609: Admission Nutrients (Part 3 of 6: Leadership): Important Ingredients for a Well-Balanced College Admission Process—And Life
The College Essay Guy Podcast: A Practical Guide to College Admissions
Release Date: 06/24/2025
The College Essay Guy Podcast: A Practical Guide to College Admissions
The transition from high school to college is something that thousands of students struggle with each year, and it’s not something people really talk about. There’s a lot of pressure for students to “have it together” in some broad sense. That's why today I'm excited to talk to Dr. Jill Grimes, Dr. Jill Grimes, author of The ULTIMATE College Student Health Handbook: Your Guide for Everything from Hangovers to Homesickness, for a frank conversation about things that are often stigmatized. Content warning: We get into some pretty serious topics such as mental health, drinking, and...
info_outlineThe College Essay Guy Podcast: A Practical Guide to College Admissions
Hey friends, and welcome back to the College Essay Guy podcast. Today’s episode is the third and final episode in our series called Inside the Personal Statement Process. If you’re just tuning in, this series takes you behind the scenes as I work one-on-one with Alisha, a current high school senior applying for the Fall 2026 term. Find Part 1 and Part 2 . This episode was recorded just a few days before Alisha submitted her early applications. The focus of this episode is on one of the most challenging—and perhaps, the least discussed—aspect of writing the personal...
info_outlineThe College Essay Guy Podcast: A Practical Guide to College Admissions
Hey friends, and welcome back to the College Essay Guy podcast. Today’s episode is part two of our series called Inside the Personal Statement Process. If you’re just tuning in, this series takes you behind the scenes as I work one-on-one with Alisha, a current high school senior applying for the Fall 2026 term. In the first episode, we got to know Alisha through her brainstorming and outline. In this episode, we pick up right where we left off — Alisha’s second draft. We get into: How did the new outline work for Alisha? How to approach trimming—not just words,...
info_outlineThe College Essay Guy Podcast: A Practical Guide to College Admissions
In our new series, Inside the Personal Statement Process, we’re taking you behind the scenes with Alisha, a current high school senior working through applications right now. If you've ever wondered what it's like working with Ethan in a session, this is the podcast for you! You might remember a similar series where we got to see her whole application process. Rather than focus on the whole application, I wanted to just dive specifically into working with Alisha through the personal statement process. In Part 1, Alisha and I get into: How did Alisha approach brainstorming and...
info_outlineThe College Essay Guy Podcast: A Practical Guide to College Admissions
In today’s episode, I’m joined by my long-time colleague, and our Chief People Officer here at CEG, Sandy Longworth. Sandy has worked as a therapist, a researcher, college counselor — among other things — and has spent years studying the role that narrative storytelling plays in how teens develop their identities. Important note: While Sandy trained as a therapist, and we do talk a lot about therapy in our conversation, I want to make clear that I do not hold that college counseling and essay coaching — or what we do at College Essay Guy — to be therapy. It isn’t....
info_outlineThe College Essay Guy Podcast: A Practical Guide to College Admissions
Hi friends, and welcome back to the podcast. In today’s episode, I’m joined by two special guests: Dr. Steven Antonoff and Jay McCann, co-authors of the newly updated 5th edition of The College Finder: Your comprehensive guide to finding colleges that fit YOUR unique path. In this conversation, we dig into some of the biggest questions students and families face in the college search today, including: What—if anything—are rankings good for in 2025? Beyond starting salaries, which outcome metrics actually indicate value? What’s a responsible way for students to use AI in the search...
info_outlineThe College Essay Guy Podcast: A Practical Guide to College Admissions
Welcome back to the podcast. It’s September, which means many students are building the list of colleges they’re applying to. Today I’m joined by New York Times Bestselling Author, Harlan Cohen, who walks us through his 13 most common mistakes students make when they’re creating their college list. We cover, among other things: The importance of shifting from what “they” want… to what you want The problem with rankings The importance of doing “future math” Why treating college as a one-year experiment can lower the stakes And more Harlan Cohen is the...
