A cautionary tale about using AI as your therapist with Amanda Johnson & Chelsea Jewel
Release Date: 11/07/2025
A cautionary tale about using AI as your therapist with Amanda Johnson & Chelsea Jewel
Clarity on Fire
A curious pattern emerged within the last year: People — usually friends or coaching clients — keep coming to us, almost sheepishly, and “confessing” that they sometimes use AI (particularly ChatGPT) for emotional support. The thing is … we’ve used it for emotional support, too! AI has a lot of qualities that make it less messy than your average human. It’s a great listener, it’s endlessly patient, and it has access to an infinite amount of knowledge and potential solutions. Plus, using it is (sadly) a LOT cheaper than what you’d pay your average therapist or coach. But...
info_outline
Dear Krachel: How do I believe in a better future when I keep getting rejected and disappointed?
Clarity on Fire
Welcome to another episode of Dear Krachel (our first since June of 2024!), our advice segment where we answer listener questions about life, career, relationships, existential angst, and anything that helps you become a more whole, fulfilled version of yourself. This month we answered questions from two listeners who are both questioning what went “wrong” in their lives, how to recover from deep disappointment, and how the future can be better: Bottledottle, a medical school student who doesn’t know if she wants to be a doctor anymore, and who is deeply afraid that she wasted...
info_outline
What if productivity could feel feminine? With Jamie Knight
Clarity on Fire
“If I didn’t love you, I would hate you.” That’s a direct quote that escaped my mouth while recording this episode with my former client, Jamie Knight. 😆 Jamie inspires such intensity because she’s recovering from being that girl. You know, the cheer captain and valedictorian of her high school class. Got a bachelor’s and master’s degree at the same time, and had a 4.0 in both. Had a top-tier job offer before she even started her last semester of college. Ran half marathons, for fun! Excelled in her career and made absurdly good money by anyone’s...
info_outline
Message from the Universe: Something beautiful is being born in your life
Clarity on Fire
Need a little clarity, guidance, or just a fun pick-me-up? Then today’s your day, because we’re back with the first Message from the Universe episode in over a year! ✨🔮 If you’re new to this kind of episode, every once in a while, we sit down and pull a few cards from one of our favorite oracle decks and share the messages — and our interpretations — with you. And every time, we end up with a message that feels spot-on and super timely. So, ! After you listen, leave a comment to share how this one spoke to you! ...
info_outline
We’re back! And spilling the tea about the last 15 months
Clarity on Fire
Heyyyy! Did you miss us? Or maybe completely forgot we existed and went on with your life? (Valid, if so). Perhaps you felt a small void in your life where conversations between two friends about all things life and career used to be, that you haven’t been able to fill in the last 15 months. If that’s the case, we have GREAT news for you: The Clarity on Fire Podcast is back! If you’ll recall, we went on hiatus back in June of 2024, mostly because life had taken some wild twists and turns. There’s a LOT to share about what’s happened since then. So, listen is...
info_outline
New to Clarity on Fire? Start Here! (2024 Edition)
Clarity on Fire
In case you missed it, last week we announced that – for a few reasons, but mostly because Rachel is having a baby later this year! If you’re new-ish to Clarity on Fire – or have been around for a while but want to introduce new people to us – that gives you an excellent opportunity to catch up on our over-400 episodes. Buuuut we also know that’s a LOT of content and you might be overwhelmed! 😅 So, we’re making it easy for you (or your friends) to know where to start. Here’s where we recommend starting if you’re new to Clarity on Fire: Before...
info_outline
We’re going on hiatus again (& having a baby)!
Clarity on Fire
Yes, you read that subject line right — we’re taking another hiatus from the podcast … because one of us is having a baby! 🤰🏼👀 So, without further ado, dive into this special episode where we share … ALL the details behind this baby announcement Our plans during the hiatus When you might hear from us on the podcast again And where you can find us in the meantime (because we’ve got new things cooking, in addition to the bun in the oven!) We’ll still be posting on Instagram occasionally while we’re away, so if you haven’t yet. You can also follow...
info_outline
“Failing at life” & retreating to Italy with Susanne Reichart
Clarity on Fire
In the last few years my client Susanne went from having a very normal, run-of-the-mill career to relocating to Italy, renovating a beautiful property, and opening a retreat space (she calls it a “thinker’s residence”) for creative people who long for peace and quiet to work on their most important projects. Getting to help Susanne take this dream from vision to reality has been a highlight of my last few years as a coach, and I’m so excited to finally get to share her story with all of you! Listen in to this month’s brand-new interview with a normal person, where...
info_outline
Dear Krachel: How do I stop blaming myself when things go wrong at work?
