633: Leadership Starts with Listening with Abby Strong
Release Date: 09/24/2025
661: Why “Good Enough” Pet Care Isn’t Enough Anymore with Niki Tudge
Pet Sitter Confessional
What does “professional” pet care actually mean—and why does it matter so much right now? Collin sits down with Niki Tudge, founder of the Pet Professional Guild, to talk about the gap between what pet owners assume they’re buying and what many providers actually deliver. Niki shares the eye-opening real-life process she used to hire a pet sitter for her own dogs—and why it convinced her the industry needs higher minimum standards. Together, they discuss practical ways to educate clients, set non-negotiables, and document care like it truly matters. The conversation ends with a...
info_outline
660: Starting 2026 on the Right Foot
Pet Sitter Confessional
What if 2026 isn’t about doing more—but about doing what actually lasts? In this episode, we talk about why the end-of-year holiday rush can push pet sitters and dog walkers straight into toxic productivity. We walk through how to name what didn’t work in 2025 (without shame), especially where policies, boundaries, and overcommitment quietly drifted. Then we shift to what did work—life-giving habits, decisions that reduced stress, and systems that keep you steady even when you’re tired. Our goal is simple: a grounded, repeatable, sustainable 2026 built on consistency, not intensity....
info_outline
659: Giving Back Through Your Business with Cheyenne Williams
Pet Sitter Confessional
How can you use your pet care business to make a bigger impact? Cheyenne Williams returns to share how community involvement has transformed her life and her business. From leading suicide prevention walks to supporting foster care initiatives, Cheyenne explains how giving back is not just about writing checks—it’s about connection, purpose, and passion. She shares the challenges of balancing business demands with emotional nonprofit work, and how boundaries and clarity of purpose keep her grounded. This conversation is a powerful reminder that we were whole people before our businesses,...
info_outline
658: Converting Clients to New Services
Pet Sitter Confessional
What do we do when a service isn’t working anymore—but we don’t want to lose the revenue or the client? In this episode, we walk through how converting clients is leadership, not upselling, and why adding or changing a service isn’t a failure. We break down two conversion scenarios: when the service is a poor fit for the pet/client, and when it’s a poor fit for the business. We share practical strategies for leading with friction points, using observational authority, and making the transition feel low-risk through trials and clear replacement paths. We also talk about the reality...
info_outline
657: At The Crossroads in Pet Care with Matthew Kutas
Pet Sitter Confessional
What does the future of the pet service industry look like as technology and client expectations evolve? Matthew Kutas, founder and CEO of Republic of Dog, talks about the challenges and opportunities facing pet care businesses today. He discusses how technology can streamline operations without losing the emotional connection at the heart of the work, and why onboarding is a make-or-break process for client trust. Matthew shares insights on staffing, scaling, and the professionalization of the industry. He also explores how pet care intersects with city planning, corporate wellness, and...
info_outline
656: The Commodity Trap and How to Escape It
Pet Sitter Confessional
What happens when clients see your pet care business as interchangeable with everyone else? In this episode, we break down the commodity trap and why it’s not a pricing problem—it’s a positioning problem. We walk through the client, financial, and operational red flags that quietly signal your business is stuck competing on price. We explain why being more trained, more insured, and more professional often hurts more when the market doesn’t reward it. Finally, we share a practical framework for moving from commodity to chosen by selling outcomes, making your process visible, and...
info_outline
655: Building a Business Worth Buying with Erin Fenstermaker
Pet Sitter Confessional
Have you ever thought about what happens to your business when you’re ready to step away? In this episode, Erin Fenstermaker, certified exit planner and pet industry veteran, breaks down the key elements that make a pet business valuable and sellable. She discusses the importance of recurring revenue, documented systems, and building a team of employees over independent contractors. Erin also explains what EBITDA is, what influences it, and how emotional readiness impacts a successful exit. Whether you’re brand new or 30 years in, this conversation offers a roadmap to long-term value and...
info_outline
654: The Phrase That Changed Our Year
Pet Sitter Confessional
What if the key to protecting your business and sanity is actually learning to care less? In this episode, we share how our unorthodox Word of the Year—“care less”—helped us step back from constant urgency, emotional overload, and decision fatigue. We talk about naming our non-negotiables, especially around safety and standards, while letting go of guilt and overinvestment in pricing pushback, employee drama, and social media opinions. We walk through the practical tools we used, like decision deadlines, “good enough” standards, and release phrases that helped us move from dwelling...
