You Can’t Make This Stuff Up! | 6 Cases and Zero Common Sense
Release Date: 03/12/2026
This Was NOT on My Bingo Card: Pro Cornhole Player Accused of Murder
Crime Talk with Scott Reisch
A 27-year-old quadruple amputee and professional cornhole player is now facing first- and second-degree murder charges after authorities say he fatally shot an acquaintance during an argument inside a Tesla SUV, then fled with the victim’s body still in the vehicle. According to investigators, Dayton James Webber allegedly shot 27-year-old Bradrick Michael Wells while Wells sat in the front passenger seat during a late-night drive in Maryland. Police say two other passengers were also inside the SUV when the argument happened. Authorities allege Webber later stopped the vehicle, asked the...
info_outline
Justin Timberlake DWI Bodycam Drops: “One Martini”… Sure.
Crime Talk with Scott Reisch
Crime Talk Store: Justin Timberlake’s newly released bodycam footage is putting the “one martini” line back in the spotlight. Redacted video released on March 21, 2026, appears to show the June 18, 2024 Sag Harbor traffic stop that led to his arrest. Police said he ran a stop sign, drifted out of his lane, refused a breath test, and had trouble following sobriety instructions. The case later ended with Timberlake pleading guilty in September 2024 to a reduced driving while impaired violation, along with fines and community service. In this video, we break down what the footage appears...
info_outline
SCOTUS vs “Election Day”: Mississippi’s Mail Ballot Deadline Fight (Watson v. RNC)
Crime Talk with Scott Reisch
Because apparently the words “Election Day” need a Supreme Court decoder ring. In Watson v. RNC, the Supreme Court is weighing whether federal election-day statutes override Mississippi’s rule that counts ballots postmarked by Election Day and received within 5 business days. The Fifth Circuit said ballots must be received by Election Day. Mississippi argues votes are cast on time when mailed on time, and postal delays should not cancel valid ballots. In this video, we break down the justices’ questions, the key statutes at issue — 2 U.S.C. §§ 1, 7, and 3 U.S.C. § 1 — and what...
info_outline
FULL AUDIO - Kouri Richins Trial Day 5
Crime Talk with Scott Reisch
Day 5 of the Kouri Richins trial, and the courtroom in Summit County is packed. The Utah mom accused of poisoning her husband, Eric Richins, is facing aggravated murder, attempted murder, insurance fraud and forgery. Scott breaks down the opening salvos: the state’s poison-and-profit theory, the defense’s “sensational media vs. real evidence” spin, the fight over hunting photos, and why people were lining up before 5 a.m. just to get a wristband. We’ll walk through what the jury heard, how the judge is running this courtroom, and what today’s moves tell us about the battle that’s...
info_outline
Woman On The Run! Ex-School Secretary Disappears After Shocking Case
Crime Talk with Scott Reisch
Crime Talk Store: A former middle school secretary in Greeley, Colorado, remains at large after authorities accused her of sexually abusing a 13-year-old student over several months. According to investigators, the case began after the two allegedly connected through social media in late 2025. Police say Brenda Meza, 34, who previously worked at Franklin Middle School in Greeley-Evans School District 6, now faces multiple felony charges. Authorities allege the case involved inappropriate communication, substance-related accusations, and repeated misconduct. The investigation became public in...
info_outline
Kouri Richins Juror Speaks: “No Sympathy” After Guilty Verdict
Crime Talk with Scott Reisch
Crime Talk Store: https://scottreisch.com/crime-talk-store A juror from the Kouri Richins trial is speaking out after the Utah mother was found guilty in the 2022 death of her husband, Eric Richins. In this video, we break down what the juror said about the deliberations, why sympathy faded as the evidence came in, and how cell phone data, financial records, and witness testimony shaped the final verdict. The jury convicted Kouri Richins on all five counts, including aggravated murder, attempted aggravated murder, insurance fraud, and forgery. The juror described the decision as heartbreaking,...
info_outline
FULL AUDIO - Kouri Richins Trial Day 4
Crime Talk with Scott Reisch
Day 4 of the Kouri Richins trial, and the courtroom in Summit County is packed. The Utah mom accused of poisoning her husband, Eric Richins, is facing aggravated murder, attempted murder, insurance fraud and forgery. Scott breaks down the opening salvos: the state’s poison-and-profit theory, the defense’s “sensational media vs. real evidence” spin, the fight over hunting photos, and why people were lining up before 5 a.m. just to get a wristband. We’ll walk through what the jury heard, how the judge is running this courtroom, and what today’s moves tell us about the battle that’s...
info_outline
FULL AUDIO - Kouri Richins Trial Day 3
Crime Talk with Scott Reisch
Day 3 of the Kouri Richins trial, and the courtroom in Summit County is packed. The Utah mom accused of poisoning her husband, Eric Richins, is facing aggravated murder, attempted murder, insurance fraud and forgery. Scott breaks down the opening salvos: the state’s poison-and-profit theory, the defense’s “sensational media vs. real evidence” spin, the fight over hunting photos, and why people were lining up before 5 a.m. just to get a wristband. We’ll walk through what the jury heard, how the judge is running this courtroom, and what today’s moves tell us about the battle that’s...
info_outline
FULL AUDIO - Kouri Richins Trial Day 2
Crime Talk with Scott Reisch
Day 2 of the Kouri Richins trial, and the courtroom in Summit County is packed. The Utah mom accused of poisoning her husband, Eric Richins, is facing aggravated murder, attempted murder, insurance fraud and forgery. Scott breaks down the opening salvos: the state’s poison-and-profit theory, the defense’s “sensational media vs. real evidence” spin, the fight over hunting photos, and why people were lining up before 5 a.m. just to get a wristband. We’ll walk through what the jury heard, how the judge is running this courtroom, and what today’s moves tell us about the battle that’s...
info_outline
FULL AUDIO - Kouri Richins Trial Day 1
Crime Talk with Scott Reisch
Day 1 of the Kouri Richins trial is finally here, and the courtroom in Summit County is packed. The Utah mom accused of poisoning her husband, Eric Richins, is facing aggravated murder, attempted murder, insurance fraud and forgery. Scott breaks down the opening salvos: the state’s poison-and-profit theory, the defense’s “sensational media vs. real evidence” spin, the fight over hunting photos, and why people were lining up before 5 a.m. just to get a wristband. We’ll walk through what the jury heard, how the judge is running this courtroom, and what today’s moves tell us about the...
info_outlineCrime Talk Store: https://scottreisch.com/crime-talk-store
Welcome back to You Can’t Make This Stuff Up!, the series where crime, chaos, and a complete lack of common sense all fight for the spotlight.
Today we’re covering six cases that sound like they were written by someone who fully gave up on humanity: an alleged murder during a planned birthday rendezvous in Florida, a deeply disturbing sibling case in Colorado, a grieving father who attacked his son’s alleged killer at court, a 13-year-old boy who stepped in to protect his mother during an alleged strangulation in Alabama, an Iowa woman accused of delivering drug-laced lasagna in an attempt to induce a miscarriage, and an Indiana foster mother sentenced after the death of a 10-year-old boy in her care.
We’re also closing with legal history from March 12, a quote about being on the wrong side of history, and a Dumb Criminal segment because apparently someone really thought using a drone and fake birds to smuggle drugs into prison was a solid business model.
Comment below: which case shocked you the most, and which one made you say,
“Yep, common sense has officially left the building.”
#TrueCrime #CrimeNews #DumbCriminal #YouCantMakeThisStuffUp #WeirdCrime #BreakingNews