America, The Land of the Free? Do You Really Buy That?
Release Date: 05/07/2022
Marketing Muckraking
In today’s episode I am joined by the indestructible Molly McPherson, who you may know as the TikTok “PR Lady,” as her followers have affectionally dubbed her. I just know her as my first stop when a brand or celebrity is in the news for reasons they’d rather not be. Molly is hilarious, warm, and witty and I’m absolutely thrilled and delighted that she’s on the show today, talking about the #1 biggest mistake that brands make before, during, and after a public relations crisis and even dishing with me on my favorite topic — the and the curious case of...
info_outlineMarketing Muckraking
Welcome to Part 4, the final installment of the Online Business Family Tree series, where we traced back how we arrived at this moment in internet marketing and online business and who are the key leaders who brought us here. We also highlighted the 10 elements of the rotten tree. To review: Prosperity gospel and the "pull yourself up by your bootstraps" myth of meritocracy Mastermind relationships and being "in the room" where it happens with powerful leaders JV partnerships Affiliate marketing Tabloid / clickbait / pain point / shame-based marketing Gaming the system Propaganda, mind...
info_outlineMarketing Muckraking
Welcome to Part 3 of this four-part series on The Online Business Family Tree, where we trace back how we arrived at this moment in internet marketing and online business and who are the key leaders who brought us here. In this installment, we’re time traveling from WWI and WWII all the way to today, where clickbait, ClickFunnels to hell, and faking it ’til you make it have spread across the branches of this rotten business tree, poisoning the fruits that fall to everyone clamoring for their taste of success. Remember, this stuff didn’t start on the Internet — it goes back hundreds of...
info_outlineMarketing Muckraking
Welcome to Part 2 of this four-part series on The Online Business Family Tree, where we trace back how we arrived at this moment in internet marketing and online business and who are the key leaders who brought us here. In this installment, we’re diving into six figure masterminds, Marie Forleo’s B-School, the Cult of the Syndicate, and how early Internet marketers like Mark Joyner, Dan Kennedy, Yanik Silver, and Russell Brunson brought mind control and manipulation online. If you don’t know — or care — about these names, never fear. We focus on what tactics these leaders popularized...
info_outlineMarketing Muckraking
If you've ever wondered how the Online Business Industrial Complex was built, this is the 4-part series for you. I'm joined by Lisa Robbin Young as we trace back how we arrived at this moment in internet marketing and online business, and who are the key leaders who brought us here, starting with Ben Franklin, Henry Ford, and Thomas Edison, all the way to and Matthew McConaughey? Yeah, he’s a life coach now. If you don’t know — or care — about these names, never fear. Lisa and I focus on what tactics these leaders popularized and how they’ve invaded nearly every corner of online...
info_outlineMarketing Muckraking
In this installment of Marketing Muckraking, we explore the question...should brands be "political"? And what does it mean to be "political" in the context of global capitalism? Are we turning to corporations because we've lost our faith in government? What do we do, as brand consumers and business owners, with the answers to these questions? How do we build a better world? In June, the world’s most powerful advertisers gathered at Cannes Lions, where this year’s biggest themes included AI, ad tech, influencer marketing, and most notably — “dialing down the politics,” which was the...
info_outlineMarketing Muckraking
Content warning: this episode touches on sensitive topics that include sexual assault, child abuse, and religious trauma. Shiny Happy People: Duggar Family Secrets released on Amazon Prime on June 2. In this episode, I review the docuseries through the lens of marketing muckraking, looking at how the Duggars and the IBLP used modern marketing, branding, and PR to re-write history as it was happening, in a bid to arrest political control of the country.
info_outlineMarketing Muckraking
Welcome to Season 2 of Marketing Muckraking! I started Season 1 with — and because I love a good callback, I’m continuing this conversation as we kick off Season 2. In my very first episode I traced back the origins of the term “personal brand” to Tom Peters and his 1997 Fast Company article when Peters told readers to “take a lesson from the big brands…establish your own micro equivalent of the Nike swoosh. Peters positioned personal branding as freedom from corporate rule: “You’re not an “employee” of General Motors, you’re not a “staffer” at...
info_outlineMarketing Muckraking
Jeff Harry is back! Earlier this year, Jeff and I asked the question: Today, the question is, "Can we fix capitalism?" Yvon Chouinard, self-styled "reluctant billionaire" and Patagonia founder recently made headlines for giving up ownership of the company and dedicating future profits to fight climate change. “Earth is now our only shareholder,” Chouinard wrote in an . The Internet went wild for the news with many celebrating the move as proof that there is hope for capitalism yet. In an exclusive New York Times interview Chouinard himself positioned the decision as...
info_outlineMarketing Muckraking
I believe that marketers and the people who consume marketing (that's everybody) need to know the history of the advertising industry and how we went from “Mad Men to Math Men” to quote Alexander Nix, former CEO of Cambridge Analytica. There is so much more to this history than a bunch of Don Drapers clinking scotch glasses while they come up with pithy slogans. Marketing history intertwines with how politics and culture took shape over the last century. To understand marketing history is to understand ourselves. If you want the short version of this, check out this...
info_outlineWhether you've been in business for 10 years or 10 minutes — and even if you're not — you know that "freedom" is a term used to sell most anything. From online courses to laundry detergent to...the United States of America.
There is a history here.
When America shifted from an agrarian economy to one based around mass production, the capitalists who owned the factories churning out mass produced goods needed all hands on deck, not just on the factory floor, but at the cash register.
Many people believe that worker rights were won solely by dedicated activists but this is not entirely true.
Decades before labor laws were passed, many forward thinking factory owners and CEOs started scaling back work weeks and increasing employee pay. Not because they had big hearts, but because they had big inventory to move. And they knew that a mass public too tired and broke to part with the few dollars they earned would spell catastrophe for their sales.
So, companies increased wages and decreased hours so that people had just enough time and money to buy the widgets they were producing.
And they rolled out widespread advertising campaigns to help people feel more comfortable spending their hard earned money.
Edward Filene deemed this "The School of Freedom," where the public was "trained" in being constant consumers.
Freedom — the same selling point behind The Constitution — was now seen as the freedom to participate in the economy and buy whatever we wanted, regardless of race, ethnicity, sex, or credo.
Today, we no longer need "training" in "The School of Freedom."
We see buying as self-care.
Our liberties may be shrinking, but the amount of products fighting for the honor of helping us "treat" ourselves is consistently growing.
In this episode of Marketing Muckraking, we dive into the history of how advertisers helped create a mass buying public and what "freedom" means as it pertains to reproductive rights.
I am publishing this on Mother's Day weekend because this year, parenthood looks different for many people, which is why I'm choosing now to share my story of choice and my own complicated relationship with motherhood.
In the spirit of this episode on consumer culture, I urge you to consume more history.
If you're going to buy, buy more books.
Learn about this nation's history and traditions.
I recommend A People's History of the United States by Howard Zinn. This was the first book I read about American history that didn't present our founders as flawless heroes. Start here and then keep reading...
Sources for this episode include:
- Captains of Consciousness: Advertising and the Social Roots of Consumer Culture by Stuart Ewen
- Land of Desire: Merchants, Power, and the Rise of a New American Culture by William Leach
- Satisfaction Guaranteed: The Making of an American Mass Market by Susan Strasser
- The Origins of the Family, Private Property, and The State by Friedrich Engels
- Self Care by Leigh Stein