info_outline
653: Fear Free Tools for Pet Sitters and Dog Walkers with Melissa Spooner-Raymond
Pet Sitter Confessional
for taking the ‘pet’ out of ‘petrified’. Get 10% off the with promo code PSC10. What does it really mean to be Fear Free certified as a pet sitter or dog walker? In this episode, Collin talks with Melissa Spooner-Raymond, a licensed veterinary technician and veterinary behavior specialist with Fear Free, about practical ways to reduce fear, anxiety, and stress for pets in our care. They explore reading body language, setting realistic goals for each visit, and using “the three Fs”—food, fun, and favorites—to create positive associations. Melissa shares real-world scenarios,...
info_outline
652: Avoiding the Ruts of Running a Business
Pet Sitter Confessional
What do you do when your pet care business feels stuck in the same old patterns? In this episode, we talk about how “ruts” form in our businesses the same way they do on a muddy trail—through repeated, unexamined habits over time. We explain the brain science behind habitual neural pathways, how stress and burnout make ruts deeper, and why comfort and fear of change keep us on the same path. We then walk through the three biggest rut zones for pet sitters and dog walkers: marketing, services, and admin overload, with practical questions to help you spot where you’re stuck. Finally, we...
info_outlineWhat does it take to transition your team from independent contractors to employees? Abby Strong, owner of Auntie Abby’s Professional Pet Sitting, returns to share how she nurtured a strong, supportive company culture while navigating major changes. She discusses the motivation behind dropping overnight services, onboarding employees with intention, and creating space for growth within her team. Abby also talks about the importance of feedback, both from clients and staff, and how being vulnerable as a leader builds trust. This episode is filled with practical advice for pet business owners ready to scale with purpose.
Main topics:
-
Transitioning to employee model
-
Building team communication culture
-
Letting go of overnight services
-
Leading with vulnerability and structure
-
Using client and staff feedback wisely
Main takeaway: “I walked into it thinking, can I afford to make this transition? I walked away realizing I can’t afford not to.”
That’s how Abby Strong describes her bold move from independent contractors to employees at Auntie Abby’s Professional Pet Sitting. With a growing team, a commitment to consistency, and a deep desire to protect her staff, Abby knew something had to change. Making the leap came with risk—but also with clarity. Sometimes, leadership means trusting your gut, listening to your community, and building the structure your business truly needs. If you’re at a crossroads, maybe it’s time to ask: can I really afford not to make this move?
About our guest: Hello! I am Abby Strong, owner and founder of Auntie Abby’s Professional Pet Sitting Service in Des Moines, IA. I opened my business in October 2019 as a solo provider driven by my profound passion for animals and their welfare. I quickly realized there was a tremendous need for quality, trustworthy pet care providers where animals are most comfortable: in their own homes! I truly feel pets are best served by staying in their regular environment while maintaining their normal routine. Turns out I was right, as I also quickly booked myself 7 days a week from 6AM to often 10PM with walks, visits and overnight jobs in clients homes. 1.5 years later, I reached a point where I needed to make a big decision: I could either continue working as a solo sitter, working at a crazy, unsustainable pace and having zero free time, or I could hire. Despite some initial trepidation that no one could do the job as well as I did, I took the plunge and starting interviewing job candidates. I never looked back!
As of today, we have grown to a team of 21 phenomenal pet sitters and dog walkers. I aspire to continue that growth. It’s hard to articulate just how proud I am of this team. We’ve had amazing success due to our incredible attention to detail, stellar client communication, professionalism and true love, adoration and respect for each animal entrusted to our care. Our sitters truly take the time to meet each pet at their level and provide an enriching, enjoyable experience. It is immensely rewarding to know my passion is shared by so many others. We believe that a carefully tailored care plan makes each pet visit highly enriching and highly anticipated. We are met with much joy and excitement by each pet and the feeling is reciprocal. Tail wags, leaps of joy, wiggles, monetary tips for exceptional service, repeat business and heartfelt client testimonials fill our hearts and let us know we are indeed in the right business!
Links:
info@auntieabbyspetsitting.com
Check out ProTrainings
Code: CPR-petsitterconfessional for 10% off
📞 Call us: (636) 364-8260
Follow us on: Instagram, Facebook, Twitter
Email us at: petsitterconfessional@gmail.com
Full show notes and transcript
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by our guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect those of Pet Sitter Confessional, its hosts, or sponsors. We interview individuals based on their experience and expertise within the pet care industry. Any statements made outside of this platform, or unrelated to the topic discussed, are solely the responsibility of the guest.
Sponsored by:
❤️ Our AMAZING Patreon Supporters
Time to Pet
Visit: https://timetopet.com/confessional
Code: 50% off first 3 months
Pet Perennials
Visit: https://petperennials.com/pages/register-for-a-business-account
Code: 'PSC' when registering for a $2 off coupon on any purchases in the 1st 90 days