loader from loading.io

593: Pro-Israeli, Pro-Palestinian, Pro-Peace with Todd Deatherage

The Holy Post

Release Date: 11/29/2023

604: Faulty Foot Washing & Pagan Christianity with Nijay Gupta show art 604: Faulty Foot Washing & Pagan Christianity with Nijay Gupta

The Holy Post

The “He Gets Us” campaign ran a Super Bowl ad showing culture war combatants washing each other’s feet. It has conservative Christians upset and non-Christians confused. Phil, Kaitlyn, and Skye react to the ad and unpack the many ways we misunderstand the meaning of Jesus washing his disciples’ feet. Then, New Testament professor Nijay Gupta is back to discuss his new book “Strange Religion” about what made early Christianity so weird and compelling. He explains what Roman religion looked like before Christianity, and how those pagan values and practices are returning. Plus,...

603: The Politics of Fear & Rethinking the Cross with Brian Zahnd show art 603: The Politics of Fear & Rethinking the Cross with Brian Zahnd

The Holy Post

Well, here we are again. The very same arguments that were rolled out by MAGA Christian leaders to justify supporting Donald Trump in 2016 and 2020 are back again in 2024. A new article in the Christian Post says America’s survival depends on Christians voting for Trump. Why do these fear tactics still work? Then, it’s true that all politicians lie, but PolitiFacts says Trump is a league of his own. And scientists explain why negative polarization in our politics may have evolutionary origins.   Then Skye interviews pastor and author, Brian Zahnd, about his new book, “The Wood...

602: When Vischer Met Reiner show art 602: When Vischer Met Reiner

The Holy Post

A new documentary hits theaters on February 16 about Christian Nationalism called God and Country. It features Phil and Skye, and many other Holy Post contributors. The executive producer of the movie is legendary actor, producer, and director, Rob Reiner, who’s created classics like The Princess Bride, When Harry Met Sally, and A Few Good Men. Reiner is a well-known supporter of progressive political and cultural causes and he’s not a Christian, which has triggered an avalanche of criticism from conservatives against those featured in the film. In this episode, Phil talks to Rob Reiner...

French Friday: Why D.E.I. is the New C.R.T. show art French Friday: Why D.E.I. is the New C.R.T.

The Holy Post

Lately, there’s been lots of talk about diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI)—sometimes as a virtuous initiative and sometimes as a boogeyman. Even Elon Musk weighed in, presenting it as a threat to our safety. Is this just another baseless moral panic? What are the potential pitfalls of DEI? David French joins Skye Jethani to discuss the issue. Plus, David French introduces, “The After Party,” a new curriculum to help Christians engage politics in a more thoughtful, humble, and hospitable way.   0:00 - Theme Song   0:18 - Show Starts   0:32 - D.E.I.   37:32 -...

601: Never Church Evangelicals and Hopeful Politics with Michael Wear show art 601: Never Church Evangelicals and Hopeful Politics with Michael Wear

The Holy Post

Evangelical voters have long supported Republican candidates, but who identifies as an evangelical Christian has changed over the years. A recent article written in The New York Times by Ruth Graham and Charles Homans argues that Trump is attracting a different kind of evangelical - one who loves their country and believes in God, but doesn’t actually go to church. Katelyn Beaty joins Phil and Kaitlyn to discuss the trend and why they aren’t as concerned this election cycle as previous ones. Then, Kaitlyn sits down with Michael Wear to discuss his new book, The Spirit of Our Politics:...

600: Not Debating Trump & Being Like Jesus with John Mark Comer show art 600: Not Debating Trump & Being Like Jesus with John Mark Comer

The Holy Post

It’s been nearly a decade since Donald Trump descended on his golden escalator and turned conventional wisdom about evangelical political values upside-down. Bonnie Kristian has a new article arguing that the only one’s still fighting about whether or not to support him are the “evangelical elites,” but for average evangelicals the debate about Trump is over. John Mark Comer is back to discuss his new book, “Practicing the Way.” He talks with Skye about the high cost of non-discipleship, and the unique ways ministry can malform a young pastor’s soul. Plus, scientists in the UK...

