loader from loading.io

Debunking Doug Andrew’s Roth IRA Hit Job Video

The Power Of Zero Show

Release Date: 04/30/2025

Vanguard--4 to 5% Stock Market Growth Over Next 10 Years (Should You Change Your Retirement Strategy?) show art Vanguard--4 to 5% Stock Market Growth Over Next 10 Years (Should You Change Your Retirement Strategy?)

The Power Of Zero Show

In this episode of the Power of Zero Show, David McKnight looks at headlines, such as those from Vanguard, BlackRock or Morningstar, that have predicted a dismal forecast for stock market returns over the next decade. Since such articles predict 4-5% annual growth for the next decade, many investors are pondering whether they should take some chips off the table. Back in 2015, those same institutions and companies stressed that valuations were too high and that, since the markets had a great run, it couldn’t possibly continue anymore. Vanguard forecasted 4-6% returns, BlackRock predicted...

info_outline
Should You Take Social Security Early Given the Scary Trust Fund Report? show art Should You Take Social Security Early Given the Scary Trust Fund Report?

The Power Of Zero Show

The 2025 Social Security Trustees Report is out and the news is bleak. This episode of the Power of Zero Show looks at the potential repercussions if nothing changes by 2033. If things don't improve, Social Security will face a cash flow deficit that triggers a 23% across-the-board benefit cut - and that's one year earlier than predicted. But that's not all… in fact, it gets far worse, says host David McKnight. The system is already $72.8 trillion in the red, an unfunded liability that's twice the size of the national debt and $10 trillion worse than 2024. This is by no means a temporary...

info_outline
The Vindication of Indexed Universal Life and Fixed Indexed Annuities: What the Ernst & Young Study Finally Proves show art The Vindication of Indexed Universal Life and Fixed Indexed Annuities: What the Ernst & Young Study Finally Proves

The Power Of Zero Show

Ernst & Young recently came out with a new updated study, which is likely to scandalize mainstream financial experts like they did with their 2021 study. Back then, they asked the question, “Is the stock market-only retirement approach really the strategy that gives you the highest levels of income and the best outcomes over a 30-year retirement?” In their new study, on the other hand, they substituted Indexed Universal Life for Whole Life, and Fixed Index Annuities for Deferred Income Annuities – a move that led to unexpected and spectacular results.  Host David McKnight...

info_outline
Can Republicans Actually Make the Trump Tax Cuts Permanent? show art Can Republicans Actually Make the Trump Tax Cuts Permanent?

The Power Of Zero Show

President Trump’s proposed Big Beautiful Bill (BBB), which has been getting everyone’s attention of late, is the topic of this episode of The Power of Zero Show.  Host David McKnight points out that the “crown jewel” of the BBB is the extension of the 2017 Trump tax cuts. The 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCGA) brought about cuts to individual income taxes, corporate taxes, and a dramatic expansion of the estate tax exemption. While corporate tax cuts were made permanent – going from 35% to 21% – the tax cuts for individuals and estates had an expiration date. If the status quo...

info_outline
Doug Andrew: Consider Rolling Your IRA into an IUL (Good idea?) show art Doug Andrew: Consider Rolling Your IRA into an IUL (Good idea?)

The Power Of Zero Show

David McKnight addresses Doug Andrew’s recommendation of turning your IRA into an IUL. David agrees with some of Andrew’s views, including his objection to rolling a 401(k) into an IRA, and then leaving it there until you die. Given the exploding national debt, most experts predict that taxes 10 years from now will have to rise dramatically to keep the U.S. solvent… Doug Andrew lists Indexed Universal Life as his “favorite financial vehicle because of liquidity, safety, predictable rates of return, and tax-free growth”. David is skeptical of advice that denigrates every tax-free...

info_outline
Financial Collapse in 3 Years? show art Financial Collapse in 3 Years?

The Power Of Zero Show

This episode of The Power of Zero Show revolves around a recent Ray Dalio video in which he issued warnings about the U.S. debt crisis. In the clip, Dalio appears to be giving America three years to get their act together and to right the fiscal ship of state. Dalio mentions the draft of his new book that goes through the mechanics of the debt – and highlights the supply-demand problem he believes will occur if the deficit doesn’t go from the current 7.2% of GDP to about 3% of GDP. Dalio touches upon what people should do when there isn’t an adequate supply-demand balance. He believes...

info_outline
Will Safe Harbor Rules Protect You If You Do a 4th Quarter Roth Conversion? show art Will Safe Harbor Rules Protect You If You Do a 4th Quarter Roth Conversion?

