loader from loading.io

Episode 138 Peter Gray on reconsidering what we know about schooling and learning

Lars og Pål

Release Date: 01/31/2024

Episode 143 Kritiske randbemerkninger til kritisk pedagogikk show art Episode 143 Kritiske randbemerkninger til kritisk pedagogikk

Lars og Pål

I denne episoden snakker vi om en retning innenfor pedagogikken kalt kritisk pedagogikk, med kjente navn som Paolo Freire og Henri Girioux som noen av de viktigste teoretikerne. Vi er mildt sagt kritiske, for denne teoritradisjonen, som påstår å være kritisk til det etablerte, er så belemret med en språklig vaghet at den tilsynelatende ofte ikke klarer å forholde seg kritisk til egne teorier.  Så hvorfor er det slik, hvorfor har vi denne tendensen til slik tungrodd og uklart språk innenfor et fagområde som pedagogikken, som kaller seg frigjørende og kritisk men som sjelden...

info_outline
Episode 142 The bright side of adolescence, with Chris Balme show art Episode 142 The bright side of adolescence, with Chris Balme

Lars og Pål

On this episode I talk to Chris Balme, the author of the book Finding the Magic in Middle School (2022) and the founder of the Millennium School, an alternative middle school in San Francisco.  We talk about what makes people enter the strange and confusing world of alternative education, and what sort of lessons Chris has learned from working with adolescents in an alternative education setting. How come we at the same time have both too low and too high expectations of adolescents, and how do we talk to parents and kids about these expectations? We cover a wide range of topics, from...

info_outline
Episode 141 Hva vi har lært om læring så langt show art Episode 141 Hva vi har lært om læring så langt

Lars og Pål

I denne episoden oppsummerer Lars og Pål en rekke spørsmål om læring og skole fra de siste episodene på podkasten. Vi er ikke alltid helt enige, og blir det ikke alltid heller, men det kan faktisk være at vi har blitt littegrann klokere.  Vi fokuserer særlig på motsetninger og forbisnakk mellom David Geary og Peter Gray (jf ep.127 og 138), om hva det betyr at barn sier at de trives på skolen, om progressiv pedagogikk og eksplisitt instruksjon (ep.139), klassebakgrunn og kjedsomhet i skolen (ep.103), hvor mye av skolesystemet som tas for gitt i mange skolediskusjoner, indre og...

info_outline
Episode 140 Hvor vil vi med skolen? Med Alexander Meyer show art Episode 140 Hvor vil vi med skolen? Med Alexander Meyer

Lars og Pål

Alexander Meyer er tilbake på podkasten, og vi diskuterer litt av responsen han har fått på boken Det store skolespranget (Universitetsforlaget 2020), John Hattie, tvangens usynlighet, lærerens autoritet og mangel på sådan, motsetningen mellom progressiv og tradisjonell pedagogikk, problemer med elevsentrerte pedagogiske ideer, kunnskap vs ideologi, hvordan barn bruker mer tid i skolen uten at vi dermed har fått bedre resultater, om skolen skal oppdra barn, Direct Instruction, hva vi bør forvente fra god utdanningsforskning, hvilke spørsmål og hypoteser vi ikke utforsker i...

info_outline
Episode 139 Stanislaw Pstrokonski from Education Bookcast show art Episode 139 Stanislaw Pstrokonski from Education Bookcast

Lars og Pål

On this episode I talk to Stanislaw Pstrokonski, the host of the wonderful podcast Education Bookcast. The podcast has been running since 2016, and on it Staś has been covering education books and research in more detail that what is commonly done in the education podcast world. We talk about what he has learned from doing the podcast, some of his favorite episodes and topics, how he has changed his mind and what prompted these changes, and what a good conversation about the school of the future should look like.  We discuss the different basic outlooks of people in discussing education...

info_outline
Episode 138 Peter Gray on reconsidering what we know about schooling and learning show art Episode 138 Peter Gray on reconsidering what we know about schooling and learning

Lars og Pål

In this podcast episode returning guest Peter Gray, retired professor of psychology at Boston College, makes an argument for why we should consider other ways of understanding and structuring learning in and outside of school. We talk about college and access to working life, possible alternative ways of learning an occupation, David Geary’s evolutionary theory of biologically primary and secondary abilities, what we need to learn and when we need to learn it, what we can observe in kids who aren’t taught in the conventional ways, kids who learn to read on their own or who learn the whole...

info_outline
Episode 137 Christian Lomsdalen om etikk i læreryrket og andre skoletema show art Episode 137 Christian Lomsdalen om etikk i læreryrket og andre skoletema

Lars og Pål

Christian Lomsdalen, den produktive mannen bak Lektor Lomsdalens innfall (startet i 2016, 559 episoder per dags dato), er en av veteranene i den norske skolepodkastverdenen. Christian har i mange år vært lektor i videregående skole, men er nå stipendiat ved Universitetet i Bergen, hvor han forsker på fritaksretten i skolen. Siden 2021 har han vært styreleder i Human-Etisk Forbund. Han lager også podkastene Tanketrigger, PedSexPod og Frokostkaffen, og er en aktiv samfunnsdebattant.  Nylig ga han ut boken Burde vi det? Profesjonsfaglig etisk kompetanse i skolen på...

info_outline
Episode 136 David F. Bjorklund on evolution, development and learning show art Episode 136 David F. Bjorklund on evolution, development and learning

