Annuity Default Risk-Why Consumers Fear What Almost Never Happens
Insurance Pro Blog Podcast | Life Insurance and Annuity Insights
Release Date: 05/10/2026
Annuity Default Risk-Why Consumers Fear What Almost Never Happens
Insurance Pro Blog Podcast | Life Insurance and Annuity Insights
If you've ever hesitated on an annuity because you weren't sure the insurance company would actually pay, you're not alone. Recent academic research found that consumers expect to receive only about 82 cents on the dollar from an annuity contract. Roughly 89% of people price in some chance that the insurer simply stops paying. The actual data tells a very different story. A 47-year study from AM Best shows zero impairments among carriers rated A or higher in 2024, and an average annual impairment rate of just 0.24% for A- and A-rated companies across the full study period. There is no...
info_outline
Should You Buy a RILA? A Skeptical Analysis of Buffer Annuities, Their Niche Use Cases, and When to Walk Away
Insurance Pro Blog Podcast | Life Insurance and Annuity Insights
A note before we begin: RILAs are registered securities, and we don't sell them. We sell fixed annuities — SPIAs, MYGAs, and fixed indexed annuities. This conversation is educational, not a recommendation for or against any specific product. RILAs — registered index-linked annuities — are the fastest-growing annuity category by new premium, with sales reaching $79.5 billion in 2025. That's more than ten times what the category produced a decade ago, and 2024 was the first year RILAs outsold traditional variable annuities. Rapid sales growth doesn't automatically mean a product belongs...
info_outline
We Tried to Blow Up an IUL Policy — How Bad Does Your IUL Design Have to Be Before It Actually Fails?
Insurance Pro Blog Podcast | Life Insurance and Annuity Insights
There's a persistent claim that indexed universal life insurance is doomed to fail because rising costs of insurance will eventually eat the policy alive. The story usually goes something like this: someone bought a universal life policy decades ago, paid faithfully, and one day got a notice that the policy was about to lapse unless they wrote a big check. That story has a grain of truth behind it, but the magnitude of the claim is wildly overstated. The original problem traces back to universal life policies sold in the 1980s as cheap alternatives to whole life. Those sales relied on...
info_outline
Are Whole Life Dividends Finally Rising Again? A 10-Year Analysis of the Top Six Mutual Insurance Companies in 2026
Insurance Pro Blog Podcast | Life Insurance and Annuity Insights
After years of declining dividend rates during the low-interest-rate era, every major mutual life insurance company in our latest analysis is trending upward. This is the first update to our flagship whole life dividend analysis since 2020, and the shift is hard to miss. We walk through 10 years of dividend interest rate data for Guardian, MassMutual, Northwestern Mutual, New York Life, Penn Mutual, and Lafayette Life. You'll hear why you can't directly compare one company's rate to another's, and why the intra-company trend is what actually matters. We talk through what's driving the...
info_outline
Whole Life Insurance vs Bonds-The Surprising Bond Alternative for Retirement
Insurance Pro Blog Podcast | Life Insurance and Annuity Insights
In 2022, the Bloomberg U.S. Aggregate Bond Index lost over 13%. Stocks and bonds fell at the same time, and the core promise of the 60/40 portfolio — that bonds protect you when equities drop — broke down completely. If you're a high-income investor relying on bonds for the "safe money" portion of your portfolio, that year should have raised a serious question: what actually belongs in that allocation? Three independent academic studies offer a surprising answer. Research from Ernst & Young found that integrating permanent life insurance as a fixed-income component produced...
info_outline
Do Annuities Keep Up With Inflation? How to Build Inflation Protection Into Your Retirement Income Plan
Insurance Pro Blog Podcast | Life Insurance and Annuity Insights
At just 3% average inflation, a retiree's dollar loses 45% of its value in 20 years and 59% in 30 years. If you're relying on a fixed income in retirement, that math is working against you every single year. The good news is that annuities don't have to mean a static income that slowly loses its purchasing power. There are two practical ways to address the problem. The first is a cost-of-living adjustment rider built into the annuity itself, which increases your income by a set percentage each year. The second is a laddering strategy where you purchase more than one annuity and stagger when...