599: Paganism Returns & a New New Testament with Scot McKnight show art 599: Paganism Returns & a New New Testament with Scot McKnight

The Holy Post

As Christianity declines in cultural influence what is taking its place? A recent article in The Atlantic written by Rabbi David Wolpe argues that paganism is on the rise, but it takes different forms on the cultural left and right. Mike Erre joins Phil and Skye to discuss the trend and why it may actually be good news for the church. Then, professor Scot McKnight returns to talk about his new translations of the New Testament called “The Second Testament.” He explains why his version uses odd language like “the Heavens’ Empire” instead of “the Kingdom of Heaven,” and why our...

598: Mailbag: Picking Churches, Candidates, & Careers show art 598: Mailbag: Picking Churches, Candidates, & Careers

The Holy Post

Phil, Skye, and Kaitlyn begin the new year by answering listener questions. They address how to make important decisions from picking a church to picking a candidate. If you disagree with a worship song in a church gathering should you still sing it? They share some of their favorite movies with redemptive themes, what alternative careers they’ve considered, and how they maintain relationships with people they disagree with. Plus, Skye shares why he thinks sermon-centric Sundays are a problem and what the alternatives are. Kaitlyn offers advice to theology students and explains the...

French Friday: Why Fundamentalism is Growing show art French Friday: Why Fundamentalism is Growing

The Holy Post

We often associate fundamentalism with strict religious beliefs and practices. But David French says fundamentalism isn’t really about what someone believes, but how they believe it. He talks to Skye Jethani about the three traits that mark every form of fundamentalism—including the non-religious variety: certainty, ferocity, and solidarity. They unpack the legitimate desires that draw people into fundamentalism, and what’s happening in American culture that may be driving more people to embrace the extremes of fundamentalism on both the right and left. Plus, they share the antidotes...

597: Holy Post Live! show art 597: Holy Post Live!

The Holy Post

New Testament professor, award-winning author, and New York Times columnist Esau McCaulley joins Phil, Skye, and Kaitlyn for a special year-end episode with a live studio audience. They review what happened in 2023 and offer their picks for the most important news stories of the year. Topics range from Tim Keller’s passing, the navel-gazing of American evangelicalism, and the comfort of Cracker Barrel biscuits. They offer predictions for 2024. Esau joins the audience to play three hilarious rounds of “Bluff the Listener.” And, a 57-year-old woman experiences an “adverse event” in an...

More Episodes

With a spike in antisemitism around the world since the October 7th attack in Israel and the horrible scenes of Palestinian suffering in Gaza, Jews in the U.S. are wrestling with what it really means to be pro-Israel. Phil and Skye are joined by Holy Post pundit Mike Erre to discuss a thought-provoking sermon by American Rabbi Sharon Brous. She asks, is it possible to support one’s own tribe without diminishing the human dignity of others? And how does this relate to Christian communities who feel “under siege” in America? Then, former State Department official, Todd Deatherage, shares about his 15-year effort to help Americans understand that the Israeli-Palestinian situation is not a zero-sum conflict. He says evangelicals need to stop viewing Israel as a “lucky rabbit’s foot,” and embrace a vision for biblical peacemaking in the region that is both pro-Israeli and pro-Palestinian.


Holy Post Plus
Holy Post Office - When to take a Bible verse literally vs metaphorically


0:00 - Intro


1:38 - Show starts


4:46 - Theme Song


5:02 - Sponsor - With God Daily


6:46 - Rise of anti-semitism


13:42 - Oppressors or Oppressees 


51:14 - Sponsor - Aura Frames -  Visit www.AuraFrames.com and get 30 dollars off their best-selling Carver Mat frame with the code HOLYPOST


52:20 - Sponsor - AG1 - Get your FREE 1 year supply of Vitamin D AND 5 free travel packs with your first purchase, go to athleticgreens.com/HOLYPOST


53:53 - Interview Intro


1:03:19 - American Evangelical’s relationship with Israel


1:14:34 - Pro Israel and Pro-Palestine


1:35:19 - End Credits

Links mentioned in news segment:


‎The Ezra Klein Show: The Sermons I Needed to Hear Right Now on Apple Podcasts



Bari Weiss’ speech at The Federalist Society


Other resources:


The Telos Group - https://www.telosgroup.org/


Voxology podcast - https://voxologypodcast.com/


Holy Post website: https://www.holypost.com/


Holy Post Plus: www.holypost.com/plus


Holy Post Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/holypost


Holy Post Merch Store: https://www.holypost.com/shop

The Holy Post is supported by our listeners. We may earn affiliate commissions through links listed here. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.