Lars og Pål

What role does our evolutionary history play in how we learn? Is it even useful to look and try to determine what’s «natural» for us humans? In what way does our biology determine what is good for us? Did evolution «design» us to be happy? What is evolutionary mismatch? What sort of skills require explicit instruction? How do we balance this need with the developmental need for autonomy and independence, which kids in our current culture get less of than before? Why is it developmentally useful to be cognitively immature, and why are young kids natural optimists?  These and many...

info_outline
Episode 135 Natalie Wexler on the role of knowledge in education show art Episode 135 Natalie Wexler on the role of knowledge in education

Lars og Pål

In this episode Lars speaks with Natalie Wexler about the role of knowledge in learning, and of knowledge rich curriculums in school. We discuss the reception of E.D. Hirsch, the importance of content for writing and reading instruction, the relationship between skills and knowledge, curriculum debates and culture wars, testing reading comprehension, Bloom’s taxonomy, Montessori pedagogy, and much more.  Natalie Wexler has published two books relevant to the topic of our conversation: The Knowledge Gap (2019) and The Writing Revolution (2017), the last one together with Judith C....

info_outline
Episode 134 Anders G. Kjøstvedt om holocaustundervising i skolen og nazistbevegelsens historie show art Episode 134 Anders G. Kjøstvedt om holocaustundervising i skolen og nazistbevegelsens historie

Lars og Pål

Anders Granås Kjøstvedt har forsket på den tidlige nazistbevegelsen, samt hvordan vi underviser om krigen og Holocaust i skolen. Han arbeider også med hvordan demokratiske verdier og kunnskaper formidles i skolen, særlig i samfunnsfag.  I denne samtalen forteller Anders om historien til nazistbevegelsen i Tyskland, landets politiske strømninger etter første verdenskrig, Hitlers rolle og den milde straffen som han får etter det første kuppforsøket i 1923, hva slags oppslutning nazistene oppnådde blant befolkningen og hvorfor, både før og under krigen. Deretter snakker vi om...

info_outline
 
More Episodes

In this podcast episode returning guest Peter Gray, retired professor of psychology at Boston College, makes an argument for why we should consider other ways of understanding and structuring learning in and outside of school. We talk about college and access to working life, possible alternative ways of learning an occupation, David Geary’s evolutionary theory of biologically primary and secondary abilities, what we need to learn and when we need to learn it, what we can observe in kids who aren’t taught in the conventional ways, kids who learn to read on their own or who learn the whole math curriculum in a couple of months in their late teens, how our expectations influence learning, consequences for not reading when society expects you to, how and when children learn to walk and what we do when they don’t, whining in different cultures, the summer slide, and what to say when people complain that they wish that someone had forced them to learn something earlier in life, how children’s independence and autonomy relates to their mental health, how we try to fix problems by taking away children’s liberty and responsibility, why we should teach them about dangers instead of trying to get rid of them, and many other topics. 

Even if you don’t find yourself agreeing with all of Peter’s arguments, we would love to hear more about what points he’s making that you think are valid and worth considering. How can we let alternative views on education actually widen our current understanding of learning and schooling, instead of just assuming the worst about each other? Send un an email to [email protected], we’ll be thankful to every kind of criticism, feedback and suggestions of further explorations and interviews that we should do on these topics. 

See more of Peter’s writings on his Substack https://petergray.substack.com/

Here’s his 2017 article about the summer slide, mentioned in the episode: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/freedom-learn/201707/facts-and-fiction-about-the-so-called-summer-slide

 

Mentions and recommendations from the episode: 

  • Jim Rietmulder, 2019. When Kids Rule the School: The Power and Promise of Democratic Education. New Society Publishers. 
  • Kerry McDonald, 2019. Unschooled: Raising Curious, Well-Educated Children Outside the Conventional Classroom. Chicago Review Press. 
  • David Graeber og David Wengrow. 2021. The Dawn of Everything: A New History of Humanity. Allen Lane.
  • Harriet Pattison. 2016. Rethinking Learning to Read. Educational Heretics Press. 
  • Elizabeth Marshall Thomas. 2007. The Old Ways: A Story of the First People. Picador. 
  • danah boyd. 2014. It’s Complicated: The Social Lives of Networked Teens. Yale University Press. 
  • Peter Gray. 2013. Free to Learn: : Why Unleashing the Instinct to Play Will Make Our Children Happier, More Self-Reliant, and Better Students for Life. Basic Books
  • Peter Gray, David Lancy, David F. Bjorklund. 2023. «Decline in Independent Activity as a Cause of Decline in Children’s Mental Wellbeing: Summary of the Evidence» February 2023, The Journal of Pediatrics 260(2)

 

Peter was previously a guest on the podcast in episode 53: 

https://larsogpaal.libsyn.com/episode-53-peter-gray-on-self-directed-education-and-schooling

----------------------------

Our logo is by Sveinung Sudbø, see his works on originalkopi.com

The music is by Arne Kjelsrud Mathisen, see the facebook page Nygrenda Vev og Dur for more info. 

----------------------------

Thank you for listening. Please send feedback and questions to [email protected]

There is no better way for the podcast to gain new interested listener than by you sharing it with friends, so if you find what we do interesting and useful, please consider doing just that. The podcast is still most in Norwegian, but we have a lot of episodes coming out in English. 

Our blogs:

https://paljabekk.com/

https://larssandaker.blogspot.com/

Alt godt, hilsen Lars og Pål