeping the focus on the Belchers’ reactions and one liners.

  • “Gail Making Bob Sled” shows how far Bob will go for family, even when Gail is clearly the source of her own drama.

  • “I Bob Your Pardon” works as both a goofy turkey heist and a small town political scandal, with the Belchers accidentally blowing open a fake pardon scheme.

  • “Now We’re Not Cooking With Gas” captures Bob’s stubborn perfectionism as he tries to salvage Thanksgiving with a makeshift outdoor oven.

  • “Turkey in a Can” stands out as the ultimate Thanksgiving episode, blending mystery, character insight, and one of the show’s funniest running misunderstandings.

  • The Challenge Accepted “Turkey Brawl” confirmed what the hosts already felt: the Thanksgiving run of Bob’s Burgers is one of the strongest holiday traditions in modern animation.


Memorable Quotes

  • “He never has a fully just easy Happy Thanksgiving. He’s supposed to cook and eat.”

  • “Bob almost dies in the snow, and she’s just playing around the whole time.”

  • “It’s not the first time I had a special baloney sandwich out of the toilet. It’ll be the first time I don’t use gloves.”

  • “No, I’m straight. I mean, almost straight. I mean, you’d like me.”


Call To Action

If you enjoyed this Bob’s Burgers Thanksgiving breakdown, hit follow on your favorite podcast app so you never miss an episode. Drop a 5 star review on Apple Podcasts and Spotify, and share this episode with a friend who always puts on the Belchers during the holidays. Use #ChallengeAcceptedLive when you post so we can find your rankings and hot takes on the best Thanksgiving episodes.


Links and Resources

  • Geek Freaks Network site and news hub: GeekFreaksPodcast.com
    This is our source for all the geek news we discuss across the network.


Follow Us

Stay connected with Challenge Accepted:


Listener Questions

We want your picks for the best Bob’s Burgers Thanksgiving episodes and your go to holiday watches.
Email your thoughts, questions, or future episode ideas to ChallengeAcceptedGFX@gmail.com, or message us on Instagram, TikTok, or Twitter at @ChallengeAcceptedLive. Your question might show up in a future episode.


Apple Podcasts Tags:
Bob’s Burgers Thanksgiving, Bob’s Burgers podcast, Challenge Accepted podcast, Geek Freaks Network, holiday TV episodes, animated sitcom discussion, TV recap podcast, comedy and pop culture podcast