info_outlineThe College Essay Guy Podcast: A Practical Guide to College Admissions
Hi friends, and welcome back to the podcast. This one’s going to be short—and honestly, it’s an episode I didn’t think I was going to record. Why? Well, if you’ve been following along with Cassidy’s journey over the past year, you know we’ve covered a lot: from brainstorming her personal statement, to revising her supplements, to weighing her college acceptances. And when we wrapped Part 5, I figured we could leave it there. I thought it might be enough to know she had some great options. Silly me. You wrote in. You wanted to know: Where did she end up? So here we are: the final...
info_outlineThe College Essay Guy Podcast: A Practical Guide to College Admissions
Welcome back to the podcast! This is our sixth and final chapter of our series on admission nutrients — qualities that can make for a healthier, more meaningful college admission process… and life. In case you missed it, we started with , with Raissa Diamante (Director of admission from Harvey-Mudd College), then I sat down with Deanna Dixon, (Dean of Admission at Smith College) to talk about , then Tom met with Dysean Alexander (Assistant Director for West Coast Admission at Lafayette College) to talk about and Nathan Faust (Loyola Marymount University) to talk about . Today we...
info_outlineThe College Essay Guy Podcast: A Practical Guide to College Admissions
In Episode 5 of our series on Admission Nutrients, Tom Campbell is joined by Nathan Faust, Admission Counselor at Loyola Marymount University, to talk about Service to Others / Community Impact. In their conversation, they get into: Why service to others and community impact is a valuable nutrient to fold into your high school experience—and life Tips on communicating your service and community-impact initiatives to admissions officers Examples of how this nutrient may overlap with the others Advice for counselors on how to explain the value of this nutrient to students and families...
info_outlineIn Episode 3 of our series on Admission Nutrients, Ethan is joined by Deanna Dixon, the Dean of Admission at Smith College, to dive into leadership and initiative. In their conversation, they get into:
- What are a few of the qualities Smith College looks for?
- How does their supplemental essay point to their institutional priorities and what they’re looking for in an applicant?
- Why are leadership and initiative important from Smith’s perspective?
- What does she think about ChatGPT?
- When it comes to equity and leveling the playing field, how does she believe the profession is doing?
- Advice for students and families going through this process
- And more!
Deanna Dixon has worked in college admission since 2006 and currently serves as Dean of Admission at Smith College. As a graduate of a women’s college, she has maintained a deep commitment to women's education and college attainment for marginalized students in general. A parent of a college senior, Deanna appreciates the dedication of college counselors and the shared partnership of matching students to the best school for them. Deanna has a bachelor’s degree from Smith College and a master’s degree in business administration from The Olin School of Business at Washington University in St. Louis.
We hope you enjoy our conversation.
Play-by-Play:
- 2:09 – Welcome and introductions
- 2:37 – What are some roles that Deanna plays as Dean of Admission at Smith?
- 4:59 – What does life look like behind the scenes at Smith?
- 8:10 – What is yield and why is it important to colleges?
- 10:01 – What are some of the “positive character attributes” that Smith is looking for?
- 14:05 – Where do these attributes show up in an application?
- 17:07 – How does Smith’s supplemental essay point to their institutional priorities?
- 22:54 – Why are leadership and initiative important from Smith’s perspective?
- 24:30 – What are some interesting or unconventional examples of students taking initiative or leadership at the high school level?
- 27:46 – Where does leadership show up on campus at Smith?
- 31:06 – How have personal statement topics shifted over the years?
- 36:39 – What’s one of Deanna’s favorite essays she has read?
- 38:50 – What does Deanna think about ChatGPT?
- 44:13 – When it comes to equity and leveling the playing field, how does Deanna believe the profession is doing?
- 49:09 – Advice for students and families going through this process
- 51:45 – Closing thoughts
Resources:
- Tony Jack’s Class Dismissed
- 3 Step Guide to Choosing a College That's Right for You
- College Essay Guy’s Personal Statement Resources
- College Essay Guy’s College Application Hub