Rethinking Nonprofit Program Evaluation with Kayla Meyers
Release Date: 10/21/2025
Innovation Starts with Nonprofit and Association Culture with Elizabeth Engel and Jamie Notter
Nonprofit Mission: Impact
In episode 136 of Nonprofit Mission: Impact, Carol Hamilton, Elizabeth Engel, and Jamie Notter talk about their new white paper Lean at 10: Culture Eats Methodology for Lunch. Ten years after Engel first explored Lean Startup principles in the nonprofit and association world, she and Notter revisit what’s changed—and what hasn’t. Carol, Elizabeth and Jamie discuss: Why the tools of innovation are accessible, yet the real challenge in adoption lies in organizational culture. how competing commitments, fear of failure, and rigid silos can quietly sabotage innovation efforts ...
info_outline
Designing nonprofits for impact with Julian Chender
Nonprofit Mission: Impact
In episode 135 of Nonprofit Mission: Impact, Carol Hamilton talks with organizational design consultant Julian Chender about how nonprofits can move beyond simple restructuring to intentional organizational design that aligns strategy, structure, and process. They discuss: how organizational design is not the same as restructuring how design choices impact effectiveness, collaboration, and long-term sustainability. the pitfalls of designing around personalities, the importance of strategic clarity when facing downsizing or merger decisions. The conversation...
info_outline
Rethinking Nonprofit Program Evaluation with Kayla Meyers
Nonprofit Mission: Impact
In episode 134 of Nonprofit Mission: Impact, host Carol Hamilton welcomes guest Kayla Meyers, founder of Bridgepoint Evaluation, for a conversation about reimagining program evaluation in nonprofits. They discuss: Why evaluation is not an audit or judgment as it has sometimes been in the past It should be a collaborative, curiosity-driven process that opens communication, supports learning, and improves impact. How to create right-sized, useful evaluation practices rooted in strategy and driven by purpose. How evaluation can be a force for good—helping organizations...
info_outline
Creating Safer Nonprofit Spaces with Paula Brantner
Nonprofit Mission: Impact
In episode 133 of Nonprofit Mission: Impact, host Carol Hamilton and guest Paula Brantner, workplace fairness consultant and founder of Accountability Ignited, unpack the real challenges nonprofits face in preventing harassment, bullying, and misconduct. They talk about: The often-overlooked gaps in nonprofit systems—particularly around reporting mechanisms—and The false sense of security many mission-driven organizations have about their immunity to these issues. How to take a proactive, values-based approach rooted in trauma-informed practices, Why codes...
info_outline
Demystifying Government Grants for nonprofit leaders with Justine Krank
Nonprofit Mission: Impact
In episode 132 of Nonprofit Mission: Impact, Carol Hamilton and Justine Krank discuss the realities and nuances of pursuing US government grants for nonprofit organizations. They discuss: common misconceptions including that government grants equals federal grants The challenges and compliance demands that come with government dollars. How to decode complex RFPs -- the hidden requirements that can make or break an application, and how to get an organization truly grant-ready — not just on paper, but with the capacity to manage the work. why the human side of...
info_outline
When the Stakes Are High: Centering People in Tough Nonprofit Leadership Moments with Melissa Kessler
Nonprofit Mission: Impact
In episode 131 of Nonprofit Mission: Impact, Carol Hamilton and Melissa Kessler explore the intersection of communications and organization development, particularly in moments of crisis, transition and change. They talk about how internal communications can either reinforce or undermine values, strategy, and humanity within an organization. how to navigate layoffs, restructuring, or organizational shifts with humanity why how we communicate is just as important as what we decide. Episode highlights: 💬 “It’s a Communications Problem” – Or Is It? [00:09:27]...
info_outline
Nonprofits Under Attack: Defending Democracy, Community, and Innovation with Carol Hamilton
Nonprofit Mission: Impact
In episode 130 of Nonprofit Mission: Impact, Carol reflects on five years of podcasting and the sobering state of the nonprofit sector in 2025. While celebrating milestones, she also underscores the challenges nonprofits face amidst unprecedented political attacks, funding cuts, and threats to long-standing principles like nonpartisanship. Despite these challenges, Carol highlights the resilience, innovation, and critical role nonprofits play in society—from filling essential gaps to fueling social movements, strengthening democracy, and sparking innovation. She calls on nonprofit leaders to...
