Good Intention Is Still Bad Theology | Judges 17:3-4

Welcome to The Daily, where we study the Bible verse by verse, chapter by chapter, every day.

Read more about Project23 and partner with us as we teach every verse of the Bible on video.

Our text today is Judges 17:3-4:

“And he restored the 1,100 pieces of silver to his mother. And his mother said, ‘I dedicate the silver to the Lord from my hand for my son, to make a carved image and a metal image. Now therefore I will restore it to you.’ So when he restored the money to his mother, his mother took 200 pieces of silver and gave it to the silversmith, who made it into a carved image and a metal image. And it was in the house of Micah.” — Judges 17:3-4

Micah’s mother meant well—but meaning well doesn’t make something right. She takes stolen silver, dedicates it “to the Lord,” and then uses it to fund an idol. It’s one of the strangest contradictions in Scripture: a mom trying to honor God by disobeying Him.

But this is where sentimental faith always leads. Yesterday, she blessed what God condemned. Today, she’s building what God forbade. When we refuse to confront sin, it doesn’t just sit quietly—it grows bold.

You can almost hear her logic: “I’m doing this for God. It’s my way of worship.” But the moment we start serving God our way, we stop serving Him His way. Micah’s mother didn’t reject the Lord; she redefined Him. She wanted God’s presence and blessing without God’s authority.

And that’s the same deception shaping modern faith. We’ve learned to baptize disobedience in religious language. Parents fund their kids’ sinful choices and call it love. Churches adopt the world’s ideologies and call it outreach. Politicians quote Bible verses while endorsing laws that mock God’s design. It’s all the same move—blessing what God condemns and calling it righteousness.

But God is not impressed by sincerity when it’s married to sin. Good intentions don’t turn rebellion into righteousness. When we fund what He forbids, we don’t build faith—we build idols.

We see it in the culture of “progressive Christianity.” We want inclusion without repentance, affirmation without transformation, and spirituality without submission. We think God should evolve with our culture, when in truth, we are the ones called to conform to His holiness.

The tragedy of Micah’s home is that it looked religious but lived rebellious. It had silver crosses and carved idols, blessings and blasphemy side by side. And that’s what happens when love loses its spine—sentimentality becomes sin, and truth is replaced by tolerance.

ASK THIS:

1. Where are you tempted to justify sin with “good intentions”?
2. How does your home reflect what you really believe about God’s boundaries?
3. Have you ever supported something “for love’s sake” that you knew dishonored God?
4. What would it look like to love your family with conviction instead of compromise?

DO THIS:

• Ask God to reveal one area where you’ve been “blessing” what He condemns.
• Repent by naming it for what it is—not “progress,” not “love,” but sin.
• Have one honest conversation this week with someone who needs truth spoken in love.

PRAY THIS:

Lord, forgive me for blessing what You’ve already called sin. Give me courage to love with conviction, to call truth what You call truth, and to stop confusing kindness with compromise. Amen.

PLAY THIS:

“Holy (Song of the Ages).”