Clarity on Fire
Welcome to another episode of Dear Krachel, our monthly advice segment where we answer listener questions about life, career, relationships, existential angst, and anything that helps you become a more whole, fulfilled version of yourself. This month we answered questions from two listeners, who both happen to be teachers (but their issues are relevant to all of us)! Worry Worm, whose confidence takes a hit whenever her students don’t meet their expected results. Is she bad at what she does, or are the kids slacking off? Tired Thriver, an elementary school teacher in...
info_outline
Exploring the nervous system with Amanda Johnson
Clarity on Fire
It’s the fifth Friday of the month, which means this should be a “bonus book club” episode––it isn’t, but it’s also not NOT a book club episode, either. 🙃😂 During our last book club conversation about Attached with Amanda Johnson – our friend, fellow coach, and all-around expert on attachment theory – we said that we wanted to have Amanda back on the podcast to have an episode devoted completely to the nervous system. So, that’s what we did! Amanda is back on the podcast this month to help us explore all facets of the nervous system, using one...
info_outlineA curious pattern emerged within the last year:
People — usually friends or coaching clients — keep coming to us, almost sheepishly, and “confessing” that they sometimes use AI (particularly ChatGPT) for emotional support.
The thing is … we’ve used it for emotional support, too! AI has a lot of qualities that make it less messy than your average human.
It’s a great listener, it’s endlessly patient, and it has access to an infinite amount of knowledge and potential solutions. Plus, using it is (sadly) a LOT cheaper than what you’d pay your average therapist or coach.
But that certainly doesn’t make it better than a human mental health professional. As helpful as AI might be, it can be equally as harmful—not all of the friends and clients who came to us ended up having a positive experience with their “robot therapist.”
So, we asked two of our coach friends (and former podcast guests!), Amanda Johnson and Chelsea Jewel, to join us for a deep-dive exploration into the murky waters where AI mixes with mental health.
Listen in as we get into...
- How all four of us started out using AI, and how it quickly evolved for each of us
- Why it’s easy, even if you’re a coach or therapist, to have blind spots when it comes to AI
- How using AI as your therapist can actually bring up MORE trauma
- Our advice about how to interact with AI in an emotionally healthy way
This episode is SO thought-provoking. The questions that we tackle are ones that all of us should be taking seriously in a world where it’s increasingly difficult to know what’s real!
Leave a comment after you’ve listened to let us know what resonated most from this conversation.
MORE ABOUT AMANDA
Amanda Johnson is a trauma-informed and somatically trained, certified life coach and reiki master. Her passion lies in the belief that each of our hearts is guiding the way to our most expansive lives - but that to live from the heart, we need to first get in touch with who we really are, not who we've been told to be. This requires an exploration and understanding of our nervous systems, the patterns we have running in our bodies and minds, and how our energy works, so that we can bring ourselves into balance and deeper connection with our intuition. Through her work at Heartspark, Amanda is dedicated to creating a safe space for anyone with a curiosity about themselves to explore how to authentically be in relationship with Self, Sacred Partners and Source.
You can find her at heartsparksoul.com and on Instagram @heartsparksoul
MORE ABOUT CHELSEA
Chelsea Jewel is an Intuitive Astrologer, Soul Alignment Coach, and Energy Healer who is committed to using her gifts and vision to help co-create a more beautiful and just world for all beings. Chelsea's work combines a mix of storytelling, astrology, shadow work, and energy awareness to help her clients reconnect with their deeper soul essence and reclaim creative power within their life stories. Part healer, part artist, and part spiritual activist, Chelsea deeply believes that we are on the verge of a collective shift in consciousness and that our deep inner work, along with the creative actions that spring from it, serves a vital role in restoring humanity's relationships within the greater web of life.
You can find her at chelseajewel.com and on Instagram @chelseajewel33
PAST CLARITY ON FIRE EPISODES WITH AMANDA & CHELSEA
A deep dive into manifestation with Chelsea Jewel (March 2022)
From totally shut down to feeling your feelings again with Amanda Johnson (June 2023)
Bonus Book Club! Attached by Amir Levine & Rachel S.F. Heller (March 2024)
Exploring the nervous system with Amanda Johnson (May 2024)
ARTICLES ABOUT AI & MENTAL HEALTH
New York Times: Chatbots Can Go Into a Delusional Spiral. Here’s How It Happens.
The New Yorker: I Treated ChatGPT Like a Therapy Patient. What It Said Should Worry Us.
LINKS
Leave us a comment on this episode
Submit your question for a future episode of Dear Krachel