info_outline
Why High-Income Earners Need a Tax-Free Retirement Income Strategy (and How Life Insurance Delivers It)
Insurance Pro Blog Podcast | Life Insurance and Annuity Insights
Most people saving for retirement have almost everything in one tax bucket — 401(k)s, traditional IRAs, and other qualified accounts where every dollar withdrawn comes with a tax bill. That's not a disaster, but it's inflexible. And inflexibility in retirement is where real problems start. This episode walks through a three-bucket framework for thinking about retirement income: tax-deferred, tax-free, and how they work together. You'll hear why qualified accounts still deserve a place in your plan — a married couple can recognize nearly $100,000 in income and stay in the 12% bracket —...
info_outline
What Is a Life Insurance Retirement Plan (LIRP) and Is It Worth It for High-Income Earners?
Insurance Pro Blog Podcast | Life Insurance and Annuity Insights
The life insurance retirement plan — or LIRP — sounds like a special financial product with its own set of rules. It's not. It's a marketing term for something much simpler: an overfunded cash value life insurance policy designed to build wealth you can access in retirement. That doesn't make it a bad idea. It just means you deserve a straight explanation of what it actually is before deciding if it belongs in your plan. The real strategy behind a LIRP involves buying a permanent life insurance policy — whole life, indexed universal life, or in rare cases variable universal life — and...
info_outline
Are Annuities Too Complicated? A Simple Breakdown of Every Major Annuity Type
Insurance Pro Blog Podcast | Life Insurance and Annuity Insights
"Annuities are too complicated" is one of the most common objections in retirement planning. But that statement treats every annuity as if it's the same product, and they're not even close. This episode walks through each major annuity type — from single premium immediate annuities and MYGAs to fixed indexed annuities, variable annuities, and RILAs — and gives each one an honest complexity rating. Some are about as straightforward as a CD. Others require real homework before you sign. The income rider gets special attention because it's the single most misunderstood feature in the annuity...
info_outline
When Does Indexed Universal Life Insurance Underperform Whole Life? A 30-Year Scenario Analysis
Insurance Pro Blog Podcast | Life Insurance and Annuity Insights
Indexed universal life insurance should outperform whole life insurance over the long run — that's the expectation. But how far do cap rates, participation rates, and spreads need to fall before that advantage disappears? We ran 30-year rolling scenarios using S&P 500 data from 1980 through 2025 to find out. The analysis accounts for policy expenses and strips out bonuses and minimum floors to keep the comparison conservative. The short answer: IUL has to get a lot worse before it just matches whole life expectations. A cap rate below 8%, a participation rate around 40%, or a spread near...
info_outlineIf you've ever hesitated on an annuity because you weren't sure the insurance company would actually pay, you're not alone. Recent academic research found that consumers expect to receive only about 82 cents on the dollar from an annuity contract. Roughly 89% of people price in some chance that the insurer simply stops paying.
The actual data tells a very different story. A 47-year study from AM Best shows zero impairments among carriers rated A or higher in 2024, and an average annual impairment rate of just 0.24% for A- and A-rated companies across the full study period. There is no evidence of a rated insurer failing to pay an annuity benefit it had guaranteed.
That gap between perception and reality has real consequences. The same research estimates that if consumers understood how reliably annuity benefits get paid, ownership would roughly quadruple. People are leaving guaranteed lifetime income on the table because of a risk that almost never materializes.
A lot of this pessimism likely comes from experience with home, auto, and health insurance, which operate under completely different rules. Life insurance and annuities are not zero-sum risk pools where someone has to lose for someone else to win. They are built on long-horizon investment management inside the insurer's general account, and the industry has been doing this successfully for over a century.
We also walk through the state guaranty system that backstops annuities up to at least $250,000 in every state, which most consumers do not even know exists. Awareness of this safety net is so low that it does not influence purchasing behavior, even among more sophisticated investors.
____________________________________
If you are five to ten years from retirement, or already retired and tired of managing market risk yourself, it is worth considering what guaranteed income could do for you with an open mind. The product landscape today is not what most people think it is. Schedule a call or message us, and we can walk through whether it makes sense for your situation.
To read more about annuity default risk visit our article, Annuity Default Risk: Why Consumers Fear Almost Never Happens