Leadership Tensions in Family-Owned Businesses | The Family Biz Show Ep. 110
Release Date: 03/25/2025
The Family Biz Show
In this episode of the Family Biz Show, host Michael Palumbos is joined by executive coach and author Cathy Carroll to explore the emotional and strategic tensions unique to leading a family-owned business. Drawing on personal experience and her new book Hug of War: How to Lead a Family Business with Both Love and Logic, Cathy reveals how families can navigate leadership challenges, intergenerational conflict, and complex relationship dynamics with clarity and compassion. The conversation dives deep into the concept of polarities—opposing truths that both carry value—and how recognizing...
info_outlineThe Family Biz Show
In this episode of the Family Biz Show, Michael interviews Michael Bower, who shares his journey of acquiring and revitalizing Eagle Metal Craft, a multi-generational family business. They discuss the challenges of succession planning, the importance of maintaining a strong company culture, and the impact of family dynamics on business operations. Bower reflects on his experiences navigating the complexities of a declining business, the significance of mentorship, and the strategies he implemented to professionalize the company and drive growth. The conversation emphasizes the need for clear...
info_outlineThe Family Biz Show
After a long haitus due to a company transition, we're back with episode 108! In this episode of the Family Biz Show, Michael interviewed Nikki Rausch of the Sales Maven, who shares her journey from a successful sales career to becoming a sales consultant. They discuss the importance of hiring the right salespeople, understanding the sales process, and the differences between marketing and sales. Nikki introduces her Selling Staircase framework, emphasizing the need for curiosity in sales conversations and the importance of training for business owners and their teams. Some major topics...
info_outlineThe Family Biz Show
What does it take to transition a multi-generational family business into new ventures while preserving its legacy? In Episode 107 of the Family Biz Show, we welcomed Ray Isaac, formerly of Isaac Heating and Cooling, now with Northwinds Services Group. Ray shares his journey of transitioning from a well-known family business in Rochester, New York, to exploring new opportunities. The episode delves into the complexities of managing a family business, the importance of maintaining a strong legacy, and the challenges of navigating transitions. Ray...
info_outlineThe Family Biz Show
Ever wondered what it takes to transform a family dream into a thriving business? In this episode of the Family Biz Show, Michael sits down with Connor and Dan Sullivan, the dynamic brother duo behind Bumpa's, a unique gastropub nestled in the heart of Charleston, South Carolina. The Sullivans recount their bold leap from stable careers in finance and corporate real estate to the unpredictable world of hospitality. They share the intricate process of renovating a historic building, navigating the challenges of opening during a pandemic, and crafting a menu that...
info_outlineThe Family Biz Show
Episode 105 – The Epiphany & The Mud Run On this episode of The Family Biz Show, president of Williams Fence Dan Willams shares his journey into the family business, the values he learned along the way that continue to shape it, the evolution of his company & the impact of the ‘08 market crash. For family business owners and aspiring entrepreneurs, Dan's experiences provide a roadmap for achieving personal and professional fulfillment while maintaining the legacy and values of their family business. ----- If you’re a family business or a family...
info_outlineThe Family Biz Show
Episode 104 - Major Components of Family Business Exit Planning John Leonetti*, from the International Exit Planning Association, joins us in this episode to discuss the importance of exit planning for family business owners. He shares his personal journey and the challenges he faced when trying to plan for the succession of his family business. John emphasizes the need for proactive planning and highlights the three components of exit planning: personal readiness, company readiness, and market timing. He also introduces the six-step process for exit planning, which includes goal...
info_outlineThe Family Biz Show
Episode 103 - Pivoting from Private to Public in Family Business Nisha Balwani shares her journey as a second-generation CEO in her family business, RCI Technologies on this episode of The Family Biz Show. Nisha discusses the challenges and successes of the succession process, including the importance of clear communication and transparency, the need for patience and the value of bringing in outside expertise for exit planning and wealth management as well as the significance of being part of a CEO peer group for support and guidance. The conversation covers topics...
info_outlineThe Family Biz Show
Episode 102 – From Zero To Millions; Growth in Family Business Matt McCauley* CEO of LogoBrands joins us on this episode of The Family Biz Show. He discusses his beginnings in the business, from starting in a garage to growing into a multi-million dollar company. He also doesn’t shy away from talking about the challenges of working with family members and the transition from father to son in the business. Matt also talks about the importance of licensing and expanding into new product categories, the significance of maintaining company culture and core values, as well as the...
info_outlineThe Family Biz Show
Episode 101 – Cobbler Nights & Continuity Plans Join us and guest Robin Hall President of VARC Solutions as we discussed the challenges and benefits of involving family members in the business, the importance of setting boundaries, and the process of growing the company and hiring employees. Robin also shares her insights on creating a business continuity plan, implementing dashboards and metrics, and the value of participating in business organizations like Vistage. ----- If you’re a family business or a family business consultant and want to...
info_outlineIn this episode of the Family Biz Show, host Michael Palumbos is joined by executive coach and author Cathy Carroll to explore the emotional and strategic tensions unique to leading a family-owned business. Drawing on personal experience and her new book Hug of War: How to Lead a Family Business with Both Love and Logic, Cathy reveals how families can navigate leadership challenges, intergenerational conflict, and complex relationship dynamics with clarity and compassion.
The conversation dives deep into the concept of polarities—opposing truths that both carry value—and how recognizing them can transform everything from governance decisions to estate planning. Cathy and Michael discuss critical tensions like fairness vs. equality, tradition vs. innovation, structure vs. flexibility, and revealing vs. concealing wealth. Through real-life stories, including Cathy’s own journey of working with her father, they unpack how forgiveness, intentional leadership development, and healthy conflict can strengthen families and businesses alike.
Takeaways
- Family businesses must manage emotional and operational polarities—there is rarely one right answer.
- Governance should be structured, but flexible enough to evolve with the family’s needs.
- Fairness doesn’t always mean equality—especially when it comes to compensation and ownership.
- Healthy task conflict can drive innovation, while relationship conflict can destroy trust.
- Estate planning requires balancing transparency with timing and maturity.
- Power dynamics, especially between generations, must be managed with awareness and intention.
- Forgiveness is a leadership tool—starting with yourself and extending to family members.
- Preparing next-generation leaders requires more than a title—it requires mentorship, coaching, and clarity.
Chapters:
00:00 – Welcome & Guest Introduction
01:25 – Cathy Carroll's Family Business Background
02:20 – The Challenges of Working for Her Father
06:20 – What “Hug of War” Means in Family Business
08:12 – The Concept of Polarities: Business vs. Family Mindset
10:15 – Domain Crossover Power: Business vs. Family Influence
14:45 – Missed Conversations and End-of-Life Regrets
19:50 – Succession Planning: Equal vs. Equitable
21:10 – Estate Planning: Reveal vs. Conceal
23:55 – Cathy’s Polarity Mapping Tool Explained
28:12 – Independence vs. Interdependence in Family Roles
32:54 – Balancing Tradition and Innovation
35:07 – In-Laws and Inclusion in Governance
39:24 – The Need for Flexible Governance
42:36 – The Role of Forgiveness in Family Business
44:51 – Cathy’s Journey to Self-Compassion and Understanding
47:01 – How to Recognize When You’re in a Polarity, Not a Problem
50:00 – Tools for Navigating Difficult Conversations
52:20 – Cathy’s Final Advice for Family Business Leaders