Libsyn Directory

Are Confessional Churches Like Confessional States?

Release Date: 05/01/2023

Paleo Protestant Pudcast

We were down a man this time. Our Anglican co-host, , was on the road which left (Lutheran) and (Presbyterian) trying to maintain pudcasting standards. We had help from our colleague in the English Department, , who grew up Christian Reformed and switched to Eastern Orthodoxy. We talked about the various strands of Orthodoxy in America, what the appeal may be to young men, and why confessional Protestants realign with the Orthodox Church. For perspective on the current appeal of Orthodoxy, see from the New York Times. The movement of some Lutherans into...

Inside Confessional Protestant Baseball

Paleo Protestant Pudcast

This discussion among the co-hosts, (Lutheran), (Anglican), and (Presbyterian), has almost nothing to do with Thanksgiving but it does resume the last one about the Anglican Church in North America. Miles Smith provides an update on the ongoing efforts to resolve conflict over . He also comments on the Matthew Wilcoxen for reforming ACNA. Disputes in the Presbyterian Church in America over opened a window on the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod led by Korey Maas. All of this may sound like too much detail. But if you believe God is in the...

What Are Anglicans Doing?

Paleo Protestant Pudcast

The bumper music for this episode, chosen by our Presbyterian producer, comes from the 1964 of an Anglican homily by Alan Bennett ("My Brother Esau, Beyond the Fringe"). The subject discussed by pudcast co-hosts, (Lutheran), (Anglican), and (Presbyterian) may be the same -- Anglicanism -- but the approach is not comedic. Anglicans around the world have been in the news, from the of a new (and female) archbishop of Canterbury, to the by a prominent Baptist historical theologian to join ACNA. the deserves way more than roughly 55 minutes...

Cultural Christianity

Paleo Protestant Pudcast

A recent announced a shift, some call it vibe, others a mood, that is making Christianity more acceptable or less appealing than it used to be in Aaron Renn's "." This is related to a question of what influence churches have on a society and its culture. Aaron Renn among the effort to take back the mainline Protestant denominations (from a that everyone acknowledges but does not necessarily measure). One of the reasons for looking to these churches instead of the Presbyterian Church in America, the Lutheran Church Missouri Synod, or the Orthodox Presbyterian Church, is that...

Does Confessional Protestantism Need Classical Education

Paleo Protestant Pudcast

It is back-to-school time and the co-hosts, (Lutheran), (Anglican), and (Presbyterian) are getting ready for classes. This makes it a good time to reflect on the kind of education that nurtures confessional Protestant piety and practice -- for both ministers and church members. The recording starts with each member of the "broadcasting team" talking about upcoming classes at Hillsdale College and how we situate ourselves within the framework of classical education, the "Great Books," and liberal education. From there the conversation explores the...

Since When Do Confessional Protestants Pay Attention to Baptists?

Paleo Protestant Pudcast

To put the question even more pointedly, with lots of stereotyping to go round, when do Lutherans of German descent who settled mainly in the northern mid-western states pay attention to Baptists in the South? This was the subject of the recent recording when co-hosts, (Lutheran), (Anglican), and (Presbyterian) discussed Scott Yenor's about "the left's" attack on denominational institutions. Part of the discussion involved the Southern Baptist Convention's place in conservative politics and the New Calvinist movement. Another part involved the dark side of...

How High Is the Lord's Supper?

Paleo Protestant Pudcast

The topic this time is evangelical sacramentalism courtesy of a good short by , a retired professor of history at Grove City College. With Dr. Harp, the co-hosts, (Lutheran), (Anglican), and (Presbyterian) talk about the recent elevation of the sacraments among Protestants, whether this is a function of Protestants trying to retrieve the church fathers or re-enchant worship services, and the relationship between preaching and the Lord's Supper. Spoiler alert: readers may be surprised to hear an Anglican (Dr. Harp) defend a high view of preaching. Listeners...

Do Protestants Catch Colds if the Pope Sneezes?

Paleo Protestant Pudcast

The death of Pope Francis and the election of a new pope -- Leo XIV -- were the circumstances for co-hosts, (Lutheran), (Anglican), and (Presbyterian) to talk about relationships between Protestants and the papacy. The conversation ranged widely, from assessments of Francis, speculation about Leo, and general observations about Christianity's need for a sound pope. Keeping up with all of the articles about either Francis' legacy or Leo's prospects is impossible. But were of the co-hosts before being recorded.

It's Like Confessional Protestantism Doesn't Exist

Paleo Protestant Pudcast

The Lutheran, Reformed, and Anglican heirs of the Protestant Reformation continue to make news by not attracting attention from observers of American Protestantism. The co-hosts, (Lutheran), (Anglican), and (Presbyterian), talk about two recent articles about traditional Protestantism that either imply or claim that such Christianity is down on the mat for the count (think boxing). One is Brad East's "" and the other is Casey Spinks "?" The conversation may not be as hopeful as some listeners want. But along with the on non-denominational...

Confessional Protestantism and Denominationalism

Paleo Protestant Pudcast

This time co-hosts (Lutheran), (Anglican), and (Presbyterian) talk about whether non-denominational Christianity is the future of American Protestantism and what stake confessional Protestants have in denominational structures. The basis for discussion is sociologist Ryan Burge's whose numbers indicate the remarkable increase of non-denominational Protestantism. Methodists, Lutherans, Baptists, Presbyterians, Anglicans, and Congregationalists may sound like the ecclesiastical equivalent of Ford, Lincoln, Chevrolet, and Buick, but institutions matter to...

More Episodes

Anglicans were in the news in April which provoked co-hosts ⁠⁠Miles Smith⁠⁠ (Anglican), ⁠⁠D. G. Hart⁠⁠ (Presbyterian), and ⁠⁠Korey Maas⁠⁠ (Lutheran) to talk about they way confessional states operate in comparison to confessional churches. Are confessional states like England or Scotland stricter than their respective national churches? How strict can churches be when their punitive instruments are ministerial and declarative? Also, can confessional churches have more freedom in a liberal society that separates church and state than in one with an established church? Are confessional Lutherans and confessional Presbyterians in the United States more confessional than their counterparts in Europe where ecclesiastical establishments still exist?

News that led to these questions was first the decision of the Global Anglican Future Conference (GAFCON) to re-order the Anglican communion away from the See of Canterbury (which has functioned as "first among equals" among bishops). The reason for this resolve was the Church of England's General Synod's decision to bless same-sex unions.

This piece of ecclesiastical business dovetailed with an article about the new confessional state in Britain, one that is progressive and almost as restrictive as the old confessional state of England prior to the 1829 Emancipation of Roman Catholics (and related recognition of Protestant Dissenters. The essay about the new confessional state made the arresting point that the new terms of orthodoxy, because always evolving and independent of legal mechanisms, are illiberal. Under the old confessional state, subjects knew at least what the rules were and how to seek a remedy. But in the new confessional state, rules from a 2023 orthodoxy could substantially differ the "current thing" three years down the line.

This episode's sponsor is Brunswick, the company that puts the ow in bowling.

TOPICS