Bonus Episode: A Conversation With Sheila O'Malley
The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
Release Date: 06/15/2025
11.03- The Bad Seed
The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
In which we discuss Dante's Inferno, St. Augustine and the Privation of Evil, and the woeful introduction of Witch-Killing Bullets. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find our back catalogue here: We would love to hear from you! Email: Facebook:
info_outline
11.02- Form and Void
The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
In which we discuss bunker fatigue, "it ain't math," a semi-blasphemous understanding of the Darkness's hypostatic union, and a controversial Never Shower. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find our back catalogue here: We would love to hear from you! Email: Facebook:
info_outline
11.01- Out of the Darkness, Into the Fire
The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
In which we discuss Enuma Elish, Dean vs. Ophelia, saving the world vs. saving each other, how air works, and whether the Darkness is a redhead (she is). SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find our back catalogue here: We would love to hear from you! Email: Facebook:
info_outline
Bonus Episode: S10 Best and Worst + S11 Preview
The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
Our favorites (and yours!) from season 10, and predictions for season 11! We would love to hear from you! Email: Facebook:
info_outline
10.23 - Brother's Keeper - Part 2
The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
In which we discuss Dean Winchester Space Cowboy, Sam's relentless love, and the moment the show jumped the shark. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find our back catalogue here: We would love to hear from you! Email: Facebook:
info_outline
10.23 - Brother's Keeper - Part 1
The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
In which we discuss the curse of immortality, the origin of Dean's tamale recipe, and this episode's unsatisfying lack of Banquos. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find our back catalogue here: We would love to hear from you! Email: Facebook:
info_outline
10.22- The Prisoner
The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
In which we discuss Dean's harshest words, the opposite of "Yes And," and the right time to burn down the Bunker. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find our back catalogue here: We would love to hear from you! Email: Facebook:
info_outline
10.21- Dark Dynasty
The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
Is this episode better than Hamlet? Michelle thinks maybe! ;) Today we discuss one of the most controversial deaths in the series and wear out the "This is Stupid" supercut. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find our back catalogue here: We would love to hear from you! Email: Facebook:
info_outline
10.20- Angel Heart
The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
In which we discuss Jimmy Novak's sacrifice, the point of no return for Claire's hair, and why this caramelly episode needed more salt. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find our back catalogue here: We would love to hear from you! Email: Facebook:
info_outline
10.19- The Werther Project
The Plaidcast Supernatural Rewatch
[This episode contains discussion of suicide and self-harm.] In which we discuss weaponized independence, diseased killer puppies, the hazards of spell coloring, and an anthem for resisting despair from Gerard Manley Hopkins. SPOILERS for ALL seasons! Looking for earlier episodes? Find our back catalogue here: We would love to hear from you! Email: Facebook:
info_outlineAfter following Sheila's writing on Supernatural, film, and television for a decade, we were honored and elated to talk with her about her backwards rewatch of the show, prioritizing character over plot, masculinity in Supernatural, the irresistible but deadly drift towards bureaucracy, good things coming in season 11, and of course the phenom that is Jensen Ackles.
You can read The Sheila Variations here.
You can read "Breaking Down the Schtick" here.
You can pre-order the Art and Making of Frankenstein here.
We would love to hear from you!
Email: theplaidcast@gmail.com
Facebook: www.facebook.com/groups/theplaidcast