The Power Of Zero Show

David McKnight looks at why many people wait until the fourth quarter to do a Roth conversion, the potential penalties, and what can be done to avoid having to pay underpayment penalties to the IRS. David begins the episode by highlighting the fact that a lot of investors wait until Q4 before they do a Roth conversion – and they prefer to pay taxes on it in cash instead of simply having the taxes withheld by the IRS. From a mathematical standpoint, it’s the correct thing to do because it allows you to get 100% of the converted dollars into your tax-free account. However, if you didn’t...

info_outline
How to Avoid the Roth Over-Conversion Trap show art How to Avoid the Roth Over-Conversion Trap

The Power Of Zero Show

In today’s episode, David McKnight focuses on whether you should do a Roth conversion, how much you should convert per year, and whether it’s possible to over-convert to Roth. David explains that an effective tax rate is the actual percentage of your income that you pay in taxes after accounting for deductions, exemptions, and credits. For David, the only reason you should do a Roth conversion is if you believe that your effective tax rate in retirement will be higher than your marginal tax rate today. David touches upon a couple of reasons why your effective tax rate in retirement could...

info_outline
The Problem with Target Date Funds show art The Problem with Target Date Funds

The Power Of Zero Show

David McKnight looks at Target Date Funds (TDFs) and why their set-it-and-forget-it approach to investing is NOT something you should rely on. David kicks things off by explaining how TDFs work, including why they tend to be a popular option for novice investors. While it sounds like an excellent approach, David points out two major flaws. “A lot of the problems with TDFs come down to sustainable withdrawal rates in retirement,” says David. The 4% Rule consists of you being able to withdraw 4% of your day one balance in retirement, adjusted every year thereafter for inflation....

info_outline
I've Maxed Out My 401(k), Now What? show art I've Maxed Out My 401(k), Now What?

The Power Of Zero Show

In this episode of the Power of Zero Show, host David McKnight discusses the scenario in which you have maxed out your 401(k) and are wondering where you should invest the rest of your money. The episode kicks off with David addressing the type of 401(k)s you should be investing in first. There are two types of 401(k)s: the traditional pre-tax 401(k) and the Roth 401(k). Should you go for a traditional 401(k) or a Roth 401(k)? It all depends on whether you think your tax bracket is likely to be lower or higher in retirement… With the national debt set to hit $62 trillion by the year 2035,...

info_outline
 
More Episodes

In this episode of The Power of Zero Show, host David McKnight looks at Doug Andrew’s recent video in which he implored his audience to never use a Roth IRA or a Roth 401(k) again.

Andrew sees Indexed Universal Life insurance (IUL) as far superior and believes it should be the source of the vast majority of your distributions in retirement.

While David likes IUL in certain circumstances, he isn’t a fan of sales strategies that debase every other viable tax-free alternative in an effort to exalt IULs.

For David, the video is riffed with errors, exaggerations and omissions.

Moreover, Andrew’s video appears to have an obvious pre-commitment to persuading you to reposition the lion’s share of your retirement savings into an IUL.

In the video, Doug Andrew’s liking for IUL as the top investment vehicle is evident.

At the beginning of his video, Andrew says that he will explain why the IUL is far superior to the Roth IRA.

David believes that the choice should never be between a Roth IRA and an IUL or between a Roth 401(k) and an IUL.

Remember: your tax-free strategy can incorporate as many as SIX DIFFERENT STREAMS of tax-free income, not just the IUL…

And every one of these tax-free income strategies has unique qualities that set them apart from all the others.

Don’t forget about what your #1 goal should be: to take advantage of every tax-free nook and cranny in the IRS tax code.

David lists the qualities that tools such as Roth IRAs, Roth 401(k)s and Roth conversions have and that IULs do not have.

One of the unique things about IULs is that they give you a death benefit that doubles as long-term care and helps grow your money safely and productively.

David touches upon what he considers “wild claims” featured in Doug Andrew’s video.

An example of inaccurate or untrue information shared by Andrew is that the IUL’s expenses will be paid out of the money that would have otherwise gone to pay a tax… which is wrong!

Contributions to Roth IRAs and IULs are both made with after-tax dollars.

“If anyone ever debases a Roth IRA or a Roth 401(k) in an attempt to sell you an IUL, you should run – not walk – the other way,” concludes David.

 



Mentioned in this episode:

David’s national bestselling book: The Guru Gap: How America’s Financial Gurus Are Leading You Astray, and How to Get Back on Track

DavidMcKnight.com

DavidMcKnightBooks.com

PowerOfZero.com (free video series)

@mcknightandco on Twitter 

@davidcmcknight on Instagram

David McKnight on YouTube

Get David's Tax-free Tool Kit at taxfreetoolkit.com

Doug Andrew

Doug’s video - Why You Should Never Use a Roth IRA Again (6 Reasons Why)