info_outline
Tribute: Fundraising Without Fear: Building Relationships That Fuel Your Nonprofit Mission with Sabrina Walker-Hernandez
Nonprofit Mission: Impact
In this episode of Nonprofit Mission: Impact, Carol Hamilton gives a tribute to nonprofit consulting star and nonprofit governance and fundraising expert Sabrina Walker Hernandez, President & CEO of Building Better Boards, by re-releasing their conversation from 2021. Ms. Hernandez passed away in July 2025 after a long battle with cancer. Episode highlights: [00:06:45] Finding Her Why: From Law to Nonprofit Service [00:13:00] Breaking Down the Fundraising Cycle [00:18:30] A Mantra for Courage: It’s Not About You [00:21:15] Helping Board Members Identify Donors: The List Generator...
info_outline
Building psychological safety in nonprofit organizations with Michael Randel
Nonprofit Mission: Impact
In episode 128 of Nonprofit Mission: Impact, Michael Randel joins Carol to explore how psychological safety—often dismissed as a “soft” concept—plays a critical role in nonprofit team performance, learning, and innovation. They discuss: The connection between organizational readiness and the deeper human dynamics that shape effective leadership and collaboration. What psychological safety looks like in action, Why it’s vital in today’s polarized climate, How nonprofit leaders can foster inclusive, high-trust environments where people feel safe to...
info_outline
From Guilt to Responsibility: A white nonprofit leaders journey into equity work with Cat Lazaroff
Nonprofit Mission: Impact
In episode 127 of Mission: Impact, Carol Hamilton speaks with Cat Lazaroff. They talk about her work around engaging white-led and majority-white organizations in meaningful culture change to more inclusive, diverse and equitable cultures. They explore: how nonprofit leaders, especially white leaders, can begin and sustain their own equity learning journeys. Privilege, identity, conflict, organizational culture, and the necessity of holding multiple truths. how culture transformation isn’t about quick fixes, but rather long-term commitments, courageous relationships,...
info_outlineIn episode 134 of Nonprofit Mission: Impact, host Carol Hamilton welcomes guest Kayla Meyers, founder of Bridgepoint Evaluation, for a conversation about reimagining program evaluation in nonprofits.
They discuss:
-
Why evaluation is not an audit or judgment as it has sometimes been in the past
-
It should be a collaborative, curiosity-driven process that opens communication, supports learning, and improves impact.
-
How to create right-sized, useful evaluation practices rooted in strategy and driven by purpose.
-
How evaluation can be a force for good—helping organizations tell fuller, more meaningful stories about their work and the communities they serve.
Episode highlights:
🚩 Evaluation’s Troubled History - [00:08:10]
❌ From Punitive to Collaborative - [00:13:10]
💡 Why Smaller Orgs Should Evaluate - [00:16:10]
🛠️ Start with Strategy - [00:19:10]
🔁 Formalizing Feedback Loops - [00:20:40]
🍽️ Make It Make Sense - [00:22:10]
🗣️ Turning Data Into Stories - [00:26:10]
❓The One Question Nonprofit Leaders Should Ask - [00:31:50]
Guest Bio:
Kayla (Mueller) Meyers is a seasoned program evaluator with over a decade of experience in assessing and improving programs for nonprofits and public organizations. She specializes in evaluation capacity building and mixed-methods program evaluation, bringing a wealth of knowledge and expertise to her clients
Important Links and Resources:
Bridgepoint Evaluation Newsletter
Humphrey School of Public Affairs
Be in Touch:
✉️ Subscribe to Carol’s newsletter at Grace Social Sector Consulting and receive the Common Mistakes Nonprofits Make In Strategic Planning And How To Avoid Them
📚Find the books referred to on Nonprofit Mission: Impact
👥 Like what you heard? Please share the podcast with a colleague or friend
🌟 Help more people learn about Nonprofit Mission: Impact by leaving a rating & review.
😀 Connect with Carol Hamilton ➡️ LinkedIn